HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

charles-salvia

618 karma · joined December 29, 2016

I develop software that works sometimes.
submissionscomments
charles-salvia··on Kurzweil Claims That the Singularity Will Happen by 2029
The problem with all these claims is that the term "singularity" implies, to most people, a sudden change after which civilization will be radically altered. I guess we'll wake up one morning and just start bowing down to our AI overlords.

Except realistically, how is this supposed to happen? Just because somebody runs ./ai_overlord on some linux box, or some VM cloud, doesn't mean that this AI suddenly somehow magically has insane industrial capacity. It can't necessarily network with all the physical infrastructure and vehicles to start carrying out goals. It's existence is limited to the various RAM chips of a digital network. It will take much longer before an AGI can actually even have a major physical impact on the world.

Also, intelligence is not magic. There are certain mathematical limits to intelligence. An AGI cannot solve the halting problem or compute the Kolmogorov complexity of some data. It can't suddenly build any physical object from raw materials without a huge amount of infrastructural work being setup in advance.

And let's not forget that human beings are also Turing complete. Which means, in theory, anything an AGI can do, we can also do. The main difference is that an AGI would be able to computationally solve problems at much greater speeds than a human. But it's totally unclear to me if this somehow translates into a sudden complete overhaul of all of our civilizational infrastructure overnight. Frankly, that doesn't seem likely. I think it's more likely the first AGIs will just trade derivatives or recommend Netflix queues.

charles-salvia··on Kurzweil Claims That the Singularity Will Happen by 2029
But we don't really know of any better models right now.
charles-salvia··on Into the woods: how one man survived alone in the wilderness for 27 years
I don't understand why this guy is particularly more interesting or amazing than the countless other homeless people who have survived in our inner-cities for decades. The only thing that makes this guy different is the superficial aspects : the setting is more rustic, there's no drugs or begging involved, he lives in a forest instead of in an abandoned subway line, etc.

In some ways, this guy actually had a much easier time surviving than many of the inner-city homeless. He essentially had access to a low-security, well-stocked resort town in rural Maine - entirely to himself with no other criminal competition and a very small police force to worry about. He didn't have to worry about getting killed by other desperate homeless people or by police, or having to constantly search for a different place to sleep every night.

Also, he wasn't even forced into homelessness. He just made a willful decision to live this kind of parasitic lifestyle. Perhaps he was mentally ill in some way, but regardless, I can't be particularly sympathetic without further information about his motivations.

charles-salvia··on Into the woods: how one man survived alone in the wilderness for 27 years
This isn't that different from what many other homeless people on the fringes of cities/towns accomplish. They setup some kind of make-shift shelter, and subsist via varying degrees of cleverness, begging or charity. The only difference with this guy is he never begged (he just stole), and the setting was slightly more rustic than usual. But for some reason people read this story and desperately try to make it more than it is, by awkwardly infusing this "wilderness survivalist" aspect into it, which really doesn't reflect what actually happened at all.
charles-salvia··on Into the woods: how one man survived alone in the wilderness for 27 years
This story... doesn't really strike me as that worthy of contemplating for too long. Really, how is this guy really particularly different from someone who is basically just homeless? I mean, instead of living on the outskirts of summer resort towns in Maine, he could be homeless living on the outskirts of Bayonne, New Jersey, sifting through trash or breaking into 7-11s at night. The whole "into the woods" thing is sort of almost beside the point here. The guy didn't actually live as some sort of pre-Columbian hunter-gatherer. He was just basically a homeless guy who robbed houses. I'm not sure why anyone thinks we can learn something from him... other than, perhaps, how to break into houses.
charles-salvia··on Why Online Dating Sucks for Men (2013)
How is this different from the default state of Western culture for the past century? Despite many positive social changes towards more equal opportunities for women, socially speaking, Western culture is still very traditional in terms of the common expectations surrounding the "courtship" dynamic between a man and a woman. The man is still expected to initiate and drive the interaction, while the woman is expected to be more passive about it. This is how it is off the Internet as well - women are routinely approached by men at bars/nightclubs etc., but it rarely happens the other way around. So why would online dating be any different?
charles-salvia··on Is Facebook a Structural Threat to Free Society?
http://www.naver.com/
charles-salvia··on Is Facebook a Structural Threat to Free Society?
Google essentially has an entire monopoly on how information enters our brains. They exert complete control over Internet search for almost everyone on Earth outside of China, Russia and South Korea. Granted, Google is not exclusively controlled by a single individual in the same way Facebook is, but the same argument made in this article could be or could have been made about numerous absurdly influential companies throughout recent history.
charles-salvia··on The line is blurring between city and suburb
So, I have to wonder: if this trend actually continues (and I hope it does), could this be a factor that helps curtail climate change to some degree? I realize that we will most likely inevitably suffer major damages at this point no matter what, but I'm wondering if trends like this (along with the rise of better battery technology and electric cars) will at least mitigate the damage to some extent.

I mean, currently NYC has a ridiculously low carbon foot-print for its population size. So if more places become dense population centers with public transportation like NYC, it can only be a positive thing in terms of mitigating climate change.

charles-salvia··on The line is blurring between city and suburb
I agree - the suburbs are really depressing.
charles-salvia··on Physical location of live stream found using flights patterns and astronomy
> Person sees the dimensions of the rooms via the live stream. Runs over Google maps and finds all buildings with those dimensions.

I don't follow. Google maps would only help if the entire building was like one room. The live stream could be inside some closet in a skyscraper with 57 floors. You'd need a searchable database of the blueprints of every building for this to work.

charles-salvia··on Troubled covert agency responsible for trucking nuclear bombs across America
> There doesn't appear to be a consistent theory as to why we aren't all dead from nukes.

Probably because launching a nuclear attack doesn't benefit nation states, if other nation states also have nuclear weapons. Also, all large high GDP nation states currently have intertwined economic dependencies, which also makes it less likely they would be inclined to launch nukes at each other.

Obviously, at the moment, North Korea stands out as a potential exception here, but they have nowhere near the number of warheads or industrial capacity to even play on the MAD doctrine level - they're certainly far from becoming anything like the next USSR.

So the only really remaining scenarios that could lead to a nuclear attack (barring massive changes in the current geopolitical order) would be that some non-nation-state actor, perhaps with fanatical motivations, gains access to a nuclear weapon. Although, in this case, without the state infrastructure to actually launch multiple warheads at the same time, it's unlikely that such an attack would be in any sense civilization-ending (even though it would certainly be very devastating, of course).

charles-salvia··on Both geniuses and madmen pay attention to what others ignore
Because the set of criminals used in the research are confirmed psychopaths, so it's the only way to conduct such a study. You cannot round up Hedge Fund managers for such a study. But this also makes what you're saying somewhat non-falsifiable. Highly successful people basically are extremely driven and ambitious, and they work all the time. (I'm assuming you relate to this.) But there is no evidence (as far as I know) correlating tendencies to be extremely ambitious, and psychopathic tendencies such as inability to feel empathy. Although, obviously, tendencies associated with both things may overlap, since a very ambitious person is more likely to appear very selfish to an outside observer.

Also, many actual confirmed geniuses like Einstein, Alan Turing, etc. clearly were simply obsessed (which is really just a more negative way of saying "very enthusiastic") about their work - they didn't necessarily care to become powerful men (Einstein famously turned down the Presidency of Israel because it was boring to him). These people were just really, really interested in the problems they were working on. This seems to intersect better with something like OCD rather than psychopathy - and indeed, there are of course many anecdotes around Princeton University of Einstein exhibiting OCD tendencies.

charles-salvia··on Was object-oriented programming a failure? (2015)
People sometimes think that OOP means "OOP or Nothing!" probably because of the popularity of languages that enforce such a mentality (i.e. basically because Java).
charles-salvia··on Both geniuses and madmen pay attention to what others ignore
As much as some of us might feel some misguided excitement over the idea of being some kind of tech savvy Hannibal Lecter, the reality is that there is no real correlation between psychopathy and intelligence (perhaps even a negative correlation.)

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/16178679

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23551975

http://www.soc.iastate.edu/staff/delisi/Hannibal%20Lecter%20...

In other words, psychopathic people aren't necessarily smarter. In fact, contrary to the Hollywood idea of the "super-intelligent serial killer", most actual serial killers were basically kind of idiots who got caught in stupid ways, with a few notable exceptions.

It's also hard to read anything Einstein (an actual genius) wrote and conclude the man was bereft of warmth and empathy.

charles-salvia··on Virtual Reality Poses the Same Riddles as the Cosmic Multiverse
No, what you're saying is that the simulation would mess with our observations - but our basic logical axioms are not dependent on observations to be valid - that's why they're axioms! They are used as valid starting points in reasoning, and nothing the simulation does could change that.
charles-salvia··on Virtual Reality Poses the Same Riddles as the Cosmic Multiverse
I think you're asking, if we took all the matter in the Universe and converted it into a giant computer, would we be able to fully simulate our own Universe?

I think the answer is that if our Universe is currently, say, nested N levels deep in a simulation hierarchy, the Universe we currently observe may appear much more vast than it actually is, but since the speed of information is limited, we could never prove this. So while the number of estimated atoms in the observable Universe is something like 4×10^79, the actual number of simulated particles may be far, far less. Certainly, the information that comes to us via the light from distant galaxies is incredibly coarse grained and time-lagged, and if we're in a simulation it may well be that no finer grained representation actually exists (assuming there are no observers in those galaxies).

I don't actually know if I believe the simulation argument, and all of this is currently (perhaps forever) non-falsifiable. By the time we're able to even send an observer to some distant galaxy ~5 billion light years away, the Universe would have expanded even more, making the galaxy even further away. But the limitations imposed on the speed of information via light cones seems to make it very computationally feasible to simulate a Universe that appears much larger and detailed than it actually is. So in other words, the inhabitants of Universe at level N of the simulation hierarchy should be able to simulate a lower-entropy coarse approximation of their Universe at level N + 1, that would be indistinguishable from Universe N to the simulated inhabitants of N + 1, provided that sufficient restrictions on the speed of information and the number of observers is enforced.

But intuitively it seems there should be a limitation here, in that as N increases the level of nested computational resources available would need to decrease, until you hit a low entropy "leaf Universe". But that doesn't really affect the probabilistic angle of the simulation argument.

charles-salvia··on Virtual Reality Poses the Same Riddles as the Cosmic Multiverse
No you could use more coarse grained representations of distant objects or less frequently observed objects. If our Universe is a simulation, for example, given that the speed of information is limited, there's no reason to completely simulate, say, whatever is happening in the Andromeda galaxy right now. If we send an observer there, the simulation could just lazily produce more fine-grained renderings.
charles-salvia··on Virtual Reality Poses the Same Riddles as the Cosmic Multiverse
Because the word "religion" has different semantic connotations. Just because I propose a question that has no falsifiable answer does not mean I have suddenly invented a religion. If I start actually marketing my non-falsifiable answers to you, then you could say I am on the road to making it into a religion.
charles-salvia··on Virtual Reality Poses the Same Riddles as the Cosmic Multiverse
More or less yes - unless the simulation itself is auto-generated by some other mindless program. (In which case we can eventually find God recursively.)
charles-salvia··on Virtual Reality Poses the Same Riddles as the Cosmic Multiverse
A Turing-machine based simulated reality certainly would have been incomprehensible, but pre-20th century philosophers have thought about the idea of the world not being "real" in some sense. I would even conjecture that the universal experience of dreaming, and the fact that we often can't tell when we're dreaming, would have probably inspired this line of thought going back possibly even pre-homo sapiens.

Of course, Plato's cave is the most famous writing about the idea of a "simulated" reality from antiquity, in the sense that it discusses the idea that prisoners who spent their entire lives in a cave would assume that the cave they see is the only reality.

charles-salvia··on Virtual Reality Poses the Same Riddles as the Cosmic Multiverse
> But if that’s the case, we run into a paradox. The argument for living in a simulation is based on the laws of physics and logic. But if we are living a simulation, we can’t trust those laws, so we have no basis to conclude we are living in a simulation.

This is borderline nonsensical. The "laws of logic" (i.e. law of identity/non-contradiction, or propositional logic), are universal axioms that would not change regardless of whether we're in a simulation or not. The "laws of physics" could change, i.e. certain cosmological variables could be tweaked, but this wouldn't affect our ability to reason about things like this.

charles-salvia··on Are They Slim Yet? Firefox, Chrome, IE, Safari
The problem with Chrome/Chromium is it's basically just a huge ton of scaffolding designed to layer an IPC framework on top of more layers of scaffolding on top of more layers that wrap blink (i.e. WebKit) which still has lots of code going back to KDE from the 90s.

The Chromium codebase has no less than 5 different string classes, is riddled with layers and layers of virtual function calls wrapping older interfaces, has an antiquated threading model that defines a "Main thread" because various ancient WebKit code scattered throughout the code base relies on global variables, etc.

It's pretty surprising to me that it works as well as it does.

charles-salvia··on Is It Better to Be Poor in Bangladesh or the Mississippi Delta?
> The Electoral College doesn't 'reduce the weight of votes coming from inner-cities and urban areas'; it allocates votes to states in roughly proportion to population.

It does reduce the weight of votes coming from inner cities, because it does not allocate votes proportionally all the time. The disparity occurs most obviously between the high populated states like New York, California, and Texas, compared with very low-population states like Montana or Wyoming. I live in New York, so my individual vote is worth less than someone living in Wyoming or Montana.

charles-salvia··on Is It Better to Be Poor in Bangladesh or the Mississippi Delta?
You're right - the 80% is exaggerated. I got it from https://www.census.gov/geo/reference/ua/urban-rural-2010.htm.... Their definition of "urban" is actually outlandish, in that it includes "urban clusters", which means towns that have > 2,500 and < 50,000 inhabitants. I assumed the 80% just included all the sprawling, dense suburbs, but I see the definition the census is using here is much looser.
charles-salvia··on Oh, you’re with them? (2016)
If you trained a neural network to recognize "high powered tech executives", it will likely start picking up on features associated with 30 to 40 year old (mostly white) males wearing sweaters or "business casual" attire. It probably would report a low value if you showed it a minority female. (Google "tech executive" on Google images to test this out.)

Human beings are really advanced neural networks, trained on years of sensory data, along with lots of bias factors. This is why things like sexism and racism are often self-perpetuating. People aren't used to commonly seeing a female, minority woman in a high position, so they don't expect it, and therefore that expectation becomes part of their bias in the future.

There are only two solutions:

(1) Do things to create more minority female tech executives, so we all expect it.

(2) Do things to make people better at hiding their biases.

Obviously, we need to do both if this situation is ever going to change.

charles-salvia··on Is It Better to Be Poor in Bangladesh or the Mississippi Delta?
It's a bit more complicated. Inner-city populations heavily vote Democrat, along with most densely populated areas. In fact, something like ~80% of Americans live in urban areas (which also includes dense suburbs), and therefore we should expect Democrats to win elections most of the time (even in spite of the fact that some dense sub-urban areas heavily lean Republican). However, this doesn't happen in practice because the electoral college system heavily reduces the weight of votes coming from inner-cities and urban areas, and also excludes votes coming from urban areas that lie within a larger, Republican-leaning state. For example, in the last election, probably most people in Philadelphia voted for Clinton, but their votes were nullified because the state over-all went to Trump.

So inner-city populations can't reliably make themselves heard on the national level via Presidential elections.

charles-salvia··on Is It Better to Be Poor in Bangladesh or the Mississippi Delta?
Well, Donald Trump matters. And he thought about them. And this is where we are.
charles-salvia··on Is It Better to Be Poor in Bangladesh or the Mississippi Delta?
I would say it's counter-productive - but at least a direct causal line can be drawn between slavery and the current lower average socio-economic status of black people in the US. Whereas, there is absolutely no causal line between the current plight of poor white people and Mexican immigrants/Islamic terrorism.
charles-salvia··on Is It Better to Be Poor in Bangladesh or the Mississippi Delta?
I think a lot of the resentment felt by the rural American poor has to do with their perception that they are constantly ignored or overlooked, while similarly impoverished inner-city minorities are at least given some kind of institutional sympathy. It's hard to say how true this really is, or how much of it is simply further fuel for pre-existing racism, but apparently this perception is ubiquitous enough that it can be leveraged to win national elections.

I will say the events of the last year have definitely opened my eyes to the situation. The thing I've noticed is that it actually is harder to sympathize with the white, rural poor than it is with the inner-city minorities, at least for me - even though I want to sympathize and I acknowledge their suffering is probably more or less equal to the inner-city minority poor. I suppose the reason I find it more difficult to feel equivalent sympathy is that it's hard to get over the fact that the white rural poor seem to constantly cling to counter-productive political/world-views that perpetuate their poverty and act against their interests. I mean it's just really hard to allocate significant sympathy towards a large voting-bloc that seems to blame all their problems on terrorism and immigration. But then again, perhaps I am generalizing - I mean I'm just a clueless liberal living in my NYC bubble so what do I know anyway?

← PreviousPage 3 of 5Next →