HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

churchill

1,533 karma · joined March 10, 2022

submissionscomments
churchill··on US Launches Financial Rescue of Argentina, Treasury Buys Pesos
No, it's not. The dollars are simply a proxy for transferring weapons/value for free. If you want a jobs program, create one to build affordable housing, infra., etc., not fight endless wars.
churchill··on Nearly 20 Percent Fewer International Students Traveled to the U.S. in August
No, your point doesn't stand at all. It's completely baseless. You took a detailed resource referencing America's departure from a gold standard and you're twisting it to support your pet immigration policy.

Now, if you want to limit non-European immigration, it's a personal opinion and you have a right to it, but you can't make a blanket statement that, "everything worked better," or misinterpret data to say what you want.

Don't pretend you're being data-driven when you've made up your mind and now you're trying to torture the data into saying what you want.

What metrics are you measuring by?

So, while it seemed like you were trying to argue logically, it appears your argument is: I don't like non-Europeans. And you're trying to massage the data into showing your opinion is data-driven because it can't stand on its own merit.

But, feel free to change my mind with more data.

churchill··on Tariffs Are Way Up. Interest on Debt Tops $1T. and Doge Didn't Do Much
Reminds me of this comment I saw under a YT video on the topic, 4mo back: The national debt won’t matter until it does…and then it’ll matter more than anything else.
churchill··on Predator drones shift from border patrol to protest surveillance
>could

More like WILL. It's the nature of all empires, first to grow, and then to shrink. But, the empire's mechanism of repression won't suddenly become humane and forget all its tools and tactics for torture, rape, extralegal imprisonment, etc. As the shrinking empire causes friction at home, those same techniques will be unleashed to suppress dissenters.

Schmitt's friend-enemy distinction doesn't save you from this either, because you can still group your red-blooded countrymen into those brackets arbitrarily once you have plenary powers.

churchill··on Tariffs Are Way Up. Interest on Debt Tops $1T. and Doge Didn't Do Much
Right from the start, any impartial observer could tell that it wasn't a sincere effort grounded in truth.

First, the goal of the tariffs was to reduce US deficit spending.

Then it was reducing debt. Isolating & containing China. Dissuading them from invading Taiwan. Replacing the income tax. Retaliating against Europe, Japan, & S. Korea for unfair trade practices. Compelling other countries to buy American. Onshoring manufacturing. Forcing foreigners to pay a premium to access American markets. Forcing Canada & Mexico to get illegal immigration & narcotics trafficking under control. Punishing Brazil for persecuting Bolsonaro. Compelling third countries to accept expelled immigrants.

Then they pivoted to: Art of the Deal! He's deliberately making unrealistic demands as an intro offer.

Which is it again?!

churchill··on OpenAI, Nvidia fuel $1T AI market with web of circular deals
On the contrary, Amazon could have become profitable on demand. They were just investing heavily into physical infrastructure back-to-back and if they ever wanted to slow down or stop, they'd be default alive.
churchill··on Nearly 20 Percent Fewer International Students Traveled to the U.S. in August
I don't think that website implies what you're thinking. The only significant thing that happened in 1971 is that Nixon suspended the convertibility of the dollar into gold, giving the US leeway to run unlimited deficits, paying for imports with paper.

Now, America wants to reduce its debt and curb industrial powers like the EU, Japan, China, etc. but it doesn't want to give up its exorbitant privilege that got it into the debt whole in the first place.

You can't have it both ways.

churchill··on Nearly 20 Percent Fewer International Students Traveled to the U.S. in August
I agree with you. We don't even have to imagine: the UK and US were planning preemptive nuclear strikes against the entire Soviet Union before they tested their first nuke.

Operation Dropshot and Unthinkable called for hundreds of nukes and conventional bombs to be dropped on Soviet cities to, "to impose upon Russia the will of the United States and the British Empire."

All in all, I don't even have a dog in the fight, but people like Qian Xuesen won't become retarded if they're expelled from the US. If I remember correctly, something like a third of all top-tier AI researchers are Chinese. If you count all those with an immigration background, they'll be close to 50-70%. They will simply create companies and products that compete and take market share from American companies.

Are Americans - the country that votes out presidents for rising gas prices - willing to make do with a lower standard of living? Because that'd what you'll get when some the world's best innovators are no longer based in your country.

churchill··on America's Soybean Farmers Are Panicking over the Loss of Chinese Buyers
If only there was a way we could have avoided this. Being the world's largest economy, you can slap your trading partners around. But, don't expect them not to retaliate, especially if you have a reputation of being abusive to the weak.
churchill··on OpenAI, Nvidia fuel $1T AI market with web of circular deals
On the surface, the circular financing seems worrying but once you dig into it, it seems quite benign, tbh. NVIDIA is handing out GPUs into OpenAI, in return for stock/future revenue, whichever way you want to slice it. OpenAI has wonky unit economics, yes, but they're growing at ~100% YoY, so it all checks out, if you ask me.
churchill··on Polymarket Founder Is Youngest Self-Made Billionaire After Deal with NYSE Owner
1. Congrats! 2. This model where you sell 0.1% of a company for $10M and immediately value your stock/holdings at $6.9 quadrillion is a bit amusing. It's not liquid, and tends to result in swings like SBF going from $28b to $100k in like a weekend.
churchill··on The Unofficial Jobs Numbers Are in and It's Rough Out There
America's uncompetitiveness in certain industries isn't because of strong environmental and labor regulations. It's scale. That's why, despite working 996, Chinese software technology companies are still in (admittedly) second place compared to the US.

Places like Silicon Valley, etc. have such a dense concentration of talent that if you want to build anything at the cutting edge, you need to pack up, leave your life behind and move over there.

Likewise, this is why China dominates in hardware. You can walk into a random store in Shenzhen and pick out enough off-the-shelf parts to build a reasonably high-end smartphone. No one in the US or Europe will even talk to you if you're not ordering 10k MOQ. And that's if you can find a supplier.

Scale is also the reason why China and South Korea build nuclear reactors at a fraction of Western prices. On budget too! Not because they carelessly expose everyone to toxic radiation.

That's why China has 200* America's shipbuilding capacity. They build so much of it that they unlock economies of scale.

It's the reason why China is churning out more PV systems and batteries than the rest of the world combined. They're building so much that their per unit costs fall tremendously. Then they parley those gains in one industry into adjacent industries like EVs where batteries are 40% of the cost. When you stack economies of scale back-to-back, you end up with an order of magnitude's difference. That's why high-end Chinese EVs cost, say <$20k, while American manufacturers are struggling.

churchill··on Nearly 20 Percent Fewer International Students Traveled to the U.S. in August
Some of them actually do that. Like when the US expelled Qian Xuesen, the founder of the Jet Propulsion Lab and he went back and built China's ballistic missile and space program. So, yep. It's happened and will continue to happen to different degrees.
churchill··on Nearly 20 Percent Fewer International Students Traveled to the U.S. in August
Sorry to break it to you, but the average American is quite...let's say, average. That's why they're average, lol. Likewise, the average Chinese. That's why their school system filters out tens of millions of schoolkids from higher education and puts them in trade school early. Same goes for India, Europe, etc.

Gifted, driven kids, the kind who will leave their family and everything they've known, to cross an ocean to study in your country, are a scarce resource.

I'm not saying you shouldn't prioritize locals, but if you want competitive, world-class educational system, you should be open to foreign students and faculty helping to keep your system competitive. It's the same worldwide, whether it's in Singapore's NUS, or Oxford, or Saudi Arabia's KAUST.

But, what do I even know?

churchill··on How Israeli actions caused famine in Gaza, visualized
You didn't debunk any claim I made in my comment. All the historical episodes I referred to were deluded people coming up with nice-sounding theories on why they deserved to take other people's stuff or force their compliance by force. Each last one ended badly.
churchill··on [dead]
I was told we'd be America First. Is Israel an American state?
churchill··on How Israeli actions caused famine in Gaza, visualized
>There are precisely zero foreign policy issues that have survived this long on the back of vibes alone.

Christian Zionist support for Israel is 100% based off vibes. Hitler's plan to invade Russia & exterminate its people for living space was based off Master Race vibes. America's Manifest destiny was based off vibes. Anti-communist domino theory was based off vibes and 58k young American kids died in Vietnam for it, not counting the 153k maimed and injured. Japan's imperial delusions that got them nuked was based off vibes.

Want me to go on?

>There are like half a dozen wars of extermination currently occurring with lots of disturbing footage. Nobody really cares. Israel is close to home because it's an ally and we styled it as a Western-style democracy (versus something closer to the Middle Eastern democracy it is.)

Would you kindly name them, good sir? Off the top of my head, I think Sudan. But, no Westerner really cares about Sudan. Israel they do care about because of the media onslaught and their countries' stance on the issue. It's one of those conflicts you just can't unsee.

churchill··on How Israeli actions caused famine in Gaza, visualized
>Where are you getting this notion that tech exports are a major source of FX for Israel? Or that Israel would stop being a tech centre if America turned its back on it? (And again, major emerging gas exporter.)

From their own economic publications. Tech exports are 53% of their export output. Gas is a laughable non-issue. Like I said earlier, the middle east is full of it. It's not a significant source of leverage since every third country has it.

>UN sanctions are way less biting than American secondary sanctions alone.

You can always tunnel around sanctions, but it kills a lot of your open-market economy. You have to sell for a lower, discounted price. Acquisitions and mergers are effectively over. Sales shrink by a lot. Your largest companies move away to avoid contagion. I mean, have you ever read about the sanctions on Rhodesia & south Africa?

>They're...still around. And they never had a weapons sector like Israel's.

They're severely, terribly weakened. Even China won't sell them any modern airframes. That should tell you something.

>I get this is your hypothesis. It simply isn't sustained. This is before we get to the point that if a couple Western countries sanction Israel for shits and giggles, there is a lot of money to be made by someone defecting and acting 'neutrally'.

I have evidence of Western & non-western countries banding together to sanction consistent bad actors, despite being even more Western than Israel will ever be. Do you have any evidence of any country surviving sanctions without severe economic damage? Please share; my viewpoint has abundant proof. I'm just supposed to believe yours.

>Again, there seem to be folks who like to see patterns that sustain extreme outcomes that support a moral view of the world. You're having to go three levels deep for every turn because the most precedented outcome here is everyone forgets and moves on.

I don't have a dog in the fight. Both countries could die to the last man and I'd still go on my merry way, whistling. I'm simply projecting based on history, which is why I cite precedent that you refuse to admit.

churchill··on How Israeli actions caused famine in Gaza, visualized
They're opportunistically buying/selling what they want. None of these are an ideological commitment to Israel's status quo. If the wind direction changes, they'll change with it.
churchill··on How Israeli actions caused famine in Gaza, visualized
>I’m one of the folks whose opinion of Israel has shifted. I don’t see them as a “genocidal terrorist state.” I see them as “just another middle eastern country.”

Okay. Opinions are on a spectrum. just like you, hundreds of millions of people who used to be pretty neutral on Israel now have strong opinions on the country. As a country, you generally want to blend in like Singapore/Switzerland and just not attract attention. Israel is attracting that attention, and for very bad reasons.

Western voters are childlike and emotional. They hate seeing blood on screen, children crying, starving, dying, being squeezed in queues for food. For any reason at all. Israel might seem like just another middle eastern country to you, but when you aggregate across 8 billion people, the average vibe has shifted negatively. By a lot.

>While it’s bad what’s happening, it’s still nowhere near Syrian or Yemeni levels

Tell that to Western voters who will be voting for 50 years. No one cares. just make it stop.

>But they’re still a legitimate country, just like, say, Saudi Arabia.

You're being nuanced. Cool. But the average human is not. Good luck beaming that moderate position into everyone's minds.

churchill··on How Israeli actions caused famine in Gaza, visualized
>You really think the French, Swedes, Russians or Chinese won't sell them planes? They're seeking to be a regional power. They don't need F-35s. (Though they're certainly handy.)

The fact we're even having this conversation is the point. Top-end equipment was always guaranteed. The fact you're shopping around mentally for second-best points to that.

>I'll grant that China has been the most consistent on Israel and Palestine. Nevertheless, Israeli-Chinese trade keeps growing.

Well, there's a reason why they've been consistent on it so far. If Israel's trade comes to depend significantly on them, they can use it as leverage against them.

>Really? According to whom? I haven't been in the UN for a while, but everyone I knew was asking when, not if. It clearly works for domestic politics, doubly following the recent trade concessions.

I should have been more specific than a few months ago. Here's what I meant. Many of these countries have no issues against Palestine, but wouldn't break openly with the US position because of how dependent they are. That happening is a vibe shift.

>The U.S. funds about 15% of Israel's defence budget. We allow them to splurge in a way they can't alone. But that just means they can't defeat Hezbollah and Iran and Hamas at the same time without us.

You keep taking my statements out of context, attacking a point I didn't make and then claiming victory. I'm not even addressing US aid to Israel, which is extensive. I'm talking about their economy! Without that trade, the economy will shrink by a lot. The technologists bringing in that FX will move away in large numbers. Spending will have to reduce by half or more, especially given Israel already has a high tax-to-gdp-ratio. The country won't survive it. More high earners will leave and you'll go into a death spiral.

Dozens of UN resolutions have been issued against Israel and vetoed by the US. If it happens without American support, they'll be placed under an intl. embargo until they comply. Ask Iran what intl. embargoes have done to crush their economy before you wave it off. What America offers Israel is both a large export market they don't have internally, and protection from consequences.

Israel is too integrated with the West, going as far as competing in Eurovision, UEFA, etc. If they break with the West, they can't survive it. I cite Rhodesia as an example repeatedly because that's where they slowly but surely ended up.

If you end up with Western sanctions, no matter your country's size, you're fucked. USSR and Maoist China can give you any lectures you want.

The 'chosen people' delusion can make it seem economic realities don't apply, but the earlier Israel can get to a lasting peace while conditions are favorable, the better.

churchill··on How Israeli actions caused famine in Gaza, visualized
>Israeli weapons are absolutely not fungible, particularly not for non-Western buyers.

My claim was specifically with China in mind. Pretty much everything the Americans will let Israel sell to non-Western partners can be gotten from China, Turkey, etc. cheaper and with less headache.

>Correct. I am guessing we'll see diversification here.

Yep. Introducing my magical new fighter jet that replaces the f35!

>...and guess who makes a state-of-the-art integrated air defences? And knows how to penetrate (and thus harden) state-of-the-art Russian air defence systems?

Well, it probably didn't work great given how India fared recently, did it? They're a committed partner of Israel and collaborate on military tech.

>Uh, China is doing whatever it can to keep America distracted. If Israel can give China technology, China will continue calling for a two-state solution while buying what it needs. (Chinese-Israeli trade has increased throughout the war.)

The only thing China reliably does is single-mindedly pursue their interests. Propping Israel up doesn't achieve that. In fact they're quite chummy with the Palestinians and lots of the weapons used for the Oct. 7 raid were Chinese-made.

>Israel is not at material risk of blanket sanctions from the West in the next decade.

If you say so. The chances of the Five Eyes breaking with America on recognizing Palestine were also exactly zero just a few months ago.

>Why does this have to go to America and Western Europe?

Because they're the only ones who have the money for it. No non-Western company/country has the amount of tech demand/cash to have completed the Wiz acquisition for $32b in cash. Their software markets have no viable customers outside the West.

>Which of the Arab monarchies is particularly distressed with Israel? Which has even walked back its previous support and recognition? The Gulf is more than happy for Israel to fight their wars against Iran.

Good point.

>It seems that everyone in this conflict has doomsday fantasies for their opponents.

I have no dog in the fight. Both countries could disappear overnight and it wouldn't affect my quality of life. I'm simply a student of history and I'm trained to see patterns.

churchill··on How Israeli actions caused famine in Gaza, visualized
>My point is this isn't a realistic threat for Israel. Its exports are highly desirable to too many parties. Technology. Weapons. Energy.

Everything Israel makes is fungible. The middle east is a river of gas. Israel's defense technology industry can't exist without Western partners. Hell, America denying them F35 repairs/upgrades effectively kills their airforce.

>Yes, if the war in Gaza continues for another half decade, Israel will run out of goodwill. But if it wraps up within a year or two? I don't see anything happening quickly enough that they can't adapt. Apartheid was a permanent state. The war need not be.

The damage has been done. Hundreds of millions globally now voice opinions about Israel openly that they wouldn't have allowed to just a few years back. These people vote in their countries, buy products, interact in the real world. We're seeing Israeli tourists get harassed openly. Would have been unthinkable in, say, 2020.

>Yeah, I'd say a strategic prerogative for Israel at this point is to diversify away from America. For the aforementioned reasons, however, I don't see that being a problem. Particularly given India and China have what they consider to be problematic Muslim populations within and around themselves, too.

India cannot even field 4.5 generation jets. Their airforce (French Rafales) got whooped in the recent confrontation with Pakistan. In fact, after China delivers Pakistan's J35s, India would have nothing to counter it. Israel's military core is air supremacy so much so that it is state doctrine to use nukes if the IAF is ever destroyed.

And China, trying to project an image of fairness to the third-world, as an alternative power, supports a two-state solution. Unlike Western politicians, they can't be lobbied and bribed to support endless wars.

I have my gripes with the West but they're still a superpower bloc. If they sanction you, you're fucked. There's a reason even China keeps its dealings with sanctioned Russian companies plausibly deniable. To avoid contagion.

You just don't understand how dependent Israel is on the West. 53% of their exports are technology goods. If you're cut off from Western markets, not only will China not buy much from Israel, they will copy their products and compete with them.

The only country you can build a shared resistance towards Muslims is India. For now, their economy is small and irrelevant. China has their Islamist problem under control and they won't want to offend the moneybag Arabs by supporting Israel (LMAO).

churchill··on How Israeli actions caused famine in Gaza, visualized
You may not realize it but Israel is slowly becoming Rhodesia/Apartheid South Africa. And i don't mean the word 'apartheid' as a cudgel.

During the Rhodesian Bush War, their forces ran circles around the ZIPRA and ZANLA with multiple battles and encounters where they'd routinely record 500:1 KD ratios like Operation Dingo, etc. They had complete freedom of action to bomb any infrastructure obstructing them, reach deep into neighboring countries and slaughter guerillas copiously.

Hell, South Africa had a dozen nukes.

Once the sanctions came on, it unraveled everything they had.

Israel is in such a precarious situation right now. Their economy depends on technology exports to an extreme degree. Cutting off that source of FX would literally half the economy overnight because cash would stop sloshing around internally from its main sources.

If that happens, all the smart kids propping up the economy will move out while you're left with extremists who want war but won't fight in the army. In fact, it's ongoing right now with people leaving the country in the midst of a war they're 'winning.'

You might think sanctions are a far-off notion, but key Western powers are breaking with America on recognizing Palestine. That's a red line designed to signal to Israel that it's losing ground. People across the world are calling for sanctions and it won't be long before they materialize.

And America? Israel's main power base are American boomer evangelicals who're going the way of the dinosaur. Like I said in another comment, their kids are either not religious, don't like bombing kids, have been radicalized by the atrocities they've witnessed, or are aligned with people like Fuentes.

I hope they can smell the coffee; if anyone had told South Africa that a nuclear power could be disarmed without a gunshot, they'd never have believed it. But, look what eventually happened.

Thanks to the ongoing genocide, America's voting demographic for the next 40 years has begun to see Israel as a genocidal terrorist state. They will be voting for the next 50 years, while the boomer evangelicals die off.

churchill··on How Israeli actions caused famine in Gaza, visualized
[flagged]
churchill··on How Israeli actions caused famine in Gaza, visualized
For those out of the loop the actions of the Israeli gov. are not some fringe overreaction. This is what the people want. by their own admission, 48% of Israeli Jews want Palestinians to be ethnically cleansed which would constitute a genocidal act, while 79% believe they should get preferential treatment over Arabs. [0]

Both Israeli Arabs & Palestinian Arabs. This is not some, 'oh no! it just happened.' Everyone who has actually spent time studying this conflict, the state of Israel has a policy of systematic rape, torture, mass incarceration, murder, and dehumanization of Palestinians at an industrial scale that's been in place for decades now.

They're just going mask-off in a way Western audiences can't pretend not to know about it any longer.

Israelis and their Western supporters try to make out their actions as that of fringe far-right loonies like Smotrich, etc. Nope. Systematic rape, torture, murder, of non-Jews has been their policy for decades now. You're just finally learning about it after so long. The ultra-orthodox don't make up a plurality of the population and used to not serve in the military until recently. So, if their abominable ideology is state policy, it's because Israelis are okay with it.

[0]: https://www.timesofisrael.com/plurality-of-jewish-israelis-w...

churchill··on Trump visa curbs push US firms to consider shifting more work to India
How are you going to enforce that? I mean this sincerely, from the bottom of my heart.

Ban SWIFT transactions to India? They'll just start hiring in Eastern Europe, the Philippines, etc. Not to mention explosive lawsuits that'll ultimately find that the government doesn't have those powers.

I can understand and sympathize with you feeling sad about jobs being outsourced but, this is technological evolution. America has a tiny slice of humanity's population and if the Bell Curve is accurate, it therefore has a tiny slice of the world's supply of smart people. Or, maybe just driven hard workers, since not every H1B founds a Google.

If you don't let them move to America, then fine, your homegrown companies will export jobs to them. The only way to prevent this is to levy blanket tariffs on all countries to force them to onshore. But, then, they'll retaliate, hurting America's export industries and the economy. Making America a less attractive place for the businesses you're trying to hold back. They'll consequently move out.

It's the same thing with tariffs. If

churchill··on Israel wants to train ChatGPT to be more pro-Israel
Yes, I know it's happening right now, but there are evangelical boomer types that i expect to carry their Zionism to the grave.

Fun fact: Pew research recently published a chart/matrix [0] showing how different religious groups in the US see each other and evangelicals had a +37 favorable rating for Jews, while vice versa, it was something shocking like -50 unfavourability/dislike. Utter contempt.

Not surprising to anyone in the know though that the Jewish community largely despise evangelicals & Christians while the other sides falls over themselves to be friendly.

[0]: https://www.reddit.com/r/dataisbeautiful/comments/1i2rf1z/wh...

churchill··on Israel wants to train ChatGPT to be more pro-Israel
Don't worry; the recent TikTok acquisition will take care of that.

As an aside, it's funny/interesting how the Gaza War has completely consumed the political capital Israel spent decades accumulating in the West. A significant percentage of people who used to have no political opinions whatsoever now see Israel as a transparently genocidal terrorist state.

I mean, what other conclusion can they reach: the average human might say nasty things on the internet but they don't like bombing tens of thousands of babies, women, healthcare workers, journalists, and civilians. When you do that, repeatedly, you're going to attract displeasure.

The last bastion of support for Israel I see are the American evangelicals who believe the whole 'chosen people' shtick. But, their children's generation are mostly either irreligious, Israel-skeptic, or outright embracing people like Fuentes.

If Israel doesn't secure a lasting solution to their misadventures in their region, once this generation dies off, that'll be the end of the rope for them.

Also, the upsurge in criticism of Israel has forced them to show their cards. A few years ago, if you implied Israel & its proxies exercised significant control of the media, you'd have been called an antisemite. Now, you have Netanyahu bragging about the TikTok acquisition (by a card-carrying Zionist) and fmr. congressman Gallagher confirming that forcing the sale was because of Israel, and the only conclusion you can reach about Ellison's media purchases and the silencing of Israel-critical voices is that, yep, Israel definitely has too much power in Western media spaces.

PS: copied this comment from another thread. Relevant, so i thought I'd share.

churchill··on EA Announces Agreement to be Acquired by PIF, Silver Lake, and Affinity Partners
>ebitda

Beautiful turnaround if those figures are reliable, but like Munger calls them, EBITDA tends to bullshit metrics derived by cobbling up bullshit to hide that a company is losing cash.

Just like Figma booking $700M in 2023 profits which was only possible because of the $1b Adobe breakup fee. Proceeded to lose $732m on $749m in revenues the very next year.

← PreviousPage 2 of 13Next →