HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

charlysisto

171 karma · joined September 14, 2011

submissionscomments
charlysisto··on Ask HN: Is the semantic web still a thing?
Re 2.5) 2.6) and 2.7) In order to categorize things that enables you to communicate the idea, you need a common denominator that is universal & neutral enough to rely on. I think there's on place where this work is already done for you, it's wikipedia !

Watching the explanation of differential gear https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8513209, I thought why not make wikipedia the central axis around which you let the diversity of the semantic web spin at its own pace. If most people agree on this authority (or if you wish convention over configuration mess) things become easily connectable.

In other terms instead of relying on sloppy ontology rely on wikidata_id as the sort of referential association table.

charlysisto··on How a differential gear works (1937) [video]
I was generally not bad at physics but I remember not getting my head around this one...

What a great lesson for decoupling systems. I wonder what's the software equivalent in design pattern land. The facade maybe ?

charlysisto··on Ask HN: Is the semantic web still a thing?
The uses is a very interesting question because the first things that pops to mind : it would be totally useless without the proper tools to take advantage of it. Basically the web is a flatland with many arrows going from one doc to the other - a one to one relational database. Semantic web (or lets call structured web) gives it a z axis to build depth.

A trivial example I gave on another comment :

> The way google exposes the web today is unidimensional : keywords => related website list. It's great for humans to parse. But its extremely limited for machines. Why isn't there yet an API or an UI to ask for "all books of Japanese novelists of the last 2 centuries" (website links included per book).

An other example that comes to mind is : you query a person and instead of a list of related website you get a set of tabs with : bio from different sources, work, news, images & videos.... Bonus, you don't need to be google anymore to do that ! Ok that's far fetched but imagine the potential for webapps.

charlysisto··on Ask HN: Is the semantic web still a thing?
AI is back with a revenge after 40 years of hibernation in the Utopian nuclear winter. That should tell you one shouldn't bury a good idea to quickly - although I appreciate your post a lot.

Four remarks.

- I'm not sure the lack of motivation for implementing SW is economic but rather : what's the point if no one is using it.

- I don't think the shortcomings described by metacrap are foundational : it's like saying a word doesn't describe the reality of the thing it 'signifies' therefore language is useless and will not be adopted. There might be competing standards on ontology but I'm sure they'll emerge.

- AI might be (one of) the tool that make semantic web actually relevant. The reason why I believe google has an important part to play in it.

- and finally : developers, developer, developers !!! Bring an elegant tool in the ecosystem (JSON-LD maybe ?) : devs won't shy away in front of horrendous xml, and all of the sudden SW might get caught in a virtuous circle and become the previous big thing.

charlysisto··on Ask HN: Is the semantic web still a thing?
Thank you, that's precious info. I started exploring the tools last year an dug into rdf, feeling very uncomfortable with the buzz mismatch of "hey but everybody's using JSON ! that's not helping LD's adoption..."

Happy to learn the issue seems to be addressed.

charlysisto··on Ask HN: Is the semantic web still a thing?
I was aware of it but I find it's the 'minimum syndical' as you put it in french. A real way of embracing the semantic web would be, for example, to expose a LinkData compatible subset of their indexed content (a la dbpedia).

The way they expose the web today is unidimensional : keywords => related website list.

It's great for humans to parse. But its extremely limited for machines. Why isn't there yet an API or an UI to ask all books of Japanese novelists of the last 2 centuries (website links included per book). I am sure this could be in googles reach and of greta interest for everybody (replace books by manga if you wish).

And that I would call embracing semantic web.

charlysisto··on Ask HN: Is the semantic web still a thing?
Good ideas don't always follow a linear path. The buzz around semantic web probably didn't mesure at the time all the obstacles it would find on its way. Agreeing on categories is one of them but IMHO, the biggest one is legacy content and the inertia it carries on change.

I use dbpedia on a toy project and really appreciate it although I only use a very shallow portion of its possibilities. And it's still very brittle on the edges. Also I don't see it taking any momentum if it's not embraced by more of the big content players.

An interesting question would be : would semantic web favor google ? It would certainly help it index content but wouldn't also deprive it from its search monopoly ?

charlysisto··on Skunk Works Reveals Compact Fusion Reactor Details
I followed the ecat (http://ecatnews.com/) story for a year or so until my BS alarm started getting really loud - but just the prospect of it was so exhilarating, it was hard to resist the enthusiasm overflow...

Now this sounds way more serious than Andrea Rossi's saga. But I did get a lot tougher on my wait and see stand.

charlysisto··on The Ocean Cleanup
It's interesting to see he takes critics seriously and addresses them : http://www.theoceancleanup.com/blog/show/item/responding-to-...
charlysisto··on How to Drink All Night Without Getting Drunk
Yes it's called grape juice : the wine you drink because the taste is 'divine' doesn't exist in a non alcoholic form. Don't know about beer though
charlysisto··on Why Ruby Class Methods Resist Refactoring
I don't think there's any use of a heavy pattern in there, it's just leveraging the basic OO idea of state.

My rule of thumb is to use class methods as factories to initialize your object in a certain way, which is quit consistent with what the class method `new` does. Once you stay in that line of thought the rest flows quit naturally without over-thinking anything.

charlysisto··on [dead]
You know the joke/true story (?) : A friend of Niels Bohr notices a horseshoe nailed on his door. When Niels opens up his friend asks :

- you, one of the greatest scientist of this century how could you believe in such things.

- Well I've been told that superstition works even if you don't believe in it !

Incidentally a recent study seems to demonstrate that the placebo effect works even when you know it's placebo...

charlysisto··on Why we left AngularJS
Although angular is aimed at Wide/SinglePage Apps I find it perfectly suited for small scale stuff. It's like a sedan if you wish but with all the safety airbags and comfort of an mvc and the possibility to mount a canon if you move out in the jungle. It gives you a level of confidence I'd find difficult to abandon.

Also I don't see how jquery + knockout is so different from taking the angular/ember road ? (edit: I see why from a legacy point of vue)

Finally the comparison with mongodb is misleading : angular & cie brings your code from procedural mess to a well known structured area, whereas moving away from sql didn't improve any of your architecture it just proposed another one

charlysisto··on Is there logic behind France’s rumored €1 Billion Google Tax?
It's not about internet companies, it's about a set of multinational companies (amazon, starbuck, McDonald & many others including non-US) using a set of legal fiscal tricks to pay a ridicule amount of taxes compared to the national based ones & individuals. It's hurting competition and feeding the increasingly wide gap between wages & company income.
charlysisto··on Is Ruby Dying?
my question : is ruby trying to get on pair with python regarding machine learning ?
charlysisto··on New US spy satellite logo features world-devouring octopus
Funny nobody spotted it's also commonly used to represent the mafia. Small side note : mafia's power mainly relies on people's fear of being heard if they say anything against it... Just sayin...
charlysisto··on Preorder your very own cold fusion reactor
I followed this closely 2/3 years ago, skeptical, yet very excited by the possibilities of the outcome if true. I followed the heated debates on ecatnews.com, had a lot of fun but after almost 2 years of postponing a serious test, came to the conclusion it was a scam. I'm afraid this is yet another episode of a serie that just can't die.
charlysisto··on Jury: Newegg infringes Spangenberg patent, must pay $2.3 million
sadly, one word comes in mind : the new mafia.
charlysisto··on Is economics a science?
The problem with stating that 'economics is science' is the strong underlying ideological and political bias. The human factor is always recursive : the very beliefs of what is natural (aka: science) in a given culture structures the way the society works. The ancient Greeks and Romans considered slavery natural, so they had slaves and you could therefore empirically/scientifically prove the basic laws of slavery... Abandoning the way you see society to science implies the way it works is deterministic and thus cannot be changed. You basically abandon freedom to ideology with a fake science mustache.
charlysisto··on Amazon donates 0.5% of the price of your purchases to the charity of your choice
yup that's also the amount of taxes amazon's paying in europe
charlysisto··on Time is not money: Thinking about it makes you a better person
Excellent point. For me the main use/luxury of money is not having to think about it.
charlysisto··on Ruby 2.1.0 preview1 released
Please tell us, what's the use case ?
charlysisto··on Is The Web Dying?
Cinema didn't kill theater, TV didn't kill cinema, the web didn't kill tv & so on. Some parts are overlapping, some respond to different needs. I think instead of asking, "is this & that dying" why not ask what space is occupying over the other, how's it different, how is it the same. The discussion is to broad as is and leads easily to religious arguments
charlysisto··on Exploring aisles 9-13 at my local supermarket
A simple question to those afraid of regulation : why does a country agree that some substances should not belong to the market (drugs) but that not letting junk food be sold in the most cynical and manipulative way to a population dying of diabetes would harm the sacro saint wisdom/freedom of market ?

Sidenote : regulation doesn't mean banning, just tax the junk food heavily so the most vulnerable don't buy it and have clear markers it kills your brain cells just like on cigarettes & alcohol.

charlysisto··on Cyberscare: Ex-NSA chief calls transparency groups, hackers next terrorists
If you believe that, you've already accepted it, and to some extent justified it. Beware that cynicism is only one form of ideology that relies on the thought it's based on facts.
charlysisto··on The Charitable-Industrial Complex
The conclusion is a metaphor and this answer purely rhetorical.
charlysisto··on Table-to-JSON
Nice ! Could be used in a progressive enhancement strategy : render your html then extract the json out of it to feed your MVWhatever (Angularjs, Emberjs, Backbonejs, nameitjs) and let javascript take on for the cool client side stuff.
charlysisto··on Why isn't there a syncing filesystem that works like this?
Excellent point. Why doesn't dropbox have an "upload only" or "on demand" feature, I don't get it. Apple's iCloud solved this quit well : if you delete an aac file, it asks you if you want to delete it as well on the cloud. If you don't, the music is still available for streaming or downloading & you've saved space on your HD.
charlysisto··on A Comparison of Angular, Backbone, CanJS and Ember
I gave up using Backbone a year ago. Being a server side dev, the 'to much boilerplate' quickly killed the initial enthusiasm.

But while waiting for Ember to mature, I stumbled on Angular and completely bought it's original & refreshing approach that is, being ahead of what the modern browser should be : embracing html components (aka directives), observables & the beauty of dependency injection. That for me was the initial 'wow factor' beyond the nice feeling you get when binding your first view/model.

If I was to market angular I'd say it really caught the right angle of frontend webdev

charlysisto··on Backgrid: A featureful grid UI for Backbone.js
Looks awesome. I wrote Backbone.grid last year, basically some view extensions with a much lower level approach and many unresolved issues. This is were backbone (and other MVC) shines I think. Hope to see similar stuff in ember.js angular.js and so on with nifty gems for easy generation of admin section. kudos
← PreviousPage 3 of 4Next →