HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

cassowary

95 karma · joined April 15, 2016

submissionscomments
cassowary··on The Collapse of the Unix Philosophy
I don't think this is a fair criticism of the text.

However good Unix might have been in the 1970s, why am I still running it on my mobile phone? How good is it today? It seems that the major argument in its favor is legacy.

(Honestly, it seems to me that most of his criticisms could be moved away from stepwise. I'm guessing most of the configuration on my phone is stored in binary files. Someone could write the object-wise commandline utils he wants, and then create the architecture to make them more efficient. We could move there. Should we?)

cassowary··on Vim's 25th anniversary and the release of Vim 8
I've set my capslock to be escape and my alt to be control. I don't know where my alt is, but I've never really used it. (I think the only usecase for alt is Alt-Tab to switch windows, but that always feels epically unpredictable to me. What's going to happen? ... I prefer just clicking on the window I want).
cassowary··on Elm from a Business Perspective
Hi leshow, can you be more concrete? If I have a record

  `data Foo = Foo {fooA :: Text, fooB :: Text}`
then I must write a method `show :: Foo -> Text` for it. It is immaterial if I write

  `instance Show Foo where`
  `   show foo = (... implementation ...)`
or

  `shooFoo foo = (... implementation..)`
I save no code with typeclasses (at this point at least). (I do save code with the magic "deriving", but that's not part of the typesystem; it's just the compiler implicitly generating a bit of code for me.)

Likewise, map operations, fold. They need to be written and used.

I'm sceptical of Elm's claim that typeclasses aren't useful, but your post doesn't show what it sets out to, because it lacks concreteness.

Out of your post, it is only when you get to function composition that typeclasses can theoretically help — but the question isn't, can they theoretically help, it's do the help in practice.

So can you show some example? To meet the challenge and provide convincing evidence that a language without typeclasses is lacking, you would need to say "This is what the code is. And this is what it could be with typeclasses". Unless you do that, Noredink's claim that their code wouldn't be simplified with typeclasses stands.

I do not think you are obliged to do this. It is perfectly legitimate for you to ignore my message. But I think both sides can agree that this is what would be convincing to the anti-typeclassists.

cassowary··on You can’t fix diversity in tech without fixing the technical interview
"It's clear men are more accustomed to being rejected."

No it's not. Do you have any evidence for your claim? or just anecdote and stereotype?

cassowary··on Ooh Ooh My Turn Why Lisp? (2008)
I just discovered Turtle yesterday, a library for Haskell. Obviously I haven't used it much in that time, but superficially it looks amazing.

See http://hackage.haskell.org/package/turtle-1.0.0/docs/Turtle-... and http://www.haskellforall.com/2015/01/use-haskell-for-shell-s...

Here's an example:

  #!/usr/bin/env runhaskell

  {-# LANGUAGE OverloadedStrings #-}

  import Turtle

  main = do
      cd "/tmp"
      mkdir "test"
      output "test/foo" "Hello, world!"  -- Write "Hello, world!" to "test/foo"
      stdout (input "test/foo")          -- Stream "test/foo" to stdout
      rm "test/foo"
      rmdir "test"
      sleep 1
      die "Urk!"

Haskell is strongly typed: the first argument of `output` is a `FilePath`; the second is a `Text`. In some respects, strongly typed is the opposite of power tho, because there's all these things you can do, like accidentally (or deliberately) pass a Text to a function expected a FilePath without translating it first.
cassowary··on The Apple Goes Mushy Part II: OS X's Interface Decline
"The argument isn't about aesthetics, it's about functionality, a reduction in ease of use."

this. the problem is the functionality is the visual appearance of the system, so they hire visual artists who think in terms of aesthetics, not design engineers who think in terms functionality and easy of use.

cassowary··on There Is No Distinctly Scientific Method
Karl Popper or Carl Sagan? I actually don't know the latter's views very well, but I very much get the impression that he popularised a Popperian view of science in a way that Saganites simply can't get past.

A lot of people who think themself scientific and modern independent thinkers simply regurgitate what they learnt from scientific and modern independent thinkers.

cassowary··on There Is No Distinctly Scientific Method
I disagree. You've described a very good way of actually conducting science, which would probably be more reliable than the way we've been doing it. You italicised "disprove" in your earlier post because you know that when people do science, they don't try and disprove their own view. At best, they come up with experiments designed to disprove someone else's view. In reality scientists are searching for data that can be comfortably explained in terms of their view but which cannot be so comfortably explained in terms of competing views.

But the thing about science is, that even though people are doing it wrong, it still works. Science is somehow robust even to such fundamental mistakes, that it ceases to be science.

Then again, we might have spent the last century or so building a completely false model of the universe because our technique is wrong, because we haven't actually been conducting science according to the sort of definition you give. It's worth considering, but I doubt it's true.

cassowary··on Can Capitalism Be Redeemed?
But can you have free markets if corporations are permitted to influence the government? It seems impossible; humans will be influenced by those with whom they have contact.

So the alternative is to prohibit corporations from lobbying government, but that would be tantamount to removing legal personality from corporations and it is questionable whether the result is a free market system. You would also need to remove the right of people to lobby on behalf of groups of other people, and it is questionable whether the resulting system is free at all, or in any ways desirable.

The system that we have approaches free market capitalism as well as a liberal system can.

cassowary··on Can computers become conscious?: My reply to Roger Penrose
People aren't useful. Hammers are useful. It seems hard to go from useful -> intelligence, and hard to go from intelligent -> conscious.
cassowary··on Do you live in a bubble? A quiz
i think the interesting thing about the oceanographers is that they say that if you are in the water, that means you're not in a bubble, it's only the air and some other gases that might be in a bubble.

the question is how much have you interacted with what's normal in America based on population numbers, not how much you've interacted with diverse groups.

also note their target audience. it's a pbs website. it's so far deep inside the bubble it probably couldn't get out if it worked on a factory floor for a year

← PreviousPage 3 of 3