HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

cjlars

1,171 karma · joined April 2, 2009

Business owner and investor
submissionscomments
cjlars··on At Davos, IBM Chief Predicts Artificial Intelligence Won’t Be a Job Killer
No. We're (or I, at least, am) debating whether the concept of 'new job' continues to exist.
cjlars··on At Davos, IBM Chief Predicts Artificial Intelligence Won’t Be a Job Killer
> The day will come when machine productivity dwarfs that of humans by orders of magnitude

It already does. Have you tried to build a house without power tools?

Strong-form, self perpetuating, Terminator style AI has not even been invented yet and you're jumping to the closing chapters.

cjlars··on At Davos, IBM Chief Predicts Artificial Intelligence Won’t Be a Job Killer
> In 1760, the lowest 65 percent received about 29 percent of total income in Britain; in 1860, their share was down only four percentage points to 25 percent. So the lowest 65 percent were substantially better off, with an increase in average real income of more than 70 percent. [1]

Despite what Dickens may have written, the period was marked by faster gains for the lower classes than the previous century. And perhaps in part due to what he's written, we now have a social safety net -- I'll admit the quality of this system could be improved. What concerns me is making broad, major social changes in anticipation of a completely speculative (and very specific) view of the future.

I'd be curious about your answer to this: If conditions for the bottom third improve -- instead of falter -- as this trend develops, does that change your policy recommendations (about presumably, UBI)?

[1] http://www.econlib.org/library/Enc/IndustrialRevolutionandth...

cjlars··on At Davos, IBM Chief Predicts Artificial Intelligence Won’t Be a Job Killer
It's all speculation. Increases in productivity (GDP per hour worked) are typically accompanied by rising wages. So you're likely to see job losses in impacted industries accompanied by rising wages in aggregate. It's not obvious which direction inequality would head.
cjlars··on At Davos, IBM Chief Predicts Artificial Intelligence Won’t Be a Job Killer
There's a lot believers in technological unemployment here on HN and one thing I think that viewpoint misses is just how darn resilient humans are to changes in the economy. In the past 150 years, we've seen human manual labor replaced by mechanical labor. Think about that -- a lot of early California settlers walked here, and now you're commanding power roughly equivalent to 100 horses when you hop into your car. Agricultural employment went from 90%+ of the population to ~1% over a few generations. People using computers at work went from less than 1% to complete ubiquity in 30 years. And against all of this, unemployment is still near its target rate. Is the large scale rollout of predictive algorithms really a bigger wave than those that have come previously?
cjlars··on Time-saving technology destroys our productivity
I'm not sure what the happiness maximizing number of work hours is, but I'm fairly certain it's larger than zero. Even Moore's Utopia posited a six hour workday.
cjlars··on The UBI already exists for the 1%
Just did some googling on this. For the most part, there doesn't seem to be much research on inheritance & personality disorders, which is odd because 'does money make us happy' is one of the biggest questions in sociology. I did find this paper however, which is full of tangential information:

https://www0.gsb.columbia.edu/mygsb/faculty/research/pubfile...

cjlars··on The UBI already exists for the 1%
I wonder how much selection bias is embedded in this (common) sentiment. It takes a certain type of character flaw to want to flaunt your money. I'd imagine there's a silent majority among wealthy heirs that just never bring it up, try to blend in, and are perfectly well-adjusted.
cjlars··on Hedge Fund Math: Heads We Win, Tails You Lose
Serious question: Why do you think that and how did you get there?

Real returns 1950-2009 are 7% [1], so my numbers are already rounded down a bit. You might further adjust for, say Shiller 10 year P/E numbers, but how complex do you want to make it?

[1] http://www.simplestockinvesting.com/SP500-historical-real-to...

cjlars··on The UBI already exists for the 1%
Putting aside the author's soak the rich rhetoric, the recommendation, which is basically to develop a sovereign wealth fund and pay UBI from that, has seen success. Norway, the UAE and Saudi Arabia have been able to give back to their citizens through shrewd financial planning and resisting the populist urge of deficit spending.

In America, however, we've gone the other way, with gdp of ~$18 trillion, and federal debt also at ~$18 trillion, we've got a $63 trillion hole to dig ourselves out of before we can pay a net 10% of GDP out to support the poor assuming 6% real returns on the fund. Unfortunately, it's very unlikely we would ever see the political will for a such a huge austerity project.

Before you go saying we should just 'snag society’s capital income' as the author recommends, do note that large scale nationalizations as we've seen during Mao Zedong's Great Leap Forward in China and more recently Venezuela's actions under Chavez and Maduro have produced truly devastating economic and humanitarian results.

cjlars··on The UBI already exists for the 1%
Inflation isn't deductible, which means that bonds can pay extremely high (real) capital gains rates. If the bond pays 2.5% nominal per year, and inflation is 2% per year, and you pay a 20% capital gains rate, then you make 0.5% in real returns and owe 0.5% in capital gains taxes. Which is a 100% effective tax rate.

Stocks are more forgiving, at 2% inflation, plus 8% nominal returns (6% real), and a 20% tax, you would pay 26.7% effective taxes. At 6% inflation, it would be a 40% tax rate.

So this all made more sense when taxes were reformed under Reagan, which had a high inflation environment as a backdrop. Realistically, it would probably make more sense to have inflation deductible and progressive, but equal rates for cap gains and labor income. (edit: for full equivalency, you might also need a rebate for capital losses).

cjlars··on Hedge Fund Math: Heads We Win, Tails You Lose
It's in line with historical averages, some decades are slightly down or up a lot, but over, say 30 year horizons, public equity delivers reasonably consistent returns. A 6% real return on the S&P 500 is a pretty standard assumption in the finance biz.

http://www.fool.com/investing/general/2016/04/22/how-have-st...

cjlars··on IQ is only a minor factor in success
>In 2004, we had 59% of the Forbes 400 having made their own fortune, as opposed to 41% who inherited it.

Quote from your own source...

cjlars··on Cash chaos in Venezuela after banknote withdrawn
One culprit behind Venezuela's hyperinflation is their multiple exchange rate program. They have 3 official exchange rates levels, with the most favorable two reserved for government prioritized imports, like food and medicine, and the third acts as the supposed general rate for all other products. However, the third rate is not always available so a fourth, 'black market' rate has emerged, which is higher than any government rate.

So the import lifecycle is this: (1) Political insider secures import contract and exchanges bolivars for dollars to buy goods abroad. (2) The goods are never purchased, but instead go 'missing' in transit. (3) The dollars, now supposedly lost to theft, are exchanged back to bolivares at a much higher rate. The rate of return on this round-trip is on the order of 1,000%.

Although it's unclear how much money the government is printing and spending directly, it's this process of exchanging cash into more cash without actually bringing in any products that drives the inflation. The amount of cash in circulation skyrockets but the goods in circulation stay the same, or fall, and so prices need to rise. This process also has the devastating flaw of making it more profitable to feign the import of food than to actually do it and so the items most heavily favored for import by the administration are, in fact, in the shortest supply.

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2015-02-19/venezuela...

cjlars··on In 1562 Map-Makers Thought America Was Full of Mermaids, Giants, and Dragons
Commonly referenced in Latin as, "hic sunt dracones," or in English "here are dragons," is the tendency of historical cartographers to include mythological beasts and illustrations in uncharted areas of the map. The icons roughly represent the danger of going into uncharted waters or territories, and also to share knowledge about areas of which there is knowledge, but not enough to map. Serpents and dragons represent dangerous seas. Monsters for dangerous at lands, and so forth. You'll notice that the linked maps correctly identify the South Pacific as having no land, and North America as a body of unexplored land extending northward and westward of the mapped area.

The article's title, if it's intended to be taken literally, is mostly off. It seems that people at the time fell into superstitious, uneducated camps and educated, skeptical camps -- Then as now it seems. The illustrations would then work to serve up both imaginary dangers to the superstitious and knowledgeable best guesses to the skeptical.*

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Here_be_dragons

*This second paragraph comes from my interest in charts and nautical history, but is mostly my own speculation. IANAH.

cjlars··on Psychiatrists Must Face Possibility That Medications Hurt More Than They Help
Suicide rates are up, which is perhaps the best measure of the quality of mental health care people are receiving. However, there are at least few plausible explanations not mentioned in the article:

1. We have an older population -- suicide rates increase with age. [1]

2. We have a less religious population -- Christians, Buddhists and Muslims all have lower suicide rates than Atheists. [1]

3. We have a lower worker participation rate -- Unemployment is associated with higher suicide rates. Although most of the decrease in work in the US is voluntary, there is still a plausible link. [2]

[1] https://www.journals.uio.no/index.php/suicidologi/article/do... [2] https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/psychological-medici...

cjlars··on Movements of the Cold War: How the Soviets Revolutionized Wristwatches
They also seal the caseback with a screw tightened gasket, a mechanism similar to that used on common mason jars. Almost no other watch does that, instead using simple screw down tops. It was a necessary and clever design at the time (1960s) because Soviets weren't able to import machinery with sufficient tolerances to get good waterproofing using a threaded cap.
cjlars··on Why Are Developers Still Pouring Billions into Waterlogged Miami?
The inflection point, if there is one, is likely a decade or more away. Real estate losses will be unique to each area. So you're more likely to see a smattering of "Hurricane Katrina Moments" than a wholesale reversal in the financial markets a la 2008. Deep out of the money options on overexposed instruments is a plausible position to take here, especially during the ~6 week hurricane season.

Another thing to note is that it costs money to short -- you are borrowing the shares after all, so you need to pay interest on the loan. This makes a multi-year position shorting select REITs troublesome.

The position I'm taking (roughly) is to hold oceanfront property with excellent sea-level protection. Think cliff-front, not beach-front. A different play? Construction companies specializing in sea level mitigation.

cjlars··on Why Are Developers Still Pouring Billions into Waterlogged Miami?
If you look at various financial crises throughout history, you'll see that even amid increasingly clear evidence of problems, the status quo is surprisingly sticky. Things move along as normal, and everything seems fine until suddenly... they don't. In hindsight things seem obvious, but at the time it's difficult to know if you are merely flirting with the edge, or you've actually gone over it.

Miami real estate (and other low lying shorefront) isn't quite at that 'oh crap' moment yet. While the evidence for CO2 driven rising sea levels is clear to me, there are plenty of financiers from the previous generation for whom it isn't. And even if they're wrong on global warming, they might be right on sea-walls, pumps and other mitigation methods. The Raising of Chicago lifted the entire city up 3-6 feet with merely 1850s technology, so it's not as if we can't solve Miami's sea level issue with sufficient investment. The issue is who foots the bill, how large it is, and what neighborhoods are left to the sea.

cjlars··on What Percent of the Top-Voted Comments in Reddit Threads Were Also First Comment?
I would add that while it's plausible, it's by no means obvious that Reddit is leaving business value on the table. Imagine that they seek to minimize the bounce-rate on any thread such that they maximize overall time on site for each user. In this case, the important part could be that the top comment is 'not wrong' rather than 'right'. If the first thing users see is too factually incorrect, controversial, or emotionally upsetting, people could be driven people away from the site. Essentially this is the same mechanism that helps cause the Facebook news bubble effect -- people leave if you tell them what they don't want to hear, so you write an algorithm that underweights anything that might do so.

To put it into economic terms, if users have high loss aversion (from being upset, etc.) relative to their thirst for knowledge gained from great comments, you would expect exploitation to be overweighted vs exploration. The business value maximizing solution would then be that once an appropriate top comment is found, the thread should tend to stay in that equilibrium.

cjlars··on Vancouver plans to tax empty properties 1% of their assessed value
They do fairly comprehensive land value + structure value assessments for property tax in many US states. Basically they collect data on every property like square footage of building, size of plot, age of structure, etc and do a regression based on comparables in the area where the real price is known. It's not perfect for every property, but is a fairly straightforward analysis. Individuals can challenge the model's output if it's too far off. The same method could easily be adjusted for rental rates.
cjlars··on Numerai – A hedge fund built by a global community of anonymous data scientists
They would need a model built on top of the submitted models to weight or select which specific trading signals to act on. A plausible model might be walkforward testing on out of sample data, or as simple as trailing performance in live trading, or both. Still, with a large set of models, you won't be able to get around multiple comparisons problem entirely.

That doesn't matter though because you only a need small amount of good signal to be profitable in the money management biz. The larger issue is whether the aggregate signal quality is high enough to be able to pay for development and trading costs.

cjlars··on Elon Musk's Ticket to Nowhere
And yet, roughly 40,000 people make the trip to Everest Base Camp each year -- another desolate and inhospitable place with no tangible economy. An economist might say this is done for 'tourism', but I prefer Mallory's famous insight that people go 'because it's there'.

Ever since we came down from the trees, humans have been setting out on reckless and suicidal journeys for which there is no hope of return. Humanity spread over nearly the entire planet and found its way to countless isolated pacific islands before recorded history even began.

When the price and the science finally line up, there will be no shortage of wealthy old kooks happy to pony up the funds, accept the risk, and set off for the solar system's most exotic retirement.

cjlars··on Federal health expert drop flossing from health guidelines
Remember "chocolate is good for you"? Turns out that: "While research shows that cocoa can have a beneficial effect with regards to maintaining healthy vascular tone and insulin sensitivity, the reverse is true for sugar. Eating sweetened chocolate is still not good for you." [1]

Yet plenty of people seem to have fallen over each other to share that article (and this article). It seems anything that says you can have your cake and eat it too will have plenty of social media shares. In this case, it looks like flossing may be lightly studied, but is still good for us. Perhaps we can change that famous old adage to, "if it sounds too good to be true, it's probably clickbait".

Here's another piece of research on flossing, "In regression analyses, brushing thoroughness, flossing ability and frequency, and dental visit frequency were predictors of lower plaque, gingivitis, and calculus scores. In turn, these scores were predictors of shallower pocket depths and less attachment loss." [2]

That's on a study of 319 people, flossing regularity is based on surveys and dental health based on examinations.

[1] https://www.bulletproofexec.com/is-chocolate-good-for-you-he... [2] http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1752-7325.1995....

cjlars··on Income inequality today may be higher today than in any other era
Regarding [3], you're disregarding state and local taxes. I have a hard time seeing anything but an upward trend in a chart like this [4], given that spending deficits must ultimately be paid.

[4] http://www.justfacts.com/images/taxes/federal_state_local_re...

cjlars··on Income inequality today may be higher today than in any other era
Thanks for the links, I wasn't aware that the Wikipedia article was so flashed out on this topic.

However, I'm not sure I see any actual evidence to support the power theory. The economist article paints a link between education, IQ and income, but not political power. Stiglitz breifly asserts it's truth in point six in his article, but doesn't actually provide any documentation. And similarly, despite clicking through to a dozen promising sources in the wiki, I wasn't able to find any evidence of any sort of trend or change in political power associated to income inequality.

cjlars··on Income inequality today may be higher today than in any other era
Are there any facts to substantiate your assertion about power being the problem? It would seem to me that the power of elites is trending down if anything. The rise of Trump, the Brexit vote, and the rise in taxes as a percent of GDP across most rich counties would seem to go against the selfish interests of the monied elite.
cjlars··on Dunning-Kruger and other memes (2015)
At least one study uses household income [1]. The effect isn't adjusted for family size in any way I can see. Do note that the linked study differentiates between 'enjoyment of life' which they estimate starts to plateau around $75k / household and 'life satisfaction' which keeps going up with earnings [2]. That difference may explain much of the supposed controversy as outlined in the original post.

[1] http://www.pnas.org/content/107/38/16489.full#T2

[2] http://blogs.wsj.com/wealth/2010/07/02/money-can-buy-satisfa...

cjlars··on Why There Are More Consumer Goods Than Ever
Google the headline and access it through the search results.
cjlars··on Cambridge professor on how to stop being manipulated by misleading statistics
A good guideline for whether to truncate a y-axis or not is that the conclusion that a reasonable and knowledgeable researcher would draw after looking at the data should be clearly implied based on a quick cursory glance at the chart. If the chart implies an unreasonable conclusion based on a cursory glance, then it might be said to be misleading. A chart's purpose is to convey information quickly, not to convey information precisely -- for that, a table is often better.

In the example, the true effect is that there was a ~50% decrease, which is newsworthy and interesting in and of itself. Yet, intentionally or not, the chart implies a ~100% decrease based on a quick glance, and so fails to highlight the conclusion that a reasonable person would draw from the underlying data. In this case, I would say a y-axis from 0-60% would be appropriate.

← PreviousPage 7 of 9Next →