HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

colonCapitalDee

1,589 karma · joined July 10, 2019

submissionscomments
colonCapitalDee··on Fusion tech finds geothermal energy application
We spend about 3.5% of GDP on defense [1], and coincidentally about 3.5% on R&D [2]. People tend to wildly overestimate how large the modern US defense budget is. It's only around 13% of federal spending [3]!

[1] https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/MS.MIL.XPND.GD.ZS?locat... [2] https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/GB.XPD.RSDV.GD.ZS?locat... [3] https://federalbudgetinpictures.com/where-does-all-the-money...

colonCapitalDee··on Apollo Had Some Death Bets
It could be because the value of the policy changes due to changing circumstances, like switching career fields to a less dangerous job or getting a favorable medical diagnosis. Or regulatory arbitrage, perhaps Apollo can price life insurance policies more accurately because they don't have to comply with the same regulations insurance companies do.
colonCapitalDee··on Ask HN: How do you define an "AI engineer"?
I don't
colonCapitalDee··on Why are kids being forced to eat lunch in silence?
Man, taking Spanish in high school blew my mind. I'm a native English speaker with excellent grammar (I missed one question on the reading and writing section of the SAT), but it's all subconscious. I just go with what sounds right when I read aloud in my head, and it's almost always correct. When we started learning about conjugating verbs in Spanish class I was like, we do this in English? I had never thought about it before. I still haven't thought about it, I have no idea what tenses we have in English. But I can speak and write it just fine! Brains are pretty crazy.
colonCapitalDee··on House passes bill to force TikTok sale from Chinese owner or ban the app
You're making some extremely strong claims, with minimal evidence. I don't deny that the CIA can be pretty nasty to 2nd and 3rd world governments, but claiming the US is a "colonial overlord" over our European allies is just not true. The first priority of our European allies is domestic politics; just like us, everyone wants to get re-elected. Sometimes domestic politics push countries towards the US, sometimes they pull them away. Countries like Hungary and Turkey make diplomatic trouble for the US, and we don't launch coups against them. The US would love it if Germany built up a decent military, but Germany isn't because the political will just isn't there. Between the 60s and the 90s, France literally left NATO. Europe in general has been extremely slow to scale up artillery production to support Ukraine (the US has been better, although but not by much); if the US had as much power over Europe as you think we do, we would have just told Europe to up production and they would have. But this did not happen.
colonCapitalDee··on 100 Years of Rent Control in Sweden
Ever wondered why the population of Tokyo keeps going up? Hint: it's because of the apartments

> In the past half century, by investing in transit and allowing development, the city has added more housing units than the total number of units in New York City. It has remained affordable by becoming the world’s largest city. It has become the world’s largest city by remaining affordable.

> Those who want to live in Tokyo generally can afford to do so. There is little homelessness here. The city remains economically diverse, preserving broad access to urban amenities and opportunities. And because rent consumes a smaller share of income, people have more money for other things — or they can get by on smaller salaries — which helps to preserve the city’s vibrant fabric of small restaurants, businesses and craft workshops.

https://archive.is/pLedf

colonCapitalDee··on Journalist casualties in the Israel-Gaza war
This a common misunderstanding of the international laws of war, and international law in general.

In our personal lives the government can compel us to follow the law with the threat of overwhelming force; if I break the law I will be arrested, and regardless of how much I fight back I will not be able to stop it. Laws in our everyday lives are like commands from a parent to a child; the government, as the parent, can and will compel the child's obedience.

International law is different. If a state breaks international law, there is no entity willing or capable of using overwhelming force to compel obedience. States have armies and some have nuclear weapons; the amount of force required to compel a state to behave a certain way is huge, and generating that force is extremely costly. When states break international law there are consequences, but at the end of the day violence is generally not on the table.

Effective international law is a balancing act. An international standard of warfare that placed extremely strict standards on when it was permissible to kill civilians would make fighting a war significantly harder. No state would obey such a law because winning the war is the absolute highest priority, making the law worthless. Instead, laws of war try to outlaw actions that don't affect the ability of a country to win a war. No chemical or biological weapons (high explosives are more effective), humane treatment of prisoners (discourages the enemy fighting to the death), and no killing civilians unless in the pursuit of a military objective (if it's not in pursuit of a military objective, then it's a waste of resources). The goal of the laws of war is to prevent unnecessary violence, not prevent violence altogether. It's a case of "perfect is the enemy of good."

colonCapitalDee··on Intuitive Machines successfully lands on the Moon
That's to be expected, a dollar in India goes much further than a dollar in the US. https://data.oecd.org/conversion/purchasing-power-parities-p... says a dollar in India can buy you about 23 times as much stuff as that same dollar could in the US, although I'd expect that number to drop significantly for highly technical projects like a moon landing.
colonCapitalDee··on Wealth inequality is root cause of all current economic woes. Interview. [video]
The world is not zero sum! The average human is better off now then they were any number of decades ago, and things have improved for those on the bottom even more. 38% of the world lived in extreme poverty in 1990, by 2019 that number was down to 9%. In that same time frame access to basic sanitation increased from 32% to 56%, life expectancy increased from 64 years to 71 years, and so on with various of quality of life statistics.

Designing an economic system for "fairness" is a horrible idea. I would rather live in an economic system with high inequality, high standards of living, and high social mobility, than in a system with low inequality, low standards of living, and low social mobility. Inequality is bad in the same way that debt or medicine is bad: the danger is in the dose. A society with extreme inequality is probably screwed, but a society with moderate inequality is not necessarily worse off than a society with low inequality.

Wealth taxes have been tried many times, they don't work very well.

> In the natural world hoarding works in the opposite way. A stash of nuts doesn't magically grow. Quite the opposite. Real effort has to be expended to preserve the stash.

So you would prefer to spend your time roaming the forest in proletariat ecstasy looking for more nuts, rather than using the nuts to plant some trees?

colonCapitalDee··on 3M knew its chemicals were harmful decades ago, but didn't tell the public
That's barbaric. White collar crime is a policy choice. Economies require a certain amount of slack in order to function. If an economy had a zero tolerance policy for white collar crime than nothing would ever get done, because differentiating between fraud, incompetence, and bad luck is extremely difficult in all but the most straightforward of cases. If we wanted to de-incentivize white collar crime we have so many options that are (a) more humane, (b) more effective, and (c) less controversial. We could start prosecuting more cases of fraud, or improve regulations, or increase incentives for whisteblowing, or reform corporate governance, or any of a million other ideas.
colonCapitalDee··on A study of Google's code review tooling (Critique)
Yes, and it also makes it much easier for random people to break your code. It's a trade-off
colonCapitalDee··on Show HN: Dobb·E – towards home robots with an open-source platform
Spare us the conspiracy theories. Washing machines were invented because they're convenient, not because of "political propaganda". And we've already "centralized" clothes washing, it's called a laundromat.
colonCapitalDee··on Matt Levine's Money Stuff: Who Controls OpenAI
https://archive.is/SLMXp
colonCapitalDee··on Ivan Illich’s radical critique of modern certitudes (2021)
The vast majority of people alive centuries ago were subsistence farmers. They were malnourished, overworked, underpaid, illiterate, had virtually no access to effective healthcare, and had no civil rights. Also, no color TV. By virtually any measure the quality of life in modern society globally is orders of magnitude better than it was centuries ago.
colonCapitalDee··on Quadcopters can now visually track targets more effectively
The only reason chemical and biological weapons aren't used in warfare is because they just aren't very useful. An equivalent amount of high explosives is more lethal, easier to deliver, easier to transport and store, and less dangerous to your own troops. Which sucks, because it implies that arms control measures for landmines, cluster munitions, autonomous drones, and nuclear weapons are probably doomed to failure.

https://acoup.blog/2020/03/20/collections-why-dont-we-use-ch...

colonCapitalDee··on SpaceX Starship Super Heavy Project at the Boca Chica Launch Site
GPS has generated over $1.4 trillion in value in the US alone since it was opened up to the public in the 80's [1]. Millions of people use satellite TV and radio. Commercial imaging satellites are used for mapping, weather forecasting, wildfire detection, and scientific research. SpaceX's own Starlink system has revolutionized satellite internet for regions too remote or underdeveloped to be served by traditional internet providers. And who knows what we'll be doing in 50 years! Imagine if we are able to use rockets for point-to-point travel on Earth, or we figure out how to mine asteroids, or if the economics of space-based manufacturing work out.

Also, abusing environmental regulation to set space policy is just straight up a bad idea. It's fine if you think we shouldn't be investing in space, but don't try and force that belief on the rest of us in an undemocratic manner. It's very NIMBY-esque

[1] https://www.space.commerce.gov/doc-study-on-economic-benefit...

colonCapitalDee··on Amazon begins testing Agility's Digit robot for warehouse work
I was using "modern" to refer to "right now", and I think I'm correct that if civilization collapsed tomorrow we would go back to being subsistence farmers, not hunter gatherers, because we have access to all sorts of plants that are amenable to being farmed. But you're right, the phrase "modern humans" does have a specific meaning, and I did not use it correctly.
colonCapitalDee··on It's easy to screw up on breaking news but you have to admit when you do
Yes, bombing Ahli Arab hospital is an atrocity and a war crime. You know it, I know it, Israel knows it, and Hamas knows it. Hamas doesn't have a lot of reasons to intentionally blow up a Palestinian hospital, beyond maybe trying to stage a false flag attack. Israel has more reasons; Israel could have been targeting weapons stored in the hospital or a high value target. But even if Israel did have intelligence that made them think there was something worth striking in Ahli Arab, the political repercussions of striking a hospital would be so severe that I doubt they would pull the trigger.

The commenter you quoted was likely thinking something along the lines of "neither side has a strong motive to intentionally bomb Ahli Arab, so the most likely reason for the bombing is an accidental strike. Assuming that the accident isn't part of a trend of accidents, the unfortunate reality of war is that accidents happen on all sides. Thus, it doesn't really matter if it was an Israeli accident or a Hamas accident."

Should we investigate and determine if the strike really was an accident? Yes, of course. But we can also predict that the result of that investigation will be "it was an accident", and start to make preliminary conclusions predicated on that.

colonCapitalDee··on Amazon begins testing Agility's Digit robot for warehouse work
Why do we work? Because the natural state of the modern human is subsistence farming. Anything more than that (like groceries, clothes, health care, beds, running water, electricity, cable tv, magazines, restaurants, etc) requires capital and organized labor. A job is nothing more than performing labor, using capital, in concert with other workers.
colonCapitalDee··on Microsoft SEC 8-K: IRS is seeking an additional tax payment of $29B
I disagree. Corporate taxes are a drag on the economy, and maximizing economic performance is probably the single most effective thing we can do to improve quality of life for everyone long term.

As an example, here's self-reported life satisfaction vs GDP per capita: https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_pr.... Similar graphs exist for life expectancy, years of education, calorie consumption, literacy rates, and so on.

If we want to increase government revenues we should focus on efficient taxes that minimize economic disruption.

colonCapitalDee··on LLMs can't self-correct in reasoning tasks, DeepMind study finds
> A lot of people think in concepts without words at all in many scenarios.

Many scenarios, not all scenarios.

colonCapitalDee··on Stop Arguing over Elite Schools. Just Make Public Colleges Free
We spend about twice as much money on education as we do on the military. Education spending is at 6% of GDP (https://nces.ed.gov/programs/coe/indicator/cmd/education-exp...), military spending is at 2.8%.
colonCapitalDee··on Makefile Tutorial
I saw this further down in the thread: https://github.com/casey/just

Looks like a version of make optimized for running commands instead of builds.

colonCapitalDee··on Show HN: Learn piano without sheet music
See https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e2YF34XlfzU
colonCapitalDee··on A New Age of Magic
I think the source of LLM magic is not the compute, but instead written human knowledge. The LLM special sauce--what makes an LLM distinct from a compiler or a web server or a linter--is training on human generated input data. In fantasy novels a common trope is that humans generate magic (like a tree generates oxygen) which diffuses into the world to be used fuel for spells. Similarly, written knowledge is created by all of us in the course of our day to day lives, and is omnipresent in modern society. It fits!
colonCapitalDee··on Critical ignoring as a core competence for digital citizens (2022)
Another commenter said that the difference between truth and propaganda is what you believe the truth is.

- Would I like food to generally be healthier and contain less processed sugars? Yes. Do I think that the government should regulate food to be that way? Not necessarily. I won't claim something ridiculous like "regulating food is a violation of the nth amendment!", but I'm generally skeptical of government regulation without a clear and compelling case for why it's necessary. While the obesity epidemic is a serious issue, I'm not convinced that regulating food is the way to solve it. I guess my skepticism towards regulation comes at least partially from cultural influence, but that doesn't mean that it's wrong.

- You can absolutely experience freedom without a car, but the ability a car gives you to just drive anywhere (where there's a road) is unmatched.

- Customary/metric interop is the real issue, but the thing is most Americans don't interact with the metric system at all. Thus, for most people switching to metric is a lot of work (you gotta replace rulers and tape measures and learn to think in km and km/hr) for zero gain. We really should have just gone all in metric in the 1800s, at this point we're stuck with customary units :(

- I've never heard someone describe paid sick leave as communist, but it doesn't surprise me that people do. Totally agree on this one

colonCapitalDee··on I can tolerate anything except the outgroup (2014)
Sure, in the immediate aftermath of colonization colonial SA Afrikaners and Zulu were about as different as you can get. But then they shared (for some definition of "shared") the same plot of land for literally hundreds of years
colonCapitalDee··on I can tolerate anything except the outgroup (2014)
That resolves the paradox of tolerance for you, but not for everyone else. What happens when you think that I'm being intolerant, but I disagree? Back to being a paradox.
colonCapitalDee··on New York Is Full. And it’s the housing market’s fault
> You can see residential luxury high-rises where most of lights on every floor are off at night. Nobody is living in them.

Most people turn their lights off at night?

colonCapitalDee··on Blizzard’s bringing its PC games to Steam, starting with Overwatch 2
Get good. Seriously. At no point in OW2 have Widow, Tracer, or Hanzo been bad. People win with those heroes in every ELO from bronze to Top 500. Small nerfs don't matter, if you hit your shots you'll win
← PreviousPage 5 of 8Next →