14,217 karma · joined October 16, 2014
Edit: others have noted the provider and harness matters. My experience is with opencode.
Probably. I’d certainly not want to use a mechanic who doesn’t understand the combustion engine, or who is incapable of giving at least a high-level overview of it.
I haven’t followed that advice, because I quite like my jobs, and getting deep into a problem space is one of life’s pleasures. But, I do think it’s sound advice all the same.
This has been a big part of the job for anyone on a team for at least 20 years. I do agree that it’s the hardest and worst part of the job, and has now become the majority of the job for anyone who isn’t vibe coding. So, that sucks.
It’s a lot of fun working on such things, but the reality is, for most apps, almost any stack is more than fine.
Basically, they still need a human guiding them pretty closely unless you’re happy to just ship a mountain of vibe coded mush.
That said, I haven’t tried Astra in earnest yet. We’ll see in a few weeks whether or not it is a step change.