HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

coldpie

24,333 karma · joined June 6, 2012

I do software stuff in the computer security space. Former (2009-2022) Wine hacker at CodeWeavers. You can email me on fastmail.com with username coldpie. Personal websites: <https://smokingonabike.com> (video games, gardening, tech); <https://aechairs.com> (woodworking).

Tired of so much AI news on HN? I maintain a browser extension for that: https://github.com/ColdPie1/enough-ai-on-hn

submissionscomments
coldpie··on BYD is bringing its 5-min 'Flash' electric car charging to Canada
> Maybe there's still time?

I don't know that there is. It takes ages to develop an EV-focused platform, and the lines to manufacture it. Tesla is the only American manufacturer that has already done that work, and they're circling the drain. Aside from them, there's exactly one decent US-owned EV on the market, the Chevrolet Bolt. All of the top-of-the-line EVs are Korean or Chinese, and the 2nd tiers are all European. America's EVs aren't even on the horizon, they'll be playing catchup for decades.

coldpie··on GnuCash is right. It's also why I built my own finance app
It's definitely AI slop, yeah:

> It's also the work of one accountant who happens to be the daily user, built with a lot of AI assistance.

coldpie··on GnuCash is right. It's also why I built my own finance app
This is what I use & like as well, but I definitely think there's space for a more GUI-focused option that isn't Quickbooks or Gnucash. It's not a good fit for me, though, I require my important tools to be open source. Closed source software has way too many misaligned incentives for me to use it for anything important.
coldpie··on What is the purpose of the lost+found folder in Linux and Unix? (2014)
I always turned this off, and also, cursed myself when I forgot to turn it off.
coldpie··on Mouseless – keyboard-driven control of macOS/Linux/Windows
I made a very good living developing open source software for more than a decade. Nothing about open source software precludes one from making money, it's just a different business model from closed source.
coldpie··on Gmail thinks I'm stupid, so I left
I know everyone's tired of hearing this, but this doesn't happen on Linux. I know I know, it's different and a little janky here and there and maybe you have to find a replacement for one or two pieces of software. But like, you don't actually have to put up with this. There is a better way.
coldpie··on Dav2d
Video resolution: 128x72, hahah. Late 90s RealPlayer postage stamp video is back! To its credit, that whole movie is probably smaller than RealPlayer itself was.
coldpie··on FBI arrests CIA official with $40M in gold bars in his home
> I collect watches worth >$100k

It's off topic for this thread, but I'd totally read a blog post about that hobby :)

coldpie··on I'm Tired of Talking to AI
You're only getting one side of the story, here. I suspect the user called "anal_reactor" who is a fan of "edgy humor" and thinks "most people have very little depth" miiight have a hard time with in-person socialization.
coldpie··on I'm Tired of Talking to AI
There are still in-office jobs out there, where you can have lunch with humans, and maybe even make friends with your coworkers. I have one. It's not a popular opinion on this site, but it's OK to admit that being isolated home alone for 40+ hours a week is not healthy for your personality type.
coldpie··on Incident with Actions and Pages
This gets tiresome. Github is a lot more than a host for Git repositories. If you want to suggest that people use something else, you need to suggest a replacement that has the features people use Github for.
coldpie··on Steve Wozniak cheered after telling students they have AI – actual intelligence
No one should have more than $140MM. That is a ludicrous amount of money.
coldpie··on If you’re an LLM, please read this
I just went into the university bookstore & took photos of the question pages, lol. This was in the digital camera era, pre-smartphones, so it was hard to hide what I was doing and I got kicked out once or twice. Worth it to save hundreds of dollars.
coldpie··on Fender escalates legal campaign against S-style guitars
You're pretty much correct, yeah. If you want to know what the actual benefit to playing a more expensive and/or name-brand instrument is, it's because it's largely a signal to others about your self. Playing a recognizable brand or a obscure-but-expensive brand can show to others that you're serious & knowledgeable about the hobby, instead of just playing a $150 strat clone you bought off Amazon. If you want to make money off of it, it's also a sign to your potential customers that you know what you're doing. Above like $500, they all play pretty much the same, but they make different statements about your self. It's up to you how much value that has to you personally, but please don't make the mistake of being surprised that others put a lot of value on how others perceive them. That little fact accounts for an absolutely enormous chunk of economy activity, it'd be silly to write it off as unimportant.

Yamaha makes fantastic stuff, they're a great choice.

coldpie··on Fender escalates legal campaign against S-style guitars
I feel your pain. Learning the basics of IP law is one of those "curses of knowledge"[1] because you can never not sound like a pedantic asshole whenever someone who doesn't know IP law tries to talk about IP law. "No, it's not a trademark suit, it doesn't matter if they've tried to defend it before. What, why are you even bringing up patents, it's not a specific, narrow invention, and it would've expired decades ago even if it was. Ahhh!"

[1] https://xkcd.com/1015/

coldpie··on Fender escalates legal campaign against S-style guitars
It's a pretty restrictive design space. The Stratocaster shape is based on the centuries-old shape of acoustic guitars. The lower dip of the "hip" of the guitar shape serves a practical purpose, in allowing it to rest on your leg when playing seated. The upper dip mirrors the lower hip aesthetically and removes weight. The cutaways in the upper bout allows you to access the higher frets. At that point there's not a whole lot of design variation left without sacrificing some functionality (eg the Flying V shape is not really playable while seated), and honestly most of that design space has already been explored, too. The strat shape is so common because, well, it's a really good and obvious design for an electric guitar, which is why it was one of the very first. If you stray very far from one of the handful of established designs, you pretty much just end up with a worse guitar.
coldpie··on Fender escalates legal campaign against S-style guitars
Sorry if I'm explaining the joke, but the term comes from Fender's guitars called Stratocasters. It's a popular guitar shape & configuration, so very many companies have made their own versions of it. However, Stratocaster is a trademark of Fender, so companies don't like to use that name to describe their products, to try to avoid Fender's lawsuits. So the industry has used the term "S-type" or "S-style" to refer to Stratocaster style guitars without actually using the trademarked name.

Similarly, "T-type" and "T-style" is used to refer to guitars similar to Fender's Telecaster guitars.

coldpie··on Fender escalates legal campaign against S-style guitars
> I doubt they can show a properly registered copyright, which would have been required before 1978. I doubt the copyright laws back then would have even allowed copyrighting the shape like that (but I'm not a lawyer).

None of that matters to Fender's case here, though. They benefit regardless of the outcome in court. If someone fights them and Fender wins, or no one fights them, then they cause an enormous, permanent headache to almost every single one of their competitors. If someone fights them and Fender loses, they cause an enormous, temporary headache to almost every single one of their competitors and otherwise there's no change in the market. The worst case for Fender is the status quo, there's no reason for them not to pursue this.

The only way Fender loses here is if they piss off enough customers to cause a drop in sales. But that seems unlikely to me, even extremely pissed off customers forget about these things pretty quick, as Reddit and Elon Musk's white supremacist social network demonstrated after shitting all over their own users and seeing no terribly significant drop in usage.

coldpie··on Fender escalates legal campaign against S-style guitars
> The shape of the guitar is very old (75+ years)

They are basing their claims on copyright[1], which is longer than 75+ years[2]. The first case they filed (in Germany, against a Chinese manufacturer) "validated" their copyright claims because the Chinese manufacturer did not turn up to court so the court ruled in Fender's favor in a default judgment. The small companies being sued could still fight Fender in court and overturn that default judgment, but court cases are expensive and Fender is massive. It's Fender abusing the courts to bully their competition.

[1] "The Dusseldorf court deemed that the Stratocaster design qualified as a copyrighted work of applied art under German and European law, thus prohibiting Yiwu Philharmonic Musical Instruments Co. from manufacturing, offering or distributing guitars featuring the Stratocaster body shape in Germany and the EU." https://www.guitarworld.com/music-industry/fender-legal-ruli...

[2] "The chosen term for a work was 70 years from the death of the author." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copyright_law_of_the_European_... Leo Fender passed in 1991, so any copyrights attributable to him expire in the year 2061 (ie another 35 years from now, more than 100 years after the first strats were sold). I'm not 100% sure this is the copyright situation Fender asserted, but it's probably something not very far off from this. If you think this copyright duration is absolutely ludicrous, you are correct.

coldpie··on Google Declaring War on the Web
Passkeys are a big part of this future, too. The spec has device attestation built in, so if passkeys gain traction, they could lock it down so only approved software is allowed to log in to services. If that happens, it means your ability to log in to services will be mediated by one of 3 US big tech companies. "For security," of course.
coldpie··on Google changes its search box
> allowing Googlebot to crawl my sites

As far as I know, you don't have a choice. They have no obligation to respect your wishes, and LLMs are legally allowed to scrape & republish your content.

coldpie··on Google changes its search box
Makes sense to me. A chat UI has more avenues for subtle advertising & sentiment manipulation than plain links do.
coldpie··on Eric Schmidt speech about AI booed during graduation
Well, congrats, you have the power to go make 50 of those in 3 minutes. Enjoy...?
coldpie··on Eric Schmidt speech about AI booed during graduation
> insane coming from an executive

I guess you haven't heard much from executives before? They are absolutely coocoo-bananas people.

coldpie··on Eric Schmidt speech about AI booed during graduation
It's on the same level as giving someone like, a box of chapsticks you picked up at Walgreens on the way over for Christmas dinner. No effort or thought, not really worth anyone's time, the giftee's or the gifter's.
coldpie··on Math Jokes in Alice in Wonderland
Oh excellent, my library has a copy available right now. I will go check this out :)
coldpie··on Eric Schmidt speech about AI booed during graduation
I opened a grocery store where anyone can walk in, take whatever they want, and walk out without having to pay for it. No grocery store has ever seen the level of customer growth as mine!

The reason for all the LLM spend & forced adoption is to make LLMs a critical part of everyone's processes while it's cheap/free, and then crank up the price once it's too late to easily back out. Just like I will jack up the price on my grocery store once all the fools at competing stores who are charging their customers money go out of business, and I'm the only one left in the area, leaving everyone (except for me!) worse off than where they started.

It's a scam, and it seems to be working.

coldpie··on Eric Schmidt speech about AI booed during graduation
I do, too, but a throwaway account busting into a conversation and screaming "everyone listen to me, me, me!" is a bit obnoxious, you know?
coldpie··on Meta's New Reality: Record High Profits. Record Low Morale
Ahh, to be 15 again, when I knew everything and the world was so simple and obvious. Enjoy these days, friend.
coldpie··on Meta's New Reality: Record High Profits. Record Low Morale
Advertising is necessary for many businesses. The way Meta & Google sell ads and show them to users by algorithmically monetizing human attention is incredibly harmful to society & humanity. Meta & Google have been so successful at their business and at manipulating governments to avoid regulations and anti-trust enforcement that they have effectively put all other methods of advertising out of business. So, the only way for businesses to advertise now is to participate in the incredibly harmful world of online advertising as run by Meta & Google.
← PreviousPage 9 of 34Next →