HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

cmeacham98

6,239 karma · joined April 18, 2020

submissionscomments
cmeacham98··on Watermark segmentation
When in the process of removing the watermark do I distribute the work?
cmeacham98··on Show HN: I made a free tool that analyzes SEC filings and posts detailed reports
It's pretty trivial to find insider trading looking activity as a human, so I doubt it would be particularly difficult to write up an algorithm to do it. Of course you wouldn't come close to catching everything but you'd catch blatant stuff.

The problem is as a private citizen/company (1) you have no idea who placed the trades and (2) even if you did, you can't enforce the law.

cmeacham98··on Amazon Turned Drivers into First Responders in Europe Experiment
Why would they write that they aren't fine with it when they are?
cmeacham98··on The FBI Seized This Woman's Life Savings–Without Telling Her Why
I've never seen any strong evidence for this (only a handful of anecdotes), and my personal experience driving doesn't match. I saw speed traps all the time and don't remember a single one that was associated with a speed limit change.

Additionally, even if the speed limit is changed, assuming there is appropriate signage it is your responsibility to follow the speed limit.

cmeacham98··on The FBI Seized This Woman's Life Savings–Without Telling Her Why
Speed traps catch people actually committing crimes. While you as a driver may be disappointed you can't speed (read: break the law) with impunity, I as a pedestrian and public transit user would prefer more speed traps and harsher enforcement.

On the other hand, what happened in the linked article appears to be the FBI seizing the women's assets with approximately zero evidence she committed a crime.

cmeacham98··on Build a Container Image from Scratch
Because Docker/OCI/etc got the most important part right (or at least much better than the alternatives): distribution.

All you need to start running a Docker container is a location and tag (or hash). To update, all you do is bump the tag (or hash). If a little more complicated setup is necessary (environment variables, volumes, ports, etc) - this can all be easily represented in common formats like Docker compose or Kubernetes manifests.

How do you start running a system-nspawn container? Well first, you bootstrap an entire OS, then deal with that OS's package manager to install the application. You have to manage updates with the package manager yourself (which likely aren't immutable). There's no easy declarative config - you'll probably end up writing a shell script or using a third party tool like Ansible.

There have been many container/chroot concepts in the past. Docker's idea was not novel, but they did building and distribution far better than any alternative when it first released, and it still holds up well today.

cmeacham98··on GoStringUngarbler: Deobfuscating Strings in Garbled Binaries
Obfuscation tools like these only slow down attackers, they can never stop them. Even the best in the game, where there are strong financial incentives on the line, fall to attackers typically in a matter of months.

As such, you should never use them to protect data that needs to stay secret indefinitely (or for a long time), such as keys.

cmeacham98··on Certificate Transparency in Firefox
More likely guess, given a refresh fixed it: there was a slight delay with the CT log and it hadn't started returning the precertificate yet.
cmeacham98··on Welcome to Ladybird, a truly independent web browser
No, actually, they don't say that. They very clearly say that they don't (and don't believe most people will) consider what they are doing "selling your data", but that it may legally considered selling your data in some countries.

For example, Firefox runs ads using your language and city/country (on the default new tab page) - but no other data. I think the vast majority people would fine with the privacy implications of that, but this may be legally considered selling your data.

cmeacham98··on Welcome to Ladybird, a truly independent web browser
No, actually, they don't say that. They very clearly say that they don't (and don't believe most people will) consider what they are doing "selling your data", but that it may legally considered selling your data in some countries.

For example, Firefox runs ads using your language and city/country (on the default new tab page) - but no other data. I think the vast majority people would fine with the privacy implications of that, but this may be legally considered selling your data.

Being specific about what types of data they collect and how they use it is actually far superior to some nebulous promise that has no definition.

cmeacham98··on Welcome to Ladybird, a truly independent web browser
If we manage to read the next 2 questions on the list, or spend 30 seconds on a web search, one would find the link to Firefox's privacy policy which details the specific types of data they collect and how they use it, and has enumerated rights for users: https://www.mozilla.org/en-US/privacy/firefox/

This is actually a much stronger guarantee than "we don't sell your data", which is not actually a strong guarantee at all. "Selling your data" is a nebulous term that means different things from person to person, and any company that doesn't literally exchange money for data could probably claim it with some level of credulity.

cmeacham98··on Welcome to Ladybird, a truly independent web browser
They replaced that paragraph with this:

> Mozilla doesn’t sell data about you (in the way that most people think about “selling data“), and we don’t buy data about you. Since we strive for transparency, and the LEGAL definition of “sale of data“ is extremely broad in some places, we’ve had to step back from making the definitive statements you know and love. ...

There are valid complaints you could have about this change (for example, I wish they were more specific about the potential legal issues), but calling this selling your soul is unironically bad faith trolling.

cmeacham98··on Partnering with the Shawnee Tribe for Civilization VII
This math doesn't add up: I just checked a random paradox game, Stellaris, and it has 24 paid DLC (26 actually, but I've excluded an eBook and soundtrack as neither seem to have an in-game impact) - but was released in 2016.
cmeacham98··on Docker limits unauthenticated pulls to 10/HR/IP from Docker Hub, from March 1
Disclaimer: I work for Amazon, but not on ECR or ECR Public.

The rate limit for unauthenticated pulls is 1/second/IP, source: https://docs.aws.amazon.com/general/latest/gr/ecr-public.htm...

cmeacham98··on Escaping surprise bills and over-engineered messes: Why I left AWS
No - most cloud providers are postpaid, you use their services and then get a bill at the end of the month.

Making your payment method invalid doesn't absolve you of this debt and will just result in being sent to collections and/or sued if the total is large enough.

cmeacham98··on Matt Mullenweg, Automattic's CEO, Seems Bound and Determined to Wreck WordPress
Using WordPress.org services isn't some rogue hotlink, it's hardcoded into the WordPress source code. And Matt explicitly refuses to add a config option to switch servers[1] - you have to manually patch WP to do so.

Legally, he may be in the right (I'm not a lawyer and I'm not going to pretend like I can accurately predict the outcome of the ongoing lawsuit), but morally I think I can reasonably say that Matt is pretty squarely in the wrong when he's trying to abuse WP.org services to blackmail WP Engine out of 8% of their revenue.

1: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41676885

cmeacham98··on FrontierMath was funded by OpenAI
Can you give an example of a copyright lawsuit lost by a 'normal person' that's doing the same thing OpenAI is?
cmeacham98··on Amazon's AI crawler is making my Git server unstable
I work for Amazon, but not directly on web crawling.

Based on the internal information I have been able to gather, it is highly unlikely this is actually Amazon. Amazonbot is supposed to respect robots.txt and should always come from an Amazon-owned IP address (You can see verification steps here: https://developer.amazon.com/en/amazonbot).

I've forwarded this internally just in case there is some crazy internal team I'm not aware of pulling this stunt, but I would strongly suggest the author treats this traffic as malicious and lying about its user agent.

cmeacham98··on My Amazon TV Now Unmutes Itself During Prime Video Commercial Breaks
Presumably it's a bug/defect in the TV.

While that is stupid and I would return such a defective product, there's a difference between "my TV's mute is broken" and "my TV specifically unmutes itself during ads".

cmeacham98··on How is my Browser blocking RWX execution?
> this is probably a mitigating control which would make exploit development much harder in case an exploit chain attempted to leverage one of those RWX areas for execution

This didn't pass the sniff test for me - this doesn't do anything to protect existing RWX regions, and a theoretical attacker that has the ability to inject arbitrary DLLs into the browser process already has access far beyond what the browser could protect.

Fortunately, because the browser in question (Firefox) is open source, we can find the change that added this code. This is a bit of a pain because the file has been renamed twice, but here it is: https://hg.mozilla.org/mozilla-central/rev/7d2e74c69253e57fd...

And if we read the associated bug (https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1322554) we can see this is described as "policy decision", and this entire section of the code isn't exploit mitigation, but rather intended to block broken third party programs from injecting their buggy and poorly written DLLs into Firefox and causing bugs that users report to Mozilla.

cmeacham98··on Where are Mr. Beast's early sponsors now?
Mr Beast targets and is very successful in the children (think pre-teen/teen) demographic. His videos often feature giving away a large sum of money or other prize via an elaborate contest/challenge, and he's the YouTuber that can be largely credited with popularizing this style of content.

He's also recently been implicated in several controversies - including (all allegedly) hiring and protecting a misogynist/pedofile CEO, promting and then dumping various scam cryptocurrencies, and very poor conditions for contestants in his recent "Beast Games" (a spin on the hit move Squid Game).

cmeacham98··on 38C3: Illegal Instructions
If anybody that runs the website is here, may I suggest the ability to filter/sort the talks by language? Several of the talks are given in a language I'm not fluent in, and not all contain translations.
cmeacham98··on Fake Nintendo lawyer is scaring YouTubers, and its not clear YouTube can stop it
> You can't just say that you don't want to host any content that goes through a counter notice.

Why not? (at least legally speaking, it'd be a PR disaster I'm sure)

YouTube is not obligated to host any videos on their platform and US law allows for businesses to discriminate for almost any reason (except specific protected classes like race or sex).

cmeacham98··on CLI tool to insert spacers when command output stops
Fair warning - this is a bash-ism, so if you're writing a script that needs to run on multiple shells and/or a more primitive shell, you should avoid it.
cmeacham98··on US lawmakers tell Apple, Google to be ready to remove TikTok from stores Jan. 19
"A large part of it"

However, the evidence is that "at least two" Congressmen mentioned it as a reason a single time each.

cmeacham98··on Show HN: Cut the crap – remove AI bullshit from websites
Highly unethical in my opinion to not disclose the tool is summarizing via an LLM. As a matter of fact, in the right circumstances it may not only fail to do what the title says, but do the opposite - add hallucinations or other AI generated garbage!
cmeacham98··on Black Hat Rust
Is C actually good at writing a phishing page (or any webpage)?

(Although I'm not sure I would consider Rust to be adept in that category either...)

cmeacham98··on Maps.me co-founder tries to close down Organic Maps open-source fork
As you seem to be Alexander Borsuk...

Why the removal of the MIT license?

Was that decision put to a vote like "all important project decisions" are? I assume it can't have been unless Roman is blatantly lying about only noticing it a few days later.

cmeacham98··on Kagi Teams
I don't see one on the pricing page either: https://kagi.com/pricing?plan=team

However, based on that page, the team plan cannot be prepaid annually for a discount, so if you are willing to do that the individual plan is 10% cheaper.

cmeacham98··on ChatGPT Pro
Employers might be willing to get their employees a subscription if they believe it makes their employees they are paying $$$$$ more X% productive. (Where X% of their salary works out to more than $2400/year)
← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →