HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

cmiles74

4,853 karma · joined April 28, 2009

Another developer from Western MA.

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/cmiles74; my proof: https://keybase.io/cmiles74/sigs/vgamM-P-kP6khsKwIPdnT2ZwFYhbUi4VCPNyLF3rJYk ]

submissionscomments
cmiles74··on America's Driver's License Breach Is a National Security Disaster
All the better, I've long suspected that these companies are collecting this data and selling some portion of it. Having this category of business entirely disappear sounds like a solid win to me.
cmiles74··on Fuck it, make it anyway
Will the LLM tools be able to maintain this pile of code either? In my experience there seems to be some complexity maximum to a project that, once reached, the LLM tooling doesn't seem able to manage it either.
cmiles74··on Fuck it, make it anyway
For sure, there have always been obnoxious people trying to gatekeep who they feel met their arbitrary bar of "good developer" with trivia or a command of arcane details. It makes the work harder and it discourages talented people who are new to the field, like junior devs.

Maybe LLM tooling can help people demystify some of that. I think that would be a good thing.

In my experience, LLM tools are not infallible and I've seen them introduce changes in one place that causes defects in two or three other places. They write code that I find difficult to read and that can make diagnosing these bugs harder than it needs to be. People have brought me code that LLM tools have written because they are surprised that it doesn't work and are wondering if somehow they, the human, just doesn't understand something.

Maybe this is just another bump and these tools will continue to improve. Until these things aren't a problem. As it stands today, I think there's still a place for a people in commercial software development.

cmiles74··on Fuck it, make it anyway
Agreed, there may be people working with their LLM tool to learn something new. In my experience this isn’t the way these tools are marketed, from where I sit it looks like this is being discouraged. If you aren’t really learning anything then all you get at the end is the product. For a certain type of person this is just not enough.

I bet people generated solutions end up significantly different from AI generated solutions. People learn more about the problem as they work it through and they don’t always end up with the thing they were imagining when they started.

cmiles74··on Fuck it, make it anyway
I’m sure there is some of that, people looking back at years of learning a skill, maybe even turning it into a productive career, and being upset that anyone can pay for an LLM tool and get output they believe is comparable.

In my opinion, that’s not the whole thing and the article and the parent post touch on this. The part about the process of struggling to get your mind to understand new ideas and new ways of doing things, the satisfaction in putting together a solution that fits in just right and gets the job done. The feeling of goals accomplished and having improved oneself. These are things that are still out there, and the work is still valuable.

The difference, for me, is this constant background conversation that seems to be saying “this is worthless” and “you’re wasting your time”. I don’t think this is true but it’s hard to hear. Depending on where a person is in life, it can hit pretty hard.

cmiles74··on Fuck it, make it anyway
I’m not sure how this is responding to the post… I think the author is going for something different, and that it’s not necessarily about getting things done quickly or implementing every feature on their list. More about the journey and learning along the way, feeling ownership of their project, etc.
cmiles74··on Claude is only available to people over 18 years
The larger the list of thing minors cannot do, the more they will resent the constraints.
cmiles74··on Claude is only available to people over 18 years
Personally, I'm not in love with the idea that something harmful to children is totally okay for adults. If social media is that corrosive to young people, maybe we should take a look at that and make it less corrosive for everyone.

Some kind of "child lock" on the device makes more sense to me; a parent or whatever can child lock the device before handing it off, no need to collect images of the child in question and store them in some big pile at a private company.

cmiles74··on Claude is only available to people over 18 years
I have children and I am very much against the implementation of age verification in the US. It strikes me as a thinly veiled attempt to collect event more data about people. I'm skeptical that it will prevent children from accessing these services.
cmiles74··on EPA says power for data centers can sidestep pollution laws
For sure, an argument can be made that the text of the law could be tightened up. In my opinion, there's nothing in that text that would exclude these generators. In addition the rationale provide for excluding these generators seems... disingenuous at best.
cmiles74··on EPA says power for data centers can sidestep pollution laws
Are they clarifying? It reads to me like they are making up an exception for data centers out of thin air.
cmiles74··on Study reveals UnitedHealth's profit margins four times what it claimed [pdf]
I believe they are saying that only the portion of premiums paid by UHG customers _that are not_ spent on paying out claims should be counted as UHG revenue. That is if I and my employer pay UHG $18,000 over the course of the year and UHG pays out $2,500 to my doctors and to cover my prescriptions, only the remaining $15,500 should be counted as UHG revenue.

The thinking here is that because UHG is legally obligated to pay out claims, this money only "passes through" their hands. I believe the legal obligation is the thing here.

Anyway, if these pass through costs (the claims they are legally obligated to pay) are removed from the equation then their revenue number is smaller and their profit margin is larger.

cmiles74··on Felony charges for citizen deleting phone data at US Border
I can sort of see what they mean if I squint some. Sure, destroying evidence to avoid a warrant is a crime and people understand this.

OTOH this was a warrantless search, I’d argue this is materially different. AFAICT, people can still refuse to provide a password to evidence that may incriminate them. I also think scope is much, much larger than searching a home or office. The kind of data people have in their phone is far more private than the kind of stuff people would keep in a filing cabinet and there is far more of it. And a phone is easier to search. I mean, that’s why they put this guy on a list and waited for him to travel somewhere instead getting a warrant.

Myself, I find this kind of searching of citizens to be pretty crazy and I can’t believe it’s allowed. My hope is this case brings this practice to an end.

cmiles74··on Hook, hold, harvest and hide: Meta's alleged strategy laid out in first week
I don’t think any company has “morals”. For sure individuals might but a big advantage of the corporate structure is this diffusion of decision making and blame. Anthropomorphizing corporations isn’t helping us get a clearer picture of how they work or why they do what they do.
cmiles74··on Xwayland 26.1.0 rc1
I'm not sure that Zoom is the highest quality software. I find it crashy and weird under either X or Wayland.
cmiles74··on LLMs reward expertise
It's not for everyone, but I write all the code and then I ask the LLM for a review. It catches something minor thing every single time (out-of-date comments on a function or method, typo, etc.), something that's clear a mistake maybe a third of the time and, occasionally, points out something that looked fine to me but actually won't work because of some other code that I forgot about. I'm a person, I can't remember everything I guess!

I have to say on those occasional times where it finds something that I totally missed or misunderstood, those are for sure the most productive sessions. I find I'm actually working with the model, while I read the code it's pointing me at, and getting a good solution together. Often the model suggest something that's maybe too simple or, weirdly way way too complicated but it's definitely helps me zero in on a decent solution.

cmiles74··on Startup founders urge U.S. government not to shut off Chinese open weight AI
Oh man, if you weren't sure if the administration is staffed with people who do not understand the technology they are trying to manage, doubt no more!

From the article...

Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent said Tuesday on Fox Business’ “Mornings with Maria” that the administration would investigate whether Chinese artificial intelligence companies had improperly distilled American models to power their own, saying that the U.S. can “sanction” companies that engage in intellectual property theft.

cmiles74··on Private healthcare makes industries less innovative. It's time for change
It's really tough on people with a particular health condition and it can turn into an additional expense if a critical provider is suddenly out-of-network. Employers have definitely given me side eye when I've asked for details on the health insurance plan.

United Healthcare is pretty big in the US, they are also famous for forcing people to spend a lot of time on the phone, waiting on hold or advocating for care. I expect this ends up taking time that the employee would otherwise have been working as well as negatively impacting morale.

cmiles74··on OverpAId – Fire your CEO. Hire the future
Agreed. I was thinking more along the lines of what does it mean to say "I want to hire the next Steve Jobs as our CEO"?
cmiles74··on OverpAId – Fire your CEO. Hire the future
Yes, my opinion is that after being the CEO of Next and Pixar he became the CEO we associate with Apple's success in the 2000s.
cmiles74··on OverpAId – Fire your CEO. Hire the future
Is Steve Jobs even a good example of "the type of person I want to hire as CEO"? I think he probably is not.

He was a demonstrably bad CEO, so much so that the Apple board fired him. He then went on to get better at the job through running another two companies until, eventually, Apple purchased one of these companies (it was very much unsuccessful, BTW). Then he became CEO and the company and was, finally, phenomenally successful.

cmiles74··on Young adults are poor despite every metric which suggests otherwise
IMHO, municipalities are much more serious about these permits and, at the same time, neighbors seem even more sensitive to any kind of noise or even a visual disturbance. If your house is close to the street, good luck keeping any kind of renovation off your town's radar.
cmiles74··on Blatant AI slop just won a 25k USD DeepMind Kaggle Grand Prize
I have worked with people who have this attitude ("do the story, now!"). I think it eventually de-motivates people and you get a lot of bare-minimum type work from the development team. There's often a lot of stressful priority shifting as well, that can also encourage people to meet only the minimum requirements.
cmiles74··on Duskers, the scary command line game, is getting a sequel
Does not at all appear to be a game you run in the console. The first video on the Steam page does include a lot of stylized Hacknet-ish looking text.

https://store.steampowered.com/app/254320/Duskers/

cmiles74··on Claude Code sends 33k tokens before reading the prompt; OpenCode sends 7k
I think both things can be true: new models benchmark higher and eat more tokens.
cmiles74··on Write code like a human will maintain it
I’m not so sure this matters. My team manages a couple pretty new projects and I still see LLM tools doing this. I’m starting to suspect that vendors are building in these behaviors to ensure the output compiles (never throw an exception, null check every variable no matter what, never change a function or method but copy or inline its code and change that, etc.)

I think I would prefer code that is clear, understandable and simple even if it doesn’t compile and needs some straightforward polishing.

cmiles74··on What does Jeff Bezos think is going to happen?
I’d be curious to see the financials on the Kindle readers, my suspicion is that they very quickly make the cost back through book sales. If retaining customers was a concern they could simply ship people the cheapest reader before cutting service.

It’s straight up greed, IMHO.

cmiles74··on The AI Marketing Backlash: Why 'AI-First' Brands Are Starting to Fall Flat
Strong disagreement on this one, I think the coverage has proven that the current crop if anti-LLM sentiment is a much bigger thing then whatever is happening on this website.

In the case of AI generated imagery, maybe it will get to the point where people can't tell just by looking at it. If it does, at what cost? It seems to me that token cost is rising, I can't help but wonder if hiring an illustrator might end up being less expensive in the long run.

cmiles74··on The AI Marketing Backlash: Why 'AI-First' Brands Are Starting to Fall Flat
I feel that "good" music has some emotional resonance with me, at some level. In my opinion AI won't ever be able generate what I'm looking for, it always strikes me as somewhat bland or seems too much like another track.

Background music in distracting environments, where the listening is maybe the third or fourth thing I'm doing, maybe AI will be acceptable.

cmiles74··on For first time, a cell built from scratch grows and divides
I thought the NY Times article was pretty good, they had some nice illustrations.

https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2026/07/01/science/spudc...

← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →