HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

chucksmash

2,817 karma · joined December 16, 2014

submissionscomments
chucksmash··on Swiss Copyright Law: Downloading Stays Legal, No Site Blocking
Maybe a marginally higher incentive to murder people to get works into the public domain, I guess?

If only society had some other, competing set of incentives in place to disincentivize murdering people.

chucksmash··on The boring technology behind a one-person Internet company (2018)
I think the assumption is that ListenNotes is his only source of income and that he isn't burning personal savings or the capital he has invested on non-mandatory expenses.

Granted those assumptions, you've got to get pretty far up Maslow's Hierarchy of Needs to hit "rent a WeWork"

chucksmash··on Ask HN: Are you ok?
I don't grant the validity of that analogy. People aren't gears of a clock and, when you say they are to a corporation, you are giving them a pass that is built on assumptions of an agency which they lack. Maybe legally you cannot pierce the veil, but ethically and morally a corporation is just other people making decisions and doing things.

If someone is treated this way, a whole cadre of other >people< had to be the ones to enact it. My previous statement stands - maybe there are overriding reasons to do business with people like that for some, but to me that's a hard pass. If you can't trust somebody to even be a decent human being, what can you trust them with?

chucksmash··on Ask HN: Are you ok?
I guess you could approach it that way. I definitely treat job interviews that way (e.g. try not to be negative about a previous employer, even if it is justified).

If I were in a situation where I felt like I needed to approach interactions with my manager this way lest they try to screw me, I don't think I'd be interested in staying in that kind of environment. I guess some folks have overriding priorities where they are willing to endure antagonism and gotchas like that, but sheesh.

chucksmash··on Vinyl set to outsell CDs for first time since 1986
It's pretty clear if you think it through a bit.

You can buy Pet Sounds, a classic album recorded in 1966, on vinyl:

- Distribution: you can buy it from Amazon, the same distribution channel as more modern media

- Price: for $18 (very small premium over digital media in absolute terms)

- Condition: in perfect, newly manufactured condition

- Substitutability: a functionally perfect substitute good for the artifact manufactured in 1966 (even available in original mono!)

- Supply: from a growing supply of records (record company always reissuing classics!)

- Maintenance: with the same maintenance requirements as an LP of a 2019 album

Consider the equivalent for a classic car, say a 1966 Corvette:

I want a 1966 Corvette. "Old Corvettes have a soul that new Corvettes lack, there's just some ineffable quality I prefer, y'know?", yadda yadda yadda

- Distribution: Can I walk into a Chevy dealership and buy a 1966 Corvette? Nope!

- Price: Can I buy a mint condition 1966 Corvette for substantially the same price as a 2019 Corvette? Nope! DDG says perfect 1966 Corvette value would be $82k, 2019 Corvette would be $55k and I suspect the difference would be even greater tbh. $30k+ price difference!

- Condition: Can I buy a newly manufactured 1966 Corvette at all? Nope!

- Substitutability: the 1966 Corvette is substantially different from the 2019 Corvette

- Supply: the number of well-maintained 1966 Corvettes is constrained. They aren't making any more!

- Maintenance: Entirely different beasts. No common parts.

So if I want a conversation piece in my living room, I can buy a $100 record player and spend $8 more for the LP

chucksmash··on WeWork Parent Weighs Slashing Its Valuation in Half
I'd assume it'd be certain jurisdictions. You definitely don't need a liquor license to serve beer and wine universally[1].

[1]: Which leads to insane decisions like restaurants that make "Bloody Marys" with beer...

chucksmash··on TSV Utilities: Command line tools for large, tabular data files
Can't find a source for it now, but one of the design goals of JSON iirc was that it should be easy to parse.

You should have a go at writing a JSON parser to convince yourself it isn't hard. Can manually lex it in less than 150 lines of Python.

chucksmash··on TypeScript vs. ReasonML
It isn't[1]. It's a "partner project" to ReasonML which ReasonML relies on[2].

[1]: https://www.bloomberg.com/company/press/open-source-at-bloom...

[2]: https://reasonml.github.io/docs/en/what-and-why

chucksmash··on Mozilla’s Manifest v3 FAQ
> In the absence of a true standard for browser extensions, perhaps Mozilla should consider trying to form one by leading with a strong example instead of weakly implying that they will eventually probably cave to the monopolist.

That's exactly what they've tried to do. Firefox exposes a `chrome` namespace object to extensions which is intended to be more or less API compatible with what Chrome provides and added the `browser` namespace object where improvements to the base compatibility are added (e.g. switching from callback based APIs to Promise based APIs). See the bit from the wiki below and the link to the browserext spec:

> Mozilla has worked with Microsoft and Opera to implement browser extensions so that developers can write extensions that work across multiple browsers. The preliminary specification[1] matches what Google has implemented in Chrome so that extensions will work on Chrome, Edge, Opera and Firefox.[2]

[1]: https://browserext.github.io/browserext/

[2]: https://wiki.mozilla.org/WebExtensions/Spec

chucksmash··on NLP's Clever Hans Moment Has Arrived
It's not cheating, but it does circumvent the assessment value of the test imo. The quote in the article about shallow heuristics can totally be appropriated:

> [Good test takers] are prone to adopting shallow heuristics that succeed for the majority of [tests], instead of learning the underlying [facts] that they are intended to [assess].

Semi-related, I wonder where one draws the line on which heuristics are deep vs shallow in test taking. If a question assesses vocabulary knowledge by asking you to pick an appropriate word from several choices, "these are words I've seen before even though I don't know what they mean" && "here's a choice whose Latin roots plausibly give it the right meaning" seems shallow to me. It allows the test taker to select the right answer without actually knowing it. At the same time, it's not shallow in that you're incorporating quite a bit of knowledge of the language as well as the context you've developed over years of reading.

---

As soon as the conversation here turned to test taking, the thread immediately reminded me of the scene in The Wire where the students pick the right answer from the blackboard by seeing one of the choices has a lot more stray chalk marks beside it, indicating it was pointed at during the previous period.

"The answer is B five. B five's got all the dinks"

chucksmash··on Tired of Stack Overflow
Not as ironic as you'd think[1].

[1]: https://meta.stackexchange.com/a/47635

chucksmash··on What a Senior Staff Software Engineer Does
My feeling is that it traces from the institution of staff officers in the military:

> General staff: in the military, a group of officers that assists the commander of a division or larger unit by formulating and disseminating his policies, transmitting his orders, and overseeing their execution. Normally a general staff is organized along functional lines, with separate sections for administration, intelligence, operations, training, logistics, and other categories.[1]

[1] https://www.britannica.com/topic/general-staff

chucksmash··on The Baseline Interpreter: A Faster JavaScript Interpreter in Firefox 70
They released a new version on the 27th of August[1]. It looks like it that was the first release since August 2018[2].

[1]: https://www.thunderbird.net/en-US/thunderbird/68.0/releaseno...

[2]: https://www.thunderbird.net/en-US/thunderbird/60.0/releaseno...

chucksmash··on Gardens with a 12,000-person waiting list
In 2019, just beneath the surface of every last "rather innocuous activity" lies a whole raft of things to feel bad about and someone to let you know about it.

It's gardening. It's fine. If gardening (gardening!) is now something that should be "approached with caution" then we've jumped the shark as a civilization.

chucksmash··on Parts of America may already be facing recession
In 2007 I had a summer job as a gopher/assistant for a residential real estate appraiser. I remember thinking being an appraiser was an amazing gig when I started the summer and was entertaining the idea of staying on during the school year as a practicum rather than going back immediately. We were doing two houses a day, every day. Turning away work. Some appraisers were grinding, doing three a day even (figure about four hours each if you're working fast but actually doing the work). Baseline fee for a residential appraisal then was $300 for houses worth less than $1 million. The opportunity to earn $900/day is a heady notion for a broke college student, especially given you just had to measure people's houses, take pictures, look up comps, and file some paperwork. By the time I went back to school, we couldn't rely on even one house on a given day. I didn't have any insight about the overall situation (i.e. there were plenty of reasonable explanations, maybe the lender found someone willing to give them more favorable appraisals, etc), but the effect was pronounced.
chucksmash··on Flawed Algorithms Are Grading Millions of Students’ Essays
I'm surprised people are surprised by it. I guess it just hasn't gotten talked about it a lot? When I took the GRE in 2011 the rule was that my essay would be graded by one human and one automated grader, and a second human would become involved if the computer and the human differed by one point or more iirc.

Maybe nobody really makes a big deal about it because it is pretty much irrelevant anywah. Applicants provide a letter of intent that the grad dept people can, y'know, actually read for themselves, so I think unless you totally bombed the writing section nobody cared.

chucksmash··on Is Perl 6 Being Renamed?
After the initial round of "useful PyPI packages don't support Python 3 though, I can't migrate", that "I know 3.x is different and I'll have to read up on the differences....later" was absolutely the biggest blocker for adoption imo.

I know proficient Python programmers who were starting projects from scratch in 2017 and didn't want to use Python 3.x because they were in a hurry, worried that they didn't know how to write Python 3.x in a timely manner because they hadn't invested the time to learn it. Lots and lots of people just knew it was a known unknown for them, had no idea of the magnitude of the effort required to switch (tiny for new projects! tiiiny) and just put "look into this" somewhere deep on their backlog.

chucksmash··on A man who destroyed his multimillion dollar company in 10 seconds (2018)
Interesting anecdote, but holy minimal-effort-article-writing, Batman:

> Have you ever heard of the “Ratner effect”?

> Well by the end of this post you will know what it means.

chucksmash··on Banned C standard library functions in Git source code
Thanks for posting these. My company has a similar list of banned C calls so I was already familiar with the rationale. The initial patch[0] in particular is eye opening though. 157 lines of rationale and exploration of alternatives for 22 lines of uncontroversial code.

[0]: https://github.com/git/git/commit/c8af66ab8ad7cd78557f0f9f5e...

chucksmash··on Banned C standard library functions in Git source code
Whenever you write, you have to consider your audience.

I'd assume there are no comments explaining this because for the intended audience, it is self-evident. "People browsing Hacker News on a Sunday" was probably not the intended audience :-).

chucksmash··on Banned C standard library functions in Git source code
Thanks for linking this, it's always good to see how very strong engineers solve problems. Never in a million years would this approach have occurred to me. For the interested, the README in the linked repo is done well and clearly explains the approach itself as well as pros and cons. This also reminded me that I've been meaning to watch antirez' "Writing System Software"[0] videos on YouTube for quite a while now, so thanks for that too.

[0]: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLrEMgOSrS_3fghr8ez63x...

chucksmash··on Ask HN: Why do maintainers optimize for small binaries?
Possibly precipitated by this post which was on the front page yesterday with 400 upvotes:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20761449

chucksmash··on Mozilla takes action to protect users in Kazakhstan
I expect the idea is less to prevent any possible threat and is more a) to comply with regulations and b) to log enough data so if somebody does circumvent your legally required measures, they've left enough of a trail to hang themselves.
chucksmash··on Mozilla takes action to protect users in Kazakhstan
Finance companies do this for regulatory reasons
chucksmash··on Google's software mistreats or harms the user
I'd naively consider a keylogger to be software that captures your keypresses universally.

I use Firefox and have search suggestions disabled there so I am somewhat sympathetic to their point.

That said, calling server-side autocomplete on a field you explicitly are typing in strikes me as about as sensible and forthright as calling an Amazon text field that takes my credit card number a card skimmer.

chucksmash··on California’s Biggest Cities Confront a ‘Defecation Crisis’
> How many times have you heard some politician or just an ordinary person from the south or the midwest say something to the effect “we have a great homelessness policy, we buy each homeless person a bus ticket to California and send them on their way!” They usually say this with pride or with a laugh instead of being embarrassed as they should be. In fact if i remember correctly this was part of the plot of a south park episode (although i do not exactly remember whether south park endorsed or mocked that policy).

Zero times? This seems like a lazy characterization and citing South Park doesn't really help your case. According to this Guardian article on homeless busing in the US[1], these sorts of programs tend to originate in the Western states:

> A count earlier this year found half a million homeless people on one night in America. The problem is most severe in the west, where rates of homelessness are skyrocketing in a number of major cities, and where states like California, Nevada, Oregon and Washington have some of the highest rates of per capita homelessness.

> These are also the states where homeless relocation programs are concentrated. Using public record laws, the Guardian obtained data from 16 cities and counties that give homeless people free bus tickets to live elsewhere.

Key West and Ft Lauderdale are discussed in the article; Atlanta is mentioned as having been criticized for this in the run-up to the 1996 Olympics. That said, jumping immediately to "we all know how those darn Southerners and Midwesterners are" doesn't seem to jive with the facts.

[1]: https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/ng-interactive/2017/dec/...

chucksmash··on Tech Interview Handbook
I think it's a little odd to ask directly. If you are evaluating an interviewee for "culture fit" as in your example, would you directly ask them "how would you fit into our culture?" or try to evaluate their thought processes, demeanor, etc to determine it for yourself?

Perhaps it's just the context from which this conversation arises and it wouldn't strike me this way otherwise, but asking these questions directly feels a bit too much like college application boilerplate to me.

If a team wants to prioritize a diversity of perspectives, I feel the team should spend the interview trying to understand my perspective, analyze how that compares to their own perspectives, then synthesize the answer to the question themselves rather than just adding a "How will you contribute to a diversity of perspectives?" question.

chucksmash··on At Booming Toptal, No Stock for Employees or Investors
Definitely a bait and switch, even if legally it is all above table and the employers should have relied on what the paper said not what people said.

Having that contingency about taking more funding might not create any legal obligations but there is certainly an implication there.

If I cover your tab and you say you'll pay me back next time we go out, "I'm never paying you back" is an equivalent statement if there's an unspoken "but we're never going out again" at the end of the first statement, but it wouldn't be my first interpretation.

---

That said, if an Engineering Director is getting 0.02% then, assuming TopTal is worth $1b, you'd have a Director cashing out at <$200k pre-tax right? I'd imagine run of the mill ICs had a percentage such that they didn't accept it thinking "and when this pays off I'm done forever"

chucksmash··on At Booming Toptal, No Stock for Employees or Investors
Or perhaps a working partner and a willingness to get by on one income. Know a couple who did this in NYC for a couple of years on non-dev salaries and the trade-off definitely opened doors for them.
chucksmash··on Uber Posts $5.2B Loss and Slowest Ever Growth Rate
> At what point do I simply say "fuck it" and stop working too, because some ridiculous percentage of my income has to be applied towards feeding those who won't/can't/don't do anything productive?

Econ 101 opinion here, so I'm ignoring totally reasonable things like "people work for reasons other than monetary compensation" and assuming you're a rational participant in the economy, but I'd say there is no percentage at which you'd do that.

No matter how high a percentage is taken, you can always increase the topline number to make the bottom line number come out ahead of not working. I'd take a 99% tax on $1 billion/year over $14k/year in social insurance taxed at 0% if it were offered.

Anyway, isn't this similar to what the comp of people implementing something you might call automation is already doing in US tech hubs? We've had relatively low inflation in the US over the past decade (by CPI, anyway) but I can find you an article by Joel Spolsky from the aughts lamenting the fact that some tech companies were paying top new grads nearly $100k a year.

← PreviousPage 15 of 27Next →