700 karma · joined November 22, 2019
Be careful making assumptions like this. I mean, you're right, having a conscience is a product of our evolution... but so is the ability to lie. You make it sound like disadvantageous qualities would be filtered out by evolution but that is clearly not the case.
Yes, very much so, as is the case with all lifestyle products. People want to believe that they’re buying something special.
Is it reasonable to expect public figures to be 100% agreeable? I don't think so. In fact I think we'd all be a lot better off if we just stopped judging these peoples' character altogether. Shitty people can do good things. Why would we want to stop them?
Or, you know, if we’re in the middle of a global pandemic.
I do agree though that there’s so much that can be done right now without waiting for some magical future tech. Inner cities without cars can be solved with public transportation. De-urbanisation can be achieved with a combination of remote work, cashier-less shops and a well-run postal system. We don’t need to wait to do these things, they’re achievable now.
Are they? Are targeted ads really increasing the number of hairdressers and/or making them more profitable?
I guess it boils down to whether the LICENSE file is meant to apply to the code in that repo or the software it produces when built. I would expect the latter, but I guess it's a bit ambiguous since we're having this discussion.
This openness gives us consumers an opportunity to look under the hood and evaluate the tech for what it is, which is a good thing and should be applauded.
However.
I’ve used that freedom to look at their code and processes and I’ve decided that this is not software that I want my life to depend on. There are serious outstanding bugs that Comma doesn’t have the manpower to investigate fully, their default assumption seems to be that the hardware is faulty, their test suite is regularly failing, pair programming / code review is sometimes used and sometimes not, PRs are created and merged without a description or comment. That’s just scraping the surface, without going into things like whether or not Python is a good choice for this sort of thing or if there’s a bug in my car’s CAN implantation that will get triggered by this and end up killing me.
All in all, I trust Volvo more than I trust Comma.ai. Maybe that trust is misplaced? For what it’s worth I don’t really trust any level 2 self driving tech.
Comma two freeze and reboot while engaged. I recently had an incident on the interstate where my comma two froze completely (while engaged) and rebooted. The video froze, Comma's steering torque turned off, then after about five seconds in this state, the device rebooted.
Zygote restarting while OP active. So for the past couple months, after a couple days of uptime, the comma two offroad UI will glitch out. The buttons respond with highlighting upon touch, but everything else stops working. ... This time, I left the comma two to bask in its glitched state and this ended up happening; the comma two had the spinning logo, while ALSO still driving my car. In the video below, I nudge the wheel to cause on purpose ping pong to prove it was still steering.
Spontaneous disengagement/reboot. Cruising on expressway and OP spontaneously disengaged and the comma2 rebooted
Hard braking while following the lead car. Was following the lead car on a highway traffic jam, that car was going without lights so might be a reason. Braking was really hard when he stopped, almost hit him ) I had a feeling that C2 don't see it at all.
What's more worrying is that Comma's response is often either a) declare it a hardware failure or b) basically a WONTFIX:
Comma support's response is to return/exchange the unit due to presumed hardware failure. It would be nice to know what exactly happened but I get you can't thoroughly investigate every anomaly. Folks at @commma feel free to close this issue.
@Torq_boi said that it is not a model bug, but old known problem with no time to brake as lead car accelerated and braked fast. (So could INDI tuning fix that problem?)
Closing this issue since it probably was hardware failure.
If it happens a lot it's usually a hardware failure. But try running openpilot release instead of dragonpilot before drawing any conclusions.
[0] https://github.com/commaai/openpilot
Edit: Formatting.
Of course you can, just configure your phone to use a MITM proxy (e.g. burp). This won’t work for apps that use certificate pinning but most apps don’t.
Of course, you still don’t know what data they really store and/or sell.
> At the same time the GNU project and FSF endorses and make heavy use of the GPL, which by its very nature is "nonfree" because it restricts what you can do with the software.
Freedom isn’t about being able to act without restrictions, it’s about not living under oppression. Freedom itself is codified in laws that guarantee the right to free speech, free assembly etc. and these laws necessarily restrict the actions of the people. Free speech doesn’t mean anything if it doesn’t trump a police officer’s right to arrest you for speaking freely.
You can’t effectively build a walled garden with GPL code. You can’t effectively build spyware or adware with GPL code. You can’t effectively build black-box IoT products with GPL code. All these dark patterns aren’t possible with GPL code because the GPL places restrictions on what you can and can’t do with it. And by licensing your library as GPL, you’re also ensuring that it’s not (legally) going to be used in any of these dark pattern scenarios.
So yeah, the GPL places more restrictions on derivative works but ultimately gives users more freedom than the BSD-style licenses.
This is obviously wrong too, or else everything compiled by gcc would need to be licensed as GPL. If you distribute a GPL licensed program then the recipient must be able to build the equivalent program from source (e.g. you can’t rely on an internal toolchain that doesn’t have a publicly available alternative) but that isn’t what the author is saying.