HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

cole-k

385 karma · joined July 25, 2020

Hi
submissionscomments
cole-k··on How 'Factorio' seduced Silicon Valley and me
Your comparison hits home for me. I have been playing guitar on-and-off for over a decade (OK, maybe more like trying to play guitar) and I still really enjoy Guitar Hero.

It's instant gratification: I don't have as much fun practicing at .75x speed with a metronome to learn the hard part of a piece. Instead a video game tells me how great I am at "guitar" by being able to push buttons and strum on the beat, not to mention that I hear the sounds of my favorite songs come out when I do it.

For a similar reason, I like Rocksmith (guitar hero but with a real guitar), but the gratification is not quite so instant. They gamify the practicing part but I still need to do it, otherwise the part I'm playing actually sounds bad. And sight-reading is so much harder when there are more than 5 buttons.

cole-k··on DeskPad – A virtual monitor for screen sharing
I feel this is a little unfair to the parent as they are offering a solution for an unsupported platform.
cole-k··on Farewell to the car CD player, source of weirdly deep musical fandoms
I can totally relate to that, what a hit of nostalgia. I don't know if I ever bought an album on iTunes.

It's interesting how the streaming era has brought the whole album experience back. I only started listening to full albums again once I switched to streaming. Although I'm not sure how many people are taking advantage of it (for the exact reasons we both mention).

cole-k··on Farewell to the car CD player, source of weirdly deep musical fandoms
I can totally relate to the "deep and often weird attachments" you forge listening to albums, although I'm not sure I agree that there's a case to be made for it. A few weeks ago, I heard a song in a random gelato shop in Italy that instantly sent me back 15 years. To my knowledge, its band only had one hit (at least if we go by airplay), and this was decidedly not it. Yet I knew it well because I tend to listen to whole albums and this song was on the album with their one hit. After the high of hearing an obscure alt rock song in the strangest of places passed, it dawned on me that I didn't like that song now. Nor had I fifteen years ago.

I still listen to albums in their entirety, but I have to wonder how much exactly we lose by having the choice to only take what we like from them (without buying them in their entirety). In defense of the author, I will say that listening to the same song you don't like much enough times can make you at least tolerate it. Perhaps having all of the music of the world at my fingertips has just made me pickier, not necessarily happier.

The song in question, by the way, was "Time Won't Let Me Go" by The Bravery.

cole-k··on Is the world really running out of sand?
Your comment and my response exist in so many places on the internet, but I wanted to point out that most of the web-based recipes I use have a convenient "jump to recipe" button. I won't attempt to explain what SEO/copyright/whatever reasons there are for the excess prose at the beginning, though.

What bothers me more about these sites is how heavyweight they can feel even with ads stripped. I wonder if they all use a similar, bloated JS widget that my phone cannot run smoothly.

cole-k··on The secret of Minecraft (2014)
> If "resource satiation" refers to the ability of the player to build/do whatever they want, then it is true. If "resource satiation" means "having enough resources", then for some people it is impossible by nature. There's always a temptation to do more and build more.

Just to clarify my point, when I refer to satiation I mean it in the same way one might feel about MMOs. OK, let me be honest here, I don't play any MMOs but my understanding is that after you "beat" the game and max your level, one thing that might bring you back outside of new content is obtaining all the best gear, different skins, whatever you might want to collect. In the same vein, in Minecraft you could imagine wanting to obtain the best armor, weapons, food, etc. In some of the servers I played on, there were players who lived in a ramshackle hut and spent most of their time mining to get enough diamonds for gear -- and after a certain point they ran out of things to improve upon for their player character so they started looking for rare items in dungeons (remember when mossy cobble was a rare item?). At some point, they had gotten enough, and saw no further reason to keep playing. An extreme case, but not completely dissimilar to my own.

cole-k··on The secret of Minecraft (2014)
I agree, it's crazy to think how much content has been added to the game since beta 1.7.3 because I remember thinking at that time that there already was so much. Like you imply, there were all sorts of unintentional tricks to add to your bag: cart boosters, all manner of BUDs, placing a water source beneath your feet to prevent fall damage. But I think part of that feeling of wonder is nostalgia, since playing now I am not really bothered by powered rails, observers, and feather falling -- nor do I think I would be if they had been introduced from the get-go.

And of course redstone. What a lovely idea in retrospect.

Thank you for helping me revisit these memories.

cole-k··on The secret of Minecraft (2014)
Thank you for sharing, all this talk of beta 1.7.3 (which is over 10 years old, my goodness how time flies) has made me nostalgic to try it, and this might be what convinces me to, since without anything new I probably would set up in a cave and then quickly quit.
cole-k··on The secret of Minecraft (2014)
I've played a lot of Minecraft and I still remember beta 1.7.3 very fondly -- albeit for different reasons -- but I want to offer a differing perspective.

I have always struggled with balancing my desire to create with my capability to create, in and out of Minecraft. I would get so inspired by all the awesome things people built, that I could never graduate from my barebones cave-with-chests because my desire to make something great made any attempt feel crummy in comparison. The most I would accomplish was making redstone contraptions because -- to be a little reductionist -- those either work or they don't.

I hope you will pardon my digression, but the point I'm getting to is that in beta 1.7.3, the goals you set for yourself, and therefore the reasons for you to keep playing, were largely creative in nature, like building a cool house. Updates past this point gave players the opportunity to make simpler, game-directed goals. It used to be that you reach resource satiation quickly, but now it will take hours to obtain a fully enchanted set of diamond armor, kill the ender dragon, explore all the new generated structures, etc. In later years they've codified these goals in achievements, including crazy ones like getting every positive and negative effect at the same time or exploring every biome. With these updates, the people who enjoy building cool things also got more cool things to build with, but this has in my opinion been a little more secondary.

I understand why people might be disappointed, or at least confused, by Minecraft's updates now pushing it toward "pesudo-RPG" status, but I have at least welcomed these changes because they gave me and my friends a reason to reboot our server every few years to try out the new stuff.

Although I will add that if your gripe is regarding combat/pvp changes (e.g. shields) then yeah I have nothing to add to that discussion.

EDIT: I also agree with sibling comments about more content = more enjoyment, at least for me. I enjoy playing games where there are just a lot of things to learn and know.

cole-k··on CrowdStrike offers a $10 apology gift card to say sorry for outage
This reads like an article from the Onion, bravo CrowdStrike.
cole-k··on The only tourist in Moldova
Damn Scots, they ruined Scotland!

https://youtu.be/i2q0T7QXETs

cole-k··on US EPA sets health advisory limits for PFAS from 70 ppt to .02 ppt (2022)
I've heard differently from the two dentists I've seen. The first suggested using a water pick and the second told me it was fine as a first pass but I still needed to floss. Might be because my teeth are very close to each other though.

If there's evidence stronger than a dentist's opinion, I'd like to hear it, because I preferred the water pick...

cole-k··on What are third places? How do I find one?
Also in ours: https://www.youtube.com/shorts/gfru6GskeCc (sorry for the shorts link, it was all I could find...)
cole-k··on Lowercase – A simple way to take and share notes
I'm guessing that "amount" is not quantized ("number" is). Let me be absolutely clear that most native speakers will not notice the distinction (even pedants like me missed this one).

You'll also see people being pedantic about "less" versus "fewer," e.g. complaining about the "12 items or less" line being improper usage since items are quantized and therefore it should be "12 items or fewer."

cole-k··on Google made me ruin a perfectly good website (2023)
Look I hate these SEO-laden pages just as much as the next guy, but I think the binary classification of "good content" and "bad content" lacks nuance. I would refer to it instead as "bad packaging" of (often) good content. As much as I loathe having to hunt for the "jump to recipe" button on my phone each time I open one of these pages, I also appreciate being able to freely view recipes which I enjoy and cook regularly.
cole-k··on Google made me ruin a perfectly good website (2023)
While it is admirable that you are willing to produce content out of your own generosity, it seems a little optimistic to assume that everyone making content on the internet is both willing and able to share it for free.

I am somewhat curious to hear more about the better and cleaner ways to make money on the internet, but I have a suspicion that in some circumstances (such as recipes) they may put you at a competitive disadvantage. I certainly have no desire to pay to access recipes I find via Google searches.

cole-k··on Type Inference Was a Mistake
The eta reduction code hint is a weird one for sure, although let's be real with Haskell naming conventions that usually means dropping an 'x'.

If the linter cares so much about making code point-free maybe they should start suggesting refactors like

    foo x = bar x (baz x)
to

    foo = bar <*> baz
(... /s)
cole-k··on Magika: AI powered fast and efficient file type identification
A fun read in service of your first point: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bush_hid_the_facts
cole-k··on A look at the Mojo language for bioinformatics
It's unfortunate indeed if Julia does not have a well-written GC as you imply.

While I feel like I have my head wrapped around ownership well enough to write (dare I say idiomatic) Rust without too much difficulty, I do find myself often in a position where I wish I just had a GC.

I think this speaks to what your parent comment is saying: I think there are many situations where the performance improvement over having fine-grained control of my code's memory management is not worth the extra time I have to spend thinking about it. As it stands, I will sometimes give up and slap a bunch of clones or Rcs on my code so it compiles, then fix it up later. But the performance usually is good enough for my use even with all of these "inefficiencies," which makes me sometimes wish I could instead just have a GC.

cole-k··on The quiet death of Ello's big dreams
Even the supposedly indie anti-social social media outright violated their own manifesto. Is it any surprise that we're skeptical of the big promises of a bright future that corporations make all the time?

I'm curious to know if anyone has evidence of a post similar to this but for a company with a (so far) happy ending.

cole-k··on Tracking developer build times to decide if the M3 MacBook is worth upgrading
I mean yeah I've come to accept it because I don't know any different. If you can share some examples of large-scale projects that you can compile to test locally near-instantly - or how we might change existing projects/languages to allow for this - then you will have my attention instead of skepticism.
cole-k··on Show HN: Whataaabout.com – unique activity ideas for the holiday break
Native English speaker, I agree with the parent.

I don't think it's a big deal, though. The site itself is more important than the name.

Edit: If I were to say a drawn-out "what about" to someone I would probably say "what abooout" but both suggestions sound okay to me.

cole-k··on Advice for new software devs who've read all those other advice essays
> I don't understand what causes people to talk in bad faith like that.

Okay I guess I'll take the bait and assume you are legitimately confused and that your original comment was in good faith.

When you say something like

> You sound like you saw the phrase "Right Way Guy", felt it sounded pejorative (it's more gently poking fun at a common thing), and decided it must mean That Type Of Guy I Don't Like.

you might think that no one should get offended by this because you are being objective about your thoughts. But it doesn't matter that you're "just" sharing your thoughts. These thoughts are hurtful to the parent as evidenced by their reactions. They're hurtful because people don't like being wrong nor do they like being told that they're upset. If this isn't clear to you, then you have my deepest condolences because I expect you often unintentionally offend others.

If I may offer unsolicited advice, you can avoid this kinds of unpleasant reactions by mincing your words. I know a few people who speak like you did and they all are so confused when I tell them this because they think readers would be offended that they are padding their message with unnecessary formality and fluff. But without it, their message is often curt.

I see this interaction play out all the time on HN (including my response), so I hope my response is not in vain...

cole-k··on Shh: Simple Shell Scripting from Haskell
Those of you who use (or used) this as your shell: care to share your experience?

It seems a lot less full-featured than https://xon.sh/, but maybe you don't need a lot of bells and whistles for regular usage. I mostly run build, execute, and install commands.

I'm somewhat enticed at the possibility of being able to wrap common executables into forms that are typed (like nushell or elvish) and manipulate them in a way that leverages the type checker.

cole-k··on Haroldbot, client-side tool that checks 32-bit bitvector arithmetic equivalence
The way they do search reminds me a lot of https://herbie.uwplse.org/
cole-k··on You're Gonna Need a Bigger Browser
I was reading some other replies that suggested using something to close all tabs and bookmark them automatically and I had the same reluctance as you do because I also group up my tabs.

However, this makes me think: what if there was a tree-style-tab extension that let you convert a tree into a bookmark folder? Then I wouldn't feel bad at all about closing half or more of my tabs.

This could be optionally combined with some sort of bookmark/page archiving service so you can be extra-sure that content will be waiting for you if you ever decide to look at it later.

cole-k··on You're Gonna Need a Bigger Browser
Many tab user (~20-50?) reporting in.

I guess I sort of get tab FOMO where I don't want to close a page because I haven't "used it up" yet. e.g. I've had a tab group for a while for buying new shoes. Really, most of these tabs should be bookmarks, but I'm just not bothered enough to change it (yet).

Interspersed among the FOMO tabs are things I'm currently working on. These are strewn all over the place and I've observed two things about how I use them. First, when I try to prune work tabs I am always overzealous and I find myself reopening the same tabs over and over. Second, I'm sensitive to where tabs are located spatially and I'm able to frequently find my way back to oldish tabs.

So basically, I'm saying "I have a system," but that is a flimsy defense and the real answer is probably "I'm not bothered enough to change."

cole-k··on Making Hard Things Easy
Can you think of a single CLI tool that would let me commit a past incantation to a file and retrieve it later? Especially one that syncs well across devices.

The best I can think of is Atuin (https://github.com/atuinsh/atuin) but I wasn't super interested in using it - I kind of want something more lightweight.

cole-k··on Making Hard Things Easy
If you don't mind, it would be awesome to see your cheatsheet. I think this would be a great thing for people to share - like their dotfiles. But maybe they already do and I don't pay much attention to it because I'm lazy - like their dotfiles.
cole-k··on A basic guide to using Asian names
There has to be some irony that your comment is (intentionally?) obtuse when the OP is about changing how you speak to match your audience.
← PreviousPage 2 of 6Next →