HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

colinsidoti

695 karma · joined September 29, 2010

submissionscomments
colinsidoti··on Ask HN: Need App ideas for ice cream product
Ask them if you can make an app for the brand as a whole instead of just one type of ice pop. You might have a shot with a game people run their own ice cream truck business, or build their own boardwalk/amusement park.

If you make a fun social game then you can passively advertise the brand as a whole, and ideally have a longer lasting impact on consumers. If I love playing "Popsicle Challenge" and Popsicle brand ice pops are integral to my success in the game, I'm certainly more likely to buy a Popsicle brand ice pop.

colinsidoti··on Facebook To Make ‘Facebook Credits’ Mandatory For Game Developers
Heh, Facebook will need to continue making special deals with major game-makers. Facebook Connect can be used to implement all of the social features these games have incorporated. Asking a game-maker to stay with Facebook and ignore the 30% cut they're taking is unreasonable after the product is popular. I can see the cut become an automatically tiered percentage based on the amount of transactions being done. The more transactions, the lower the cut.

Facebook simply does not provide enough value after these games are popular to justify a 30% cut. In all honesty, it hardly provides enough value at the beginning. Nothing says social games cannot exist without Facebook at all.

colinsidoti··on Did social games kill Facebook’s social graph?
That's true, and something I hadn't considered completely. I think you also need to consider that removing these viral channels makes the game less fun, and potentially decreases the amount of credits people will spend on the game. Also, I imagine Zynga would be tempted to jump ship (as they've threatened before) if Facebook starts to govern features they can include at such a ridiculous level.
colinsidoti··on Did social games kill Facebook’s social graph?
"but now you just facebook friend them and take in the info dump"

True, but does this guy I'm sending a friend request to actually want me to see his profile? It seems that Facebook wants me to send him a friend request, and Facebook wants the guy to accept it, but the guy doesn't have much motivation to actually accept.

Facebook's quest for openness is interesting and I think they can do quite a bit with it, but I also think it has left users with a desire for deeper social interaction. I can make my status "girls suck," but I'll never make it "my girlfriend cheated on me and wants me to take her back and I love her but I feel like it's going to be a slippery slope"

I've always thought this is something Facebook would simply fix on their own. But now, as I consider the potential financial impact on the company, I think it might be worth contesting with a new product.

colinsidoti··on [dead]
And now it's back up. Impressively short amount of downtime (<10 minutes), and it was amazing to see how quickly twitter picked up on it.
colinsidoti··on Secret businesses aimed to exploit vaccine fears, British Medical Journal finds
An interesting anti-vaccine argument is that of chiropractors. They often believe chiropractic is a viable alternative that poses less risk than vaccines do (which they will acknowledge is still quite small, but why risk it?). I'm mentioning this because it's the side I heard about long before Wakefield's finding was published, and people seem to think there was no anti-vaccine argument before 1998.

Unfortunately this is impossible to prove, but it's interesting nonetheless. Do the research and pick a side yourself.

colinsidoti··on Simple Questions for Google Regarding Chrome’s Dropping of H.264
I'm sure the restaurants aren't very happy about it, and I guarantee a Flash website is more usable than a website that cannot be accessed at all.

The same concept applies here.

colinsidoti··on Why Caltech Is in a Class by Itself
Wow, you've managed to pick the worst reasons not to appreciate a good school, and they really don't align with anything I've witnessed at MIT.

Kid's take time off after repeated failure, but they often come back once they're off of academic probation. Others will leave to take jobs, start companies, or transfer to a similarly ranked school that they simply like better. I've heard/seen tens of these cases, but never one where students purposely transfer to a school where they're less prone to fail.

Moreover, financial aid seems generous here. And private school prices anywhere, regardless of the caliber, are very similar.

If anything, take solace from the awkward social life, the excessive workload that makes entrepreneurial endeavors seemingly impossible, and the fact that you really don't need a good school to succeed.

colinsidoti··on Ask HN: How can I quit talking myself out of my own ideas?
Pro-tip I learned from Peter Thiel's 20 under 20 application:

To avoid the wait, try and answer the question "How are you going to change the world" on paper. Try and make it at least a page. If everything you come up with sounds like a sham, it's probably not that good of an idea.

colinsidoti··on Ask HN: How can I quit talking myself out of my own ideas?
I've discovered that most of my ideas are usually missing one thing. I have a group of friends that also have a ton of ideas, and I bounce all of my ideas off of them. Most of the time we agree that something is simply missing, and we can't figure it out. Sometimes though, someone will say something that makes the project an obvious green light, and that's when I go for it.

For me, this final idea is usually the difference between "this project is going to be awesome" and "this project is going to be awesome and I know exactly how I'm going to get people to use it."

colinsidoti··on How Much Did It Cost AOL To Send Us Those CDs In The 90s? “A Lot,”
With the effectiveness of online advertising declining, I wonder if we'll start to see more physical promotions. Although, one could easily argue that physical advertisements are no longer used because the internet exists as a viable way to reach users.

On a somewhat unrelated note, the CD promo led to one of my favorite commercials: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3OqQYk2TC-8

colinsidoti··on Common Application Users Find a Glitch
Jeesh, the kid goes through so much trouble generating press and says this:

"It's kind of ridiculous," he said. "I take computer science. I have a vague idea of how this may or may not work. I think it would be just such an easy thing for an error message, at least, to pop up."

So much for taking advantage of the opportunity.

Common App is an awful piece of software and there are many places for improvement. There is definitely room for a startup in this space, and the article proves that common app isn't going to put up a fight.

colinsidoti··on Ask HN: How do you balance college and a startup?
I think the overarching idea is to focus on learning and not worry about the grades. Exactly what you'll end up with depends on the school, but also doesn't really matter. I'm at MIT, and here it's very difficult to both understand the material and do worse than a C. I imagine other schools are similar, but I can't really speak to that.
colinsidoti··on Ask HN: How do you balance college and a startup?
I am constantly applying to interesting jobs and if I come across a good enough offer I'd be happy to leave school. Good enough has a very bar though, and I haven't found anything worth leaving school. That said, I've come across many offers that are more than enough to make a living.

I also wouldn't say that my approach is doing "the requisite amount of work to pass." Classes inherently have a lot of fluff, a lot of which doesn't really teach you anything. Take my software design class, for example. There were a few core concepts they pushed heavily and I learned those well, but I already knew the small implementation and GUI details. I could have spent the time building those out and getting the A, but I'd much rather take the time to apply those details to my startup.

It turns out that learning what I felt I needed to learn earned me a B in Software. It's different for every class, but I think it's possible to both pursue a startup and get your money's worth out of school. Unfortunately, it's often your grades that take the hit.

colinsidoti··on Ask HN: How do you balance college and a startup?
Worry about learning instead of your grades. You can get C's and still gain the knowledge you need for your startup. It will cut down significantly on the amount of hours you need to devote to school.
colinsidoti··on Build a better spell checker, win $10,000
I did a proof of concept for a better spell checker about 3 years ago. Query groups of two to three words in a search engine and look at the word count. Then replace the word in question with other words that are similarly spelled and run a query with each. The word with the highest result count is extremely likely to be the correct word. Really, it's surprising how accurate it is.

The glory of this is that it works with proper nouns that don't occur in dictionaries (IE: xkcd). In Google's initial demo for Wave, they showed "Icland is an icland" be corrected to "Iceland is an island." I'm fairly confident they took a similar approach. There's also a good chance it could work for other languages, because it doesn't use anything specific to English.

The disappointing part is that most of the accomplishment comes in "Suggestion Intelligence First," meaning that from a list of 5, the top result is the correct result. In most cases, the Suggestion Intelligence is just fine, you will just need to pick the right one yourself.

If anyone's interested, this was my presentation: http://soe.rutgers.edu/sites/default/files/gset/Presentation...

And this was the "research paper." Unfortunately it was a three week program, and myself and the other coder (IE: the ones who understood how the thing worked) didn't contribute much to the paper. Feel free to ask if you have any questions. The email in there isn't actually my email: http://soe.rutgers.edu/sites/default/files/gset/Paper08-Hung...

colinsidoti··on "Save a tree" with the WWF's new unprintable "green" PDF format
Who wants to start a company? I just registered WWFtoPDF.com and WWF2PDF.com
colinsidoti··on Is The Silicon Valley Talent Shortage Getting Worse?
This article seems to imply that "acqui-hires" are a tool to bring in great engineers, but I feel like Facebook and others are after great entrepreneurs.

Perhaps the final sentence should be changed to: "Now might be a good time to leave school and start a company."

colinsidoti··on Attn, flight-search startups: Priceline, Expedia say hotels are where it’s at
Room77 has been recruiting heavily at MIT and are "working to bring a unique twist to hotel search"

They seem to have quite the team: http://www.room77.com

colinsidoti··on Open for discussion: PDF as HTML-replacement
Why constrain ourselves to the proportions of physical paper if we're not using physical paper as our medium? The current suite of technologies is much more suited towards all viewing devices. Just in general, web technology has come a very, very long way in the past 5 years in terms of CSS, JS, and even Flash. We've nearly reached a point where web developers have agreed a standard method of development. PDF was not developed for interactive web development and all of their form features are noticeably afterthoughts. The list goes on and on, switching from HTML to PDF just doesn't make sense.
colinsidoti··on CarWoo (YC S09): Dispelling 3 myths about Y Combinator
I was biting my fingernails as I read your first paragraph...well played sir.
colinsidoti··on Low Hanging Fruit for Most Online Stores: Better Search Features
Yes, but perhaps larger forums with dedicated servers can handle it? If this is true, selling a Search Replacement for forum software could really be a viable business.
colinsidoti··on Ask HN: Palantir or Facebook?
Between your current two, I would say Facebook because it sounds like you'll enjoy yourself more there.

That said, you also say: "My dream is to one day create my own startup (possibly right out of college)"

In that case, I would recommend a funded startup with something on the order of 5 employees. I've never worked at a larger company so I can't bash them, but I could say my experience at a small company still in "startup mode" helped me tremendously with my own startup.

colinsidoti··on Low Hanging Fruit for Most Online Stores: Better Search Features
I had the same first instinct. Search is almost always an after thought unless it's the primary focus. If anyone wants a startup idea, the search feature on forums is something that people constantly suggest using, but generally provides awful results. Furthermore, a lot of forum owners restrict search usage for guests because it eats memory. If you make a replacement for vBulletin, phpBB, and Invision I wouldn't be surprised if you could sell it for $50+ to more active communities.
colinsidoti··on Ask HN: Learning PHP
Meh, vBulletin isn't going to let me get a link that works for everyone. If you have an account on SitePoint just search threads by e39m5 and sort in ascending order. Sorry about that.
colinsidoti··on Ask HN: Learning PHP
For me, it has always been best to learn by doing. Think of something you want to build and go for it. You'll certainly make mistakes but don't worry about it; the web is pretty forgiving on a small scale. When you need general help, try asking a question on SitePoint. There's StackOverflow too, but I feel like SitePoint has more a learning environment while StackOverflow is just a place to get answers.

With every project you complete, you'll discover new and better ways to do things. Just be open about asking questions and showing your code. If you ever find yourself thinking there's a better way to something, there probably is, so go ahead and make a thread on SitePoint.

To prove I'm not making all this up (assuming this link works), this is all of the threads I've made on SitePoint in ascending order: http://www.sitepoint.com/forums/search.php?searchid=4499370 . Added disclaimer: In October 2005 I was 14, so excuse any poor writing in those posts

colinsidoti··on Ask HN: When to learn AJAX?
AJAX, how it's commonly referred to now, is simply the process of loading content from an external page into a Javascript variable. Most of the time it's not even AJAX anymore, but rather AJAJ (Asynchronous Javascript and JSON). In terms of getting started there really isn't much to learn, especially if you have some experience with jQuery.

The big thing you need to remember is the A: Asynchronous. Especially if you're new to programming, this won't make any sense to you. As you use it you'll just get frustrated about why it works the way it does. It takes a bit of experience to learn to use it well, so give it some time. Remember these two key tips: 1. The code following your AJAX call should not be dependent on the content you are loading. Javascript will continue running line by line after the AJAX request is sent, NOT after the content has been loaded. If any code is dependent on the loaded content, it belongs in the return function. 2. The return function for an AJAX call only has the data from the page it loaded, it cannot* see the variables you defined before you made the request.

Other than that, just realize that the true power of AJAX comes from the data you're loading in. You can use it to create an <iframe> of sorts that simply loads pre-built HTML files into a div, but that's not all that exciting. If you use something like PHP to process and load data, you can start to make some very cool applications. If you're looking for a good learning project, I would recommend creating a simple "shoutbox" that works completely with AJAX, including periodic refreshes to check for new comments.

If you don't know what a shoutbox is: http://www.shoutmix.com/main/ Some jQuery functions to check out: .load(), .post(), .get(), .ajax()

*: A lot of times, your return function WILL be able to see variables you defined before the AJAX request because they ended up in the global scope. I'd recommend that you don't rely on this unless your making the variable global on purpose. Otherwise, there's a lot of potential for a debugging nightmare.

colinsidoti··on Ask HN: stupid startup idea, but it works?
If your startup works than it's good no matter what. I still consider Twitter stupid, but what do I know. Tons of people think Farmville is stupid, but Zynga is doing extremely well.

It might not help that you think your own idea is stupid, though.

colinsidoti··on Tell us your naughty stories
My high school had a work study program that was designed for students that weren't planning to attend college (IE: auto mechanic, electrician, cosmetologist). It allowed these students to get a job before they even graduated, and made their job search significantly easier. As a senior, I was the first student to take advantage of work study with the intention of going to college. It took many meetings with the principal and my teachers, but was worth working for a startup in NYC :).
colinsidoti··on Ask HN: Is a Doctorate Worth it?
No, at least not immediately. You can always go back to school, try and take a stab at work experience. My first real job was at a startup between my junior and senior year of high school. I loved it, and now I'm asking myself if my Bachelors is worth it.

Unless your pursuing something that you absolutely need the PhD for, don't worry about it for now. You might enjoy yourself more in industry.

← PreviousPage 6 of 7Next →