HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

carterehsmith

502 karma · joined April 7, 2014

submissionscomments
carterehsmith··on Glassdoor and its effect on workplace culture
Perhaps, Glassdoor could add company address to the title?

So then, the reviewer that had bad experience with "XXX, Singapore", would not post it against "XXX, Austin, Texas".

carterehsmith··on BMW's Apple CarPlay annual fee is next-level gouging
>> Conversely, if 1% of a thing is nothing, can I have 1% of your company's common stock?

If you bought 80% of it, yeah, 1% would not make much of a difference. But you want it for free? Well, dream on.

carterehsmith··on BMW's Apple CarPlay annual fee is next-level gouging
>> My suggestion is that not everyone says "oh, the lease is $800 a month, another $80 a year is fine." $80 is still enough that being charged $80 for a pencil, or a chicken sandwich, or whatever, would be outrageous. And leaving a bit flipped is incalculably less work effort than preparing a chicken sandwich.

You are comparing apples and oranges, montlhy payments and yearly payments. "$800 a month, another $80 a year". How about being honest, "$800/month, another $7/month"?

>> FWIW: I've purchased or leased various BMWs and Audis over the last decade, and have rejected every offered subscription plan for pushbutton concierge, car wifi hotspot, etc., and have regretted paying more than $0 (on a one-time basis) for BMW's older iOS integration product.

Who cares about what you did or did not? Looks like you are here to congratulate yourself. Why would that matter to anyone other than you?

Or maybe you were stretching to get the car that you cannot afford. Who cares about adding 1% or 2% of the monthly price for something that is useful? Among people that buy luxury cars (myself included) I've not seen that. You need winter tires? Could be several thousands. Nobody blinks at $7/mo. I don't think you have been honest here.

carterehsmith··on 219 days of postmarketOS
>> Then make it super easy to reflash them back to factory. Problem solved.

Or, make it super hard to flash in the first place. Problem avoided.

carterehsmith··on Experiences with running PostgreSQL on Kubernetes
>> obviously has some pretty good experience at running data stores in the real world, at scale.

I missed that part. Did they mention it in the article? Perhaps they should mention that kind of stuff more prominently. Numbers... and such.

carterehsmith··on 219 days of postmarketOS
>> it's getting more difficult to flash ROMs onto most phones, not easier

Turns out, that is a niche use of a phone. Few people really need it.

But, some of them post on Facebook and Twitter "here is how to flash your phone and get unlimited games"

... and then many of those get bricked or attacked by viruses, and/or get otherwise disabled, and now the provider needs to deal with the tech support issues.

Plus, the ads may be redirected to someone else.

So yeah, if I was Samsung or Apple, I would not want you to flash the ROMs.

carterehsmith··on Paul Bocuse, Celebrated French Chef, Dies at 91
Paul Bocuse is considered a God among the chefs.

What we have here is someone telling us they had a great meal there, 27 years ago, at the age of 12, and the most impressive thing was: some waiter picked up forks from the floor super-quickly!

So that looked like some (inappropriate) joke to me.

carterehsmith··on BMW's Apple CarPlay annual fee is next-level gouging
Ok, so you want to get a new BMW. If it is a lease, that may be $500 or $1000 or whatever per month. That's after downpayment of $many, will be more without downpayment or trade-in or whatever you got.

BMW throws in a cellular connection ("BMW assist" or whatever they call it) for $0, for the first X years. Not sure how many.

You can also get carplay, free for the first year (I think) But then after that, carplay will be like $80/year. That is <$7/month. How does that even register, never mind make any difference?

And what is the narrative here, like "Oh, I was looking at BMW and Audi; I bought Audi because of the BMW's price-gouging $7/month fee!".

Did that ever happen? May be, but it just does not compute. Far as I can tell, if you are concerned over $7/month, you will not be buying a new BMW or Audi. It just does not add up.

carterehsmith··on BMW's Apple CarPlay annual fee is next-level gouging
>> Having carplay continue to work after they build the car requires bmw do exactly nothing.

You seem to think that carplay can automagically connect to the internet without any cost involved.

That cannot happen. It is a cell phone basically and needs a monthly plan just like your phone. Do you have free internet on your phone? No. So, don't expect free internet in your car, either.

carterehsmith··on BMW's Apple CarPlay annual fee is next-level gouging
I don't think you understand how this technology works, so I will try to help here.

Briefly: some car manufacturers provide a car with a cellular connection. That is, the car can connect to the mobile network, just like your cell phone can.

So now, with cellular connection, your car can show you online maps, or play online music, or whatever services Apple CarPlay, or Google whatever, or proprietary solutions can provide. Just like your cell phone.

Now, I hope this is getting clearer. Is your cell phone usage free? No. You pay Verizon or whoever, a set, monthly fee for the usage. You probably also have a cap (like, 10G data/month). The important takeaway is: the service is not free. You pay for it, usually on some kind of a monthly plan.

Now back to the car. It needs the same cellular service that your cell phone needs. Given that your cell-phone usage is not free, it is kind of obvious that your car's cellular connection is not going to be free, either. Makes sense?

Now.

So now, we know that there are things that are one-time cost (like, when you buy a car for cash), and then there are ongoing costs. For example, your car may need regular oil changes, checkups, and maybe a monthly fee for cellular, and another monthly fee for that Sirius thing. Some carmakers may decide to sweeten the deal that is your car buying experience, by eating up the cost for any, or some of the above. Mind you, it still costs money to e.g. do the oil change on your car; it is not free; it is just that the manufacturer has decided to pay for it. The same logic applies to Sirius and CarPlay and OnRoute or whatever.

It is important to realize that, whether it is the oil change or Apple CarPlay, these are ongoing things that the car manufacturer cannot provide themselves. Oil change is not provided by the car manufacturer. Rather, that is provided by dealerships or other independent shops. Same with cellular, car manufacturers do not own cellular networks. Rather, they will hook up your car to whoever provides the cellular.

Bottom line. Whether we are talking about the regular oil change, or CarPlay, there is a cost to it, and someone (the car owner -- who else?) will have to pay for it.

Hope that helps.

carterehsmith··on Paul Bocuse, Celebrated French Chef, Dies at 91
According to HN, their claim to fame is.. they can get forks off the floor super fast. We are talking seconds here.
carterehsmith··on Paul Bocuse, Celebrated French Chef, Dies at 91
>> At most restaurants they do not manage to pick your fork off the floor before you can take 1-2 seconds to do it yourself

Where I live, local KFC can do it in 0.68 seconds. I saw it when I was 9, 25 years ago, so it is legit.

carterehsmith··on Documents reveal that Whole Foods is leaving some shelves empty on purpose
>> so who knows

Yes, these are the key words. "Who knows". I don't know who made these decisions, do you?

carterehsmith··on Network Latencies and Speed of Light
Also, radio towers; because, the fiber (or whatever) cables usually zigzag following the roads or utility poles; meantime, the two radio towers can exchange radio waves traveling in a straight line.
carterehsmith··on BMW's Apple CarPlay annual fee is next-level gouging
On the other hand, will you decide to not buy that 428 (and take your business to... whatever competitor) over $80/year?

Btw it's not like the BMW is the only one charging for the mobile connection in the car... it's basically another cell phone + monthly plan, they are not free.

carterehsmith··on BMW's Apple CarPlay annual fee is next-level gouging
I mean, if you think that $80/year is "gouging" then you are not in their target demographics. To wit, over the price of a new car (whether BMW or Kia), the $80/year does not begin to register.

>> I'm certainly in BMW's demo

No, you are not. Carmakers target people that will actually want to buy a new car. They do not target people that drive a 2002 or whatever rustbuckets, for obvious reasons.

carterehsmith··on Paul Bocuse, Celebrated French Chef, Dies at 91
>> for my twelfth birthday.

Not sure if serious or trolling.

carterehsmith··on Training Your Brain So That You Don’t Need Reading Glasses (2017)
>> and saw life-changing benefits.

I do not see any "life-changing benefits" claimed in the article.

Looks like the only improvement he got was reported by the very application that he was using. Quote:

"Yet, after a couple of months, the app reports I can read fonts nearly one third the size I could when I started and much more rapidly. According to feedback from GlassesOff, my vision after training is equivalent to a man about 10 years younger than my age "

carterehsmith··on British 15-year-old gained access to intelligence, pretending to be head of CIA
Lol, how did that go? I am thinking... something along these lines:

Telemarketer: When you sign up with ShitWare, our Platinum partner, you get a free BigMac (tm) with a crumpet and a small drink! This exciting promotion is only available to our subscribers! Limited time offer. Quantities are limited. Only in participating restaurants. Some conditions apply. Taxes (incl. VAT) not included.

Queen: Goodness gracious, did you just say free BigMac (tm) and crumpets? That is, like, fucking amazing! OK I clicked on that link, it says "Your Windows is infected! Click here to clean!" Is that OK? Btw where is my food.

Telemarketer: It is, indeed, perfectly OK! Just click on where it says "I Agree". BTW it is one crumpet (not "crumpets") or a hashbrown, subject to availability. This exciting, time-limited offer is ---

Queen: Yeah whatever dude, just send the food in.

Queen: This is good. Most good.

carterehsmith··on British 15-year-old gained access to intelligence, pretending to be head of CIA
Interesting. I wonder, what was the procedure when some random telemarketer dialed one of those Queen's unlisted numbers? Or, whatever unlisted numbers.

Is that something that BT would intercept?

carterehsmith··on Building a Website with C++
"Building a Website with C++" "Is This Even Possible?"

We can just "flag" articles like this one.

carterehsmith··on NSA deleted surveillance data it pledged to preserve
Would that work in one those "secret courts" like https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Foreign_Intellig...

These seem to be kind of outside of the regular legal system.

carterehsmith··on Documents reveal that Whole Foods is leaving some shelves empty on purpose
>> management is grossly incompetent

They did build the big, succefull business in a super-competitive market that is grocery. You cannot possibly achieve that if you are incompetent.

carterehsmith··on Best ways to kill your startup
That article looks like a bot-generated content. There are Facebook bots, Twitter, Amazon bots (like, bots that generate book contents), even Youtube bots with (sometimes super-weird) machine-generated videos.

BTW they do get clicks, so this is not some AI research moonshot, it is more like a little cottage industry popping up.

carterehsmith··on Datomic Cloud
>> Especially queries are insanely fast compared to other databases.

Nice! Insanely fast? Awesome. What kind of queries compared to what databases?

carterehsmith··on The hidden costs of serverless
True. If the article is about someone promoting their business/product/solution, maybe it should be a "Show HN".
carterehsmith··on What Makes the Hardest Equations in Physics So Difficult?
There are different definitions of "summation". Also different definitions of "integration".

I can see how overlapping notation can be confusing for laymen (me included).

But that does not mean that people that came up with those are crackpots, just because they reused the "=" symbol.

carterehsmith··on What Makes the Hardest Equations in Physics So Difficult?
Good question, I guess I should have made that more clear.

Terence Tao has a nice lecture published... trying to find it, brb.

In any case, the gist of it was: long as we treat the numbers in the sum as integers (ie discrete), we will get ill-defined sums, contradictions, infinities, and so on.

Once we switch to real numbers (and there is an underlying function that is differentiable), things "can" be made to work and converge. To -1/12 always.

So that's it. In particular, if we decided that our smallest unit of measure is... the size of atom, or whatever finite value, many of these techniques will just fail to work, and they won't match what we measured. Which means something is wrong. Maybe things really are continuous. Or maybe they are not, it is just that our math is not sophisticated enough.

Obviously this is an open question.

carterehsmith··on What Makes the Hardest Equations in Physics So Difficult?
>> The pages you're referencing are all crackpottery.

So... I can trust Ramanujan and Abel, that published results on these things, and Terrence Tao that has a nice writeup, and a bunch of others, or I can trust HN user "Kazinator", who... published some middle-school algebra "proof" on HN.

Guess who is crackpot here.

>> https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ramanujan_summation

carterehsmith··on Memo: Foxconn cost to Wisconsin nearing $4.5B
>> Canadian economy is now slightly stronger than the US

But... is it? That was kind of my point. It is not clear at all.

So in Canada in particular, I remember big issues with the likes of GM and Ford. Here is what happens:

1/ Government attracts GM with tax breaks, will finance infrastructure, provide loans etc, etc.

2/ GM says "great". Builds the plant, employs people. This is the good part.

3/ Once the tax breaks expire, GM declares that the plant is not profitable anymore and shuts it down.

4/ So... was the plant beneficial to Canada? Depends who you ask. Some pundits add the numbers and say that Canada lost money in the deal, some say Canada gained.

What is obvious is that government spent a boatload of money to provide a job to like 3,000 people for three years.

Some argue that it would have been much cheaper to just give that money to random 3,000 people.

← PreviousPage 4 of 16Next →