HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ckozlowski

2,273 karma · joined May 20, 2013

Infrastructure/Operations geek, hockey player, and internet spaceship pilot.

Solutions Architect at Arpio.io

submissionscomments
ckozlowski··on Are Xiaomi browsers spyware? Yes, they are (2020)
I suspect that your point is that "a Chinese device doesn't mean it's reporting to China." I think it's good not to make this assumption.

That said, I also think it's incredibly naive to think that a collection system wouldn't make use of a local proxy to mask the ultimate destination of the information. It's such a trivial task to do, and provides a host of benefits to obfuscate and sow doubt as to where the data is going and will be ultimately used for.

I'm not assuming that "it must be reporting back to China through a proxy!", but rather, the absence of certain national IPs in that list shouldn't be used to rule out scenarios either. An idea scenario for me would be that the device didn't call back period, or if it did, it did so to endpoints that could be authenticated and audited.

ckozlowski··on NFTs and a Thousand True Fans
There's a lot of original art that's purchased that will never appear in a museum or have someone's name attached to be shown to the general public. While I'm sure there are some who do so for the reasons you describe, they're far from the only one.

There are people who buy originals because they truly like the work, and they appreciate and enjoy seeing the original, physical piece that you don't get with even the finest print.

You also have collectors who, in addition to the above, also buy art as an investment. Say you buy a piece at a small art show from a new artist. You pay a few thousand for it. They keep painting, and years later, are appearing in larger shows, or may have created a piece or two that generated a lot of attention. Now those early works you have from them could be worth a lot more as they're indicative of that person's earlier period. There are forums, exchanges, and shows exclusively for this sort of trading.

(Source: Married to a (digital) fantasy illustrator, attend a lot of art shows, and talk with artists and collectors. I hope to own an original or two from some of my favorite artists in the coming years. And no, it won't be an investment. =)

ckozlowski··on NFTs and a Thousand True Fans
I think you're both onto something here.

For art I'm skeptical (See my reply in this same discussion for why), but for creative works with utility, and NFT might be more useful if the platform they can be used on requires validation of the token. In that sense, it seems to become a sort of public DRM.

I'm sure we can spend a long time musing on the implications of that.

ckozlowski··on NFTs and a Thousand True Fans
I'm thrilled the see this discussion on here, and you're very correct. There's nothing stopping the artist from making more digital prints. And this is currently why at art shows you see original, physical media pieces (oil, acrylic, watercolor) going for high prices, while digital art has seemingly no collectability.

Some years ago, I was at an art convention https://ix-online.com/default.asp) and was discussing this with a couple of collectors one evening, asking if they'd ever buy an "original" digital piece. And they indicated that they would, but only if it either had some sort of embellishment making it truly original as a print (Artist signature on the print, maybe a message or small sketch on the back, etc) or, some sort of agreement, be it binding or on pain of loss of reputation, that more prints in the series wouldn't be made. In other words, something to make it rare.

The only digital pieces I've seen go in excess of four figures are ones that have been "hand embellished", that is, the artist drew their image on the computer, printed it, and then went back over with a physical medium to give it the look of traditional media. And since that can (currently?) only be done by hand, that makes it unique, and therefor to collectors, valuable. And these works are not only valuable in the sense that the individual enjoys it, but many works appreciate and grown in value as the artist grows and so become an investment as others now want to own that unique work.

I'm married to a fantasy illustrator who works in a digital medium, and while I'd love to see her art be juried into the same showcases I see reserved for the physical medium, the flawless reproducibility that's possible seems to deter collectors more than some certificate that says "I own this" does. Perhaps over time that digital signature will eventually be valued more to the collectors than the rarity, but in everything I've seen, for an art collector, holding up your blockchain when everyone else can fulfill their demand for that work and obtain the same quality is cold comfort.

I'm really interested to see if anything becomes of these, but currently I'm more skeptical than optimistic.

ckozlowski··on In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020)
>You have to start somewhere, right?

Agreed, and I suspect from a scientific method perspective, MBTI is something that's being explored in reverse. We've got a strong feeling that these different axis exist, but haven't yet landed on a truly robust and reliable way to evaluate them. So it's a lot of fuzzy intuition about things still.

As long as these proponents explain the analog nature of the scales and the immaturity of the field as a whole, (which I know doesn't happen much), I don't see much harm in it. But I agree that outside of one's on personal insight, using it to make any sort of business decision is folly.

ckozlowski··on In two incidents, F-16 aviators were rendered unconscious, but saved by software
Yeah, he was already booking it.

This looks like it was an air combat exercise. At the very start of the video (0:07) you see a big round circle and some lines that are spread a the top and close together at the bottom. That's the EEGS gunsight, and in the censored portions of the screen is likely the bandit/hostile he was tracking. (Exercise of course.)

Either his target slips out of gun range or he switches to a different mode, but regardless it looks like he pursues, rolls 90 degrees and "buries the stick in his lap" (F-16 has a side stick that doesn't move, but whatever. =). I'm told you have to be careful with this, and probably in the F-16 doubly so. (As C.W. Lemonine has said in a few of his videos, the F-16 will try to kill you.) In the top left of the HUD, straight up from the "C" is a decimal number showing the Gs on the aircraft, and it climbs rapidly from 3-4G up to 9G. He loses about 100knots of airspeed (still pretty fast though!) but then you hear that exhale around 0:18 and he starts to slip off the horizontal and enter that dive. His 9G turn probably is what knocked him out, and yeah, breaks Mach 1 briefly as he heads downward.

Then as ya said, he pulls another 9G when the system pulls him out of the dive.

The "knock it off" calls after are to indicate that they're not fighting anymore. As I understand, that's not slang, that's the actual terminology used.

Crazy stuff.

ckozlowski··on In two incidents, F-16 aviators were rendered unconscious, but saved by software
Indeed. And another thing to consider is that some modern 4th gen performance aircraft require that fly-by-wire by design, as they're designed with inherent aerodynamic instability. You'd rapidly lose control of the plane if there was a FLCS (FLight Control System) failure. Checking status of these is part of the startup sequence.

These systems are often triple or quadruple redundant, and will prevent the pilot from executing some maneuvers if it would put too much load on the aircraft. This can be relaxed for say, wartime situations, as placing high-Gs on the air frame reduces it's lifespan.

ckozlowski··on In two incidents, F-16 aviators were rendered unconscious, but saved by software
Yup! And on the left side, the decimal number above the "C" is the current G on the aircraft, so you can see that number increase as he recovers.

For OP, here's a great guide that ChuckOwl of the DCS community did for the F-16C in game. HUD breakdown is on page 35 of the PDF.

https://www.mudspike.com/chucks-guides-dcs-f-16c-viper/

ckozlowski··on Free Surface to Air missile simulator from Hungary
I suspect it's mostly field manuals and exported references.

With older systems, it's easier to get hands on those as they've been exported to so many places around the world. I know DCS for example has had trouble getting their hands on manuals for current Russian equipment (there's explicit laws on it that's hampered a lot of their development there), but for older systems, there's a lot you can find outside the country of origin.

ckozlowski··on The Uncensored Guide to ‘Oumuamua, Aliens, and That Harvard Astronomer
I'd gotten the impression that Loeb isn't trying to convince the public and scientific community that it was an alien probe so much as is he trying to show it could have been.

I think is agenda is to get the community looking for these things more often, perhaps out of some disappointment that if it had been an actual probe (a la "Rendezvous with Rama"), we'd already have missed it.

Whether it's worth bending the science to fit this narrative is of course, questionable.

ckozlowski··on What It Feels Like to Fly an A-10 Warthog
Thanks for this!
ckozlowski··on What It Feels Like to Fly an A-10 Warthog
S-3 Viking I believe.
ckozlowski··on What It Feels Like to Fly an A-10 Warthog
This is more to draw attention to an unusual fact than any desire to "correct" you, but a single two-seater was built: http://www.airvectors.net/ava10_1.html#m7

It was a single prototype. One of my minor claims to fame in life is that I worked with a guy who was a test pilot, and actually flew in this aircraft.

Of course, your larger point stands however, and general there's no "type conversion" craft like you see in other two-seaters for this purpose. That said, if you had a solid flight background in other types of aircraft, it'd be unlikely that you'd have issues in the A-10. It's reportedly an easy craft to fly, there's little peculiarities that would give a pilot issues like you see in some high-performance craft. Straight wing, low landing speed, no built-in aerodynamic instabilities or anything like that.

ckozlowski··on What It Feels Like to Fly an A-10 Warthog
>But why then do the soldiers on the ground demand the A-10?

I think that's a much more difficult question to answer and probably a lot more subjective. Define "Demand"? Do they demand it over other platforms? And why? I don't have the answer to any of those, and I suspect that the extent that they demand or prefer the A-10 might be in part due to the fact that it just looks impressive. I think you might be onto something as well with regards to "seeing them in the conflict"; the A-10 is often regarded as "being down in the mud" with the troops, where as a JDAM drop from an F/A-18 or B-52 is going to be a angry fist out of nowhere. You can't bond with it, except maybe the soldier talking to it over the radio. =P

The Viggen (in DCS) is hella fun. It's very fast at low-level, and brings a different feel than any other warplane in in the sim. It's very much a product of it's time; with cutting edge electronics but from the 60s and 70s. It's also a very purpose-built craft too: The ideal Viggen mission is to plan a route to strike against a pre-planned target, dump it's warload in an instant, and get out. The electronics are rather janky and will remind you of an Apollo-era computer, but again, they were cutting edge for the time, and it's remarkable how effective they are still. In DCS the Viggen will teach you good planning and tactics as your weapons and sensors are relatively primitive. But it's navigation is excellent, it's speed and handling at low-level are supurb, and it automates in all of the right places so that you can focus more on your surroundings.

In DCS I flew it in those same large scale missions along A-10s. We had rudimentary ECM and chaff/flares to keep us alive. But it was really our speed that did so. You pop up close to the target, using the ground to mask you all the way in, keeping your speed as high as possible (this is where good planning helps) and then egressing out, preferably back under cover (again, planning!) Done well, we'd be long gone before a SAM could respond, let alone close the distance. It didn't always work though, and against targets that were much more in the open, we didn't do so well. And that's pushing mach .9, or 600+ KIAS. So you can see how an A-10 bumbling along at 200-300 is having a rougher go of it.

I'd check out this great video here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DpFIHZJbTtY Also search the /r/hoggit discussions over on Reddit. Viggen has a small but loyal following. It's not a good all-rounder, but it does certain things very well, and with style. =D

Also, check out any of the "F-111 w/ Jeff Guinn videos" over on Aircrew Interview, and how they handled SAMs and how "high speed/low level" was a very difficult problem for air defense to solve back then. Different plane, but very similar mission set. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jAyMklJSwi8

ckozlowski··on What It Feels Like to Fly an A-10 Warthog
I'd like to see the sources for this.

There was a lot of focus on DU at times, especially with regards to Gulf War Syndrome (perhaps because of the "uranium" being in the name) but I believe most of the focus has now shifted elsewhere, particularly with regards to the anti-chemical and anti-biological mixes soldiers were given in the run up to the invasion. I can't find many of the articles I've read on this over the years, but Wikipedia has a decent summary: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gulf_War_syndrome#Causes

The thing with DU and what ended up ruling it out as much of an exposure factor is that it is extremely heavy. Particulates of it don't travel far. They sink, fall short, etc. They don't waft around in air or get suspended in water like some compounds do. I don't think anyone would suggest that you ingest the stuff, but from what I'd read, the extreme weight of the stuff kept it localized and unlikely to be ingested or exposed to in any amounts that would cause wide issues.

That there were other factors that could cause these effects I don't dispute. But it was my understanding that it was determined that it was concluded DU wasn't one of them.

ckozlowski··on What It Feels Like to Fly an A-10 Warthog
It's a little misleading, though it compliments the A-10.

The A-10 was designed knowing it was going to get shot at and take hits. It doesn't have the speed other craft do, though it was somewhat underestimated just how many hits it'd take. All of those redundancies and protections are designed to protect the pilot and save the aircraft. However, an A-10 doesn't have to be shot down in order to be considered a "mission loss", which is what would happen. A damaged aircraft is no longer mission effective, as the pilot is now focusing everything on keeping it airworthy and getting it back to base. So as one of the other posters indicated, while many wern't a total lost, many were damaged, and either had to abort or cut short their mission as a result. From a sortie effectiveness perspective, that's the same result as a downed plane. https://baloogancampaign.com/2015/02/02/10-future-us-close-a...

ckozlowski··on What It Feels Like to Fly an A-10 Warthog
I feel ya. The A-10 has so many fans (and for good reason), that it's nigh impossible for anyone to believe it's obsolete. But you're right, and you're perhaps being unfairly downvoted.

There's a great article here breaking this down: https://baloogancampaign.com/2015/02/02/10-future-us-close-a...

To summarize: - The A-10 was designed for an era when SAMs weren't as sophisticated as they are today. The GAU-8 cannon was to be an affordable weapon for eliminating tanks, but even as it was entering service it was soon clear that modern systems were outranging the cannon, and the Maverick soon became the primary anti-armor weapon of the A-10 due to it's standoff range. (source: colleague who was an A-10 test pilot (in the only two-seater made no less!) and links I can't find now)

- This proved true in Iraq (see link above) where the A-10 was getting shot up quite a bit against frontline units, and F-16s with their higher speed were sent in instead. It's a good reminder here that again, the cannon is no longer the primary weapon against armor in a high-threat environment. When that's taken into account, the A-10 and F-16 have similar weapons capabilities.

- The A-10s primary advantage in a low-threat environment is it's high endurance time. Here, it's being squeeze from two sides: Low-cost COIN aircraft like the A-29 Super Tucano, and high altitude bombers with targeting pods like the B-52. (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vw2qPzl1gtM). The A-29 is very effective in the counterinsurgency role for a fraction of the cost where it's not running against sophisticated AA systems. On the other end, you have the B-52, loitering at 35,000+ with an enormous load of munitions that can be called down on command and well above the range of man-portable systems.

- Check this video here of the late John McCain and a hearing with the Air Force. I've FFed the time to the general's answer to him. McCain, experienced as he was, is looking at this from a prior era here, and I think the General proves it. https://youtu.be/_up7IHd3LDs?t=218

The Air Force, feeling the budget squeeze, is rightfully concluding that the A-10 can go. They can perform the COIN/light ground attack role with much cheaper aircraft or by leveraging the huge advances in targeting with pods attached to the B-52, B-1, and F-15/F-16. At the high-threat end, they have the F-35, who's stealth, ECM, and sensors make it much more survivable than the A-10. (No, really. It does.)

And lastly, if anyone wants to see what this actually plays out like, try the A-10 simulator in DCS. It's a fantastic module. And then better yet, fly a mission or two on the public servers with the A-10 in a mixed threat environment. It'll be eyeopening.

And regarding those? I flew as part of a group online where we'd design and then fight realistic scenarios for our online wing. Props to our A-10 crews, but I got to see (simulated of course) just how limited these craft sometimes were. They were incredibly slow, and so took forever to get to the operational area, meaning the rest of our fighters had to either take off late, leaving them uncovered, or take off early and hit the tanker several times so that they'd be in the strike area to cover when they arrived. With a full load they were sitting ducks most of the time; jinking away from modern SAMs was practically impossible unless you were really sticking close to a ridgeline, which limited where you could go. Often the A-10s would get to the area after a long cruise, only to find some threats still up. They'd then have to loiter somewhere while an F/A-18 with HARMs came to clean up. We had a lot of aircraft overhead and around the A-10 to give it a role in the mission, whereas a package of 2-4 F-16s/F/A-18s with Mavericks could accomplish the same.

(Me? I flew the Viggen. We don't need no escorts, Swedish Dorito go "zoom".)

Anyways, hope this helps illustrate the issue for some of your detractors.

ckozlowski··on The Armed Forces Officer Chapter Twenty: Writing and Speaking (1950)
My grandfather gave me some advice when I was in high school.

He was a radio and communications engineer from the 1950s to 80s. By the time he retired, he'd worked as a program manager with a staff of hundreds. His advice to me, a budding IT enthusiast and likely heading for a career in such, was simple:

"Learn to read and write well. You can't be a good engineer if you can't write well."

It was invaluable advice.

ckozlowski··on Intel is dying and we can’t save it
I’m not convinced by that Intel is doomed, especially by allegations that they can no longer design a performant chip, and especially that AMD has them finished.

Not that they’re entirely without merit; Intel faces challenges that, left resolved, will spell the end of the company. Just like any other firm that ignores problems.

Most of these arguments, especially the ones of “what are they going to do about AMD?” seem short-sighted. Intel has been here plenty of times before, facing down strong AMD competition only to come back and crush them a few product cycles later. Jim Keller can only come around so often. No, AMD’s issue is that they can never hold onto that lead through enough product cycles to really make a lasting dent in market share. It’s especially unfortunate for AMD right now, as supply constraints are choking what is its best performing product in years. Can’t really claw back a ton of market share when no one can get your chips.

It’s asked by the tech tubers and other observers why Intel continues to ship old Skylake variants. Process issues with 10nm are a factor here. But I suspect there’s a big one that no one’s really discussing.

And that’s the fallout from Spectre and Meltdown.

Keep in mind that the exploits in these flaws were found in products that were 10 years back at the time they were discovered. Each new chip isn’t a ground up design, but iterations on designs that stretch back years. I suspect, that the reason we haven’t seen truly new designs in over several product cycles is that Intel is having to redo large parts of their architecture that would have otherwise been carried forward in a normal setting. Gamers and enthusiasts may not have seen much of an impact to their apps as a result of these; none of the microcode updates results in big FPS drops in any games that I am aware of. But there were notable enterprise workloads that did. It’s often overlooked that the consumer marketplace is just one part of the larger IT ecosystem, so a redesign there is a must.

The timing of this is horrible of course, as it comes right when their new process is failing. So double-whammy there. Fortunately, or unfortunately, worldwide lack of fab capacity I think is preventing their rivals from exploiting this as much as they could. As for RISC, I think that is an entirely different threat, and to me, far more threatening and plausible. Intel saw this and tried to get into mobile chips, But I feel x86 is intrinsically at a disadvantage there.

I’m interested to see where Intel will be at once they have a new design ready to go. We’ve been here before. Pentium 4 ended up scaling far better than the Athlon XP did, and Core 2 and Nehalem utterly crushed AMD’s offerings when they were launched after a few years of AMD on top. There’s good reason to believe they can do so again, and a big reason why we haven’t seen an attempt is because they’re continuing to undo their mistakes of the past. We’ll have to see if they can.

My two cents.

(Disclaimer: Not a fanboy, I’m writing this on my AMD 3700X. =P )

ckozlowski··on US military and intelligence computer networks (2015)
You need the DoD Root CAs.

You can get them from here, just follow the instructions: https://public.cyber.mil/pki-pke/end-users/getting-started/

They're not bad to have in general.

The notice you see there is standard boilerplate.

ckozlowski··on China CCP to Nationalize Jack Ma's Alibaba and Ant Group – Report
It reminds me a lot of the Mikhail Khodorkovsky case. Similar struggle, it feels.
ckozlowski··on Pentagon Puts F-35 Full-Rate Production Decision on Hold
Completely agree with all of this. When you're looking at firing missiles like the P270 and P-700 AShMs that have a mass close to a small fighter aircraft, there's nothing to be gained by vertical launch here.
ckozlowski··on Pentagon Puts F-35 Full-Rate Production Decision on Hold
It happens: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_9-LjeoOpeM

That said, I think it's more propaganda than a rule. Especially since plenty of Russian vessels utilize vertical launch systems. I believe the necessity of the angled launch systems like what you'd find on the Kirov, Slava, and Kara classes were more due to the immense size of those missiles. Look at the U.S. Talos and UK "Sea Slug" missiles for western examples. As missile technology became better and more miniaturized, you start seeing more vertical launch systems where it makes sense.

The one area I've seen consistent arguments for horizontal launch are in places where a missile failure (see above) would be much more dangerous, such as on a carrier deck. This is why I believe you still see Sea Sparrow and SeaRAM systems placed on the wings and below the deckline, so that a failed launch won't land back on a deck full of fuel and ordinance. The ranges that point defense systems are working at can't allow for a missile body to "tip over" and still hit the target at range.

ckozlowski··on SpaceX Starship Users' Guide [pdf]
A C-17 load that doesn't require a ground stop in a foreign country or a tanker based in another country to refuel that same cargo plane. Advantage indeed.
ckozlowski··on Metal monolith found by helicopter crew in Utah desert
You might like this article then: https://www.nytimes.com/2020/07/16/magazine/colin-powell-ira...
ckozlowski··on They're deleting my channel, but they don't know why? [video]
I was just coming to see if someone mentioned this! I work for AWS, and it's both surprising and heartening to see how often I see this anecdote get repeated, and many times by us to our own customers. We had teams looking for weeks at all of our other services for other instances of this.

It was a good operational lesson and one I'm happy to see shared still. If a command will let you perform a self-inflicted wound like that without checks, then it's time to review that command. Err on the side of caution and bias towards minimizing blast radius even if it means sacrificing some speed. "Move fast and break things" may be true at times, but not when the "*" character is ever involved. =)

ckozlowski··on [dead]
Looking like that's the case for me as well. Ashburn, VA here.
ckozlowski··on Arwes – Futuristic Sci-Fi / Cyberpunk Graphical User Interface Framework
Without getting into specifics, this is absolutely the case.

There was one instance where, when the new ops center opened, getting the tour of it was the thing everyone wanted. The brass thankfully obliged. Over a period of weeks, small groups got to go over and the new center, with it's large blue display edge lighting, and electronically frosting glass. I'll never forget this bemused airman, pressing a button while a circle of us stood around in a half circle, giving a very Simpsons-esq "Oooooooooohh!" as the glass went transparent to opaque, and transparent again.

Was it necessary? Absolutely not. Was it cool? Hell yeah it was. =D

ckozlowski··on I Tried to Live Without the Tech Giants. It Was Impossible
Except where absolutely necessary, we've been WFH since March. We were allowed to expense some things for setting up a home office.

The few physical workspaces that are still active out of necessity have a ton of sanitation measures in place. Regular cleanings, temp sensors, etc. I knew someone was paying attention to detail when those "foot handles" started appearing on the bottoms of the bathroom entry doors.

A lot of my colleagues and myself have been busier it feels than any time prior. There is honestly a real sense that a lot of people are suddenly depending on us more than ever. It does give the sense that we're critical infrastructure, and the leadership communicates and appreciates as such.

ckozlowski··on I Tried to Live Without the Tech Giants. It Was Impossible
Absolutely. So long as the employees who run it believe in upholding that benevolence themselves.

Disclaimer: I'm a current TAM with AWS.

← PreviousPage 7 of 18Next →