HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

conartist6

2,741 karma · joined November 2, 2021

https://github.com/conartist6 https://github.com/bablr-lang
submissionscomments
conartist6··on No AI, 52 min. Build all Linux Files utils in C by Hand [video]
I can, but I can also find problems with all the analogies offered by AI apologists.

To me it's not the human in the loop that's weak, it's programming tools that fail to create and utilize bandwidth in the human/computer interaction cycle. Look at how much raw UX bandwidth people can show off when they're pushed to the limits! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ki9EeaF4MLI

I just think the people selling the idea that AI will outstrip people's abilities to express themselves haven't actually considered what the practical constrictions on self-expression are and whether or not the limits we experience in practice are really the limits of human expressive capability.

If we're at the limits of expressive capability, the only improvements will come from replacing humans. If not, we may be able to win quite a lot of ground back just by building better instruments. ...that's why I'm working on replacing git

conartist6··on No AI, 52 min. Build all Linux Files utils in C by Hand [video]
Uh huh.

Like writing! Everyone knows that after the printing press, nobody needed to know how to read or write anymore

conartist6··on A tiny Pacific country rolls out universal basic income
McDonalds isn't critical to the economy staying running like trucking is.
conartist6··on The AI cost of JavaScript frameworks
That JS supports await isn't nearly as much a problem as the fact that it defensively defers execution any time it encounters one.

This hurts most badly for iterators.

Files are usually read from disks in chunks of 64K bytes. If you present the data as an async byte iterator you'll get 65,534 defensive deferrals, and one actual wait.

If you have ten layers of transformation it will be 655,350 defensive deferrals and 10 real waits.

These defensive deferrals aren't so expensive in terms of CPU time, but they ARE very expensive in terms of wall clock time. All other work must be halted so the event loop code can run. Eventually synthetic deferrals dominate the wall clock cost of running the program. This isn't hypothetical either. Here's someone trying to build steam parsing on Node and finding that it's too slow to be useful: https://github.com/nodejs/node/issues/31979

The solution is stream iterators. They are sync when they can be and async when they must be: https://docs.bablr.org/architecture/spacetime

conartist6··on A tiny Pacific country rolls out universal basic income
That's just unrealistic. They'll strike and shut down all shipping before they just roll over
conartist6··on The AI cost of JavaScript frameworks
I mean maybe I'm too grumpy, but never in my life did I think I'd have to fight against a strong contingent of people who really don't see the value of abstraction. Taking crazy pills must feel like this.
conartist6··on Retired professor arrested for blocking delivery robot. Will do it again
I don't think there's anything dishonest about being in the business of making tools. I am in that business. ...but I can only afford to fund that R&D because I first worked as the software equivalent of a plumber for many years.

Without the ability to own the things I build I never would have been motivated to build them, and without a career ladder I couldn't have worked my way up until I had the funds (and experience) needed to start my own venture.

conartist6··on Retired professor arrested for blocking delivery robot. Will do it again
What I mean by the term is creating value directly and in response to immediate needs. E.g. "your sink is broken > your sink is fixed" or "here is your burrito" or, ya know, taking care of kids and the elderly. It's stuff that needs no R&D, but also still has to be done for society to work.
conartist6··on Retired professor arrested for blocking delivery robot. Will do it again
Just out of curiosity, can anyone report on how the robots act in terms of right of way? Lets say the sidewalk narrows around an obstacle like a tree or trash can or lime scooter or whatever. If the robot approaches the constriction at the same time as an elderly pedestrian, how does it behave? Will it pause instead of entering? Will it back up a bit when a human would do so to be polite? Will it crowd in someone walking with a cane? In short, what are these things like to be around?
conartist6··on Retired professor arrested for blocking delivery robot. Will do it again
Yes. But when you act in protest, the goal is usually to gain attention.

Now the story is that the police came and protected an innocent robot by chaining up an old woman. That sure makes them seem like misanthropes.

conartist6··on Retired professor arrested for blocking delivery robot. Will do it again
I don't think it's that awful that there be honest labor. There is a great deal of creativity that is not possible without self-sufficiency: https://www.honest-broker.com/p/the-blue-collar-jobs-of-phil...
conartist6··on Why Anthropic's filing crushed tech stocks
"The shift in politics is even starker. In the 2010s and early 2020s, big tech was well-liked by most people. But AI is absolutely loathed by the public. These companies have never faced real public dissatisfaction, they all imagine themselves to be the good guys, with the credibility of having created magical search engines and smartphones. But that era is gone. They are now akin to the bankers on Wall Street in 2008, and politicians are winning elections by saying they hate AI as much as the voters do."

Yeah I see this too. That we're not innovating any more also doesn't help make our industry look good

conartist6··on Some Thing is Happening A note from the AI companies
I don't think this point is well stated. We have things like ECC to help with math being imperfect so that feels solvable. The problem with LLMs is much more subtle. They induce cognitive errors in humans. I'm doing it right now I'm saying "them" like they have individual identities, but they do not.

If you know they're just mirrors, then you know that looking in the mirror isn't the same as exploring the world.

It turns out, though, that many people can be trapped in a hall of mirrors. They will happily buy a condom for their brain.

conartist6··on Wall Street closes sharply lower as AI cash burn fears spark tech selloff
I liquidated my retirement yesterday.

We all know the market is too good to be true.

We all know we created a great hollowness where once was our indomitable spirit. When a tree has died but still stands, what's left is the fall.

To the industry I once knew and loved: may the fall be swift, and may you be reborn from the ruins

conartist6··on AI isn't replacing SREs, it's deskilling them
The amount of trust AI has set on fire is incredible.

Business and people that I once though competent I trust no longer.

I'm watching leaders I thought had vision throw the future away for the shortest-term gains.

What have we become?

conartist6··on Emacs Turns 50
I wonder what you'll think of Paneditor.

It's like "what if the web browser became emacs".

I want to build it because it would put an experience with the level of power described so thoroughly here onto every device simultaneously. I think it would be an incredible boon for programming literacy.

At the same time we could make programming feel natural to do on touchscreen devices, and in languages other than English. Combined with just having a place to play and learn (a reason to write little programs) my hope is that such a tool could inspire a new generation of programmers who previously were locked out

conartist6··on "No human at the helm": Delaware plan would let AI agents run businesses
Who is liable
conartist6··on Ghostty 1.4
I am building what you speak of!
conartist6··on Kentucky man becomes the first humanist granted religious exemption from AI
You're saying there's nothing left to invent. I think that explains a lot of the complacency around considering AI to be the last ever frontier for progress. I obviously don't agree. I've gone looking into "why don't we have better version control" and the answer is definitely not that we already have all we could want.
conartist6··on Kentucky man becomes the first humanist granted religious exemption from AI
It is progressing, yes, but it subsumed the productivity of humans.

Where before humans learned and built better tools, now you keep paying forever to get re-trained models. What makes it a regressive feedback loop is that the people who used to learn and push the frontier are now using AI to repackage others' work as their own. Eventually what will be left to train on but copies of copies of copies?

conartist6··on Kentucky man becomes the first humanist granted religious exemption from AI
Aren't the AI users the Amish here?

They've stopped technological progress. I tell you since AI started taking over, my experience is that nearly all forward progress (in software at least) has come to a halt. We've been standing in place, maybe sliding backwards a bit.

Here's the thing about AI: intelligence isn't a new thing, and it isn't a tool. The Amish can tell you that having a brain doesn't meant that you don't need a plow. In some ways they're much smarter than the AI crowd, all of who loudly keep insisting that brains will make plows and tractors and combine harvesters obsolete. You're so convinced that intelligence is the ultimate replacement for tools that you've stopped climbing the tech tree of tools...

It's like the tech industry itself no longer believes in technology.

conartist6··on Software may be getting worse, but it used to be horrible
What????

If it's getting worse, one can logically deduce that it used to be better

If it used to be better, why are you saying it used to be much worse? You cannot have it both ways unless AI already fried your brain.

...and if we are actually heading the wrong direction, why does it matter that we haven't regressed fully quite yet. AI is pushing us towards regressing fully. It's only a few miserable humans ranting about wanting a future filled with hope

conartist6··on Type Server Protocol
"without adding or losing meaning" sounds impossible for spoken language.
conartist6··on The Git Forge for Agent-Human Collaboration
Sure seems like a kludge to me.

But it's not like I've ever heard an AI user talk about why.

You would have to care about human user experience to care that it is fundamentally broken.

conartist6··on The Git Forge for Agent-Human Collaboration
Spoken like a true AI zombie. 10/10 at reciting the official propaganda. But do you have any actual hard-won knowledge? Are you unique? Individual? Again I put this question: have you ANY idea what you BELIEVE???
conartist6··on Three new discoveries in mathematics, computer science, and physics
Go fuck yourselves
conartist6··on The Git Forge for Agent-Human Collaboration
"We founded Entire on a single belief, human developers no longer write most of the code."

This isn't a belief. What do you actually believe about the future of software?

Let me put it this way. The premise of agents is that some combination of programming languages and programming tools suck so incredibly much that humans don't want to use them.

You're effectively betting that this problem can never be fixed. AI is a layer of kludges on top of the problem of bad programming tools. Haven't you ultimately made a rather cynical bet?

conartist6··on I refuse to accept a censored Internet. Join Me at FOSDEM 27
Wow that's fucking dark.

Does the tech industry still even see technology as a source for good in the world, or do we now see ourselves as the dictators' keys to power.

What future do we have if we have become totally cynical and Amoral?

conartist6··on The Goose Programming Language
Amen. Not to mention these people usually want others to laud them for creating a world they can't bring themselves to actually live in.

If you believe you are making something worth other people's time, you should ALSO believe you are making something worthy of your own time.

conartist6··on We should be more ambitious with the software we build
Ah yes, only the customers lose
← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →