HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

carussell

2,674 karma · joined September 22, 2009

I don't HN anymore.
submissionscomments
carussell··on Update on Pocket and Firefox Integration
Someone tries to make this plea in every thread, but it's bunk and shows an ignorance of history, an ignorance of the concrete figures actually at play, and it helps perpetuate the image of a frail non-profit that Mozilla really rides hard, piggybacking on the circumstances and accumulated goodwill from an era that no longer matches reality today.

Mozilla in 2018 brings in 10 times as much revenue as it did in 2008, but is 1/10th as effective and doing 1/10th as much good work.

0307ea7a0f89f4c893e89e6a4992b82b1a812c22e9510410f9e4279a52368d04

carussell··on Update on Pocket and Firefox Integration
> Of course, someone will probably have to audit their code to ensure they really are protecting our privacy

Not doable, because despite declaring (at the time that Mozilla merged with them) that Pocket would become open source, that never happened. To put it another way, we're a month away from the one year anniversary of the date that Mozilla decided to begin operating a closed source, for-profit service.

PS: This is your periodic reminder that the thing you're probably thinking of when you hear the name "Mozilla" actually went away years ago and doesn't exist anymore.[1] It's got the same name and looks kind of the same, like an alien in a human suit, but it's silly to give this any more weight than it deserves. If it helps, think of Mozilla as having undergone a reverse takeover. (It's more complicated than that, and most of it actually predates the Pocket stuff, but if it helps, it helps.)

1. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15940727

carussell··on ActivityPub: decentralized social networking protocol
Last summer I tried untangling the OStatus/pump.io/ActivityPub/ActivityStreams nest hoping to piece together a big picture mental image based mostly on what Wikipedia has to say, and found it mostly frustrating.

For anyone who's similarly curious or confused, LWN published a pretty great overview last month—their "Federation in social networks" article:

https://lwn.net/Articles/741218/

carussell··on 7-Zip: Multiple Memory Corruptions via RAR and ZIP
I don't know what this comment contributes to the conversation besides being vaguely condescending. I didn't ask why an AV product would be re-using 7-zip code.
carussell··on 7-Zip: Multiple Memory Corruptions via RAR and ZIP
Two comments:

The way its written, I first took the mention of finding this "during the analysis of a prominent antivirus product" to mean that you were reverse engineering some AV thing and found that it was scanning for this vulnerability (i.e., to protect against bad archives). After a second read, it seems like maybe not, and that the AV itself re-used parts of 7-zip for its own implementation and was therefore vulnerable itself. Still not sure, though.

The way the stylesheet makes the "rendered" form (especially section headings) resemble markdown source is pretty neat.

carussell··on GitLab 10.4 released
For anyone running this, can you comment? For example, one recurring criticism, before GitLab and the community managed to stamp out the expectation that it would be feasible, was that people were trying to self host a GitLab instance on a cheap SBC (e.g., a Raspberry Pi) or the smallest DigitalOcean plan and were surprised when this wasn't doable, while Gogs and Gitea handle this fine.

So to get a general idea of what sort of setup is expected in order to run a gitbucket instance, if you're running one, what are the relevant details?

carussell··on The Melancholy of Don Bluth (2017)
If you publish an article that uses embedded media, please don't do it like this. Not one of the media embeds in this article is accompanied by anything resembling a useful byline or caption.
carussell··on Thunderbird Starts Working on Improving Its Interface
Everything submitted to addons.mozilla.org gets audited.
carussell··on An Experimental Course on Operating Systems
Haiku, Minoca, SPIN, Fuchsia, etc. If you're actually interested in alternative computing, choices abound.
carussell··on Signal partners with Microsoft to bring end-to-end encryption to Skype
You have a "Portfolio" link in the sidebar that doesn't seem to be for anything, and a broken #contact anchor.
carussell··on Spectre and the end of langsec
It's funny that you mention buffer overflows. An interesting thing to point out—and I'm not sure if anyone has; I've looked before—is that if you follow Meredith Patterson's line of reasoning about langsec for protocols in particular, you end up at the conclusion that C-style, NUL-terminated strings are the right way to do things.

This doesn't mean there aren't other defects in the apparatus where C exploits thrive. It's just that (if you adhere to the langsec school of thought) you are required to confront the conclusion that it's been pinned on the wrong thing.

carussell··on Introducing the new SourceForge
Logan, I just went through the process to create an account. The signup page has a few employment related fields that are required to create an account. They probably shouldn't be.

EDIT: There's also this[1] alignment issue in the settings wrt to "City of residence" where the text field is off by ~1 pixel.

EDIT2: On the page where I uploaded my SSH key[2], it says updates occur after a small delay. The linked page in the docs says that this delay is ~30 minutes. In any case, I was able to begin using SSH immediately. If that info is no longer fresh, I suggest removing it, especially since it's probably a turnoff for a lot of users.

EDIT3: When I run sf-help --web at the shell, it prints an error:

    [colbyrussell@shell-22009 ~]$ sf-help --web
    Use of uninitialized value $user in concatenation (.) or string at /usr/bin/sf-help line 96
1. https://imgur.com/a/2d0lr

2. https://sourceforge.net/auth/shell_services

carussell··on GitMask – Develop Anonymously
I'm not here to defend arguments I never made.
carussell··on GitMask – Develop Anonymously
The person who wrote that post is me.

> Is that like, showing the commits you make on your profile?

Yes.

> Having a page that shows what you've worked on at all?

Yes.

> This seems like good ways to be difficult to work with in open source projects

First, open source doesn't start and end with GitHub.

Second, I prefer not to publish anything to Facebook or Twitter feeds, either. That's a position that folks seem to find palatable. (In fact, it's one that programmers appear to be disproportionately sympathetic to.) I don't see why it shouldn't remain so if the subject of the conversation is GitHub.

> for zero benefit

Opting out of the same kinds of personal broadcasting on GitHub isn't "zero benefit" to me. And if it is zero-benefit, it means the service linked here is zero-value. I feel differently. We don't have to agree.

carussell··on GitMask – Develop Anonymously
If you're creating multiple sockpuppets, then you're violating the GitHub TOS. If you're using a single sockpuppet with the intention of busting up the ability to link your activity, you're limited to a single repo, and possibly a single commit.
carussell··on GitMask – Develop Anonymously
This is cool. I've been looking for an "open relay" to help with collaborating on GitHub-hosted projects that's easier than doing account resets.[1] I'll check it out later.

Side note: the Git project is enforcing the Git trademark now.[2] If you want to use "Git" for your branding, you'll need to get approval.

1. https://www.colbyrussell.com/2016/02/13/keeping-a-low-profil...

2. https://public-inbox.org/git/20170202022655.2jwvudhvo4hmueaw...

carussell··on Under 'Kenyan Time,' You're Expected To Arrive, Oh, Whenever
You focused on the word "game", but the key to the thought lies in the word "opaque".
carussell··on Single Board Computers Introduced in 2017
Previous discussion from last week:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15975229

carussell··on Decentralization Roundup for 2017
Dat doesn't match that description. It has funding from a few different orgs with respectable endowments and is focused on solving real problems for non-tech people trying to share data.

Beaker is interesting because it's enabling things that aren't possible on the HTTP web, and (again) focusing on making it stupid easy for non-tech people do things. Meanwhile, the major browser vendors' idea of forward motion amounts to working on things that web developers can use to impress other web developers and maintaining existing barriers to entry.

carussell··on Apple Autocorrects Names of Some Medications to Names of Different Medications
This is reminiscent (in scope for errors, not mechanism) as the problem from a few years back with the Xerox machines that would alter the text of copies:

http://www.dkriesel.com/en/blog/2013/0802_xerox-workcentres_...

https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2013/08/confu...

carussell··on GitPlex – browse code in Git repository like in IDE
Sourcegraph is also working on a similar service.

Also: unless you've okayed the name with the Git folks, you're going to need to change the name. Git is trademarked, and they are no longer allowing just anyone to use the mark without first seeking permission. (GitHub, GitLab, and others have been grandfathered in.)

See https://public-inbox.org/git/20170202022655.2jwvudhvo4hmueaw...

carussell··on Google Maps' Moat
> No love for OpenStreetMaps here?

Last year, when SVP of Engineering at Google left for Uber, I suggested[1] here on HN that Uber getting into mapping (for exactly the reasons in the article) with OSM would be mutually beneficial (in the same way as outlined in another comment from today[2]). It didn't get a warm response. (IIRC, at first it was even downvoted into the gray.)

1. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13447070

2. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15968077

carussell··on A plan to rescue the Web from the Internet
> It should have had protocol-level technologies for preserving historic data, for search, for offline use, for authoring and publishing. [...] He was talking about the lack of protocol-level solutions for resilience of the Web.

That's completely at odds with what Kay actually advocates for. His position is strongly aligned with the "mechanism, not policy" philosophy. That is, what he advocates for is less of what you want, not more. This is apparent from that Dr Dobbs interview, his work with VPRI, back to his OOPSLA speech in 1997. To wit:

> HTML on the Internet has gone back to the dark ages, because it presupposes that there should be a browser that should understand its formats. [...] You don't need a browser if you followed what this staff sergeant in the Air Force knew how to do in 1961. Just read it in, it should travel with all the things that it needs, and you don't need anything more complex than something like X Windows.

Kay has always sat on the diametrically opposite site of the table as those favoring the Principle of Least Power—one of the most underappreciated tenets of computing. Tim Berners-Lee called it out in Axioms of Web Architecture:

> At the other end of the scale is the weather information portrayed by the cunning Java applet. While this might allow a very cool user interface, it cannot be analyzed at all. The search engine finding the page will have no idea of what the data is or what it is about. The only way to find out what a Java applet means is to set it running in front of a person.

You can get a better view of what a world that more closely adhered to Kay's vision would look like in Stanislav's (an adherent's) post, "No Formats, No Wars": http://www.loper-os.org/?p=309

carussell··on Firefox is on a slippery slope
It's surprising that people are surprised by these things. Mozilla is not on a slippery slope. That was true years ago, but it proceeded unmitigated. By now, though, these things are the natural result of that decay.

There's a lot of power in branding, apparently. People keep saying things like, "Mozilla is a good company at heart", and I'm at a loss. Mozilla 2017 is nothing like the Mozilla that existed when the Foundation was established, or when the Mozilla Manifesto was adopted. Tons of key people left in a few different waves: first when Google pulled them off the project to go build Chrome, and then lots more who trickled out over the years during and after the Kovacs/FirefoxOS era. What remains is (a derivative of) the codebase + the name "Mozilla" + and, like, Mitchell. But that's it. Keep calling it the same thing, though, and somehow folks act like we're talking about the same thing.

Mozilla imploded—or rather, got Netscapified—years ago. To believe that Mozilla or Firefox is your old friend who's still helping you fight the good fight is incredibly naive and can only come from someone who hasn't actually been paying attention and is easily fooled by (trivially contradicted) surface-level details (like a name). I mean, it's not even like some philosophically tricky ship-of-Theseus problem. Mozilla is dead, people, and this isn't news.

carussell··on Comcast to Customer Who Noticed Secretly Injected Code: Maybe It’s Your Fault
There are good reasons to oppose what Comcast is doing. It would be nice if we could focus on those then, instead of the kinds of responses that have been appearing. The latter are not just unlikely to get anything to change, but are probably detrimental. The type of intellectual dishonesty present in the article, its headline, and peanut galleries like HN is the sort of thing that could end up inoculating folks like jlivingood on the Comcast end against worthwhile parts of public criticism.
carussell··on Accident Forgiveness Comes to GPLv2
For anyone wondering about the image in the header with a stylized Stallman as a Vishnu-like being, it's from Hackaday staff artist Joe Kim.

http://theartofjoekim.tumblr.com/

carussell··on High-Level Problems with Git and How to Fix Them
I do consider the LKML-centric use case. (Often—probably more often than most.) No such realization is setting in. How about you elaborate?
carussell··on High-Level Problems with Git and How to Fix Them
This is one of the few things that Launchpad got right. jquery, for example, would be at launchpad.net/jquery, and your own work would hang off of that. GitHub went with inverted namespaces (user/repo) instead, where every personal fork is an island unto itself, and the world is worse off for it.

I had hope that GitLab would take the opportunity to fix most of the problems GitHub introduced (or at least a few), but they seem to be interested in just copying the mistakes and chasing the market segment made up of people who's only criteria begins and ends with like GitHub, but on-prem.

carussell··on High-Level Problems with Git and How to Fix Them
Partial commits through piecemeal staging is great as a poweruser's tool, like rebase. But it's beyond weird that anyone thought it was a good idea to make people deal with staging for every commit.

It doesn't even have to go away. (And on that note, I'm bummed that the conclusion in the article is to do that, especially because everytime this comes up, there's an uproar.) But, jeez. Just tuck it away so futzing with it is an opt-in decision for the 5% of the time that you need to make sure you aren't committing all of your changes. (And on note #2, if a person is doing partially staged changes more often than that, my question is why? What kind of chaotic, stream-of-consciousness style of development leads to that, and is it even producing good results? It doesn't take especially careful planning to not end up in the scenarios where partially committed changes is the answer.)

carussell··on Comcast is injecting 400+ lines of JavaScript into web pages
> I don't think I twisted or misrepresented anything, and no one seems to be suggesting the anything was actually misrepresented

No, that is what I'm suggesting. Your comment reads as a quote. After reading it, I went to the linked page and looked around for the context. Turns out, there was no context for that quote, because it's not a quote, because those words aren't actually in the original text.

← PreviousPage 4 of 34Next →