HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

chad_oliver

869 karma · joined September 22, 2010

submissionscomments
chad_oliver··on Two days in an underwater cave running out of oxygen
I'm not sure I agree. Children don't ask to be born, and they don't get to agree to that trade-off. Parents are responsible for the children they bring into the world.

That said, parents don't always get a choice. Sometimes pregnancy is unplanned or even unwanted. I'm not sure how much moral responsibility parents bear in this case, but this scenario illustrates that the issue of responsibility isn't always black and white.

chad_oliver··on Chinese umbrella-sharing startup loses most of its 300,000 umbrellas in 3 months
Was that meant to be parody? That's an honest question; I'm not sure whether you're serious or not.
chad_oliver··on Amazon to Build a Permanent Mary's Place Family Shelter Within Its Headquarters
He explicitly doesn't assume that:

> I swear I'm not (a) claiming this is necessarily in reality the case

chad_oliver··on Biggest Spike in Traffic Deaths in 50 Years? Blame Apps
New Zealand too. If you want to make calls while driving, you have to have a hands-free system. It baffles my mind that there are countries in which people can legally interact with their phone while driving.
chad_oliver··on Snapchat Passes Twitter in Daily Usage
But that's exactly the point. Search volume isn't the same thing as usage.
chad_oliver··on SpaceX Falcon rocket explodes on landing after delivering satellite to space
You have to accelerate the rocket back to the launchpad if you want to land on solid ground -- there's no convenient landmasses at the right distance. That takes fuel.
chad_oliver··on Urban highways destroy wealth
What problem were they meant to solve?

(That's a serious question. I'm interesting in hearing how other people view the purpose of an urban highway.)

chad_oliver··on Transatlantic divide: how U.S. pays three times more for drugs
I live in New Zealand, which has a centralised purchasing agency for pharmaceuticals (called Pharmac). The TPP doesn't require New Zealand to disband Pharmac. It can still negotiate reduced prices on behalf of the Kiwi public. The only change is that there is a more rigorous feedback and appeal process, which seems perfectly reasonable to me.
chad_oliver··on Need a Kidney? Not Iranian? You’ll Wait
Why not? That's a serious question; I'd love to hear your opinion.

It seems to me that if they freely consent to sell their kidney, then they'll only do it because it's a better option than not doing it. Sure, in a perfect world everyone would have enough money to survive, and there would be no need for this. But is it really ethical to deny them options?

chad_oliver··on Leaked: What's in TPP’s intellectual property chapter
Perhaps, but there is no way that the TPP is going to produce at 10% increase in GDP per capita. I'm generally supportive of free trade agreements, but in the case of the TPP, all the low-hanging economic fruit has already been picked. There are no significant remaining trade barriers that can be removed to generate quick growth.
chad_oliver··on An Incredibly Detailed Map of Europe's Population Shifts
Why would anyone ever want that? Because people have different opinions about what is best. You are absolutely entitled to think that a more populous Ireland would be a bad thing, but you're being downvoted because you can't seem to see that that's just a personal preference, not an absolute truth.

Personally, I live in New Zealand (population: 4.5 million), and I'd strongly prefer it if we had twice as many people. A bigger population can sustain a healthier economy, with more opportunities for everyone. However, I'm well aware that I'm an outlier; most people think differently and I respect that.

chad_oliver··on Going undercover as a sex worker
You might want to read the execute summary of this report [0]. It was produced by a panel whom the New Zealand government commissioned to examine the effect of legalising prostitution in New Zealand. The results are perhaps more ambiguous than anyone would like, but at least you know that the report isn't politically slanted.

(For a little bit of context: prostitution became legal in New Zealand in 2003.)

[0] http://www.justice.govt.nz/policy/commercial-property-and-re...

chad_oliver··on College Is Much More Than a Means to a Higher Salary
New Zealand seems to be similar, with the added bonus that we only have a handful of universities so there is no distinction between 'good universities' and 'the rest'.
chad_oliver··on Churchill’s disaster – Gallipoli
I think you're confusing external identity (how other countries see us) with national identity (how we see ourselves). Gallipoli was hugely influential in defining how New Zealanders and Australians thought of themselves and their nation. It was our coming of age, the moment when we started to see ourselves as nations rather than colonies.

(Of course, that description is a little bit exaggerated: I'm sure reality was much fuzzier and messier. But that just proves the point that Gallipoli has become our national myth. It defines us now, even if it didn't really define us then.)

chad_oliver··on Latin America Is Quitting Smoking, and Africa Is Taking It Up
Australia and New Zealand are very much part of the West, because that label is far more about cultural and political alignment, rather than geography. New Zealand and Australia are just as 'European' as Canada or the USA.
chad_oliver··on Stack Free Recursion (1995)
As you probably know, the stack is made up of stack frames, and a stack frame is added each time you go 'deeper' by calling another function. A stack frame is removed every time you get to the end of a function and return. So, yes, the stack is closely linked to the depth of function calls.

However, in modern systems (or basically anything you'll ever see today, including the cheapest microcontrollers), the stack doesn't just keep track of where to return to after each function completes. It also stores all the local variables used by the function. This is vital because it allows the variables to be restored after you return from a 'deeper' function. A convenient side effect is that when the function completes and the frame is popped off the stack, the references to the local references are destroyed and the data can be garbage-collected.

In this sense, local variables are directly related to stack frames. If your system doesn't store local variables in the stack frame, it almost certainly doesn't store them anywhere else (stack frames are the natural place for them), and you've only got globals to work with.

chad_oliver··on If you traveled back in time to 1975 equipped with a modern laptop...
Yeah, I love that problem. If you want the maximum effect with the minimum effort, introducing the printing press would be a good move. However, technological change isn't really sufficient -- to do the most good, you'd need to have a strong grasp of economics, politics, medicine, the sciences, and (of course) most fields of technology.
chad_oliver··on How can an introvert Asian engineer like me make friends?
The best way to make friends is to find some sport or social club and join in. Friendships should develop over time, as you see people frequently in a relaxed setting.

A good idea here is to join a social sports team -- in New Zealand I'd recommend you play rugby, but I don't know what you play in America.

If you don't like sport, that's cool. Just find something that you're interested in, and find some pre-existing group of people that is formed around this common interest, and join in.

chad_oliver··on Why we're suing the CIA
It may not be directly associated to the democratic process for electing a government, but I think you'll find that it's still closely related to democracy in general.

Democracy is fundamentally anchored on the idea that the legitimate right to govern derives from the people, not from the sword or from the blessing of a priest. This means that governments exist to serve the people, not the other way around. The freedoms of the constitution derive from this principle.

chad_oliver··on Absolute Zero
Also:

"A chunk of helium ice would behave as a single, solid, oversized, and stupefyingly slippery atom, which may be capable of passing ghost-like through certain materials. But that's another matter altogether."

chad_oliver··on What Do Animals See in a Mirror?
To be fair, a visual mirror is just a special type of wall.
chad_oliver··on How not to respond to Heartbleed – CBA, an Australian bank (read the comments)
Yeah, but the bank cares about its image.
chad_oliver··on What Happened to Canada?
Why not? You've made a bold statement, but provided no reasons.
chad_oliver··on This girl in SF stole my MacBook Air
Yes, but those two aspects of their culture are totally orthogonal. Why can't we build a society where we have the former and not the latter?
chad_oliver··on European Parliament passes net neutrality law
To be fair, trade between European countries has increased by orders of magnitude since WW1, and that remains true even after you account for general economic growth.
chad_oliver··on European Parliament passes net neutrality law
WW1 was an Austro-hungarian civil war at its heart. It spiraled out of control because we didn't have the system we have today.
chad_oliver··on Windows on Devices
April fools?
chad_oliver··on Challenge HN: Keep lame April Fools' gags off the front page
I'm not sure I agree in this case. The Oxford English Dictionary gives ones of the definitions of guy as 'people of either sex' [0]. There's value in defending this meaning, and not running away from it because it could be misinterpreted. This is similar to how geeks like to defend the positive definition of 'hacker', rather than avoiding it.

To be clear: I'm not trying to minimize the feelings of women or other marginalized communities. Rather, I'm just saying that one way to respond is to aggressively 'colonize' words so that a positive meaning becomes the dominant meaning.

[0] http://www.oxforddictionaries.com/definition/english/guy

chad_oliver··on Turkey blocks use of Twitter after prime minister attacks social media site
It seems that Erdogan reads religious freedom as "right to be as Islamic as one wishes." Of course, they're both valid outcomes of religious freedom, but it makes a big difference to those who use religious freedom as an excuse to move the country in a particular direction.
chad_oliver··on If Singapore is the most expensive city, then why Redmond costs more?
> in Singapore, a new Toyota Camry costs almost US$150,000

Wait, what? Surely that's a typo! If not, what makes it so expensive?

← PreviousPage 2 of 11Next →