HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

chordalkeyboard

1,123 karma · joined November 27, 2019

These aren’t my boards but this is originally why I came here: https://www.gboards.ca/ .
submissionscomments
chordalkeyboard··on Activists who embrace nuclear power
The problem is bioaccumulation of radioactive isotopes.
chordalkeyboard··on Activists who embrace nuclear power
> It's kind of facile to argue about a hypothetical future a thousand years in the future when we're facing crises right now that depend on solving energy issues yesterday.

Its facile to dismiss the negative of creating waste that has to be managed for thousands of years based on a sense of urgency for solving immediate problems. Thats payday loan mentality, not statecraft.

> Scenario 1: a hypothetical societal collapse happens and scientific knowledge and written language are somehow lost. A handful of people explore a dangerous area and are swiftly killed by radiation from tampering with a storage facility.

Society collapses and the remaining primitive population is decimated or eradicated because of unmanaged waste entering the ecosystem.

> Scenario 2: millions die from climate-related catastrophes and ecological collapse leads to famines that kill millions more.

You think society collapses to the extent that we can no longer manage the nuclear waste, and millions of people don’t die? Millions of people die in both scenarios, but in one they are greater risk of nuclear waste exposure.

> We know we're facing scenario two as a distinct possibility, or we'd be happily burning coal until we can't find any more.

What is your plan to get China et al to stop burning coal, by the way?

> Fuel reprocessing is a thing, modern reactors deplete the fuel much more thoroughly, and there isn't even that much of it. All of the spent fuel France has used since the 1970s fits in a small fraction of their basketball-court sized storage facility.

I can roll over my payday loan on a miminum wage paycheck, what could go wrong?

chordalkeyboard··on Nocebo effect hampering Europe’s vaccine roll out
> Or register with your email address to read our website free for the next 24 hours

No thanks

chordalkeyboard··on Malcolm X family says letter shows NYPD and FBI conspired in his murder
> There is nothing wrong with the web page. The Guardian, one of my favorite sources of news (NPR being another) has a solid web site, please try again.

It repeatedly crashed on my ipad, I’m a web consumer, if I can’t access content on a modern device, the webpage is in fact broken.

> If it is true what the article says, I think that it is healthy for our country to get it out, clean the air, and try to learn to have more over site in the future.

This is absolutely true, and indicates that journalists like the grauniad are negligent in putting important information on webshites.

> One of the shining moments for democracy in the USA was when McNamara admitted that he and President Johnson lied repeatedly to the US public about the Gulf of Tonkin episode to get us into the Vietnamese war. I hope that that was a learning experience for everyone to trust but verify what the government says.

“Trust but verify” certainly, I’ll verify that TS SAP’s are being executed according to the will of the people, just as soon as they give me access.

chordalkeyboard··on [dead]
Interesting comments on the post....
chordalkeyboard··on How to have better arguments online
> But I don't share the common HN conceit that commenters on HN are better than elsewhere.

I think this is better expressed as “people almost everywhere else are terrible.” Its not that HN is better (although the crowd here is learned, intelligent, and generally aspires to professional behavior), its that most places online with more than 20 average daily users are trash.

> I could share a little CSS to add dark mode support and a few other tweaks to HN, if anyone is interested.

Please

chordalkeyboard··on Show HN: Sabre – The bullshit-free (c) programming language
> there is an argument

Lol

chordalkeyboard··on Are Disagreements Honest? (2004) [pdf]
I think its human nature. If you don’t think this is something you do, then you’re probably doing it more.
chordalkeyboard··on The madam of Bangladesh’s oldest brothel
Horrific.
chordalkeyboard··on White House working with Facebook and Twitter to tackle anti-vaxxers
Anti-vaxxers like the President and Vice President?

https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/politics/with-covid-19-vaccin...

chordalkeyboard··on The Texas power outage is a nation-wide problem
> I haven't heard of municipal light companies making it illegal to generate your own electricity or not connect your house to the grid, apart from general fit-for-occupancy laws.

It sounds like you haven’t done much research on this but anyone who has tried to opt out quickly discovers that these things exist. For example, in many municipalities it is illegal to occupy a dwelling that is not served with electricity from the grid. Having discovered this myself because the power company refused to sell me power, because they couldn’t confirm my identity, because they only way they were willing to confirm my identity was through a credit bureau asking me about my credit history, of which for some reason they had no records, (respectfully) I’m unwilling to do the unpaid labor of searching the internet to prove something I know very well from personal experience. Suffice it to say I rented a house and was unable to legally occupy it for a week because I had to get someone else to call the power company and turn on the lights. There are laws that prevent people from opting out.

> In general for any given decree, one can always choose to to ignore it and bear specific consequences. This applies to de jure governments and de facto government alike. It takes a functioning market with many different options to diminish those consequences to the point where they can be accepted as some natural order rather than centralized diktats.

Agreed, and thanks for the reply.

chordalkeyboard··on The Adams Event
That’s a possible cause for punctuated equilibrium evolutionary theory
chordalkeyboard··on Perseverance Rover lands on Mars [video]
You multiply 7* 8 then add 3 and put that number over 8* 5, resulting in 59/40, roughly 1.5”.
chordalkeyboard··on The Texas power outage is a nation-wide problem
> For the qualities under discussion, generation companies have seemingly acted in lockstep, therefore it makes sense to view them as a singular entity. And it's not productive to call signing up for electric service consensual in any meaningful way. The ability to technically opt out isn't worth much when it would significantly impact your life, as evidenced by the vanishingly small amount of people who do so.

This is true.

> You can also come at the reduction from the other direction and define how interacting with the "government" is technically consensual as well. eg don't pay taxes, do the work required to not have your income flows surveilled, etc. Or in this case, don't sign up for the (de jure) government power grid, and go your own way.

This is willfully ignorant of how governments don’t let people do any of this. Being subjected to violence if you decline to participate is the opposite of consent.

> The point is that all frameworks ultimately have their limits - they are only good when their reasoning power holds. True understanding requires being able to switch between them as appropriate, rather than shoehorning everything into one and insisting that it must fit.

I agree with this and I was unclear. I mention consenting interactions because many of the people who oppose increases in the scope of state-sponsored activities prefer to source their necessities from markets. I’m aware that the tentacles of the government are long and broad and no part of the economy (least of all power generation) is free from this interference. There was probably a better way to express this in this thread.

chordalkeyboard··on California State Legislator Introduces Bill to Decriminalize Psychedelics
> It's also hella dangerous combined with weed

I’ve never heard this before; it seems like something I should know; respecfully, would you mind elaborating?

chordalkeyboard··on Caltech to Remove the Names of Robert A. Millikan and Other Eugenics Proponents
The sibling was flagged and killed while I wrote the following reply; I’m unwilling to let it vanish into the aether:

> Eugenics, the only discredited science, that seems to work exceptionally well when applied to plants, livestock, microbiology, horses, household pets, but magically fails when the idea is applied to the human race?

The failure is a result of the lack of a definition for “good genes” aside from whatever any random person thinks is good. That is, the fitness of an organism always and necessarily refers to a specific environment, and the characteristics (genes) that make it fit for that environment are not the same as the ones that make it fit for another environment. This means that there is no objective measure upon which to determine which genes are good and which are not. Eugenics is subjective.

> The idea is morally reprehensible, but the idea that all you have to do to cull out say "sickle cell disease" from the human race as a whole is to stop say "black people" from breeding is actually scientifically sound.

In the first place, sickle cell anemia provides some protection against malaria. So whether it is adaptive or maladaptive depends on the environment. But secondly, sickle cell evolved naturally, and removing it from the breeding population doesn’t stop that from happening again.

> Like I said the idea is morally reprehensible and we should never do that. But the idea that you couldn't theoretically control a population and eliminate "undesirable" traits from the gene pool is just willfully ignoring the obvious soundness of the mathematics.

I don’t think people are denying what you’re claiming here. They are responding by noting that there is an incredible power differential between the eugenicist and the people who are prevented from reproducing (I’m sure this is obvious) and there is no objective basis on which to scientifically decide who is supposed to reproduce and who is not. Together these facts create the inescapable impression that eugenics is about having kids and preventing the competition from doing the same.

chordalkeyboard··on The Texas power outage is a nation-wide problem
> These are the exact same pathology. You're drawing a distinction based on whether one is "government", but they're the same type of lethargic entrenched entity, regardless of how they were chartered.

One type of lethargic entrenched entity survives on the basis of consensual interactions, the other survives on the basis of economic values extracted by threats of violence. The pathology is in forcing the people who want to benefit from consensual interactions to support a system of coercion.

> The actual problem is the lack of accountability. The free market philosophy points us to exit as an ideal of accountability. Sometimes exit works very well - switching electric providers during quiescent times to get pricing that better matches your usage. And sometimes relying on exit fails terribly, like this rare event where it is easier to balk at obligations rather than have prepared enough to fulfill them. If we care about exit in general, then it behooves us to recognize when it fails.

I can agree with this.

chordalkeyboard··on The Texas power outage is a nation-wide problem
It probably doesn’t matter because neither halting the tide nor producing heat in the winter are problems that are solved by authoritarian measures.
chordalkeyboard··on The Texas power outage is a nation-wide problem
> The belief is that every American should have uninterrupted access to electricity. The fact is that we are woefully under investing to keep that state of affairs. You can have your own beliefs, you can't have your own facts.

The belief that the best way to get every American to have uninterrupted access to electricity is through public investment in infrastructure is belied by your admission that hasn’t happened. Which is a fact.

> For some reason people who want to spend less money on infrastructure don't mention that they wouldn't mind if 50% of people don't have access to roads, hospitals, or electricity.

For some reason the people who want to spend more money on publicly funded projects insist on casting aspersions rather than introspecting on why they’re always dependent on expropriation for basic things.

chordalkeyboard··on The Texas power outage is a nation-wide problem
Thats probably a result of superior management of infrastructure rather than “application of enough force.”
chordalkeyboard··on The Texas power outage is a nation-wide problem
Was King Canute making maximal use of his power when he ordered back the waves, or could he have deployed his army to the beach to reinforce his edicts?
chordalkeyboard··on The Texas power outage is a nation-wide problem
Then this is the indicated response: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/King_Canute_and_the_tide
chordalkeyboard··on California State Legislator Introduces Bill to Decriminalize Psychedelics
> Why is it nonsensical?

Because territorialism is ubiquitous in the animal kingdom and aboriginal societies also had a concept of territory. They reject it because its a social convention and therefore its always possible to reject it. But they reject it because they don’t like being excluded from territories and they think rejecting the social convention of land ownership will result in a new arrangement where they are no longer excluded from territories. However this is like rejecting the social convention of English because you want to be able to make noises that English-speakers consider to be insulting. They haven’t addressed the fact that society relies on ownership notions in order to do things like produce food and housing; and they have no plan to allocate scarce resources in the absence of ownership norms.

> I've always interpreted this as being an attempt to call attention to things like the relative shortness of our lives in comparison to the earth and an argument that there's a certain amount of hubris involved in saying that you own components of ecosystems that you exist within and depend on to live.

Thats a valid response to a metaphysical concept of ownership as a thing-in-itself that has meaning outside of human relations. My response is to ground ownership in reciprocal norms that arise emergently from human interaction. And to justify them on the basis of egalitarian human rights.

chordalkeyboard··on The Texas power outage is a nation-wide problem
For certain values of ‘us’ ;)
chordalkeyboard··on The Texas power outage is a nation-wide problem
> Ensuring the electric grid doesn't collapse when it gets below 20 degrees is in fact exactly the sort of thing that can be fixed with enough application of force.

This seems like the sort of belief system that inspired the story of King Canute and the tide. [0]

> Spend the money, or we'll take it from you. Done.

I understand that a lot of people only care about justifying the expropriation of wealth. But it seems you’ve forgotten to include the part where the expropriation is actually justified on the basis of promises to do something good with that money.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/King_Canute_and_the_tide

chordalkeyboard··on The Texas power outage is a nation-wide problem
> It has nothing to do with the government and everything to do with beliefs.

Government is not separable from the beliefs of the people who inhabit it and participate in its processes.

> Pointing out simple facts like that all grids have been under invested in for 50 years

Surely you can see that this is a belief and not a “fact”

> that we need to spend trillions to bring them up to todays standards and that we need to diversity power sources is met with derision and downvotes.

Well if people disagree then I feel it would be better for them to discuss. But it seems like there’s this perception that there is no room for reasonable disagreement and that’s what I was pushing back on.

We can agree that the grid needs more investment and still have differences of opinion on how to generate that investment.

chordalkeyboard··on California State Legislator Introduces Bill to Decriminalize Psychedelics
Some people reject ownership of land. Its good that this is getting more discussion because I think its generally nonsensical and this idea is rather old and doesn’t get debunked because up until recently it rarely made it out of socialist/communist dogma.
chordalkeyboard··on The Texas power outage is a nation-wide problem
> Texans preferring to go cold and starve than suffer the burden of regulation or government. This was not the philosophy of Texas governance succeeding as planned, it was clearly a monumental failure.

Authoritarian government also has failures that result in millions of deaths; I’m unsure how you can be so confident that no one in Texas (of all places) would rather freeze to death than willingly accept the risk of being frozen to death by a tyrannical government that promises things then breaks promises.

To be clear this isn’t about the object-level issue of preferring starvation under one ideology to starvation under another. This is about the inability of other people to comprehend that anyone could possibly feel differently than they do about who starves you to death.

> None of us are trying to die for the glory of a sociopathic libertarian ideal.

None of us are trying to die for the glory of a psychotic marxist ideal but we still pay taxes.

chordalkeyboard··on The Libet experiment doesn't disprove free will (2019)
Thats not really true, the probabilities are the literal explanation that precedes any interpretation.
chordalkeyboard··on The Libet experiment doesn't disprove free will (2019)
> If you're not going to put more effort into understand something new, it is not my job to make you understand it.

I’m quite confident in my understanding that ‘free will’ is nonsensical and useless but that confidence doesn’t extend to assuming that I couldn’t be incorrect. However you’re asserting that its useful and so the correct response is to invite you to teach me. Now your response is that (after days of discussion and many replies) you can’t be bothered to explain yourself to someone who won’t educate themselves. Well that implies that I should have explained why ‘free will’ is nonsense in order to prompt you. This reveals a lack of understanding of the issue. My arguments are going to be unpersuasive unless I use the same definition of ‘free will’ as you (which you refuse to provide). Of course if I had made the argument, the natural response would be to say that I didn’t understand, used the wrong definition, etc. so we can avoid all that useless banter by having you explain to us what ‘free will’ means and how it is so logical and useful of a concept.

> There is like 10 differnet ways to explain it with different kinds of logic, how am I supposed to know which one you want to hear?

The context of the discussion is clear as to what sort of definition would be appropriate.

> So you couldn't even find one example huh? That link not people talking to GPT as a converstaion with an sentient being.

I see you have shifted the goalposts by invoking another ill-defined concept. Thanks for the reply.

← PreviousPage 9 of 34Next →