HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

charlysisto

171 karma · joined September 14, 2011

submissionscomments
charlysisto··on Elm in the Real World
I don't know if my case is representative, but as a backend dev I'm still on the fence with javascript and at the same time eagerly wanting to step in the frontend realm, because, well Internet. And it seems that elm finally got the right combination of reliability (functional, immutable....) and friendliness (nice syntax, good docs...) for me to cross the rubicon.

Add to the mixture charismatic personalities like R. Feldman and E. Czaplisky and this could be the answer.

charlysisto··on New Adventures for Elm
Here's the path I've been following :

(ruby)rjs -> prototype -> jquery -> backbone -> angular -> react -> flux -> redux -> elm...

But I'm just a backend guy happy with Ror, just waiting to go on the frontline... with the proper weapons!

My feeling about elm is that it's more than the new kid on the js block. It's closure without parens, it's Haskell without academy, it's Redux without facebook, it's duck-typing without quacks, it's MVC without objects and last but not least evan Czaplisky (the creaor) is the new Aaron Patterson (bright and fun!)

I'm all in (but yeah I've been bitten before)...

charlysisto··on How Your Brain Decides Without You (2014)
I guess appreciating humour has something to do with one's brain perception - or the lack of thereof.
charlysisto··on How Your Brain Decides Without You (2014)
Another case for duck typing... (a shameless rubyist)
charlysisto··on Pirate needs 200k video views to avoid being sued
I guess this is the modern equivalent of being whipped by shame on each view. With a sort of promotional after thought - where economy substitutes law. Mmmm It doesn't seem the DNA of this method will survive longer than a few sarcasms and a 'shame on you' backlash
charlysisto··on René Girard has died
I'd like to point out that he also heavily influenced Jean Pierre Dupuy (also professor at Standford) who wrote a few brilliant books. Among them : "l'Avenir de l'économie". Don't know if it's translated in english but for my fellow french hackers I highly recommend it
charlysisto··on René Girard has died
Why anti scientific ? His theory is based on a lot of anthropological observations. He elaborates a very robust hypothesis with rigorous reasoning and comes up with a brilliant/thought-provoking and yet simple theory (so much more simple & elegant than freudian theory) on the structural role of religion, rituals and sacrifice in human societies.

Overall you don't need to agree on everything he says or consider it as scientific ! Scientific proof anyway in human matters are hardly testable, subject to contradiction and ideological bias. So criticizing him because of a lack of scientific rigor is just bashing in an open door.

However I don't know much about Paul Ricoeur, so I'd love to know what you consider great about his work.

charlysisto··on Help categorise images to fight Varroa destructor (bee parasite)
It would be nice to have a little more context on this project
charlysisto··on Write like you talk
What you just wrote illustrates perfectly your point.
charlysisto··on Placebo Button
You probably know the joke (from popstar Zizek) :

When a friend of Niels Bohr (quantum theory) goes to his house in the country side he's bewildered by a horse shoe hanging on the great scientific genius's door. When Niels opens the friends asks : "but truly a rational man like you, how could you give any credit to such superstitions" and Niels Bohr answers : "Well I heard that superstition works even if you don't believe in it"

Yes I'm amazed by the power of placebo because "it works even if you know its a one/don't believe in it."

I actually wrote in the placebo field : "Give me a break". And my God it worked. I felt relieved. Like that weight on my chest just faded away. Although I suspect the fact the button/pill is blue has something to do with it.

Anyway who cares... "Give me a steak"

charlysisto··on The state of Computer Vision and AI: we are really, really far (2012)
In a nutshell I don't see how any kind of adaptive intelligence can bypass the reinforcement process of trial and error through interaction. Then again you could have simulated interaction, but that may be the equivalent of the machine dreaming :-)
charlysisto··on The internet’s own boy: the story of Aaron Swartz [video]
The part (59mn) where his former girlfriend confesses she's still angry, angry at a system that tries to trap you and turn everything against you and ruin your life... is devastating.
charlysisto··on The state of Computer Vision and AI: we are really, really far (2012)
Good point. The thought actually actually popped into my mind after I wrote the post : "Wall E" and many more films/books have suggested this accelerated learning path.

However this is information only, not interaction, I suspect this will have a serious distorsion effect on how the AI "perceives". It's a wild guess, but I believe interaction is at the root of understanding.

Edit : yes you also mention interaction through video games, which I skipped when I scanned your comment. But then again video games might be still far from the depth of real world interaction, more of a learning enforcer than the source of it - like books are for us....

charlysisto··on Why Hasn’t the World Been Destroyed in a Nuclear War Yet?
Because we're still here to write about it !

Sorry for this silly recursive joke. However it has a point : For some philosophers (e.g : Gerard Dupuy) theorizing the self realizing prophecies, in order to prevent a catastrophy, you need to think about it as if it already happened in the future. It is the only way to act on it to counteract the curse of determinism... Enjoy the paradox !

charlysisto··on The state of Computer Vision and AI: we are really, really far (2012)
The flash you get out of a joke is build up on a huge framework of human interaction that takes literally years to acquire for the "dedicated" BI of a brain. The fact the AI is only starting to reach the power of facial recognition which is for us a seemingly "low level automatic" function tells us the amount of learning left for an AI to come close to our understanding of the world. Not only in terms of computational power but in length and diversity of the learning process.

Assuming sufficiently powerful Neural Networks, they will probably go through years of learning our world through interaction, just like a kid does, before it "gets" the joke. Doesn't mean it's impossible, and that's quit scary (in a good and bad sense I guess).

charlysisto··on Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer
Absolutely my point, and the notion of collective fiction and how it structures communities through faith, money, democracy and what not, is very dear to me. If you look at how we speak of "the markets" today (the markets are confident, the markets are happy, the markets are scared, the market is always right) it is very close to how ancient greeks would mention their gods... speaking of greeks the gods aren't happy with them... time to kill some goats...

But my main point was the widening divide between our artificial environment and our biological one, the raising concerns that the first is destroying the latter and what we can do about it! I think turning your back to civilization with the notion that it's all an illusion is a dangerous misconception.

charlysisto··on Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer
Not to question this guy's remarkable decision or the article itself, just one expression I see quit often and makes me cringe each time, that is : the real world (referred here as a little haven of nature).

Is the 19th century Industrial revolution just an illusion, the factories, the cars, the towns, the wars just a view of the spirit, and the little birds singing in the trees the real world ?

Is the current (electronic?) revolution an illusion, just a bait for digital addicts, a virtual world that drags us away from our real world ?

I think it's quit the opposite. I think the real world is this huge uncontrollable human growth on the branch its standing on.

Don't get me wrong, I was raised in the countryside and my entire soul is deeply bonded to the forest, and the animals and insects living in it. But don't call it the real world. Rather something like the fading world. And we need all the talent and imagination behind computers (or in labs), where we can have true impact on things and save it.

Going back to it is the true illusion...

charlysisto··on Learn AngularJS
Right now on HN "Learn AngularJS" is standing right above "Don't React" :-)
charlysisto··on Don't React
dhu... thanks
charlysisto··on Ask HN: How do I become a faster programmer?
I believe your asking yourself the wrong question. It should be how do I write better code ? Being faster (on the long term) can only be a side effect of resolving this part first...

How ? By deepening techniques :

- familiarity with the language - knowledge of good architecture (SOLID if your in OOP) - knowledge of the domain you're tackling with - balancing abstraction with implementation according to the weight of a problem - not overtesting

Yeah becoming faster takes time...

charlysisto··on Ask HN: How do you curate and keep up with general news?
no one lives in a cave here. It's close to impossible to keep away from the noise. After all sharing news is being part of the human community. You don't want to cut yourself from it.

However you don't want to get overwhelmed and there's a lot of sensationalist journalism out there that seeks to stimulate your reptilian brain. On the other hand theres' also good (aka rational/analytical) journalism that helps making a sane narrative out of it without getting you stuck in the rabbit hole.

Stay close to those whatever side of the political spectrum you find yourself and you'll save a lot of time.

charlysisto··on Thepiratebay.se is back online
yes, would love to have some comments on that too
charlysisto··on Coding is not the new literacy
You could call this article UML editor vs text editor. What it may point out would be the lack of a modeling tools. UML is old fashioned, java/entreprisy, and new ones like omnigraffle aren't specifically targeted towards modeling domains. Whereas text-editors are evolved, bright and shiny.

On a another level I agree that what's truly fascinating with programming is not mastering the quirks of a specific language but translating an external model to the shape of rules expressed in a language which has it's own internal logic. Not just to have a static interpretation like painting or literature would provide but a dynamic one which evolves with user and data interaction.

This is really unique in human history

charlysisto··on The State of JavaScript in 2015
I appreciate this effort and will give it a try.

One of my main problem with javascript frameworks is having to drift away from the original server HTML. Not everybody wants to go the whole way down the Single Page Abbit hole. It's not only a question of speed or SEO.

I think many devs are both backend & front-end craftsmen, and as so build the backend first and then wish to 'grow' their frontend part on that foundation. Or ideally wish they could. Instead they have to fork the project into 1). the Good Ol' server HTML part 2). the API SPA part.

No matter how close angular or react (with jsx) stays to HTML, you still need to rewrite the whole view to comply with it's templating needs. There's no incremental evolution there, and worse : having to duplicate and sync maintenance on both ends, breaks the DRY principle which is fundamentally bad - since you end up with 2 sources of truth.

Pre-rendering the view with react on node (even if your on rails or whatever) may be a solution I don't know yet. Another take I guess would be to render your server html files with a template which complies with their JS counterpart. Yet another take would be to use HTML as the API instead of JSON - which is proven to work quiet well.

Anyways, just to conclude I think devs would feel more confident if they could rely a little more on the servers end while the frontend finds its ways and stabilizes a little.

charlysisto··on Rich Hickey – Inside Transducers [video]
Thanks for the answer. Indeed Ruby in general has the limitations inherent to its "non functional" nature. However regarding 2) Enumeration can now (in ruby 2.0) be lazy and thus take each item one after the other through the whole chain.

(1..Float::INFINITY).lazy.map{|a| p a; a*10}.map{|a| p a+1} # => 1 11 2 21 etc...

So it can work with streams & so on... But I know (from a Jessica Kerr presentation) it also has limitations there.

charlysisto··on Rich Hickey – Inside Transducers [video]
So Transducers generalize the usage of Enumerable functions such as map, reduce, filter, flatMap (...).

Please could someone tell me if this is conceptually different from ruby's Enumerable module which only needs the class its included in to implement `each` so anything can be enumerable ? Or is it a similar but just in translated to the FP world ?

charlysisto··on Reasons to not use Ember.js
The title and some of the critics are unfortunate but this post nevertheless is hitting a soft spot for me. I've been through backbone & angular and I'm starting to question the necessity of a full blown framework when all I want is some structured js for each page/resource.

More fundamentally it seems the offer on js libraries are either tailored to eye-candy widgets or the big SPA. Nothing has popped in my radar as proposing an incremental step from server side HTML to MV([A–Z]) Dom/json manipulation which entices you to almost build the app twice.

What I'd really like to see rather than a client-side-solution is a server/client migration path from html to spa without being tide to one or the other

The links he included (see below) bring up the same concerns....

http://mir.aculo.us/2013/02/26/client-side-mvc-is-not-a-silv...

http://www.shopify.com/technology/15646068-rebuilding-the-sh...

charlysisto··on What is the probability your vote will make a difference? (2012) [pdf]
That's a very good point. Going to vote has a draining effect, especially in communities with poor voting culture, which can count for many more votes than the simple linear 1 + n effect of your participation. It also has an effect on the legitimacy of democracy, on its health and longevity, beyond the party brought to power.
charlysisto··on Just had a heart attack
I usually don't pay attention to who's who on HN but last week there was an interesting debate on the status of semantic web, and the name "mindcrime" stuck as I appreciated his comments a lot. Always a bit of a shock to find out those virtual personas are made of flesh...

Hope you recover fast, and yeah EXERCISE (if the doctor says so).

charlysisto··on Ask HN: Is the semantic web still a thing?
> Modern search engines have largely figured out how to provide a fairly high-level ontology equivalent to this use-case by simply parsing out the content on the pages and centrally storing it.

If google opens up it's index to the world so you could use it as an api to query the web with the power of a relational DB, the case for semantic web would probably be pointless. But it's locked and only serves there ad system.

I'm not defending Semantic Web per say, but because the lack structure in the web makes it only 'parsable' by gigantic entities like google. Their work is remarkable and they offer a nice service I can consume. But I can't really build on it.

I think the debate should shift from the means to the goals... Semantic web might not be the right way to do it, but I strongly believe in the necessity of a way to (openly) connect the dots of all that data or it's a giant waste.

What are the relational stores you mention in a) ?

← PreviousPage 2 of 4Next →