AI is back with a revenge after 40 years of hibernation in the Utopian nuclear winter.
That should tell you one shouldn't bury a good idea to quickly - although I appreciate your post a lot.
Four remarks.
- I'm not sure the lack of motivation for implementing SW is economic but rather : what's the point if no one is using it.
- I don't think the shortcomings described by metacrap are foundational : it's like saying a word doesn't describe the reality of the thing it 'signifies' therefore language is useless and will not be adopted. There might be competing standards on ontology but I'm sure they'll emerge.
- AI might be (one of) the tool that make semantic web actually relevant. The reason why I believe google has an important part to play in it.
- and finally : developers, developer, developers !!! Bring an elegant tool in the ecosystem (JSON-LD maybe ?) : devs won't shy away in front of horrendous xml, and all of the sudden SW might get caught in a virtuous circle and become the previous big thing.