HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

cartoonworld

1,021 karma · joined October 21, 2019

submissionscomments
cartoonworld··on We Tested Comma AI's OpenPilot
Also likely selling access to the ml model and/or training data. Openpilot is accruing many trips/miles for their dataset, the model and data isn't open-source.

That appears to be where the gold is stashed to my eyes.

If the software is open source and works very well, comma will still have a long lead in developing a great self driving model for which the bricks are miles driven down the road in normal commutes and trips by real drivers in real world conditions.

cartoonworld··on We Tested Comma AI's OpenPilot
I personally respect OpenAI, Love the data link on cars. I think we should never be frightened of hacked cars, we should definitely be hacking our cars (and trucks, forklifts, lawnmowers, combines, papershredders, robots).

Just wanted to add many comments on Can and obdII:

In the United States the obdII port is required beginning in model year 1996. The obdII port and the CAN is analogous to rj45 and cat5, 5e, 6, etc.

Should note, the can bus is anything but bog standard.

However, in 2008 the United States required that all vehicles provide an iso15765 interface as the basis of the on board diagnostics. Iirc, 15765 is a subset of Can that's for cars and not forklifts. Can is controller area network.

There are a large variety of protocols talked across Can, far too many to list as you have noted. There are schemes which are serial, parralel addressed and not, and even analog signaling cohabitating this generic breakout port.

Where it differs between cars is the capabilities of the DLC, if the vehicles isn't equipped with a sensor suite, there will be no correspondent ecu subsystem to query, but for the most part you can send control messages to anything you want on a DoT approved vehicle, unless it is locked away behind a specific gateway and the car manufacturer is still hiding the method to control access to the device.

None of this applies to infotainment devices or comfort features.

Consumers should rue the day we return to the age of mystery subsystems requiring special protocols.

The reason I say this (and I suspect but, can't remember the 2008 iso 15765 mandate rationale) is that you probably want your mechanic to be able to fix your car, right?

Anybody who might be interested in the wild and fun world of automotive Com protocols such as this I can recommend to you this good and recent resource from 2020: https://www.csselectronics.com/screen/page/simple-intro-to-c...

cartoonworld··on Everything I Know About SSDs
Yeah they sure are, they are manual transmissions with a solenoid controlled dual-clutch setup. One clutch engages the next gear as the first releases, there is no lost thrust as with a single clutch pedal, and you get to save all the weight of hauling around a huge valvebody and fluid and clutch bands.... Great stuff.

The Howstuffworks article is great. Have fun. https://auto.howstuffworks.com/dual-clutch-transmission.htm

cartoonworld··on VVVVVV’s source code is now public, 10 year anniversary jam happening now
You can still do with haxe: https://haxe.org/use-cases/games/

Haxe is somewhat a flash clone. https://github.com/HaxeFoundation/haxe/

cartoonworld··on The MTA is going after an Etsy artist over a New York subway map it didn’t make
>What really makes me angry about the whole ordeal is that the USPS is a consistent money loser.

Insofar that the the USPS is a subsidized service, I don't agree that it is a money loser. Considering that the mail is the way that nearly all bills have been collected, historically, I'd say it has far more than paid for its self.

cartoonworld··on Amazon, Apple, Google, and the Zigbee Alliance to develop connectivity standard
I am surprised this is how we have ended up. We have already had a pretty good looking model for this sort of voice activated computer interaction thanks to Star Trek: TNG.

It would be far more palatable for the devices to wait for a command cue ("Computer--") to respond with an activation bleep. After the bleep, the commands begin to be interpereted.

Instead we have a listener always awaiting commands. What could be a helpful and invisible servant is instead some kind of jerk who interjects with the most literal interpretations of normal conversations.

If I wake up in the morning feeling grumpy (every day) and say some crazy crap (totally possible) on my way to the can, will an apple contractor employee be able to figure out what the hell I really wanted by reviewing the seconds of audio?

I have made death threats to wall hanging photographs in those 30 minutes before my medication kicks in. There is no checkbox for this in the privacy settings. I know with some of these smart things you can change the prompt, but this feels like not the best we can come up with.

cartoonworld··on Mailfence: Secure and Private Email Service
>The secure email services provide far less product-based value, though clearly the security and lack of ad tracking is there.

I have thought about this as well. What do you think could be added to secure email services to make the value more appealing?

In the dark distant past, ISPs of old would include email as a side effect of their data services including shell accounts, user file hosting, and maybe even CGI-BIN, if you paid.

The only thoughts I have had were to bundle some kind of VOIP/SMS package along with the secure email offer. Perhaps some startup MVNO could also include secure email and other advanced features along with their mobile data services.

All of this seems pretty far fetched, as email looks to be as niche of a product category as Premium IRC.

cartoonworld··on We Just Got a Rare Look at US National Security Surveillance
>I don't think that logic follows? That statistic could just mean that they're actually doing most things legally and properly, which is the outcome you'd want, right? I'd be worried if a significant percentage of their requests were turned down.

I think you're correct that the logic employed doesn't follow. It is useless to look at the statistics alone and conclude one way or the other that FISA is or is not a rubber stamp. However, I think you are doing a category error: Criminal court proceedings are adversarial, FISA court is not.

Because there is no defense, public oversight, or judicial review. FISA cases are sealed, and secret. There is no risk of jury nullification or new caselaw because these cases are not argued by an adversary. Outside entities subpoenad in this fashion are barred from speaking of it (Under 99% conviction federal criminal statutes) Nobody is risking re-election here and the judges are appointed. The adversary is a strawman in FISA. The public is functionally shut out as well. It was designed for this purpose, the lack of accountability is a critical feature.

In order to employ the statistics properly you require context. In my high school sociology class the instructor posed this statistical fallacy: Drownings and grass growth rates are positively correlated. A naive observer born and living on Mars might ban grass to prevent drownings. This missing the mark because correlation != causation, and the true correlation is more people swim in the summer when grass grows faster. There is not swimming on mars.

>Also, as a comparison point: apparently several federal judicial districts have a 100% conviction rate [...] Do you see these statistics as implying the whole thing is just a rubber-stamp process altogether?

Comparing to high criminal conviction rates (often in the high 90%), the prosecutors and attornies general use the conviction statistics for their re-election campaigns. Cases which would result in "Jury Nullification" or some other modification of caselaw or jurisprudence are abandoned, keeping the rates artificially high. Refer to "Stingray" caselaw. This effect is partially caused by the adversarial court system being helmed by elected officials.

This is to say, that the regular criminal courts are an adversarial public system in which the accused get lawyers. Those lawyers sometimes win in court, other times the AG or prosecutor drops the charges when it looks like they will lose due to the legal arguments employed by the adversary. Dropped or unajudicated charges aren't counted in the statistics. Losing cases are not tried.

In order to maintain your claim here, there is some missing data:

1: Who is the adversary in FISA?

2: When does the public review the court proceedings?

Given the answers to 1 and 2 being "Nobody" and "Never", the statistics tell a much different tale than the criminal conviction statistics. Now the logic may follow.

cartoonworld··on ACLU sues Homeland Security over 'stingray' cell phone surveillance
A sibling comment noted the FCC rules for antenna structures. FCC regulates some of this, and the cell towers should all be on that list. That said, I don't know how to easily access the FCC information aside from a service like antennasearch or some other thing. There are also paid services for this sort of thing. IF you are searching for towers, also make use of a fiber search, as all these towers need fiber to run, unless they use backhauls or something which seems less likely. The towers are usually owned by something like COMTECH III, LLC and then the entities leasing the tower space operate everything else.

In addition to the FCC, FAA, there should be a massive public paper trail for tower construction. The locality, state, and feds are involved in this.

So, in a roundabout way, I think your thoughts were: "If FCC regulated and lists this, why the tower search crap?" The reason is that if you get the FCC, state, and local to OK your tower and use it for long range deer hunting, the FAA maps will still show your 220ft deer stand, but there are likely no cellular transceivers on the tower. On a cell tower there could easily be 2 today, and then 4 next month.

So the location and use of the towers doesn't always coincide with the cellular network equipment hanging off it, which is what would need to be monitored.

Also I'd wager that the open sensor method of opencellid, MLS, WiGLE will give you better data. If you are doing your own research, it would be greatly helpful to compare to the official lists, but you'll need to verify it anyhow.

If anybody is doing this work I would be interested in knowing more about this landscape.

Interesting stuff.

cartoonworld··on ACLU sues Homeland Security over 'stingray' cell phone surveillance
Antennasearch is a good resource, and somehow the database update functions still work, but it appears unmaintained, somewhat janky, and the copyright notice reads 2004-2009. I resent the popup windows and the google maps integration is broken. Luckily, there are several community efforts to map the cell coverage.

Check out https://opencellid.org/ which is an open source WiGLE-esque cell location collection. You can contribute with the TowerCollector[1] android app (also on fdroid).

Mozilla also operates Mozilla Location Services[2] as an API for developers. People can contribute location anonymized data to Mozilla by a settings menu checkbox, or using their special app.

WiGLE[3] of course includes cell tower detection in their wireless geographic logging suite.

[0] https://opencellid.org/

[1] https://github.com/zamojski/TowerCollector/

[2] https://location.services.mozilla.com/

[3] https://www.wigle.net/

cartoonworld··on Google under investigation for ‘Thanksgiving Four’ firings, discouraging unions
They sure are, I call those forces "Greenbacks".
cartoonworld··on Why does the Librem 5 phone cost that much?
This internal expansion is a really cool feature. I'm not sure how much use I would make of it, but I really like this feature and I was surprised they were able to cram it in there. Nice one.

More info: https://liliputing.com/2019/08/librem-5-smartphone-will-have...

cartoonworld··on Why I Voted to Sell .ORG
I think Richard's piece leaves out everything of substance. I don't understand how this helps the ISOC mission, users of .org, the public interest of the Internet at large, or anyone at all except of course Ethos Capital.

PIR, the registrar in question generated $48 Million in support grants for ISOC in 2018 tax return. He's trying to make the case that selling this $50million revenue from grants is worth it. He think the governance of .org and the maximum possible cost increase will be fine.

What possible reasons has he given for any of that?

He vaguely indicates that it'll be fine, and instead asserts that $28/yr could be affordable? It is, but why not just jack up the price in the first place, if its a money thing? They could be getting $100-Million in ten years, why sell it off to a private capital investment firm with no track record of "Governance" and a mandate only to private shareholders and investors?

If you happen to check https://ethoscapital.mu/investments/ to read all about their clear mandate for Governance (whatever that means the the context of "Exposure to a Diversified Pool of Unlisted Assets") hopefully the irony[0][1] of their using the .mu (Mauritius) tld is not lost on you. Sorry if this last bit seems petty, but just wow. What about any of this makes anyone think this doesn't look like a gift to private equity? I would like to see the sale price.

[0] https://business.mega.mu/2013/07/29/internet-210-government-...

[1] https://web.archive.org/web/20141110042124/http://news.islan...

cartoonworld··on Why I Voted to Sell .ORG
As you said, according to the 2018 tax return revenues from PIR running .org resulted in $48,000,000.00 in cash grants handed over to the Internet Society.

How much is the sale worth? That $48M Grant was worth more than Internet Society's total revenue in 2016 according to wkipedia. ISOC just sold a sustainable $50Million revenue stream.

If LetsEncrypt copped a $0.10 fee per certificate, how much would it cost for Richard to rubber stamp a Symantec acquisition of LetsEncrypt?

cartoonworld··on Why does the Librem 5 phone cost that much?
Aren't the baseband components typically separated because they are a different regulatory domain?

My understanding is that integators buy the baseband module (with FCC and other licenses) and add it to their device so as to not incur the patent fees and oversight required by developing the radio device into every regional handset.

cartoonworld··on Why does the Librem 5 phone cost that much?
If the price were 20% less it would demand some more eyeballs.

When I saw the price I assumed they were trying to position a premium product. I think this is a little bit of a mistake given that in the market of handsets, Apple owns the "premium" devices, and maybe samsung counts as #2? Nobody is crossing that Rubicon.

$700 isn't really bad but I don't like the look of it. Maybe if they can make this thing for 6 or 7 years. People who are worried about this have been aware of Essential phones which aren't the same, but end users aren't shopping these Freedom characteristics.

I predict another few years of nobody batting an eye to these devices. Great shame.

cartoonworld··on Why I Voted to Sell .ORG
His argument seems to be:

1: The Internet Society does great work protecting the Internet 2: Ethos is a worthy successor to the Internet Society as the steward of .org.

This is incoherent. THis blog post can be summed up in one sentence: "I reckon its fine."

Thanks for voting to sell .ORG Richard Barnes. I know he thinks its fine, I think jacking the prices up 10% year over year is nonsense. What do the financials look like and what's the internet getting out of this?

A money grab looks like a money grab.

cartoonworld··on Psilocybin for major depression granted Breakthrough Therapy by FDA
Well, at the very least you can see Shane Mauss at Mycomeditations in January[0]

[0] - http://www.shanemauss.com/club-dates/

cartoonworld··on Uber loses licence to operate in London, will still operate while appealing
That is the governments job.

They aren't regulating an app on the store, they would be in this hypothetical scenario regulating the labor practices of a multinational corporation, which is for sure the job of any government.

cartoonworld··on Uber loses licence to operate in London, will still operate while appealing
No indeed there's no gun, and luckily if you can't afford a car to drive, Uber would love to sell you a subprime auto loan as see on FTC TV: https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/blogs/business-blog/2017/01/...

I wonder if we would all feel the same about some other ponzi scheme.

cartoonworld··on Tesla PowerWall 2 Hack
Yes, while reading this initially I, too had the same reaction: Typical tech startup bootstrapping seat-of-the-pants stuff. But upon smelling the coffee, and remembering a few conversations I have had with ostensibly reasonable people, this sounds totally batshit.

>Growing high double digits each year for more than a decade in a brutally competitve space, developed 4 hugely successful vehicles, first US auto company to [...] grow to significant size (>700,000 cars sold) since Ford

People get in this product and they don't see the startup culture making wins and beating the odds to deliver a Ludicrous! Tesla Model S with heated leather seats. They see a finished product who's origin, to them, may as well have been a Star Trek replicator. To this point, I have encountered people who argued strongly that Teslas are "Self-Driving Cars" already. They really give stuff the benefit of the doubt sometimes.

So many issues attested to in that engineer's report need to have been already handled. It is amazing that they have created this manufacturing line out of nothing, I mean they build these things in tents, really bucking the odds here, but it causes me much pause. I would have hoped Elon would have worked out bootstrapping this manufacturing process, I think he discounted what it takes to pull off consistent manufacturing quality on many levels. This was Toyota's innovation a lifetime ago, shame that Tesla didn't seem to hire up any of that greying industry knowledge.

I now feel a deeper understanding of Tesla's icing-out of the repair/aftermarket. Seems obvious in retrospect.

>I believe there’s also an element of envy, or misunderstood beliefs that the best tech approach is taking things slowly. Yes, in isolation. But then market forces will crush you

>There’s no evidence that the approach have led to more injuries or deaths than cars do in general, quite the opposite. Tesla cars are safer than competition, the argument can be made that fast deployment is a net win regarding safety.

Get with the program. This is not an electric toothbrush with a subscription model, people are going to die. When product safety and manufacturing quality take a back seat to business whims, you are going to get trouble. Sporting this Boeing-esque reasoning is going to get people killed.

cartoonworld··on Volkswagen Axes All Non-Electric Racing Programs Worldwide
I would say "Cold Weather Performance"

My understanding is that Lithium based batteries (and lots if not all others) have unfavorable properties at human-cold temps. When at -5 or -10C say they work pretty poorly, slowing charge, discharge and capacity.

cartoonworld··on Losing the News: The Decimation of Local News and the Search for Solutions
Ok thanks, I know that generally as Ranked Preference Voting and the more specific proposal of IRV Instant Runoff Voting

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Instant-runoff_voting

Do you have any more info about this type of voting? I would always be interested in reading more analysis of this topic.

cartoonworld··on Twitter lets you use 2FA without a phone number
No, In addition to what you have mentioned, and sibling comments have noted about implimentation, it is SMS that is (has been? --But i can't find info if this has been remedied) insecure as well. This is the "SimJacker" whitepaper describing technical means of hijacking among other games.

https://simjacker.com/downloads/technicalpapers/AdaptiveMobi...

cartoonworld··on Twitter lets you use 2FA without a phone number
I agree with you if you are saying Telcos have no economic incentive to take any security posture for their customers. Regular users cannot fathom that the service they pay for is somehow able to be manipulated and that their communications can be redirected arbitrarily without legal order via technical means.

It is known that there are security issues with ss7 specifically [0][1][2] and the global telecom network was, it seems, never secured. I would conjecture that there are some other problems with mobile phones[3] some that we are not aware of.

I also am in lock step with your claim that this should not be surprising.

Telcos are indeed not paid for security. The security of the telephone network must not be counted on. In fact, military and government business must often be executed on special non-public phone exchanges or SIPRnet. Telcos do not offer any security guarantees, and are rather obstinate toward any demands such as this. Negotiating a more secure service is impossible.

>So it is rather odd to hold telcos reponsible for the failure of some security mechanism they where never part of.

It is certainly not odd. If the general public wakes up and their assigned phone numbers are meaningless, all of their customers will be unhappy, it simply wouldn't pass the sniff test of a 6-year-old.

However, there is positively no incentive for anybody to shop for security in this space. Few living people believe or can even fathom that there could be a problem with using their phones in this manner. Despite the public fraud[2] that has been enabled by the Telco's apparent lack of any security engineering, the market is not providing any security mechanisms for this, I would imagine in part due to the concessions on interoperability made during the development of these global telco protocols.

There (appears to have been) zero work done for the security of this critical system. Customers do not recognize any possible threats, telcos have no interest in improving their networks in this regard, the US government has developed a nickel allergy towards telco regulation in the 30 or 40 years following the 'Bell conclusion. Finally telco's don't care to change, and if they did there would be decades long disputes regarding implimentation.

No, it is wholly unsurprising to find an entrenched, obstinate partner in this field.

[0] https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2014/12/ss7_vulnerabi...

[1] https://simjacker.com/downloads/technicalpapers/AdaptiveMobi...

[2] https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2017/05/thiev...

[3] https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2016/09/leaked_stingr...

cartoonworld··on Google to restrict political adverts worldwide
Thanks for posting this, I was also unaware.

Slightly off-topic, but Facebook offers a similar thing: https://www.facebook.com/ads/library/

I like these additions to ad serving entities, this is an important development. I'm really surprised I was not informed about these ad transparency portals, and that nobody seems to be paying attention to these. I would have wagered there would be various activists using this tool already. None of my news channels have this on their radar.

Does anybody know of other ad transparency portals, or of any projects working with these portals? Whats the likelyhood that these portals vanish into nothing, or behind a paywall or whatever? Are there APIs?

cartoonworld··on Losing the News: The Decimation of Local News and the Search for Solutions
>1) Double politicians (or leftover politicians). Most of English speaking world has left over votes with no representative, have politicians elected with leftover votes. These are paid positions with no power.

I don't understand what you are proposing here. I think there is a point about constituencies, but I do not parse your logic. What do you refer to by leftover votes?

cartoonworld··on System76 Will Start Designing and Building Its Own Linux Laptops in January 2020
>Tell that to the Fujitsu people building the A64fx chip. (Which by the way turns out uses HBM for system memory. I was dreaming of AMD doing this!!) Or even just to Marvell/Cavium :)

I hear ya, but aren't those efforts kind of like very high-performance controllers for other equipment? Surely the Cavium stuff isn't processing frames directly on the host cpu, instead they leverage the ISA to add support for specialized subsystems, (At requisite cost) right? Plus the advantages that the datacenters are chasing down with this architecture are density related, which is to say a lot of little things doing little jobs.

How much of the datacenter push is replacing general purpose, hot cores, with specialized lower power devices? Who's running The Cloud on arm yet? How many ARM cores are we gonna cram into a laptop? (I would like many, please.)

Wrt the Fujitsu effort, it seems like an interesting development, but I don't envision that platform hitting desktops. Its possible, but where are the units? You can already buy a Talos II today.

>The whole point of "SoC" is cramming everything onto the one package. It's the most efficient way to do things, and everything from the Raspberry Pi's Broadcrap chip to the biggest AMD EPYC is a SoC.

Yes of course. But this bloats the power and heat budget of the SoC by more than a little.

The biggest AMD EPYC SoC (I really disagree with this generalization of SoC but I understand what you mean) is a huge piece of silicon and not the same kind of ARM ISA lego game. Growing an arm die with specially designed HPC subsystems to that size, also including 128 PCIE lanes, and 10GbE, probably means some really expensive ISA purchases or in-house development, if looking at Fujitsu gives us any clues.

AMD and Intel are already experts at managing the power and heat budgets. Reproducing these efforts looks like another steep engineering cost to my eyes.

One additional mention, and of coursethank you for your time: Seems you might be interested by some other ARM ISA datacenter efforts, check out the RockPro64 Arm cluster that Pine Microsystems has created to host their online services. Ctrl+F "cluster" in the following link. I don't know where to find more detailed information yet. https://www.pine64.org/2019/11/05/brave-heart-edition-pineph...

cartoonworld··on System76 Will Start Designing and Building Its Own Linux Laptops in January 2020
I agree, that looks like it could strike a good relationship for System76 and AMD. Vast, rambling, inexpert conjecture about some of the roadblocks:

The Intel offerings for mobile are very well developed and cost effective. Apple alone pushes quite a bit of development in this segment, in part because lots of us nerds out there with a commit history are running that hardware. Intel can supply powerful, integrated, shrink wrapped subsystems, etc already tailored for mobile form factors. Their marketshare here is crushingly dominant.

Conversely, the AMD mobile platform relies on realtek and others, eliciting howls from grumpy users with certain numbers of greying beard fibers. AMD doesn't supply the ethernet, wifi, storage in this fashion, requiring the integrators to do more work. Making a change will likely be costly, perhaps even riling the, now merely sated, Intel naga from its E-Commerce/Big Data fed slumber, into a veritable springtime of onerous contract terms and volume requirements.

Then there is of course the video subsystem wicket. I have encountered a bunch of anecdotal people that I mentally associate as BSD users who simply prefer the Intel UHD graphics. They like counting on the low power, and simple functionality, as do I. I recognize that AMD has improved by vast geologic scales in the last decade on the drivers and opensource front. I don't fully understand why the graphics haven't enveloped the world. Seems like everyone is happy with Intel UHD-whatever and Mali, or just take what comes and complain if it is buggy.

Additionally there is a mentality of "At least Intel works properly!" that is still floating around a bit, which I don't exactly understand fully. It seems useful to myself, now, to pause and reflect on Intel's ongoing hardware security vulnerability uh--management. Certainly a masterclass of disclosure and mitigation.

Finally, wrapping my afghan around these poor old bones here on my Internet enabled armchair, I wonder what life would be like if the CPU market were more like the automotive industry, and Intel were producing Taxis and Uber vehicles. Would this kind of systemic defect not have been completely ruinous? Much different industry of course, but one thing makes me chuckle--maybe those banks shelling out for those 30 year old Mainframe support contracts had the right idea all along.

cartoonworld··on System76 Will Start Designing and Building Its Own Linux Laptops in January 2020
My impression is that POWER is more suitable for desktop computing. Many people would like access to a non-x86 portable device (with, say, 64gb ECC RAM and great I/O.)

I don't know how well the POWER line has progressed since say 2004ish and ARM sure is coming up, but if you intend to use a lot of (fast) I/O and virtualization on your portable workstation laptop it seems to me that POWER would be a great alternative, although surely at a nice price premium over the various ARM ISAs.

ARM on the other hand seems to thrive on the other end of the spectrum--low power consumption and inexpensive. Wouldn't most solutions require that you cram the IO subsystems into the silicon SoC package?

I reckon this kind of thing would eat your power/cost advantages back into the x86 realm.

← PreviousPage 10 of 13Next →