HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

chucksmash

2,817 karma · joined December 16, 2014

submissionscomments
chucksmash··on “Secrets” about the consumer audio business you may find interesting
> But those purposes are only allowed because they serve greater purpose. On their own they are meaningless.

This gets it backwards. In most places, we haven't arranged society as "everything is banned except for this list of allowed activities," more as "everything is allowed except for this list of banned activities."

We're not necessarily good at divining utility of actions when deciding what should be banned, either.

That any individual activity serves some greater good is a happy accident, there's no natural law that individuals will take actions that are net positive when you zoom out.

chucksmash··on Woman sues after DNA from rape kit used to arrest her
https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-60346300:

> French diplomatic sources told Reuters that Mr Macron had been told to choose between accepting a Russian PCR test to get closer to Putin or abide by strict social distancing rules.

> "We knew very well that meant no handshake and that long table. But we could not accept that they get their hands on the president's DNA," one of the sources told Reuters.

> The source did not elaborate on how the Russian intelligence services could exploit Mr Macron's DNA.

Doesn't provide insight into why one should be concerned, but it's useful information to know that nation states are wary of each other in this regard for some reason even if we don't know what that reason is.

chucksmash··on Fabrice Bellard: Portrait of a Super-Productive Programmer (2011)
There's a weird interplay between comments and submissions on HN. Popular comment about Bellard yesterday? Bet you'll see a write-up of Bellard submitted today.

The third stage will be tomorrow when comments casually refer to information gleaned from the article submitted today as if it were common knowledge. There will be an article about a new JS framework and someone will make a comment like "of course, programmers like Bellard[0] managed to be quite productive without the use of a similar framework."

The circle of life is majestic to behold.

chucksmash··on FTC proposes rule to ban junk fees, bait-and-switch tactics plaguing car buyers
I bought a car in-person in 2020, and tried a "get a quote emailed" search earlier this year. 100% prefer the in-person experience.

Response to my online quote request came back with "we don't have any of that model/year in stock" and then thus far, 15-20 marketing follow-up emails trying to sell me other cars, following up on my experience, etc, in addition of course to the modern marketing "guilt trip" emails ("Hi chucksmash, I sent you an email the other day with a few other models you might be interested in but never heard back, hope everything is okay, please let me know" 3x times). When all I did was click an "email me a quote" button because the web page didn't show a price.

Adding insult to injury, the page for unsubscribing cannot process a "+" in an email address.

At least when I walk into a showroom I can also walk out. Giving anybody your email address in 2022 is basically subscribing to CatFacts.

chucksmash··on ‘Why Am I Not Rich and Famous?’ The Delusion of Our Times
Or perhaps it's not quite as binary as "either you believe success is all luck or you're arrogant."

There's a lovely book, "The Drunkard's Walk - How Randomness Rules Our Lives" that has a good take on this.

I don't have time to find the passage right now, but the idea is essentially this: even if you work in an endeavour where success is overwhelmingly driven by luck, success still requires: taking a chance to have the opportunity to become lucky, an open mind and preparation to recognize the good luck that has occurred, and the skill to exploit the opportunity that luckiness has brought.

One must make chances for luck to occur, and one must have a prepared mind to take advantage of luck when it does occur.

I wouldn't necessarily read the replier as saying they have succeeded and luck had nothing to do with it (i.e. the binary view).

The problem with a view point of "it's all luck," IMO is this will lead you down the path of learned helplessness and even if you do get lucky you won't be in a position to capitalize because if you thought it came down to a roll of the dice, why would you bother skilling up in the first place?

chucksmash··on Writing an app is like coding for LaserDisc
How does such a system reconcile the need to be opt-in to maintain backwards compatibility with the web as it exists with the likelihood that the audience you want to reach (developers who can't be bothered to Do It Right) are just the ones who will not opt in?

Ancient history now, but HTML5 was developed by WHATWG specifically as pushback against priorities of W3C at time (chief among which was push for XHTML).

That's not to say things cannot be improved, just to say this has all happened before and it will all happen again (and it is worth paying attention to what happened last time).

chucksmash··on Tell HN: Otter.ai bot recording meetings without consent
Some security conscious organizations will ban all external software and then approve exceptions on a case by case basis as they pop up.

In such a place, someone has already long ago submitted a ticket to have Google Chrome blessed and the employee installing Chrome is following regs.

chucksmash··on Writing an app is like coding for LaserDisc
> Parsers should be fail-fast and deterministic, this is one of the many problems of the web. Developers don't notice their incorrect code due to this and without noticing rely on the implementation-specific way one browser handles the issue.

This was XHTML documents when sent with the correct Content-Type. "Just don't display anything if the document is malformed" is worse for users if devs still create malformed documents.

chucksmash··on Snap lays off 20% of employees
Another justification people give for Google staffing levels is keeping talent locked up/not competing with Google. To the extent that's the case, thinking wouldn't be along the lines of "could we get by with fewer workers?"
chucksmash··on Stable Diffusion is a big deal
> I don't know if it has anything to do with construction but doubt it. If you actually walk everywhere shoes don't last very long these days, especially shoes under $100.

By construction, I mean the material and design of shoes people tend to wear. I can't say I've ever met someone who takes sneakers or running shoes to a cobbler and these shoes are more common nowadays.

chucksmash··on Stable Diffusion is a big deal
You're nitpicking one of the given examples without engaging the user on the point they were trying to make.

To be nuanced, maybe they might have said, "cobblers are less in demand now that many people have moved from owning fewer pairs of shoes they make last through repair to owning more pairs of shoes that they tend to get rid of when they are worn out due to changes in construction materials used in production," but if people have to write like that to make points, nobody will ever make a point.

chucksmash··on They're trying to get me kidnapped and tortured, but Twitter doesn't care
This is a good point and I think pretty well captures the "and what is Twitter supposed to do about it" angle.

To say "well, thus and such comedian is connected to the regime, that's why he has tweeted about me," well, what level of investigation is Twitter supposed to do that they a) disprove the allegations lobbed at OP (working for RAW provocateurs) and b) are able to support the allegation against the comedian's intent, and thus prove that the whole interaction is as the OP says it is?

Doing so goes beyond moderation, it goes beyond fact checking, it's nearly at the level of a personal background check or a trial.

What is being asked of Twitter seems totally outside the realm of what a social media company should be doing. It seems like OP wanted to do the right thing, to speak truth to power, but is now realizing that power was listening.

An account that publicly exposes your identity is not the right place to antagonize people with machine guns if you are not willing to take on personal risk, and that has nothing to do with moderation policies.

chucksmash··on Why are D-sharp and E-flat considered to be two different notes?
Having to bend up to a given note each time you need to hit it will be slower and less precise.

Generally the bend is done after the fretted note is struck as well. I guess it would be possible to always pre-bend to a given alternate note if you wanted a constant tone, but it definitely seems like working against the grain of the tool versus just using a fretless instrument.

chucksmash··on One kitchen, hundreds of internet restaurants
At some point around 2018, I ended up with an alter-ego named "Franklyn."

I'm not clear what the origin was - if I set it up late one night to cause trouble, if someone else did it and tagged it with my email address as a joke, or if some resume scraping software borked something up.

Anyway, Franklyn gets invited to interview for $320k/year roles now.

chucksmash··on The end of the manual transmission is near?
I reread after I posted, saw the "new" and was wondering how I'd missed that.

I was also looking at Rangers and Tacomas earlier this year. I've seen pre-2020 model year Tacomas listed for $45k. Surreal to think, " Hmm that 4 year old, used mid-size pickup is a little pricey, maybe it's better to get something more frugal like a BMW."

chucksmash··on The end of the manual transmission is near?
You're in luck, that's about what manual transmission '00s pick up trucks with hand-crank windows are going for these days.
chucksmash··on Tether will not freeze Tornado Cash addresses
Sure, and I'm free to value my home at 1 gigadollar.

Sellers are free to decide what prices they will not sell below, but they do not determine price. It takes buyers and sellers to do that.

I'd have a better argument that my home was worth $1 billion if inside the guest bedroom there was USD 1 billion. That'd be a pretty good way to convince buyers that my home's price was pegged to the value of one giga dollar. If it was $900 million in cash and $100 million in IOUs, that'd still convince some people too, so on and so forth.

I gather the issues with Tether are a) we don't know just what they have because of a lack of transparency, b) from what we DO know, in chasing yield, they've picked up some higher risk assets that they say are baaaaasically the same as cash (Commercial paper from Chinese real estate developers iirc?) that could be susceptible to losing value in a financial contagion scenario, and therefore be worth less than the dollar put in when Joe Q Crypto wants to take his dollar back out.

chucksmash··on How to pay your rent with your open source project (2020)
> If I spend 10 hours on a take home instead of my consultancy I'm out thousands of dollars.

My reasoning for not demanding I should be compensated:

1. Presumably something about the opportunity on offer is more compelling than your second best option of working on your own consultancy earning $200+/hour, otherwise why are you applying for the role in the first place? I'd argue that if the opportunity is otherwise compelling in the long term, demanding breakeven for one day's work is being penny-wise and pound foolish. Taking it to an extreme, if there was a job that paid $10 million/year but the interview process was so involved I needed to burn an entire year's worth of vacation time to interview for it, whether I'd do it would come down to expected value of the decision (i.e. probability of passing the interview), not the absolute investment I was making.

2. I'd consider this form of cost-analysis rationale a weak one because it can be applied to basically any decision in life yet it gets applied selectively, so it's kind of a roundabout way of saying "I don't want to do that." Nobody (probably?) is applying this analysis to sleeping 6 hours a night versus 8, yet that would yield 10 more billable consulting hours (per week!) too.

chucksmash··on How to pay your rent with your open source project (2020)
Why do you feel the interaction was cruel? A brief "no" seems like all you'd get from most companies too.

My understanding is the policy is intended to avoid pointless debates and inadvertent legal liability (e.g. "when you told the candidate 'good luck with the new baby' at the end of the rejection convo, it created the impression they were not selected because they have kids.")

Why did he owe more feedback than "this isn't up to par?"

Based on past threads on HN I'm in the minority in preferring take-home projects and not feeling I'm owed compensation for the time it takes to complete them.

I like them because you have more of an opportunity to demonstrate your craft versus a standard leetcode whiteboard session where the 45 minute time constraint means you need to focus on pumping code out as quickly as possible. Also a good one can be an entertaining diversion in it's own right. Different strokes for different folks, I suppose.

chucksmash··on Ask HN: URL format for blog posts - which format is best?
Example 1 with the `posts/` prefix for canonical url.

Even with that canonical url, you can still provide your own url shortening service a la example 3. Given the choice, I'd slightly prefer using a first party shortener that maps a single shortened link per piece of content versus third party one creating a shortened link per share.

year/month prefix is useful to readers if the content becomes stale quickly.

chucksmash··on ID This SciFi Short Story
You're right! I saw a scifi Stackexchange link, clicked into it, and saw it was a [story-identification] question for a story about numbers but I missed that it was a different question about identifying a story about numbers. Sloppy of me, but speaks to the depth of content on that tag!
chucksmash··on On Car Seats as Contraception
I'm somewhat sympathetic to this view. My parents moved between states a week after I was born and for the entire 12 hour trip my mom held me in her lap in the front seat. When we made short trips in-town, we as kids would get to sit in the "way back" of a hatchback without seatbelts (or even seats) as a treat.

Neither of these were optimal safety choices. We were definitely at a higher risk of death or injury. If everyone did this society wide, the number of child fatalities in traffic accidents *would* be higher. Yes, people who relate such anecdotes and then say, "...and we survived" are literally demonstrating survivorship bias.

Times change and I don't think I'd make these same safety trade-offs with my kids. I'm also not sure taking these kind of risk/reward trade-off decisions out of the hands of parents is a net positive either.

It's hard to talk about whether the current status quo is reasonable because for many of us, that status quo predates us and "wait, you're saying you are FOR more kids dying in car wrecks" is a pretty natural reaction. For that reason, I think it's easier to consider the reasonableness of an incremental, hypothetical change to the current status quo. Imagine a study comes out tomorrow that shows that children in wrecks have a 3% higher fatality rate in cars manufactured before 2015, so a law is passed saying that as of 2024 driving a pre-2015 car with children in it will be a ticketable offense. Is there anything that would give you pause about this scenario, is it an unalloyed good thing, or is it another "I mean, I GUESS it's for the best, it's complicated tbh" situation?

chucksmash··on On Car Seats as Contraception
I don't take the article as saying this is THE way to adjust birthrate.

They're just highlighting a case where a) they believe regulation is depressing fertility rates and b) the author presents the regulation as not very effective at improving safety outcomes. So the justification for making the change is:

> It is often said that governments can do little to increase the birth rate.

> I find this implausible. We do lots of things as the government that decrease the birth rate. We could Stop It. Or do the opposite.

The article advocates that loosening car seat restrictions for older children is a way the government could improve fertility rates just by ceasing an action it is currently taking ("Stopping It").

chucksmash··on Tell HN: Google Cloud suspended our production projects at 1am on Saturday
I noticed something similar five weeks ago. Imgur would get stuck on the loading animation if I was in private mode but work otherwise.

It seems to work—at this moment, anyway—even in private mode for me now though. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

chucksmash··on ID This SciFi Short Story
+1. I was in the process of linking this exact question as well, what a world.

Love that the top answerer shows their work, and as a bonus they reached out to the author of the story:

  UPDATE: I emailed Greg Cox about
  the question. Here's his response:
  
  > Wow. I had no idea people were
  > still talking about that story,
  > which I haven't thought of for years.
  > I can't speak for the original
  > questioner of course, but that 
  > description sure sounds like my
  > story, which I wrote nearly thirty
  > years ago!
  > 
  > greg
chucksmash··on C99 doesn't need function bodies, or 'VLAs are Turing complete'
You're technically right, which is the best kind of not invited to happy hour.
chucksmash··on Productivity porn
Teach Yourself C++ in 21 Days
chucksmash··on Hikaru Nakamura's Forbidden Platform
chess.com satisifices. Have had several times where I thought "Even I could make a better platform than this" (for instance: their PGNs always used to show today's date in the game metadata instead of the date the game was played and it took four emails over a week to make support understand why this was wrong).

When I open the app and look for a 10/0 match though, I always find one right away, and this + cursory game reviews covers ~100% of my use case, so shrug.

chucksmash··on Understanding Jane Street
Had "The Man Who Solved The Market: How Jim Simons Launched The Quant Revolution" on my shelf for several years as an out-of-the-blue birthday present but I finally got around to reading it earlier this year and I'd absolutely recommend it.

The emphasis on published work rang a bell, but thumbing through the book I can't find it off hand.

chucksmash··on The worst dam idea: evaporating the Mediterranean to power Europe
> Brackish water, sometimes termed brack water, is water occurring in a natural environment that has more salinity than freshwater, but not as much as seawater.

> Some seas and lakes are brackish. The Baltic Sea is a brackish sea adjoining the North Sea.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brackish_water

← PreviousPage 10 of 27Next →