HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

citizenpaul

2,707 karma · joined December 14, 2014

meet.hn/city/37.3688301,-122.036349/Sunnyvale

brief.rope7830@fastmail.com

submissionscomments
citizenpaul··on AI’s impact on engineering jobs may be different than expected
This sounds like a rant from a dysfunctional out of touch manager more than anything. From a 57 day old account here to pump AI because humans are terrible and not printing you lambos. Totally not a shill or anything. Humans = bad AI = good. Shill.

When you area asked specifics about how you use AI so effectively when others cannot you do not reply. Shill.

I've hired close to 200 people and 4 were bad apples that I had to fire. So no real life does not reflect what you wrote. Most people want to do a good job.

citizenpaul··on The behavioral cost of personalized pricing
>Put another way, do "one price for everyone" and "customer blindness" benefit rich people or poor people more?

I would say "one price for everyone" has indisputably been proven to benefit the poor more. This is just based on the last 100 or so years of the average persons live quality being raised by astronomical amounts because of the paradigm of customer blindness. Fixed prices are a very recent thing and if you look around it worked out pretty well. This new pricing is 100% predatory. backwards.

citizenpaul··on AI’s impact on engineering jobs may be different than expected
Can you expand on the tech stack and languages used?
citizenpaul··on Google AI Overviews cite YouTube more than any medical site for health queries
I did read or listen on a podcast about the booming business of AI data sets late last year. I'm sure you are right.

Doesn't change my point, I still don't think they can resist pulling from the "free" data. Corps are just too greedy and next quarter focused.

citizenpaul··on Google AI Overviews cite YouTube more than any medical site for health queries
Unrelated to this but I was able to get some very accurate health predictions for a cancer victim in my family using gemini and lab test results. I would actually say that other than one Doctor Gemini was more straightforward and honest about how and more importantly WHEN things would progress. Nearly to the day on every point over 6 months.

Pretty much every doctor would only say vague things like everyone is different all cases are different.

I did find this surprising considering I am critical of AI in general. However I think less the AI is good than the doctors simply don't like giving hopeless information. An entirely different problem. Either way the AI was incredibly useful to me for a literal life/death subject I have almost no knowledge about.

citizenpaul··on Porting 100k lines from TypeScript to Rust using Claude Code in a month
Well I cloned the repo and cannot generate this battle test by following the instructions. It appears a file called dex.js that is required is not present among other things as well as other suspicious wrong things for what appears to be on the surface a well organized project.

I'm very suspicious of such projects so take it for what you will, but I don't have time to debug some toy project so if it was presented as complete but the instructions don't work it's a red flag for the increasingly AI slop internet to me. I'm saying I think they may have used one simple trick called lying.

citizenpaul··on Porting 100k lines from TypeScript to Rust using Claude Code in a month
Its not. The project does not work or actually implement anything. It just compiles and passes some arbitrary tests the author wrote.
citizenpaul··on Porting 100k lines from TypeScript to Rust using Claude Code in a month
Am I the only one that is going to call this out? Am I the only person that cloned the repo to run it and found out it does nothing? This is disingenuous at a best. This is not a working project, they even admit this at the end of the article but not directly.

>Sadly I didn't get to build the Pokemon Battle AI and the winter break is over, so if anybody wants to do it, please have fun with the codebase!

In other words this is just another smoking wreck of an hopelessly incomplete project on github. There is even imaginary instructions for running in docker which doesn't exist. How would I have fun with a nonsense codebase?

The author just did a massive AI slop generation and assumes the codes works because it compiles and some equivalent output tests worked. All that was proved here is that by wasting a month of time you can individually rewrite a bunch of functions in a language you don't know if you already know how to program and it will compile. This has been known for 2-3 years now.

This is just AI propaganda or resume padding. Nothing was ported or done here.

Sorry what I meant to say is AI is revolutionary and changing the world for the better................................

citizenpaul··on AI will not replace software engineers (hopefully)
>government research discussion

Its bad. The most depressing part is that it is because of de-funding not AI. While at the same time this field is probably one of the only venues for escaping the AI sinkhole but its being dismantled rather than built up. Source my partner in research.

citizenpaul··on AI will not replace software engineers (hopefully)
>build things we never would have attempted

I think there is something here but not much. The majority of business are carrying some SAS products that are an entire marching band when all they want are a drummer and guitar player. Making bespoke efficient tools will surge for sure.

The problem is that the building of these tools is all the same end. Increasing industry control to few players and further widening wealth inequality. Which leads us back to where does everyone go to work at that point?

We are at some sort of societal inflection point where we need new industries but only 20% of degrees are in some sort of science. 80% of degrees are in what is becoming nothing more than resume checkboxing for jobs that no longer will exist. Who is going to make the next big industry breakthough with 20% of degrees in business management? I don't see any push to get people in college for actual meaningful progress.

It seems it did happen, humans have hit post scarcity in survival terms(unevenly distributed). However we have in no way planned for what happens here, fairness has never been a priority. The cuthroat capitalism that made this possible is now eating itself with no plans to change.

citizenpaul··on Google AI Overviews cite YouTube more than any medical site for health queries
I think we hit peak AI improvement velocity sometime mid last year. The reality is all progress was made using a huge backlog of public data. There will never be 20+ years of authentic data dumped on the web again.

I've hoped against but suspected that as time goes on LLMs will become increasingly poisoned by the the well of the closed loop. I don't think most companies can resist the allure of more free data as bitter as it may taste.

Gemini has been co opted as a way to boost youtube views. It refuses to stop showing you videos no matter what you do.

citizenpaul··on Case study: Creative math – How AI fakes proofs
>STEP 2: The Shock (Reality Check)

I've found a funny and simple technique for this. Just write "what the F$CK" and it will often seem to unstick from repetitiveness or refusals(i cant do that).

Actually just writing the word F#ck often will do it. Works on coding too.

citizenpaul··on Video Games as Art
If a banana duct taped to a wall is art then so are video games.

https://www.npr.org/2024/11/21/nx-s1-5199568/a-duct-taped-ba...

citizenpaul··on Microsoft gave FBI set of BitLocker encryption keys to unlock suspects' laptops
>massive thug salary

Common misconception due to movie brain. The average "salary" of a misc gang member is under <30k per year. Violence is cheap any male under 30yo can easily do it and the poor ones are often willing. Junkies will often do anything including murder for next to nothing ie another hit. Junkies are actually quite reliable contrary to movie brain beliefs.

Anyway wrench hitting does not need to scale. They only want the passwords of people they perceive as being a threat to them which is a very small number of people.

citizenpaul··on The behavioral cost of personalized pricing
I think you answered your own question.

This is like the ultimate version of going back 1000+ years economically and socially. Where a merchant would size up how desperate or rich they thought you were and charged you based on that rather than a reasonable price.

It wastes the time of the poor whom must be willing to walk away without anything when they can "afford it" and further deepens the problems when you are desperate.

Except now they can also spy on you 24x7 and buy information from other spys while they make their decisions and have 100% information asymmetry. Now they also HAVE to charge you more to make back the money they spend spying on you rather than just running a normal business.

You already answered your own question though. It is the peak of exploiting power wealth disparity, there is zero chance of it being used beneficially.

citizenpaul··on Microsoft gave FBI set of BitLocker encryption keys to unlock suspects' laptops
Relevant XKCD

https://xkcd.com/538/

citizenpaul··on Microsoft gave FBI set of BitLocker encryption keys to unlock suspects' laptops
None of this matters. XKCD. Hit him with this $5 wrench until he gives you the keys.
citizenpaul··on Claude's new constitution
Thats a logical fallacy FYI. The people that would be most at risk of abusing power are removing their limitations. The average person that has zero likelihood of doing such things is restricted so it don't matter.

Fox meet henhouse.

Gov = good , people = bad. Gov is people....

citizenpaul··on Proof of Corn
This actually is a good summary of my theory of AI. The best use case for AI is replacing management. Thats the real reason AI is floundering right now with making money. The people in charge would literally need to admit that they are basically no longer needed and act accordingly.

This of course will never happens so instead those in power will continue to try to shoehorn AI into making slaves which is what they want, but not the ideal usage for AI.

citizenpaul··on What if AI is both good and not that disruptive?
Cunningham's Law?

Ok. Aside from the obvious things like , calculators can't be co-opted for undermining and exploiting their users? Calculators can't be primed with false information for manipulating its users? Calculators just offload some longform math, and lets be real a huge percent of people barely touched a calculator after school. AI is basically glued to 70% of the populations hand.

Even at its current level AI is diminishing the value of being someone knowledgeable.

At the core computers are a power consolidation machine. AI streamlines boring/slow aspects of consolidating that power to those that control the AI.

citizenpaul··on Waiting for dawn in search: Search index, Google rulings and impact on Kagi
>why can't they just do it

Money. Google controls 99% of the adverting market. That's why its called a monopoly. No one else can compete because they can never make enough money to make it worth the costs of doing it themselves.

citizenpaul··on What if AI is both good and not that disruptive?
I think lots of SWE massively overestimate the amount that people in power care if the software really works most of the time. Yes even in financial matters. Here is a not secret, Accounting will stop any strange money loss that would cause any problems, its their job. If it happens often enough they will complain and have an SWE fix it. There is a reason so many companies take forever to pay out.

How much of the world currently runs on horribly broken,outdated and inaccurate spreadsheets? Disposable AI slop apps are just a continuation of this paradigm. I do think that AI slop apps will become competitive with broken spreadsheets and 10,000 scattered python notebook files, causing a massive drop in need for various SWE,Analysis, Data Scientist type jobs. I've seen report systems with individual reports in the millions that were only run once (and many not at all), a huge percent of digital work is one off disposable items.

SWE is first and foremost a power structure for the people in charge. The first thing you do when you are in power is always minimize the amount of people with power you depend on. I think that AI already is reducing the amount of people needed to maintain and develop what are basically state of the company applications for the C-suite. Sure tech first companies will be hit less hard but for example the fortune 500 will be making continuous cuts for the next decade.

citizenpaul··on Claude's new constitution
>specialized uses that don’t fully fit this constitution

"unless the government wants to kill, imprison, enslave, entrap, coerce, spy, track or oppress you, then we don't have a constitution." basically all the things you would be concerned about AI doing to you, honk honk clown world.

Their constitution should just be a middle finger lol.

Edit: Downvotes? Why?

citizenpaul··on What if AI is both good and not that disruptive?
I almost think at this point anyone attempting to make this absurd connection is a paid shill.

No AI it is not like calculators, looms, engines, or any other advancement.

If AI continues to improve we will need a complete reset of how human society works. That will not happen without mountains of bodies. There are 2 main ways civilization re-balances when work/worker ratio becomes untenable. War or famine. Hope you and you loved ones are on the lucky side.

citizenpaul··on What if AI is both good and not that disruptive?
On "oddlots" a financial podcast they frequently mention that there is no good exit for AI at this point. Either it massively disrupts industries and the average person is driven closer to poverty, or it does nothing and the historical amount of money wasted will lead to a depression or recession that drives the average person closer to poverty.
citizenpaul··on Caltrain shows why every region should be moving toward regional rail
What I wrote is accurate. You are referring to a line that goes out of the city to elgin, a tiny town, that is the only part with two tracks. The part that serves the Austin area has only one line and is as I described. Hey what do I know I just lived next to it for 4 years, and drove to work even though I could walk to the train because of how terrible it is and would add 1-2hrs to my commmute.
citizenpaul··on Caltrain shows why every region should be moving toward regional rail
You should check Austin TX where they tried to do the same thing, but only built one rail.... So yea you have to wait like over an hour just for arrival if the train is at the other end. For what should be a 15 min ride because literally only one train can go back and forth. The train drivers sometime stop the train to get food at in-n-out burger too, seriously.

Its one of the dumbest things I've ever seen, a testament to inefficient bureaucracy. I'm not sure anyone uses it.

citizenpaul··on AI coding assistants are getting worse?
Also that I specifically mentioned bikeshedding yet the reply bikesheds my simple example. While ignoring the big picture that LLM's still regularly generate blatantly and easily noticed false information as answers.
citizenpaul··on AI coding assistants are getting worse?
Probably not related but it reminds me of a book I read where wizards had Additive and Subtractive magic but not always both. The author clearly eventually gave up on trying to come up with creative ways to always add something for solutions after the gimmick wore off and it never comes up again in the book.

Perhaps there is a lesson here.

citizenpaul··on AI coding assistants are getting worse?
It was clearly a simplified example, like I said endless bikeshed.

Here is a real one. I was using the much lauded new Gemini 3? last week and wanted it to do something a slightly specific way for reasons. I told it specifically and added it to the instructions. DO NOT USE FUNCTION ABC.

It immediately used FUNCTION ABC. I asked it to read back its instructions to me. It confirmed what I put there. So I asked it again to change it to another function. It told me that FUNCTION ABC was not in the code, even though it was clearly right there in the code.

I did a bit more prodding and it adamantly insisted that the code it generated did not exist, again and again and again. Yes I tried reversing to USE FUNCTION XYZ. Still wanted to use ABC

← PreviousPage 5 of 34Next →