1,123 karma · joined November 27, 2019
https://graymirror.substack.com/p/tech-solutions-to-the-tech...
Tibet would like a word.
>> Given an initial situation, a Pareto improvement is a new situation where some agents will gain, and no agents will lose. [0]
Neonological seems to believe that pareto improvements are not possible because of negative externalities. Maybe they are right but positive externalities also need to be accounted for.
Apparently the many disagree with you, and like their cars.
> This assertion is completely unfounded.
You can keep pretending that things you don’t like don’t exist.
Thats uncharitable, and in my opinion ignorant. Inflation distorts the signals people use to make investments, leading to misallocation of assets.
Thats a good demonstration of ignoring the interests of everyone who doesn’t share your opinion, but it’s not how representative government is supposed to work.
> That's not a real problem. You solve it by ignoring it and getting back to things that actually matter.
Then you can go back to ignoring bitcoin.
> Again inflation is easy: once you obtain money, purchase assets.
Again, this is not an answer for the problem, and pretending it is just ignores the reality that billions of people live with every day.
Bicycles are nice but have lower capacity for cargo and passengers; mass transit is less flexible. So they aren’t strictly superior.
> Bitcoin does not solve any problem that any other transaction network technology can't solve,
How else do you propose to have a distributed ledger that is resistant to inflation?
I upvoted even though I disagree, because yes.
Source, tried to get electricity in Tampa, Florida, after leaving the military. Was denied because TECO only was willing to “verify” my identity through Experian, and Experian <see above>.
Thank you for the complement but I didn't invent banking.
Their wages don't keep pace with the inflation of assets, so they are continually unable to save or invest their way out of poverty.
> (they do)
Consumer goods and assets don't appreciate at the same rate.
> then how are they harmed by inflation?
for the umpteenth time, they are paid in depreciating units while the real value of assets appreciates in nominal units; creating a problem where in order to save they must invest, and they continually have less real income to invest, because the paychecks are getting smaller (in real terms) and the assets are getting pricier (in nominal terms).
How fortunate for the capitalist that he can retain his entire workforce by paying them less and they are not even likely to notice.
> You claim that central banks depreciate the currency because they "think wages among the working class are too high." But rhetorically, you are doing more than just referring to the explanation I gave above. You are implying that central banks "think" working class wages are too high, and want to lower them to hurt working class people.
Banks wanting to hurt working class people is an unnecessary hypothesis. they merely want to help their friends who own businesses and would like to pay less in real terms for their workforce.
> the purpose of inflation in that instance is to implicitly reduce the downward rigidity of wages so that employment does not contract as much in a downturn.
give workers a stealth way cut so the business can afford to keep all of them, yeah, I get it.
> Presumably you, champion of the working class, would rather more people be unemployed?
I want them to be unemployed the same way you want them to be tricked into making less real money.
They (or their households) have an income, which is paid in units that are constantly depreciating while the investments are increasing in nominal terms. Of course they have no assets, because central bank policies have priced all of the assets out of their reach.
> Yes they do. If they have money, they have Robinhood. If they don't have money, inflation doesn't matter.
They don’t have enough time after working and chores to investigate which assets to purchase on the stock market, which is why banks existed before the central bank destroyed the savings market.
You’re misinformed. There are 3 considerations: dividend yield, capital gain, and security of principle.
> Both are gains. If you hold 100 shares and a company doesn't issue a dividend you can sell 1 share to obtain a 1% dividend. Or you can wait for them to issue a 1% divided and be left with 99% the value. It's a no-op. Same thing. You've failed at basic math here.
Owning cash isn’t the same as owning a business and almost everyone understands that. I’m not sure if you’re really this clueless or you’re trying to gaslight me, either way you’re wrong.
> No. You are strictly wrong. When a dividend is issued the stock goes down by that amount. [1]
> After a stock goes ex-dividend, the share price typically drops by the amount of the dividend paid to reflect the fact that new shareholders are not entitled to that payment.
> strictly
> typically
You don’t seem to understand the subject based on this exchange. Do you realize that’s not a rebuttal to what I said?
> No dividends are less valuable because they offer no flexibility in recognition date.
So if they are less valuable then you understand that some investors would prefer them less, and this is not the same as only caring about total returns?
> In fact, I believe, correct me if I'm wrong, dividends are treated as ordinary income. On the other hand if you sell something you've held for 1 year in lieu you'll get long-term capital gains treatment.
So you do understand that they are different, and investors care about more than total return?
You seem to be unaware that different investors have different investment goals.
> What any investor is looking for is a total return, and it doesn't matter in what form.
Yeah, no. Some investors want dividends, some want gains, some are more concerned with security of principle, some optimize for total return. This is taught in finance 101.
> Inflation only sets the benchmark rate for total return.
Inflation creates a margin rate of profit that must be met or a business loses money.
> When a company issues a dividend its stock price drops by the decrease in net asset value of the company once the dividend is issued.
It depends. Sometimes the price goes up because they have shown that they are in a position for the owners to take profit. Sometimes it goes down because shareholders want to reinvest their capital elsewhere and its timely to do this immediately after dividend receipt (because you’re not waiting for the next dividend).
> The difference between an unrealized gain and a dividend is the difference between a "realized" and a "mark-to-market" gain. They have different profiles, and different benefits. For instance, a mark-to-market gain can be rolled forward into different tax years where as a realized gain must be attributed to the current tax year.
I’m glad you understand this. Now based on this, can you see why some investors would prefer dividends and some would prefer capital gains?
> Please, for the love of stocks, take an ECON class. I'm not a complementary tutor, and you're so far off the reservation it's hard to even know how to reign you in.
Really now, this is rich. If you think my perspective is that outlandish then you truly have not studied this to any great extent.
This is false, rich folks have far more debt than poor people, not to mention access to lower prices for loans.
> Without inflation they'd be assessed the same interest rates, with the same risk premiums, but would not benefit from inflation so this is strictly worse, is it not?
You’re right that the rich, who hold vastly greater amounts of debt, would not benefit from the central bank depreciating their liabilities.
> That has nothing to do with inflation which impacts the principal of issued loans.
When the principal decreases by 2% per annum and the rich person pays 2% interest and the poor person oays %600 percent, the rich person gets free credit while the poor person pays ~600% per annum. Surely you can see that this is worse for the poor person, even before factoring in that the rich person gets capital gains from asset inflation while the poor person gets real decrease in wages.