HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

chordalkeyboard

1,123 karma · joined November 27, 2019

These aren’t my boards but this is originally why I came here: https://www.gboards.ca/ .
submissionscomments
chordalkeyboard··on Four Basic Truths of Macroeconomics
> Absolute value of assets doesn't matter. What matters is future appreciation potential of those assets. That's my point.

Someones ability to buy in to those assets is relevant for their ability to realize that appreciation.

> You can infinitely subdivide them and see the same appreciation potential recognized over a greater number of units.

So? The units here don’t matter. The fact that the central bank policy resulted in real wage decrease and nominal asset price increase means that central bank policy benefitted the asset seller at the expense of the asset buyer. Playing fast and loose with units doesn’t change this.

> Remember when you invest in something what you want is for it to become less affordable. That decrease in affordability is called an "ROI" or return on investment.

This is a revealing statement and is actually good example of how central bank policy has distorted even the way people think about assets. You only want your investments to increase in price if you intend to sell or collateralize them. As investments proper, you want to earn dividends. But inflation has driven the prices of assets far out of proportion to their returns, so now people think of r.o.i. as something that happens when you sell.

chordalkeyboard··on Four Basic Truths of Macroeconomics
You misunderstood my comment.

> if you'd exchanged it for assets in the year of issue like you were supposed to

like you were supposed to This is exactly how the central bank policy is set up for the wealthy.

> You willingly took the haircut.

Alas, most Americans (and all the poor ones) do not have the same access to investment opportunities as myself.

chordalkeyboard··on Four Basic Truths of Macroeconomics
> Clearly dollar-denominated asset holders lose by first order effects

I don’t think you understand how this works. There are more dollars chasing the same number of assets, the asset holders are standing still while the dollar holders are falling behind.

> We benefit because otherwise those jobs would be lost entirely

If those jobs are lost due to decreased demand, the null hypothesis is that they should be lost, because they are no longer required. Its fine for you to feel otherwise but that’s why you would argue in favor of your alternate hypothesis where, despite the decrease in demand, we somehow know better than all those consumers, and decide that keeping a few apparently useless jobs around is more important than all those workers having stable incomes.

> along with the associated production which is worse in first order terms, but because it both reduces output and contracts demand, has second-order effects that would result in more job losses and production cuts.

If people aren’t purchasing those goods and services its entirely possible that we don’t need them to continue to be produced and propping them up with inflation is a bad idea.

> If the workers individually prefer not to be employed than to be employed at reduced real wages, they of course can voluntarily choose not to work (which by contracting supply will drive up wages for the remaining workers.)

This would be a good argument for asking them to take a pay cut. Inflation is a bad answer to this because it doesn’t result in a predictable or easily measureable decrease in wages. Btw this also has implications for the decision to use such a coarse-grained means to affect the economy.

> Yes, naturally if demand decreases both market-clearing price and market-clearing quantity should decrease. Wage stickiness pushes that all into quantity and not price cuts, which is more disruptive than smaller quantity cuts with some price cuts (both for the produced goods and the labor to produce them.)

If wage stickiness is a bad thing, then perhaps a cultural change towards accepting some variability in wages due to market conditions is indicated. However, its not clear that wage stickiness is even a bad thing, and its not clear that the guys who manipulate policy in order to deceive workers about the real value of their wages are doing it for the workers’ own good.

> Inflation doesn't prevent manufacturers from noticing demand cuts,

It absolutely can, what do you think this whole discussion is about? If they didn’t inflate the money supply then businesses would notice decreased demand and fire some workers, thats what you said.

> it just makes it more possible for them to cut prices as well as quantity in response to demand fluctuations

Not necessarily, in fact by increasing the nominal price of inputs it can make it more difficult for businesses to even survive.

chordalkeyboard··on Four Basic Truths of Macroeconomics
> I have at no point stated that. What I said is that inflation affects all debts equally.

So you do, at least, understand that a person with more debt benefits more than a person with less debt?

> Interest rate on loans is defined on "cost plus" basis, where "cost" is the treasury interest rate, and the "plus" is based on your default risk. However, the "cost" is the same for everyone no matter what.

So you are aware that poor people generally pay a premium for loans, based on their risk of default? And you see how that impacts their access to credit? And how this leads to wealthy people benefitting more?

> You can get a mortgage with as little as 3% down payment, so yes, I am referring to someone who has a $100K mortgage debt, a $100K house an $10K in other, misc assets like savings or investments.

That is the kind of person who may benefit from inflation, depending on their investment choices.

chordalkeyboard··on Four Basic Truths of Macroeconomics
> Boy are you going to freak out when you learn about stock splits and fractional share investing.

You really must be confused if you think thats a rebuttal.

chordalkeyboard··on Four Basic Truths of Macroeconomics
> Imagine last year you bought some asset, that someone else did not, and it appreciated 2% with the price level. You are not any better off.

I am better off if the nominal value of that asset matters, which it does if I want to sell it or leverage it. And anyone on a dollar denominated income is worse off.

> I see you are implying that the other person "couldn't afford" to invest and kept their money in cash instead, to argue that the other person is worse off.

You misunderstand, they don’t need to “keep their money in cash”. The asset price increased. Thats all. They are paid less in real terms, by design, therefore the asset costs more to them, because of inflation.

> the issue here is holding cash, not the wealth disparity.

This applies to people who are paid in dollars, it does not require them to hold them.

> Don't hold cash if you are worried about inflation.

Obviously the wealthy are in much better position to take this advice than the middle class, the working class, and the poor. Therefore inflation benefits the wealthy disproportionately.

chordalkeyboard··on Four Basic Truths of Macroeconomics
> You claim that central banks depreciate the currency because they "think wages among the working class are too high." But rhetorically, you are doing more than just referring to the explanation I gave above. You are implying that central banks "think" working class wages are too high, and want to lower them to hurt working class people.

Oh I know it does seem like the banks “want to hurt working class people” when you look at what they are doing and why. But thats an unnecessary hypothesis. They don’t need to care about working class people at all, just the financial interests of the oligarchs.

> Which is the opposite of the standard explanation - the purpose of inflation in that instance is to implicitly reduce the downward rigidity of wages so that employment does not contract as much in a downturn.

In other words, trick the workers into taking a pay cut, because they make too much money. “For their own good” and how convenient that it happens to pump up the assets that the wealthy own.

> Presumably you, champion of the working class, would rather more people be unemployed?

I want them to be unemployed the same way you want them to make less money in real terms.

chordalkeyboard··on Four Basic Truths of Macroeconomics
> lol, printing money wouldn't have changed anything there. If they made a -5% real return with no printing, and there's a 2% inflation rate, they'd have made a -3% notional return, or, and I believe this is true, a -5% real return.

This makes no sense. You print money and spend it on buggy whips, they continue to make a positive return. Because you printed money and took up the slack demand.

> Just as a 2006 vintage Krug isn't the same as a 2010 vintage Krug, a 2006 vintage dollar isn't the same as a 2010 vintage dollar.

This doesn’t make sense either, in 2010 the 2006 dollar is worth the same as the 2010 dollar.

chordalkeyboard··on Four Basic Truths of Macroeconomics
> Generally you have to have more assets than debt to be considered "wealthy." This is why the word "net" is important in the parent comment.

I think you’re missing the point.

> you are completely ignoring the second-order effects

I’m sure I referred to them repeatedly.

> an economy with low, stable inflation is good for everyone

This is argument by assertion, which I have already responded above by explaining, in detail, how this is not the case.

> look at the deflationary spirals of the great depression (or any pre-1900 crash) and any hyperinflationary economy of your choosing.

You’ve helped me to show why an unstable currency is bad. You haven’t supported your assertion of why a depreciating currency is good for everyone.

> COVID hits, demand plummets, we do nothing to try to keep people in jobs or keep the financial system from collapsing. Less production is indicated!

Sounds good. Those pesky billionaires are going to be upset that we don’t continue to pump up their asset prices but whatever.

> No one is talking about counter-cyclical monetary policy and implying it is being used to keep anachronistic firms in business.

Why not? Why is it good to print money so unproductive workers don’t get laid off, but its bad to print money to keep unproductive firms from disappearing?

chordalkeyboard··on Four Basic Truths of Macroeconomics
> It lets everyone do so

Citation for your claim that everyone has access to cheap credit. Are you aware of payday loans? [0]

> and as a fraction of net worth, the poor are way disproportionately exposed, and hence benefit.

Citation needed for your claim that the poor can access these low interest rates.

> A billionaire with $1B in net worth isn't leveraged to 10B in real estate.

Citation needed. Why do you think a person with $11B in assets wouldn’t borrow $10B?

> Someone worth $10K may easily have $100K in mortgage debt, however.

Citation needed. Do you mean someone worth $110k has a $100k mortgage? Or do you mean someone worth -$90k has $10k in assets and liabilities totalling $100k?

> Why do you say people who have both debt and assets benefit more than those who have just debts?

Because inflation causes assets to appreciate in nominal terms (assuming constant real value) and debt to depreciate in real terms.

> They strictly dont because those assets have to outperform inflation. Debts do not.

I’m not sure what you mean by “outperform inflation”

> That's irrelevant - that is to say, a separate problem

It means your theory about poor people benefitting from low interest rates is not true.

> because inflation affects everyone regardless of interest rate equally.

Citation needed.

> Interest rates are set based on likelihood of default.

You know this and yet you continue to assert that poor people benefit as much or more than the wealthy? I guess you think a person with a minimum wage job and no assets is just as likely to default as a billionaire?

> Yes, in aggregate, no the cost of houses hasn't increased on an inflation adjusted dollars per square foot basis since the 1970s

Right, when you adjust for the inflation, it hasn’t increased at all. Which is basically the point. The prices go up because of inflation, people who hold assets sell them for more money, people who earn paychecks get the same amount of dollars but can buy less for it, etc. None of this is controversial except when saying it around the proles who might take offense at the efforts of oligarchs to eat the bottoms out of their paychecks and savings.

> No, this is a fundamental misunderstanding. All businesses see their expenses and revenues rise with inflation.

But not at the same time or at the same rate. After all, if all prices relected inflation at the same time, there would be no point.

> If they choose not to adjust their salaries commensurately, they've made a conscious decision to reduce pay a fraction of income.

No, the bankers are the ones who made the conscious decision. Good rhetorical judo tho.

> [citation needed]

> You've stated a bunch of stuff as fact without sources.

Some of it is basically common knowledge, like poor people not having the collaterall, credit history, or social value required to access the same loans as billionaires. Some of it just seems like fundamental misunderstanding on your part, like your belief that all prices inflate at the same rate.

[0] https://www.cnbc.com/2021/02/16/map-shows-typical-payday-loa...

chordalkeyboard··on Four Basic Truths of Macroeconomics
> That does not increase the real value of those assets,

Exactly correct. It decreases the value of the money use to pay for them, resulting in a higher nominal price and fewer people in society who are able to afford them, resulting in less access to capital for the majority of society.

> and it does not have any distributional consequences.

False. When assets go up relative to currency, fewer buyers can compete for those assets, leading to the wealthy owning more and the poor getting poorer.

> But you'd rather expose your ignorance on the Internet for us to see.

I’m quite sure I’ve acquitted myself satisfactorily in this discussion, if you feel the same about yourself, perhaps you’re the one who needs to peruse the literature.

> I happen to know a lot about central banking, actually. You might be pulling a Dunning-Kruger on this one.

Then how could you have been ignorant of Krugman’s statements to the effect that inflation was necessary because workers’ make too much money? Did you know he had said that? If so, why ask me for a source? If not, how much do you really know about central banks? Especially if you think that the words of several economists are evidence of some conspiracy?

chordalkeyboard··on Four Basic Truths of Macroeconomics
> As everyone includes the rich, it is true that they benefit, but not especially true.

Asst holders benefit disproportionately, as do debtors. The people who benefit most have both assets and debt. These are wealthy people.

> The alternative is not “employment at the same wages” when demand drops, it's “production cuts and unemployment, resulting in larger second order demand drop, resulting in more production cuts and unemployment, etc.”

So by tricking people into taking less compensation for the same amount of work, we benefit how? If demand decreases then production should decrease, because less production is indicated.

> That this is generally worse for everyone including the working class, both as a whole and even many of the workers in the sector seeing the initial demand drop should be pretty easy to see.

No, I’m seeing the opposite. When the automobile replaced the horse-and-buggy, demand for buggy whips decreased as it should have. printing money so that the buggy whip makers didn’t notice that there was less demand for their product would have been a disservice

chordalkeyboard··on Four Basic Truths of Macroeconomics
> Do they? Generally inflation benefits debtors and not lenders, because debts are denominated in dollars in the year of issue, and repaid in future dollars, which are worth 2% less per year.

Yes, exactly. This allows wealthy people to borrow money and pay it back with less value.

> Overwhelmingly poor and middle class folks are debtors (think mortgages).

Poor people often don’t have access to these extremely low interest rates because of structural inequalities and credit requirements (and exceptions tend to leave them worse off as well, see the subprime fiasco). Meanwhile the cheap credit bids up the prices of those assets, benefitting the people who have them (wealthy) as opposed to the people buying them (upwardly mobile or aspirational).

> Mortgages have become more and more affordable each year. This means folks can afford more and more house for the same money, after all the bulk of the payment of a 30 year fixed is interest for the first 10+ years.

Not in aggregate, because the cost of a house increases as people bid for houses with the cheap credit.

> Yeah but at the end of that day that's irrelevant. The only thing that matters is what those units represent. If I gave you 5 today and 3 tomorrow does that mean anything? Or course not. 5 what and 3 what? That's what we're talking about

Right, and at the end of the day those units represent less value because of the actions of the central bank. Furthermore those actions were intended to have that exact effect. So how are you claiming that business owners are supposed to work in opposition to central bank policy? Clearly if the central bank wants wages to decrease in real terms, and business owners increase them nominally to make them neutral in real terms, this frustrates central bank policy and they will logically just print more money.

> It's your responsibility in a capitalist society to allocate capital most productively and so if this particular allocation isn't the most productive, your job is to go find it.

The problem is the distorting effect of low interest rates means that what is productive in terms of nominal r.o.i. is not what is productive in real terms, but the market distortions are so pervasive and persistent that people have to chase the nominal returns. This is incredibly destructive to value, society, and community.

chordalkeyboard··on Four Basic Truths of Macroeconomics
> Source this claim.

Asset price inflation vs depreciation of debt in real terms. Wealthy people hold assets that are valued in currency. Depreciating currency causes those assets to go up in nominal terms, and additionally depreciating currency causes a flight to assets. Wealthy people (by definition) have more assets than non-wealthy people, hence this flight from currency to assets bids up the prices of assets.

> Everyone benefits from a depreciating currency, because inflation provides a buffer against deflationary spirals that lead to large recessions.

Thats a theory-laden and motivated explanation. Surely you can do better than just argument by assertion?

> Tell me exactly how inflation benefits only the ultra-wealthy and not anyone else.

Thats not my claim.

> I would suggest that you clarify this claim so it does not sound so much like a conspiracy theory.

I suggest you do your own research and discover that the central bank is very much fact and not at all theory.

chordalkeyboard··on Four Basic Truths of Macroeconomics
> What's your point.

Should be obvious from the discussion, especially for someone who “knows quite a bit” about the subject.

> Hi yes I know quite a bit about sticky wages and inflation.

Then why did you ask me for a source for a statement that is well understood among anyone who has studied the subject? Krugman’s statements to this effect are so well-known as to have been written about in other publications.

Back to the original statement: Is it that hard to say “we think wages among the working class are too high so the central bank depreciates the currency”? well is it?

chordalkeyboard··on Four Basic Truths of Macroeconomics
> Ah you get it. That's the idea. Buy gold if you want, I don't care, but money is an intermediary, not a long-term store of value.

Only because the wealthy benefit from depreciating currency. It doesn’t have to be this way, and it is this way because of policy that is designed to benefit the ultra-wealthy.

> They're paying you less value so it's a decrease. You're tripping yourself up focusing on units.

They’re paying the same, but the units depreciated because the oligarchs want workers’ wages to go down.

> If you treat it as one you'll have a bad time. Just like if you treated your horse as a boat.

Or treat a savings account as a savings account.

chordalkeyboard··on Four Basic Truths of Macroeconomics
> ok let me be more polite: source???

Other than the quotes from the op that started this thing, you can go read the NYT resident economist Paul Krugman on “sticky wages” and inflation. Its paywalled (so I won’t provide a link) but should be the first results on any search engine.

> If you think your assertions are "actually true" then back them up.

This comment thread started because the first thing I quoted was an economist asserting this in obscurant language. I suggest you re-read from the beginning.

chordalkeyboard··on Four Basic Truths of Macroeconomics
> Inflation only matters from the time you receive your paycheck to the time you invest it in productive assets or buy the necessities of life.

It means the people who save by depositing cash in the bank lose value over time, causing them to purchase investments out of necessity (rather than purchasing them because they believe its a good investment). This bids up the price of investments relative to their return, which effectively reduces returns to a level commensurate with the artificially low interest rates.

It also negatively impacts anyone who is long cash for any reason (perhaps their business requires them to retain a certain amount) and anyone who relies on fixed payments denominated in dollars (retirees, pensioners, disabled persons, those on public assistance, etc.).

> After that it sets the benchmark rate of return for your investments.

Those are nominal returns, not real returns. Inflation generates no real returns.

> If your salary fails to track inflation that's between you and your boss who's giving you a pay cut year over year

Nice rhetorical judo, to frame the central bank’s actions as normal and the lack of an increase as a decrease.

> or between you and congress if you're under the minimum wage umbrella.

Alas, if congress could lower the minimum wage without political fallout, economists might suggest they do that instead of inflating the money supply.

> Currency only has value while its changing hands and inflation is an incentive to change hands. If you'd invested in anything at all 100 years ago you'd have just as much value as you do today. If you insisted in sticking a square peg in a round hole and hid your cash in your mattress the whole time, inflation did its job and took that value from you.

This is why time preference should be taught in school.

chordalkeyboard··on Four Basic Truths of Macroeconomics
> If what you want to say is that you think the government is run by a shadowy cabal of elites whose main purpose is to impoverish the common man, then just say that.

I’m not sure why I would need to go that far afield when I can just deal with the actual words spoken by actual economists where they literally say this with slighty obscurant language. This isn’t a “shadowy cabal,” its mainstream media and economics here.

If the actual intent of economic policy is so threatening to your worldview that you need to poison the well by invoking shadowy conspiracies, perhaps you should re-evaluate your own perspective on the issue.

> I'm just going to call you a conspiracy theorist because it's probably not worth arguing with you, and "the amount of energy needed to refute bullshit is an order of magnitude larger than to produce it."

Yeah it would probably require an infinite amount of energy to refute my assertions, since they are actually true. And I think we are beyond considering the existence of the central bank to be a “conspiracy theory”, it’s kind of established.

chordalkeyboard··on Whistleblowers: Software keeping inmates in Arizona prisons beyond release dates
I’m not sure why you’re being downvoted. You did offer a reasonable answer. I think other people are reacting emotionally, the same way I did, because they are morally outraged at the perceived situation.
chordalkeyboard··on Show HN: Community of professionals, with satisfaction and transparency at core
Failure to offer an independent login option is tone deaf in this day and age.
chordalkeyboard··on Transportation Engineers Are Legally Obligated to Protect the Public
> Does this mean that transportation professionals are bad people and solely to blame for the transportation pandemic in the U.S.? Certainly not. But just as Dr. Semmelweis’ peers in 1847 bristled at the idea that they might be killing their patients by not washing their hands during medical procedures, a portion of transportation professionals are also actively hostile to the suggestion that they bear some responsibility of the death toll in this country, despite being in the best position to do something about it. Many more who are well intentioned were not prepared by university curricula to think proactively about applying ethics to design and end up learning from peers to do things as they have always been done. For others, the profession just represents a paycheck and they have not considered the issue. Still, another portion of engineers and planners have recognized the problem and have worked to bring reform from within. The development of manuals from organizations like the National Association of City Transportation Officials and engineers pushing for lowering speed limits in communities around the country are good examples. Unfortunately, these individuals are often stymied by the great barrier of the infamous “standards.”

Yeah the problem is systemic and our transport networks have to become more suited to bicycles if we want to tackle obesity and carbon release.

chordalkeyboard··on Whistleblowers: Software keeping inmates in Arizona prisons beyond release dates
> Yes, thank you for the tautology. You'll note that this was exactly my question: does the state make such exceptions?

Why would they?

> I'm a bit perplexed by your responses -- it seems like you either have information you aren't sharing, or like this subject make you impassioned.

I’m sorry if I come across negatively. I am impassioned about this. People who are locked up have no recognized rights. They are at the mercy of the guards. Not the legislature, not the prison system, the guards.

chordalkeyboard··on Whistleblowers: Software keeping inmates in Arizona prisons beyond release dates
> at which point the authority in question would recognize that this constitutes an exception to said revocation.

I think you misunderstand the nature of authority by thinking that they would recognize this as an exception.

> You know ... the obvious way.

Whats obvious here is that an incarcerated person only has the options that the carceral state permits to them.

chordalkeyboard··on Whistleblowers: Software keeping inmates in Arizona prisons beyond release dates
Most people who can afford good lawyers never spend a day in custody.
chordalkeyboard··on Whistleblowers: Software keeping inmates in Arizona prisons beyond release dates
How do you propose for an inmate to contact his representation?
chordalkeyboard··on Whistleblowers: Software keeping inmates in Arizona prisons beyond release dates
You’re assuming that agents of the government are expected to follow their own laws. Those laws are for you and me, not our beknighted public servants.
chordalkeyboard··on Project Xanadu
> Because purchasing digital stuff is done within the realm of capitalism, which uses scarcity to guarantee value. If the scarcity is removed or reduced, the price goes down approaching to 0. We saw cost reductions happen with music with Napster, and movies with Bittorrent.

Yes, I believe this is why they are called “micropayments.” Its expected that the price will approach zero.

> And the way to enforce scarcity with digital stuff means anti-user encryption and rights-reduction with DRM.

I’m sorry, this seems like a non sequitur. Why are they trying to maintain scarcity again?

> And without DRM, a single user "buys" the content, breaks the connection with transclusion,

Then how would people know the version of the content they have is the same as the content they want?

> and uploads it for cheaper than legit,

You misunderstand. There is no such thing, they own the content, the price they charge for transcluding their copy is their decision. They’re allowed to charge a low price.

> Then you're making money on copyright violations

So its clear that either the law would have to change or people wouldn’t be using this for copyrighted works. This could replace copyright by giving content creators an alternate means of distribution.

> and do you really think the powers that be would allow

No you’re right, might as well just give up and go back to facebook and youtube

> and do you really think the powers that be would allow this system with anonymous accounts/payments/withdrawal? (And there's your user tracking, user attestation, and anti-privacy tech

So basically no problems with Xanadu that you can identify, but a lot of assumptions about society and politics that you believe would make it untenable. Got it.

chordalkeyboard··on Project Xanadu
I’m not seeing why. You purchase a copy of the datum. If someone links to you, they pay a micropayment and ontain their own copy, which they can then sell. It “should” be trivial to set your micropayment to zero if you want.
chordalkeyboard··on Two Concepts of Constitutive Rules (2018) [pdf]
> For the world-to-word direction of fit we must distinguish between three kinds. For all three kinds it holds that somehow the facts in the world are adapted, in order to “fit” what is expressed by the words. One case is when the words function as a directive, as when James shouts “Carol, stop!” when he fears that his young daughter Carol will cross the busy street. This order aims at making Carol stop, and if the order is successful in the sense of “efficacious”, Carol will stop and the facts in the world fit the content of the order.

> A second form of the world-to-word direction of fit manifests itself in constitutive speech acts. Constitutive speech acts are speech acts performed with the intention to bring about a particular change through the operation of a rule or convention. They differ from directives which operate by means of a causal, rather than a rule-based, connection. Examples of constitutive speech acts are the baptism of a ship (“I hereby baptize you the Princess Victoria”), making a promise (“I promise you to be back before 8 o’clock this evening”), granting a power (“You can consider every promise made by Michal on my behalf as a promise made by me”), and the issuing of a command (as distinguished from an order).

> The third kind of world-to-word direction of fit concerns the effects of rules. Take for example the conceptual rule (the meaning postulate) that the word “rectangle” denotes quadrilaterals with four orthogonal angles. Given this rule, if something is a rectangle, it must be a quadrilateral with four orthogonal angles.

← PreviousPage 8 of 34Next →