HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

carussell

2,674 karma · joined September 22, 2009

I don't HN anymore.
submissionscomments
carussell··on Show HN: Hearth – A Dropbox-like, IPFS-powered personal website publisher
You're making a category error. IPFS (and friends—like Dat) are analogous to HTTP. Would you call HTTP a silo? No; services like Facebook and Google Drive are silo-y, but HTTP is not. The people working on the P2P web are just trying to make some design choices at the protocol level that facilitates its use in a more decentralized way than the services that HTTP has encouraged to flourish.
carussell··on Show HN: Hearth – A Dropbox-like, IPFS-powered personal website publisher
Although not IPFS, Dat[1] is another protocol (associated with Beaker Browser, linked in another comment here), and there's a group trying to build the P2P web on that. In the case of Dat, you can create an account on Hashbase[2], and that will give you a permaseed for your content, even if your device is offline. And then, of course, if you have enough fans they're able to relay your content amongst themselves and any other interested parties who show up.

1. https://datproject.org

2. https://hashbase.io

carussell··on Do not use NPM 5.7
> for me I just want to use npm to install a program or two.

I don't think you're introducing new information. When I wrote my original comment, it was intended to fully acknowledge that this is what's at play. And rereading it, seems like it does that well enough, but I might be wrong.

But in any case, I'll run it with sudo then, is absolutely the wrong thing to do, regardless of the bad choices on NPM's part—on par with I just want to use my online banking, so I'll click through this certificate error, or I just want to take some notes, so I'll grant this mobile app the full permissions it's asking for.

There's a reason I used the phrase "normalization of deviance". It's a phrase that came out of post mortem investigations into simple process failures at NASA that led to proper (catastrophic, life-ending) failures, and an urge to find an answer to the question, "how in the world did we get here?"

carussell··on Do not use NPM 5.7
`sudo npm install -g` is one of several examples of the normalization of deviance rife in the NodeJS community. Most command-line utilities distributed through NPM recommend running as root (implicitly—because they all suggest installing it as a global package). Here's[1] Microsoft's instructions to install the TypeScript compiler, for example.

NPM's awfulness notwithstanding, it's trivial to write a shell script to do what you say and add a symlink to ~/bin. But everyone on StackOverflow will tell each other "just run it with sudo", and they do, and then quickly move on with their lives (presumably to be followed with "and break things"). Instead of doing the right thing, raising their hackles about how poorly NPM is designed, and holding its community leaders accountable.

1. https://github.com/Microsoft/TypeScript/blob/b29e0c9e3ab2471...

carussell··on Signal Foundation
If you're suggesting that Signal will eventually federate, there's nothing in those two links to support that interpretation. In fact, to the contrary:

> Early on, I thought we’d federate Signal once its velocity had subsided. Now I realize that things will probably never slow down, and if anything the velocity of the entire landscape seems to be steadily increasing.

> You're free to use our source code for whatever you would like under the terms of the license, but you're not entitled to use our name or the service that we run. If you think running servers is difficult and expensive (you're right), ask yourself why you feel entitled for us to run them for your product.

carussell··on Signal Foundation
A null vision. Moxie is against federation, and he's against interoperable clients.

https://signal.org/blog/the-ecosystem-is-moving/

https://github.com/LibreSignal/LibreSignal/issues/37

carussell··on Email is your electronic memory
Sounds like jwz's "intertwingle"[1] strawman with a smidge of "unity of interface"[2], or JetBrains's old Omea information manager[3].

1. https://www-archive.mozilla.org/blue-sky/misc/199805/intertw...

2. https://www-archive.mozilla.org/unity-of-interface.html

3. https://www.jetbrains.com/omea/features/

carussell··on This Conversation Is Going Nowhere
I'm not trying to imply that any given game as it currently exists would be a suitable candidate for the format. In-game puzzles would obviously benefit greatly from consideration by the authors of the input method and player environment. Dense text descriptions and really tricky minigames ordinarily expected to be presented visually don't make a perfectly smooth transition for casual, voice-enabled play, the same way that traditional WIMP desktop apps don't make for good use on mobile touch devices.
carussell··on This Conversation Is Going Nowhere
I've thought for some time now that the real killer app for natural language assistants—especially voice activated assistants like Alexa, perhaps slightly less suited for text-based chatbots—lies in short, episodic, choose-your-own-adventure-style games. The more I think about it, the more I'm not really sure why this isn't a thing yet, and why we haven't seen a resurgence in the popularity of interactive fiction—albeit this time for the masses, and not necessarily limited to those inclined to go load up a copy of Zork.

And content creation is more accessible than ever. I mean, have you seen an example of what the source code for an Inform7 game looks like?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inform#Inform_7_programming_la...

To reiterate, it almost seems crazy that there isn't a massive catalog of $0.99 serials that you can play through in 45-minute chapters while cooking, driving down the road with the family or on the way to work, etc.

carussell··on Show HN: A Decentralized StatusPage on IPFS
The Dat project, which is somewhat similar to IPFS, and the people behind Beaker have addressed these things. So you can have a site like dat://9900f9aad4d6e79e0beb1c46333852b99829e4dfcdfa9b690eeeab3c367c1b9a/ or you can access the same thing as dat://fritter.hashbase.io using DNS-over-HTTPS for Dat (which is a mouthful, so I've been calling it DSN [Dat Short Names] instead). TTL is controlled by the publisher, just like with DNS. The main downside with the current incarnation is that while the content network itself is decentralized, short name resolution is not, since it's bootstrapped from the traditional DNS/HTTPS infrastructure for now. Which means the short name works only so long as the publisher continues responding.

Beaker is a web browser for Dat sites. The 0.8 release is supposed to happen sometime in the next month, I think. The same team set up hashbase.io to make it trivial to create a short name for a Dat site, and so that you can have Hashbase act as a fallback superpeer/permaseed for your content.

carussell··on Write dumb code
Here are links to two of my favorite essays that make a similar point:

Java for Everything[1]

Too DRY[2]

And then there's a third, which is not quite the same topic, but still in the same vein. It's arguably even more relevant today than three years ago when it was written, especially given how much attention is being captured by ecosystems that attract folks who end up generating a morass of terrible tooling:

Helping my students overcome command-line bullshittery[3]

1. https://www.teamten.com/lawrence/writings/java-for-everythin...

2. http://jamie-wong.com/2013/07/12/grep-test/

3. http://pgbovine.net/command-line-bullshittery.htm

carussell··on LinuxBoot: Linux as Firmware
See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intel_Active_Management_Techno... and https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intelligent_Platform_Managemen...
carussell··on Clive OS: Go applications that can run without an operating system (2016)
This submission is here because of the link to the intro to OSes book[1] by one of the Clive authors that was posted yesterday. It's worth taking a look at the other stuff referenced on this page page, as well as the author's other links.[2]

To answer your question:

> Better performance? Could be.

That's one aspect. If you follow the link from the Clive page to its predecessor Nix[3], its tagline is "high performance cloud computing is nix". A current (2018) justification for that project can be found in the form of an abstract for a paper with the same name[4].

But then the other part is given away in the abstract for Clive itself: "Clive introduces new file system technology and novel interfaces for the construction of networked system"[5], which is another way of saying that this is blue sky research, which is itself a codeword for we decided to try out a bunch of things purely _because_ they're different and want to see if anything will come out of it. Notice how the screenshot here shows the OS shell is some sort of acme-like[6] made to run in a web browser, for example.

To repeat my earlier remark, the author's other pages are well worth a look. For example, don't miss this[7] page chock full of links to research OSes (although many of them are dead). Or there's Picky[8], which looks like what you'd get if you took Pascal/Oberon and more or less did a transliteration so that the grammar gives you a curly brace language instead of a wordy, shouty one with BEGIN, END, etc.

1. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16253193

2. http://lsub.org/ls/nix.html

3. http://lsub.org/ls/nix.html

4. http://lsub.org/ls/nixbltjabs.pdf

5. http://lsub.org/export/clivesys.pdf

6. http://syssoftware.blogspot.com/2016/02/clives-ink-screensho...

7. https://lsub.org/who/nemo/os.html

8. http://lsub.org/ls/picky.html

carussell··on Introduction to OS Abstractions Using Plan 9 from Bell Labs (2007) [pdf]
Is there a contingent of 9fans doing work on using Plan 9 for DevOps? The fact that doesn't have popular graphical software (or even the same conventions) wouldn't hold it back there. If it's really as well designed and coherent as the praise always makes it seem, it should be an attractive option on the server. So developers can stick with Windows/Mac/Linux on personal machines, and should be deploying to Plan 9 in the cloud, right?
carussell··on Ikea founder Ingvar Kamprad has died
Now you're begging the question. In the original anecdote, we started with something we know based on observation—that very few IKEA products end up in stores selling recycled goods—and are offered the conclusion that this is because they shortly end up in the landfill due to their quality.

However, you've now taken that (flawed) inference and are presenting it as the starting point—as if it were an axiom, rather than the very thing that is in contention.

carussell··on Ikea founder Ingvar Kamprad has died
The original anecdote is that there were very few IKEA items in a store for recycled goods. The point you seem to be ignoring is tjoff's comment that IKEA products are so good that you can resell them and don't have to resort to donating them.

Here's my anecdata:

My desk is made by IKEA. It's sitting in front of me right now, having been disassembled, moved, and reassembled 5 times.

I had an IKEA bed that I got rid of a couple years ago. I ended up doing that by putting it on Craigslist and selling it for cash. I don't remember exactly how long it took, but the turnaround time for the whole thing was super fast.

carussell··on Mozilla Is Hiring a Developer to Work on Thunderbird Full-Time
> My edit in brackets) You meant towards improving Nylas Mail, not Thunderbird?

No. What I wrote is what I meant.

> it sounds like Nylas was reaching out Mozilla to replace Thunderbird with their re-licensed Nylas Mail

Yes. (But not "replace", necessarily. Replace parts. Merge. Improve.)

> I'm not sure that ever happened

Uh, okay? If you hadn't heard that before, that's... fine. But, I mean, now you have. And I don't know what else to say.

> I'm not sure GPL is a totally suitable license for Mozilla Foundation

You're right; it's not. Thunderbird is MPL. They can't accept GPL contributions and continue to make releases available under MPL. That's why I specifically mentioned how Nylas relicensed their code to one that is compatible (MIT).

> I'm fully agree that upstream Thunderbird could clearly indicate their will to move off Gecko

I didn't say move off Gecko. I said dropping XUL. Moving off Gecko is almost definitely not in plans for the short term, and probably not even in the long term.

This conversation has been excruciating.

carussell··on Mozilla Is Hiring a Developer to Work on Thunderbird Full-Time
> Are you implying it somehow is meaningfully different?

I don't know what you're asking. Different from what?

You think the fact that your friends have never heard that Mozilla is a non-profit contradicts what I wrote? I did not say that most people know that Mozilla is a non-profit. I didn't even say that most technical people would know that.

carussell··on Mozilla Is Hiring a Developer to Work on Thunderbird Full-Time
> but turned out by "please use this" they still require you to opt-in with Nylas Identity tied to Nylas Cloud

We're talking about Thunderbird development. When I wrote that they changed to a compatible license and reached out to say "please use this", that's not referring to their attempt to get users. That's a reference to their attempt to donate their code and energy towards improving Thunderbird.

> They could only help replace free (from mail vendors) Thunderbird, playing by the rules of the Thunderbird.

Huh?

carussell··on Mozilla Is Hiring a Developer to Work on Thunderbird Full-Time
Mozilla has always reaped a lot of benefits, PR-wise, out of the impression people form when they hear that it's a non-profit.
carussell··on Update on Pocket and Firefox Integration
1. You're sorry? No you're not. Now that is disingenuous.

2. When responding to a comment about your inability to engage rather than writing out snarky one-liners, choosing to rebut it by replying in the form of a snarky one-liner doesn't do anything to help your case.

3. Respond to the content of my message or fuck off.

carussell··on Extensions in Firefox 59
> Am I missing something

You're not. This was one of jwz's big complaints when he wrote about why he doesn't use Firefox[1] several years back, and nobody has ever fixed it.

1. https://www.jwz.org/blog/2012/04/why-i-use-safari-instead-of...

carussell··on Mozilla Is Hiring a Developer to Work on Thunderbird Full-Time
Sure, but the big thing is the "serious" part. We're basically talking about the patch paradox[1]. At any point in time, someone could have stepped up and made it known they were willing to do the necessary work to move off XUL. But without a similar commitment from upstream to accept a future involving a mail client built on web standard tech, it would be a wasted effort. Heck, Nylas even built their own such email client, relicensed it to a compatible license (GPL -> MIT), reached out to say, "please use this" and ask how they could help, and still nothing happened.

1. https://www.colbyrussell.com/2017/08/06/contributors-dilemma...

carussell··on Update on Pocket and Firefox Integration
DuckDuckGo has some open source extensions and SDKs to integrate with their service. DuckDuckGo itself, however, is not open source. Do you realize how misleading it would be if someone said this, and then I showed up with a link to their open source extensions, and how misleading it would be to try and appear as if I'm refuting something that I'm not actually refuting? That's exactly what you've done here with regard to my comment about Pocket.

There's a reason why nobody else posted the link you did in the 12 hours between my comment and yours, including the dozens of Mozilla/Pocket employees who saw what I wrote. It's because that's not Pocket, and what I wrote about Pocket still not being open source is true.

carussell··on Mozilla Is Hiring a Developer to Work on Thunderbird Full-Time
The most important thing here is that there's now a serious plan in place to move Thunderbird off of XUL and XPCOM. If Thunderbird builds can happen without incurring the expense of building Gecko (and there's no reason that shouldn't be the ultimate goal), then community contributions in the form of code changes would likely increase several times over.
carussell··on Update on Pocket and Firefox Integration
When you read my comments, are you ignoring every fourth sentence or something?

Mozilla is not in a downward spiral due to money. We are not in a situation where Mozilla leadership must decide to jump and hope to survive, or don't jump and be burned alive. Mozilla is in a better financial position than it was 10 years ago; its year-over-year expenses vs support is stable, while in absolute terms they're bringing in much more and have half a billion USD in assets.

carussell··on Update on Pocket and Firefox Integration
The general tone of your two comments is that I've been disingenuous, when the real disservice to the conversation is the zero-effort, thread-derailing snark.

Here's a more verbose way to say exactly the same point I was making, but possibly (hopefully) less susceptible to zero-effort dismissals from the kinds of people who like scoring easy points by taking potshots against auxiliary details instead of taking the main thrust of the argument into consideration:

"Mozilla in 2018 brings in 10 times as much revenue as it did in 2008. Is it 10 times as effective and doing 10 times as much good work? The same as before? Or is it closer to 1/10 for both?"

carussell··on How a fix in Go 1.9 sped up our Gitaly service by 30x
They wouldn't need to stop the world and do a full rewrite. It would be feasible if they stop writing new components in Ruby and began replacing the existing parts piecemeal.
carussell··on Update on Pocket and Firefox Integration
Let's suppose there is no published source to corroborate the statement I wrote. Is the statement ipso facto untrue?

Alternatively, let's say there's a source, but I don't provide it. Does that effect whether my statement is true or not true?

Thirdly, now let's suppose there's a source available, they've measured it, found a result that agrees with what I wrote, and I offer it up. Now what happens? Does that change anything for you? Do you say, "Oh, when I wrote [citation needed] before, what I really meant is that I disagreed with you and was trying to express that through a sideways remark. I've considered the information in the source you provided, though, and have now adjusted my mental model accordingly."

I just want your answers before I invest any significant effort into trawling through data and putting work into a response. Otherwise, it would just be a massive waste of time on my part, right?

carussell··on Update on Pocket and Firefox Integration
> your comment is just anger

As the author of the comment, I don't think so. (And I think my interpretation has more weight.)

> What is your point? Do you care to actually answer my curiosity on what business models besides advertising are available to fund the continuing development of Firefox?

I made it very clear in my original comment. A sustainable model existed 10 years ago—when Firefox was consequently an effective instrument for actually advancing the mission, and the way the project was managed was an example of the right way to run a project. And that model still exists. Since then, though, Mozilla has thrown the mission and principles half out the window while simultaneously asserting a defense that they need to make money.

Hearing this plea after what Mozilla has done is like going to a burger joint you really like and being told that they had to raise prices because all burgers now come with a special ingredient, and the special ingredient is spit.

← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →