HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

citrablue

366 karma · joined May 1, 2018

submissionscomments
citrablue··on Hundreds of skulls reveal massive scale of human sacrifice in Aztec capital
Not sure why this was downvoted, but I support your question.

As modernists, we believe that it's important to punish the person who is responsible for a crime. It is not clear that is

1/ "Justice",

2/ shared by our ancestors,

3/ any more clear or moral than other belief systems.

It boils down to the purpose of the modern justice system. I've heard all the following reasons, each with deficiencies:

1) because doing wrong must be met with punishment (tautology)

2) because it keeps dangerous people off the street (not structurally optimized for)

3) because it makes our society safer (abstract/generic)

4) because it makes it clear that each individual is responsible for their actions (most believable to me)

I guess my question is this: why do we put people in jail (or kill them)? Personally, I don't think our justice system exists to make "good society" safer[0]; I think it's to control people so they behave in the same way those in charge want people to behave. (I.e., the initial motivation is amoral.)

[0] if so, victimless crimes wouldn't be so heavily regulated

citrablue··on Hundreds of skulls reveal massive scale of human sacrifice in Aztec capital
How are they different? (I don't mean this sarcastically)

In one world, we believe that a crime committed causes harm against a social construction. In the other...

To me, it seems like the crucial difference is whether the person responsible for the act is the one punished. It is not clear that is the objective of the modern (American) justice system. It is even less certain that was an issue with pre-Enlightenment justice systems.

Human nature seems to be more "someone has to pay!!" more than "the person responsible has to pay!"

citrablue··on Personalisation Is Asymmetric Psychological Warfare
I prefer to think the secret military ops (capabilities) were the gasoline; Snowden lit a match to illuminate the tank.
citrablue··on Just How Much Money Do “Influencers” Make?
It's the agencies sitting in between brands and influencers who are that good. They're incredible salespeople, and since they get paid a percentage of the spend, it's in their interest to have as many influencers who can post, so they can sell as many posts as a brand can be talked into.
citrablue··on Confessions of a Disk Cracker: The Secrets of 4am
FWLIW, I think there's a destructive poetic justice in the situation. It's not the noblest impulse -- to screw someone who you perceive screwing you -- but it seems eminently human.

The delicious part is in the slow play. Would it be better to halt the creation, rather than degrade it? In that case, there would be no skill development in addition to no product, which seems objectively worse.

citrablue··on No Copyright Law: The Real Reason for Germany’s Industrial Expansion? (2010)
That seems pretty close to how westerners use the term, unless I am missing something?

Context matters, I think is what we can all agree on. Unfortunately, in order to agree on the appropriate context, we have to see each other as peers and working for the same goal. (I think this is what's fucked with the current American political system -- it's less "you have your facts, I have mine" and more "you think this context/lens is what matters, I disagree and choose these base assumptions."

Naive realism wrote bigly.

citrablue··on UPS’s $20B Problem: Operations Stuck in the 20th Century
You are saying that you don't think UPS' automation efforts will reduce the effective workforce by 20% in the next decade? I would strongly disagree with your certainty, and believe if their per-package efforts don't decline by > 20%, they will consider their efforts a failure.

Also, it is possible the union sees no end-game in sight and is just trying to preserve jobs as long as possible. (The robots won't have a union, and if they did, this union would be unlikely to be a part of forming it.)

I think I agree that the UPS union's decision is possibly a poor one, but come on -- it's easy to see why they made it. Making self-interested, short-sighted decisions is literally what humans are best at.

(Plus, it's not like we can pretend to predict the future and better than they can!)

citrablue··on Ask HN: If I Close My Data Centers, What About the People/Jobs Lost?
Your comment would be more palatable if you gave the OP benefit of the doubt. It seems reasonable to assume that someone who is in the position to affect such change, and is willing to ask HN for advice, likely has actual cost savings estimates.

Perhaps saying something like, "Are you sure the cost savings are really there, and you won't face unexpected hidden costs in the future? I have experience with X,Y,Z, and we found that while the cloud is optimized for x64 deployment, we had hidden costs A, B, C, crop up after 9 months."

As it is, it's only added noise and made you look bad.

citrablue··on SpinLaunch raises $40M to build a machine to catapult objects into space
While the high engineering costs are definitely comical, wasn't Juicero's failure because nobody wanted their revenue-driving product, the juice bags? Seems like a $600 device could still be profitable (and subsidized) if the core revenue driver was viable.
citrablue··on Fitbit employees charged with stealing trade secrets from competitor Jawbone
The timing is interesting, assuming it took a few years in draft before being voted to pass. According to a "Jose Canseco" like book called Confessions of an Economic Hit Man, the USSR would frequently attend international trade shows and directly purchase/bribe/steal technology from westerners. But only after the fall of the union did it become a criminal act for an American commit.[0]

Then again, this was also the first period when technology really became ubiquitous. Perhaps it just reflects the spread of tech.

[0] of course treason / violation of oath was a crime, I'm just curious if anyone more versed in history than I can provide more insight.

citrablue··on The Limits of Expertise
To be fair, we don't really know what works in terms of governance and what doesn't.

We do know what science currently says, but that doesn't mean it will forever indicate the same conclusion (to wit: nutrition). It does not provide much insight into a complex world like politics and civics, which are better thought of as an open system with unclear interactions between inputs.

(Also: "science" is not some unified view that has the on-high pope with decrees.)

citrablue··on AI Nationalism
The timeline only matters if the generational period is the same. For the rest, I agree that we don't currently. But things change.
citrablue··on Massive Martian dust storm endangers NASA rover
Is the idea that this one lasts long enough that it deposits sand on my friend's panels, and they doesn't have enough backup juice by then to move/clean it off?
citrablue··on AI Nationalism
Didn't we already get all this functionality from one optimization algorithm, namely, biological evolution?
citrablue··on Gitlab 500 error
The day-to-day is certainly up for debate -- I prefer SQL myself. But imagine the initial learning curve for someone fairly new to programming. Persisting data to, and reading data from, a "database" is a lot easier in code than learning SQL (which frequently use a client-server system, only further increasing the surface area of knowledge required to produce working results).

The difficulty required to think about a solution increases significantly with additional components.

citrablue··on I fear Google's control of the web
I disagree on the third point. It was spam and scams that ruined self-hosted email. Gmail (and other large providers) became the solution to that because the network effects of centralized spam filtering made for an increasingly valuable service to users.
citrablue··on Gitlab 500 error
I agree, and also think the tools we use shape us (and vice-versa).

It may be a tradeoff between lower standards (e.g. "Can you use an ORM?") and steeper learning curve before someone can produce useful work. The former optimizes for more bodies that meet a certain criteria, the latter may optimize for a higher skill level on average.

There are many other factors that contribute, but it's interesting to think about. (I know, for example, the Navy SEALs lowered their standards a ways back to increase enrollment... and some friends have said it's had a negative impact on the teams, because they have taken some people with behavioral profiles that would never have made it in the past. But they had more missions due to changing nature of warfare, and needed the numbers.)

citrablue··on Alternatives to Google Products
Is a power imbalance necessarily wrong? Is it avoidable? Is it suddenly OK if you try to avoid the imbalance but swap one entity for another (dependent on companies versus dependent on your own time/ability to audit code)?
citrablue··on Alternatives to Google Products
It's pretty easy (less than 2 hours work per quarter) to build your own filtering system that works similarly effectively.

Google built a bunch of ML systems that work by default for everyone. Personally, I just have a bunch of filters setup that do the same thing. Has taken minimal effort but some discipline to file incoming emails based on my own patterns.

citrablue··on Alternatives to Google Products
This is true iff you look through the code yourself, or are willing to trust that others have done so in as thorough a manner as your use case (attack vectors) necessitate.

Apple isn't worth consideration if you are willing to put in the effort, or delegate trust, to other systems. If you'd prefer to delegate trust to them, how is that effectively different that FOSS that you haven't examined?

citrablue··on Popularity of technology on Stack Overflow and Hacker News: Causality Analysis
There are two primary approaches, both with their issues. Media Mix Modeling is the top down approach, where you input all marketing activities over time with corresponding response (sales) data. Direct attribution (multi touch attribution) attempts to identify each touchbase a specific customer had with your brand, and use that to infer causality.

https://medium.com/@BenHinson/understanding-the-difference-b...

citrablue··on Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in wealth (2016)
I wonder how this compares historically, adjusted for era. Any idea?
citrablue··on Ask HN: What do GitHub stars mean to you when evaluating a project, if anything?
How many people have viewed this repository and decided to save it for later. Basically, how many people have bookmarked this project?
citrablue··on Performance Reviews Are a Waste of Time
Trust isn't a binary, it can be extended to differing degrees. In absence of advanced comms, you have to extend trust, but how far? That comes with an opportunity cost -- I wouldn't loan money to someone I'd only communicated by 8 week delayed handwritten letters, but I (possibly) would do that to someone I'd talked to on Skype for an equivalent amount of time.

(This might not be rational.)

citrablue··on US government to use facial recognition technology at Mexico border crossing
Because scale matters. Things that are acceptable when they're difficult and expensive become unacceptable when the cost drops towards zero.

When you can do things broadly and cheaply, you tend to do so just because you can. This is analogous to "data mining" in "big data", aka one major issue with modern science -- when you look at everything trying to identify basic patterns, you'll have a heck of a lot of false positives.

citrablue··on Performance Reviews Are a Waste of Time
Subtle adjustment, I think the real cause is scaling human relationships. IT enables this scaling. So if interpersonal trust scales sub-linearly with number of connections, it's not really IT corroding trust, it's what IT enables.
citrablue··on Estonian Manors
I'd love to know more about the costs involved. As the sibling noted, annual recurring costs are interesting, but also super curious about the property values. Is it relatively easy for a foreigner to purchase one?
citrablue··on Behind the Messy, Expensive Split Between Facebook and WhatsApp’s Founders
Proof of work from non-paying customers? Something that benefits the company (retweet to pay), or better yet, something that makes the world better? (eg pick up trash, socialize with an invalid, etc.)
citrablue··on Ask HN: Are you working on interesting technical problems?
Or the damage done to everybody, particularly the poor, from MT's "suffering is Christ like" mentality.

My point is, you have to compare them entirely. At least Gates seems to have moved into the "good" quadrant later in life.

citrablue··on The Cost of Developers
Much manufacturing and warehouse software is on Windows, with extremely high end costs. ERPs, some are moving to the cloud but so much is still hosted locally. With HUGE annual license fees (often in the millions per year).

These systems are slow, unintuitive, and annoying. But they're stable. Companies don't want to risk their existence to change something that sort of works, so you'd be amazed at what a ERP solution with $X00,000 annual costs can get away with.

(In turn, they are often managed by / developed by the IBM/Oracle level of consulting b.s., which further drives up the costs.)

← PreviousPage 6 of 7Next →