HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

colonCapitalDee

1,589 karma · joined July 10, 2019

submissionscomments
colonCapitalDee··on Blizzard’s bringing its PC games to Steam, starting with Overwatch 2
Overwatch is an objectively better game now than it was in 2019, and it's not even close. You are wrong, and I find it hilarious that you want a "deep, thoughtful apology".

Role lock and 5v5 have dramatically improved the health of the game. They've made matches more even, lessened toxicity, improved queue times, improved player experience, improved game balance, and made the game more dynamic. There are definitely drawbacks: tank synergies like Reinhardt/Zarya or Winston/Dva were fun, and having the option to play triple damage or GOATS or whatever was cool. But the tradeoff is so overwhelmingly positive that it kind of blows my mind that people want to go back to 2019 Overwatch.

colonCapitalDee··on Threads: The BBC drama which affected a generation of viewers
Painfully naive.

WW2 was an existential war. The Allied powers had agreed that the only acceptable end to the war was unconditional surrender by the Axis. Combatants mobilized their entire societies to fight -- the US was spending about 40% of GDP on the military in 1945. The nuclear bomb had never been used before, so the nuclear taboo did not exist. Allied air forces had been pounding Axis population centers with conventional bombs for years, killing millions. The American invasion of Okinawa caused the deaths of approx 100,000 Japanese troops, 20,000 Americans, and 150,000 Okinawan civilians. American military planners thought that an invasion of the Japanese home islands would have similar casualty exchange ratios as Okinawa, which would leave hundreds of thousands of American troops dead, millions of Japanese troops dead, and millions of Japanese civilians dead.

There were scant alternatives to the bomb. The war had to end fast, the American people demanded nothing less. Wearing down the Japanese with continued strategic bombing, a naval blockade, and the Soviet invasion of Japanese held areas on the mainland would be slow, uncertain, and cause many more deaths than the atomic bombs did. The Japanese willingness to surrender is hotly debated, so all I'll say is this: the Americans had observed constant Japanese fanaticism over the course of the war. Japanese soldiers would pretend to surrender while they clutched grenades to their chests, the surrender of Japanese units larger than platoons was nearly unheard of, and the Japanese population was basically brainwashed. A common saying on the island was "victory, or a hundred million dead souls".

So given all that context -- existential war, lack of a nuclear taboo, normalization of strategic bombing, lack of belief in the Japanese will to surrender, and political pressure to end the war quickly -- dropping the bomb was inevitable. It was horrible, unfathomably cruel, and ended the innocent lives of blameless men, women, and children. It wasn't nice, fair, or honorable. But there was no better option, so we did it.

colonCapitalDee··on Once hailed for decriminalizing drugs, Portugal is now having doubts
I'm sorry, but what? Meth is not an "energy drink". Meth is a highly addictive substance, both physiologically and psychologically. Its use destroys the human body and mind. Meth is too dangerous to be used casually, in the same way that Russian Roulette is too dangerous to be played at board game night.
colonCapitalDee··on News is bad for you – and giving up reading it will make you happier (2013)
I read the news every day without stressing out about it, and I did not have to go to therapy or whatever to be able to do so. I can't help but think that finding the news stressful is irrational. In the grand scheme of human suffering mainstream news is table stakes. Read about what life is like in North Korea, Afghanistan, Venezuela, or South Africa. When reading an article about US healthcare, think about what healthcare options are available to mothers in sub-Saharan Africa. When reading about the ending of Affirmative Action, remember that 70% of urban Chinese students are admitted to college, compared to only 5% of rural ones.

This isn't to say that finding the news stressful is some sort of moral failing. It's irrational, but humans are irrational. If reading the news stresses you out, then sure, don't read the news.

colonCapitalDee··on News is bad for you – and giving up reading it will make you happier (2013)
> One sad casualty of modern times is the weekly news magazine. The slower pace and longer deadlines meant they were much better at keeping a regular person informed without all the noise of daily updates. They were also more accurate than daily news, since they weren't as rushed they could do better fact checking and research.

The Economist is still going strong. It's my primary news source for exactly these reasons

colonCapitalDee··on A profit-price spiral in Germany
Not a strawman. Direct quote from the parent: "Yes, a lot of people who bought expensive properties may forget about any returns, there could be some margin calls and banking system won’t be happy."
colonCapitalDee··on The impact of the ‘long peace’ on modern military capabilities
The full quote is "they have real security threats from revanchist powers (Israel, Taiwan, Poland, Finland, Ukraine, etc.)". The listed countries aren't revanchist powers, they're under threat from revanchist powers.
colonCapitalDee··on The case for South Korean membership in the G7
The G7 became the G8 when Russia was added in 1997, then went back to being the G7 in 2014 when Russia was expelled for annexing Crimea.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/G8

colonCapitalDee··on U.S. Rep. Angie Craig drops college requirement for staffers
I've seen this in the startup ecosystem; it's a prestige game. When I was applying to jobs last year I would see startups brag on their websites about how many MIT, Harvard, Berkeley, etc grads they had. The most egregious was a startup that had a "select your school" dropdown that was basically the US News top 20 CS schools followed by "other"
colonCapitalDee··on Shell admits 1.5C climate goal means immediate end to fossil fuel growth
Not sure why this is getting downvoted? He's right. The odds that global warming will stay below 1.5C are miniscule. I guess there may be PR benefits in pushing 1.5C because it's ambitious (shoot for the moon and land among the stars), but those PR benefits will be offset by the fact that anyone who does the tiniest bit of research will realize that it's bullshit! Not to mention that using 1.5C as a goal without lying is difficult.

"If we do <x> we'll be able to stay under 1.5C" <- lie

"If we don't do <y> we won't be able to stay under 1.5C" <- possibly true, but deceptive

"Our goal is to keep global warming under 1.5C" <- lie, a goal is by definition achievable and anyone who's giving statements on climate change knows that 1.5C is not achievable

colonCapitalDee··on Navigating the world when your senses conjure up phenomena others can’t perceive
That sucks.

> I can put any flavoring like vanilla or strawberry in the milk and it'll be perfectly fine.

Could you use this to train yourself to taste milk normally again?

colonCapitalDee··on Gov. Inslee signs bill to remove death penalty from Washington state law
> Those 4% would still spend their lives in prison, and prison is a terrible place to be.

You're missing the point. If someone is incarcerated and later found to be innocent, they can be released. If someone is executed and later found to be innocent, nothing can be done.

colonCapitalDee··on 'Algebra for none' fails in San Francisco
"Teacher! Will we ever use any of this algebra?"

"You won't, but one of the smart kids might." [1]

Dumb kids can turn into smart kids, so they need math too.

[1] https://www.smbc-comics.com/comic/why-i-couldn39t-be-a-math-...

colonCapitalDee··on 'Algebra for none' fails in San Francisco
> But as long as they have these outlets where they can just educate their own kids and leave everyone else behind, they will.

Education is a collective action problem. Parents care more about their own child's education than the education of other children. This should not be surprising, and it cannot be changed.

colonCapitalDee··on Lessons from America’s astonishing economic record
An alternative take would be that China only saw prosperity after partially adopting Western economic values. Additionally, Chinese economic development and Western economic development occurred in vastly different contexts. China had access to Western imports to jump start their industrialization and access to the Western scientific and policy know-how needed to build an advanced economy. The West had to figure things out as they went along. This is obviously a broad generalization, I just want to make the point that China is definitely not a slam dunk counterexample
colonCapitalDee··on Ageing studies in five animals suggests how to reverse decline
I don't think about those things every time I drive, but I have given it some serious thought. I choose to drive anyway.
colonCapitalDee··on Yann LeCun and Andrew Ng: Why the 6-Month AI Pause Is a Bad Idea [video]
> Well there's quite a lot here that's just flat wrong, but you get the gist of some of it.

If you're going to be condescending the least you could do is be correct.

> Computers can't pass turing tests because the answer is divergent, or in other words has multiple possible answers.

This is wrong. Computers can absolutely pass Turing tests; an obvious example is ChatGPT. Not sure what you mean by divergent, to my knowledge it's not a technical term in this context. Given that you use it as an explanation for an obviously false statement I'm not going to even try and interpret it.

I've seen you arguing in with other people this thread. Instead of claiming that others have no credibility you should instead examine your own. FYI, probabilistic Turing machines and Turing machines are the same in the same way that Javascript and Java are the same.

colonCapitalDee··on My diatribe against “skeptics” (2016)
Here's a word you should know (if you're not familiar with it already): contingent. The more commonly used definition is "dependent on", as in "my grade is contingent on good study habits", but it can also mean "subject to chance", as in "the number of deaths in the Romanian Revolution was contingent."
colonCapitalDee··on Yann LeCun and Andrew Ng: Why the 6-Month AI Pause Is a Bad Idea [video]
I think there is. As a thought experiment, imagine an alien supercomputer with nigh infinite RAM. Alien programmers have used this computer to create a chatbot using a simple decision tree. Because the computer has so much RAM, this chatbot's decision tree is comprehensive enough for the chatbot to masquerade as a human. This chatbot could pass a Turing test with ease, and yet its "brain" is nothing more than a series of if statements.
colonCapitalDee··on I’m a doctor: Here’s what I found when I asked ChatGPT to diagnose my patients
"A computer can store and operate on data"

"That's really downplaying things. My computer can play cat videos"

colonCapitalDee··on Defamed by ChatGPT
Would you describe a filesystem that "only" preserved 80% of files as reliable? Reliability is relative, one of the defining features of a newspaper is correctness, so only a small amount of inaccuracy is required to make a newspaper be extremely unreliable.

I would describe a 0% accurate newspaper by reading it and using appropriate descriptors. Perhaps it is satirical news, a poem, propaganda, gibberish, or simply a newspaper that is never correct.

colonCapitalDee··on I’m a doctor: Here’s what I found when I asked ChatGPT to diagnose my patients
ChatGPT's heuristic may lead it to emit a sequence of words that suggest to English speakers that they should provide clarification, but ChatGPT is congenitally incapable of determining that answering a question requires more information that was provided in the prompt and that clarification is needed. Rephrased, ChatGPT can ask for clarification, but only as a side effect of satisfying it's heuristic.
colonCapitalDee··on Janet for Mortals
You aren't understanding Janet. (bottles i) invokes the bottles function with parameter i, so the lyric is "99 bottles of beer on the wall".
colonCapitalDee··on Understanding ChatGPT
So you're saying that LLMs are sentient because we can't prove that anything or anyone is sentient?
colonCapitalDee··on Jaron Lanier on the danger of AI
Climate change is horrible and will change life on Earth for the worst for all forms of life, including humans. But given the choice between (a) no industrial revolution and no climate change, and (b) industrial revolution and climate change, I'm picking (b) every time and it isn't even close.
colonCapitalDee··on The Cornell University Witchcraft Collection
"I'm just using quotation marks to strawman your argument. Just being rhetorically dishonest!"
colonCapitalDee··on Robots have been about to take all the jobs for 100 years
> WW1 was primarily a result of european and american societies having excess population to "thin out".

No. Some actual reasons for WW1: Franco-German animosity, the famous web of alliances, advances in weapon technology and accompanying arms races, nationalism, and cold geopolitical calculus (Germany thought their power relative to the other Great Powers would decline in the future).

colonCapitalDee··on Build full “product skills” and you'll probably be fine
High-level decision makers like founders and C-suite execs will be the last roles automated away. ChatGPT is effectively a personal assistant that works fast and works cheap. That's a game changer because suddenly peons like you and me get our own personal assistants, but for high-level decision makers it's just an incremental improvement over what they already have.
colonCapitalDee··on Apple delays bonuses for some divisions as it scrutinizes costs
My org at FAANG+ has had hiring frozen for a while, and while we're getting interns we're getting much fewer than in previous years.
colonCapitalDee··on Repeat yourself, do more than one thing, and rewrite everything (2018)
Not the person you originally asked, but I have the same rewriting habit.

Automated tests are essential for rewriting code. If I want to rewrite untested code I either add tests or don't rewrite it. The rewritten code also needs to be tested.

Whenever possible, split up big, untestable rewrites into a series of smaller, testable rewrites. Let's say I want to rewrite component A with subcomponents B and C to use some new library Foo. I might first rewrite B to use Foo, then rewrite A (and A's tests!) to work with rewritten B. Then I rewrite C to use Foo, then rewrite A again to work with rewritten C. Then I finally go rewrite A to use Foo. This is more coding then doing the whole thing in one go (I rewrote A 3 times!), but it's a net time saver because when I make a mistake I can quickly find and fix it.

When I'm on the clock I rewrite code for practical reasons (maybe the current structure of the code can't support some new requirement, or technical debt has gotten high enough to make maintenance difficult, or whatever). This is rare-ish. Rewriting code, especially production code, is risky and time consuming and just generally not worth it.

Most of the time when I rewrite code I'm rewriting my own code, and I'm doing it for personal reasons. I like good code, I like reading it and I like writing it. To me code has aesthetic qualities, code can be beautiful and elegant. It's also educational. Imagine a writer that never edits their work; they're probably not a very good writer. It's also fun! I'm already familiar with the problem domain, so I can devote my entire focus to solving the problem instead of splitting my attention between solving the problem and figuring out wtf is going on.

← PreviousPage 6 of 8Next →