HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

chimpanzee

640 karma · joined March 23, 2023

You can take that cookie and stick it up your yeah.
submissionscomments
chimpanzee··on Varoufakis: Capitalism is dead, long live Technofeudalism
Just to clarify in case of any misunderstanding of my comment (to which you originally replied)…

I don’t view serfdom as a net benefit to the serfs. Nonetheless there were initially small benefits that surely dwindled to nothing over time. I think this is exactly where the op metaphor is most apt. When power is traded for comfort, what seems like a good deal now will eventually become a raw deal in the future. (And we moderns surely have more relative power than the serfs ever had)

chimpanzee··on Varoufakis: Capitalism is dead, long live Technofeudalism
> Also, in feudalism the owners of the land would not provide services as these platforms do, they would only exert the power of ownership. The relationship here is more complex, as the cloud-serfs are also a source of capital as they buy the items sold by the platforms.

Both of these claims (that owners did not provide services and that serfs were not sources of capital) is contradicted by wikipedia: “Serfs … were entitled to protection, justice, and the right to cultivate certain fields within the manor to maintain their own subsistence. Serfs were often required not only to work on the lord's fields, but also in his mines and forests and to labour to maintain roads.”

The source for the Wikipedia text isn’t quite clear to me, but the content jibes with my prior understanding of serfdom.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Serfdom

chimpanzee··on The Tao of Programming (1987)
> What's the difference between multiplication and addiction conceptually?

Addiction is multiplication by infinity.

chimpanzee··on How were gladiators portrayed in ancient Rome?
Oh I believe your reasons.
chimpanzee··on How were gladiators portrayed in ancient Rome?
> The post almost certainly has a slant, and if it does, yes, it’s reactionary.

You and the poster must know each other quite well. I on the other hand don’t know them at all (as far as I know). And their past visible comments don’t suggest habitual trolling. With little else to go on seems best for me to give them the benefit of the doubt.

chimpanzee··on How were gladiators portrayed in ancient Rome?
Yes thank you, that is what “reactionary” means. But the post only mentions the Romans in order to draw a comparison (albeit likely based on faulty information), and then asks how others feel about it. This isn’t support for past eras. It’s a curiosity into the current state of affairs using as comparison the only available reference: the past.

Your own difficulty in understanding the poster’s intent underlies the problem with the “reactionary” label. They could simply be misinformed. Misinformation leads to dissonance, surprise and curiosity. Which leads to posting online to settle their inner confusion/questions.

chimpanzee··on How were gladiators portrayed in ancient Rome?
Why do you consider that post to be “reactionary”?
chimpanzee··on John McCarthy’s collection of numerical facts for use in elisp programs
But me big man. Me move mars.
chimpanzee··on Employees in Asia are spending most time looking busy at work, says Slack report
> Not bad for a guy with no boss and no job title.

This is the way. Anarchists wouldn’t be at all surprised.

chimpanzee··on If we want a shift to walking we need to prioritize dignity
The pyramid structure is used to illustrate that upper layer concepts are supported by the bottom layer concepts. So, in this case, dignity is less essential than safety. Given safety, one can begin to develop dignity.
chimpanzee··on A chimpanzee brought Xerox to the masses
Thank you.
chimpanzee··on How to foster shoshin
Uh oh, sounds like somebody could use some shoshin!
chimpanzee··on Language models can explain neurons in language models
Imagine a world without words. No need to imagine really. It exists. It’s everywhere. It’s the core. It’s what words represent, but words can only represent it to an entity that has experienced it to some degree. ChatGPT “knows” nothing about it. You do. Whether you recognize it or not.

ChatGPT is a machine, an algorithm, a recombinator of symbols. It doesn’t know what the symbols refer to because each symbol necessarily refers to another symbol until you finally reach a symbol that refers to a shared, real experience…perhaps (Hello Wittgenstein!). And ChatGPT has no experience. Just symbols. It can’t intuit anything. It can’t feel anything. Even if you put quotes around “feel”, what does that even mean for a software algorithm running on hardware that does not feed continuous, variable electrical sensations to the algorithm? It only feeds discrete symbols. Do you feel the number 739? Or do you “feel” it? Um what? Whatever inner experience 739 happens to produce in you is grounded in some real experiences in the past. Likewise any fake memories you have that somehow seem real, those are still grounded in a real feelings at some point. You could do this ad infinitum. If you are alive, you have experience. But ChatGPT has no experience, no grounding.

Problem here might be that we are trying to use words and logic to describe something that cannot be described by either.

This is why the gong is struck.

chimpanzee··on Language models can explain neurons in language models
That’s the point. You don’t know exactly what happened. So you have to reason your way to an answer, right or wrong.

I’m sure it elicited ideas in your head based on your own experiences. You could then use those ideas to ask questions and get further information. Or you could simply pick an answer and then delve into all the details and sensations involved, creating a story based on what you know about the world and the feelings you’ve had.

I could have created a more involved “prompt story” one with more details but still somewhat vague. You would probably have either jumped straight to a conclusion about what happened or asked further questions.

Something like “He kicked a ball at my face and hit me in the nose. I laughed. He cried.”

Again, vague. But if you’ve been in such a situation you might have a good guess as to what happened and how it felt to the participants. ChatGPT would have no idea whatsoever as it has no feelings of its own with which to begin a guess.

Consider poetry. How can ChatGPT reason about poetry? Poetry is about creating feeling. The content is often beside the point. Many humans “fail” at understanding poetry, especially children, but there are of course many humans that “get it”, escpecially after building up enough life experience. ChatGPT could never get it.

Likewise for psychedelic or spiritual experiences. One can’t explain such experience to one who has never had it and ChatGPT will never have it.

Same goes for all inner experience.

chimpanzee··on Language models can explain neurons in language models
“God, that felt great!”

As detailed as possible, describe what happened.

chimpanzee··on Language models can explain neurons in language models
(In case it was missed, I’ve added a relevant addendum to my previous comment.)

Not sure an example is needed because I agree it “explains” better than pretty much everyone. (From my mostly lay perspective) It essentially uses the prompt as an argument in a probabilistic analysis of its incredibly vast store of prior inputs to transform them into an output that at least superficially satisfies the prompter’s goals. This is cool and useful, to say the least. But this is only one kind of reasoning.

A machine without embodied perceptual experiences simply cannot reason to the full-extent of a human.

(It’s also worth remembering that the prompter (very likely) has far less knowledge of the domain of interest and far less skill with the language of communication, so the prompter is generally quite easily impressed regardless of the truth of the output. Nothing wrong with that necessarily, especially if it is usually accurate. But again, worth remembering.)

chimpanzee··on Language models can explain neurons in language models
Ah ok. Here you use the word “explain” which implies more of a descriptive, reducing action rather than extrapolative and constructive. As in, it can explain what it has “read” (and it has obviously “read” far more than any human), but it can’t necessarily extrapolate beyond that or use that to find new truths. To me reasoning is more about the extrapolative, truth-finding process, ie “wisdom” from knowledge rather than just knowledge. But maybe my definition of “reasoning” isn’t quite right.

Edit: I probably should define reasoning as solely “deductive reasoning”, in which case, perhaps it is better than humans. But that seems like a premature claim. On the other hand, non-deductive reasoning, I have yet to see from it. I personally can’t imagine how it could do so reliably (from a human perspective) without real-world experiences and perceptions. I’m the sort that believes a true AGI would require a highly-perceptual, space-occupying organ. In other words it would have to be and “feel” embodied, in time and space, in order to perform other forms of reasoning.

chimpanzee··on Language models can explain neurons in language models
Do you put yourself in the 10% or the 90%? I’m asking in complete seriousness.
chimpanzee··on Guidelines for Brutalist Web Design (2018)
Pragmatism!
chimpanzee··on Help make mass surveillance of entire populations uneconomical
Or they can just filter for age, likelihood of technical proficiency (indicated by such things as education, prior employment, family, peer group, etc), and likelihood of “effective political concern” (or whatever we might call a person’s affinity for independence, skepticism, distrust of authority, knowledge of past authoritarian transgressions, knowledge of current authoritarian capabilities, and access and willingness to non-technical resources, eg time or money, needed to act on their concerns)
chimpanzee··on Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolute pitch (2012)
Thanks for the video link! Very cool. The poor singing combined with the on-the-fly guitar tuning gave the piece a grungy punk-like feel, at least to my ears. I rather enjoyed it.

A cute (translated) comment from the video: “To sing with this guitarist is easy! Just praise the Lord and he does the rest!”

chimpanzee··on AI Will Rapidly Transform Labor, Exacerbating Inequality, Insecurity, Poverty
> Everyone can agree that AI will dramatically lower food prices until they near the price of raw production

Please provide some sources supporting the existence of this mythical treasure, this economic prediction on which “everyone can agree”.

chimpanzee··on Joe Biden’s 2024 Opening Argument: It’s Me or the Abyss
>> Good jobs are difficult to come by if you don't have a college degree.

> what awful logic…[anecdote]…the lesson here is that you actually don't NEED a college degree…

Do you see the straw man you erected?

GP never once claimed that a college degree was “needed”, only that lacking one made life more difficult. An effective counter-argument against that would certainly consist of more than a single anecdote.

chimpanzee··on Parrots learn to make video calls to chat with other parrots: study
Some words, like “language”, are often used in the common sense rather than the technical sense. Sometimes for simplicity. Sometimes for humor. And sometimes it happens on Hacker News.

But, if we’re being pedantic, I should mention that there are languages that do not require ordering for meaning but instead use declensions and conjugations (though ordering may still be used for further expressiveness). Though maybe you include this in your “fixed literal vocabulary”.

Edit: A quick search suggest parrots can indeed use a basic grammar via sentence structuring. One of a few relevant search results: https://cosmosmagazine.com/science/biology/polly-wants-a-con....

chimpanzee··on Seagate hit with $300M penalty for selling sanctioned storage to Huawei
And thank you for the friendly and encouraging comment.
chimpanzee··on Parrots learn to make video calls to chat with other parrots: study
Why not language? We could then ask them how they feel rather than just assuming. People themselves usually prefer receiving informed, accurate sympathy rather than sympathy based on crude assumptions.

And physiology alone seems unlikely to tell us how they “feel” about it.

Perhaps they are so amazed by the technology that they couldn’t care less about the flicker :)

chimpanzee··on Parrots learn to make video calls to chat with other parrots: study
Alternatively, GP is suggesting these barriers are part of the “natural” change and can have their own positive effects. We can fight them if we wish, naturally, and doing so brings about a necessary balance. But we shouldn’t fool ourselves into believing that we are necessarily “doing good” in relation to the other. And we shouldn’t believe that achieving the extreme, the unbalanced, is necessarily “best”.

“Freedom-of-information fighters” are always simply fighting for a belief and a desire, not a truth. And in turn bringing balance or potentially imbalance depending on one’s assumptions regarding “Mother Nature’s Grand Evolutionary Scheme” or whatever we want to call it. Just as all fighters have been doing throughout time.

chimpanzee··on 'Devastating' melt of Greenland, Antarctic ice sheets found
> look at the data slightly differently

You mean like look at it upside-down? Or with your eyes closed? Please explain.

chimpanzee··on 'Devastating' melt of Greenland, Antarctic ice sheets found
Jokes aside, I suspect future waterfronts would be unstable and potentially toxic, due to shifting land caused by the weight of the water, erosion from the flow, and landslides from weather and vegetation loss.

On top of that, toxicity may be an issue in some areas as the water overcomes man made structures (eg roadways and basements) and systems (eg sewage and fuel delivery) that were never intended to come into contact with water.

But still…someone will market it.

chimpanzee··on Disciplined Minds, a critique of the system of salaried professions [pdf]
Meaning…within HN? Or at large?

I’m always a bit confused by the HN algorithm. I think it depends highly on your own points [1], timing of the post, and the rate at which it picks up votes and comments. Those are just guesses though…

Topics might matter too, but I don’t see why this would be deprioritized as it isn’t a news items. But it also isnt tech and has a tinge of politics so that doesn’t help

This submission, being a digitized book, is also quite a long read, making it more difficult to start a discussion.

1: it could also be that those with many points are likely to have figured out how to maximize their submissions via timing and topic, or they simply submit a lot and therefore rack up points through “brute force”, creating the illusion that points affect submission ranking

← PreviousPage 6 of 7Next →