HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

chobeat

632 karma · joined February 5, 2018

submissionscomments
chobeat··on The Ghost in the Machine: An AI Perspective on the Soul [video]
No, it's not, but the problem with his argument is that he gives a narrow and extremely specific definition of consciouness and then all the structure works.

I'm not really that much in the debate about consciousness but I'm a lot into the one about intelligence: there are many definitions of intelligence and none of them seems satisfying. You can define intelligence from a rational point of view, as some kind of function or model, but it's extremely narrow, arbitrary and limited. That's the trick he uses. To me it's not enough. The very idea of intelligence is restrictive, antropocentric and confusing. That's because with the existing tools we have (including reason) we cannot converge to a satisfying idea of intelligence, that eludes our analysis.

chobeat··on The Ghost in the Machine: An AI Perspective on the Soul [video]
A good part of the 20th century's philosophy is about this. I mean, many philosophers talked about it extensively even before (Kant? Hume?). It's not an argument, it's a whole branch of philosophy and epistemology.

I've never read a book specific to this topic but if you want one, here's one that looks good, engineer-friendly and simple enough: https://mitpress.mit.edu/books/outer-limits-reason

chobeat··on The Ghost in the Machine: An AI Perspective on the Soul [video]
Nobody here criticized the value of reason. The problem is when you overvalue reason. Water is good for you, too much water kills you.

Saying "too much water is bad" or "water is not good when your problem is that your socks are wet" is not an attack on water itself. You waterists should all calm down.

chobeat··on The Ghost in the Machine: An AI Perspective on the Soul [video]
In the beginning, when he gave a simple and arbitrary definition of Intelligence, I already got where he was going.

It's a well-worded, better-than-average, STEMlordish explanation of reality but still very limited. The guy is smart but should read more before trying to propose just another theory of reality/mind/everything.

chobeat··on The Ghost in the Machine: An AI Perspective on the Soul [video]
Rationality works for some things, doesn't work for others. Do you want to make sense of the world in a way that helps with your suffering? Rationality doesn't work for most people.

Do you want to include in your model of the world knowledge that cannot be obtained with rationality? Well, then you should use something that is different than rationality.

As a society we held rationality above everything else for a couple of centuries thanks to illuminism. Yes, it helped a lot and rationality is a good tool to solve a lot of problems. Is it a perfect tool? No. Is it an omnipotent tool? Is it the tool to kill all the other tools? No. Luckily, as a society, in the last century we began to understand the limits of rationality and we are slowly transitioning to a world where rationality is used only in the context where it belongs, acknoledging its limits. The same happend with religion. In the past we used religion to explain everything and it wasn't good. Then we said: "Ok, religion takes the spot of religion and just that". The same is happening with rationality but engineers didn't take note yet, pretty much as priests took a while to be content with their spot (and still try to make religion leak in other parts of society).

chobeat··on Employees at Amazon's New NYC Warehouse Launch Unionization Push
Or... it's the main target of accelerationist activists to radicalize the knowledge workers and subvert the status quo through high-tech powered dissent.

Or just both.

chobeat··on Employees at Amazon's New NYC Warehouse Launch Unionization Push
Countries don't compete with companies. What are you even try to say?
chobeat··on Employees at Amazon's New NYC Warehouse Launch Unionization Push
or every company in the USA given the surreal working culture and level of exploitation that is common throughout the nation.
chobeat··on Superintelligence: The Idea That Eats Smart People (2016)
There are so many criticism/debunk of the Singularity theory that there's not even a debate anymore.

I would say that debating the scientific likelihood of a singularity is sterile because they don't provide any argument on that plane. The debate is mostly philosophical and/or theological nowadays.

One good paper I like on the subject is this one: https://jods.mitpress.mit.edu/pub/resisting-reduction

but quickly googling "singularity criticism/debunk" will bring you so many sources.

chobeat··on Superintelligence: The Idea That Eats Smart People (2016)
Singularity is a religion full of bullshit.

Resist reduction!

https://jods.mitpress.mit.edu/pub/resisting-reduction

chobeat··on Superintelligence: The Idea That Eats Smart People (2016)
And even if you defy computational constraints, it will still be constrained by physical limitations. You can experience the world just so quickly. Stuff needs time to happen and you being faster than stuff won't be any help after a while.
chobeat··on Superintelligence: The Idea That Eats Smart People (2016)
Both your argument and the argument that you're criticizing make assumptions on what intelligence is and what are the properties that define human-level intelligence. How can you know that consciousness is not a prerequisite for human-level intelligence if you cannot define human-level intelligence?
chobeat··on Superintelligence: The Idea That Eats Smart People (2016)
No, if there's no ground to do so. Chemtrailers believe that there are gigantic conspirancies to subdue humans (and ultimately worsen the condition of the whole humanity) but we shouldn't take them seriously.
chobeat··on Superintelligence: The Idea That Eats Smart People (2016)
Changing your political regime gives you UBI. That's literally the only way to get UBI. It's not gonna happen magically by itself.
chobeat··on Deep learning pioneer Yoshua Bengio is worried about AI’s future
No future is inevitable. That's what the californian ideology convinced you of.
chobeat··on How Smart People Sabotage Their Success
The last one is probably the hardest to relate to because we live immersed in a ideology that values reason and rational thought above everything else. That's the best tool a human has and can solve every problem if used properly. That's what we inherited from a 300 hundred years old cultural movement that today feels outdated. The whole premise is faulty, a good amount of people got over it already, but not society as a whole and for sure not engineers, because supposedly they are good at analytical thinking. It's hard to willingly let go your position of power by saying: "well, the thing I'm good at maybe it's not the most important in the world".
chobeat··on Google drops plans for Berlin campus after protests
It's complicated: if your freedom of movement harms somebody else, is it ethical? As an emigrant I can value the freedom of labour and movement but I can also see that this harms people if it becomes too extreme like in Berlin. That's why here lot of leftists are criticizing open borders and free immigration: mass migrations are a product of capitalism and we should solve the problem at the root, not just cope with the symptom.
chobeat··on Google drops plans for Berlin campus after protests
It's also that Berlin is heavily radicalized and can radicalize even the worst STEMlord. So after moving here it's not rare to get into politics and understand that, on a local scale, your decisions matter.
chobeat··on Google drops plans for Berlin campus after protests
Programmer in Berlin here. I'm very happy Google gave up. The political implications of being anti-gentrification are complicated: here I know many anarchists that are fervently in favor and others that are fervently against. Same for the commies. I have my opinion but I don't think it's worthy to bring it into the discussion.

I'm happy for a single reason: as long as Berlin startup scene preserves its working culture (that reflects German working culture in general), it will be a better working environment than the Silicon Valley. Big campuses and the presence of foreign corporations in general will have a slow but steady cultural influence on the IT workforce, normalizing the level of individual and systemic exploitation that is acceptable in the USA but not in Germany. Unpaid hours, unclear separation between work time and leisure time, ideological brainwashing, identity politics are all things I wouldn't like to see in the company I work for, but if a majority of my colleagues have worked for American corporations before (because they can afford to offer good salaries), it's more likely for it to happen.

Zalando is enough of a meat-grinder, we don't want more.

chobeat··on Google drops plans for Berlin campus after protests
This would go against the interests of the locals, that, frankly, in a community should come before the interests of some programmer that would find a job somewhere else.
chobeat··on Google drops plans for Berlin campus after protests
Irony that might be true on the internet but not in the real world.
chobeat··on Ask HN: Cheap places to live with a good intellectual atmosphere?
I would say that from an European POV, USA's democracy has been compromised way earlier than Turkey's. While Erdogan is somehow a new element in Turkey's democracy, systemic corruption in the USA has been prevalent for almost a century, while Turkey had a somehow solid democracy in place.

Trump is just an error in the system, a person that is incapable of following the rituals and gain advantage of a low-profile attitude.

chobeat··on It doesn't have to be crazy at work
Big platforms are a strategic asset that Europe is missing. Hardware production is a strategic asset that USA is missing. In case of a prolonged trade war, I'm not sure Europe is in the worse position between the two.
chobeat··on Germans don’t do tech startups – more access to capital might change that
> Startups often include difficult and intense work environment

Compared to the USA? Lol, you have no clue. The standard for a software engineer in SV is to take drugs to work 12 hours a day 6 days a week, pay a fucking high rent living with 4 other people and if he's foreigner and freshly arrived, he has to suck his boss' cock everyday because they might take away his visa sponsorship and put him into troubles.

In Berlin most people I know work less than 8 hours a day, can afford to have their own apartment at their first or second job and save enough money and energy to go travel somewhere every 3 months. Because you know, we have 30 days of holidays per year.

chobeat··on Why Salt Was So Important Throughout History
I'm reading that book right now. It's very well written and light considering the many complex subjects that it covers.
chobeat··on Workers of the world unite on distributed digital platforms
I advocate for platform cooperativism and workers self-organization and this article is still terrible. Every single technical reference is wrong and the level of confidence in the blockchain is way beyond what is reasonable at this time.

At some point I was expecting some comment on Comrade Elon Musk, the Lord and Saviour of the proletariat.

← PreviousPage 6 of 6