HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

concerndc1tizen

321 karma · joined July 25, 2024

submissionscomments
concerndc1tizen··on Bluesky's science takeover: 70% of Nature poll respondents use platform
The more you suppress normal people, the more people you will add to your opposition.

But perhaps the right wing knows that.

Maybe they're adding fuel to the fire by supporting extremist LGBT people.

Wouldn't that be something!

concerndc1tizen··on Bluesky's science takeover: 70% of Nature poll respondents use platform
Bulldozed: flagged, downvoted, villified, sidetracked, strawmanned, ad hominem, getting cancelled.

They often use tactics like brigading, dogpiling, astroturfing.

concerndc1tizen··on We Need to Talk About Docker Hub
Dude,

I'd argue that the people in these comments are suffering from cognitive dissonance.

I see people presenting two beliefs:

1) enterprises should be free to offer the services they want, to who they want

2) consumers have the right to bully enterprises that don't offer what they want

And that's fine. People can have different politics.

But IIUC, these two beliefs are mutually exclusive.

Dictionary for the illiterate:

- Bully: when you use peer pressure, through public exposure, to induce negative consequences, as a political strategy, for furthering an agenda, and getting the victim to align with your interests.

concerndc1tizen··on We Need to Talk About Docker Hub
> If you would like a discussion about ensuring abstractions over the services you use

Yes, please.

I'd love to hear your ideas, and I agree that we still need to figure things out, particularly how to make open source self-sustaining.

concerndc1tizen··on We Need to Talk About Docker Hub
> if you genuinely would like a discussion about the pitfalls of the funding models of open source

That is absolutely what I want, and I appreciate your contribution to the debate.

> you're forced to use words like "smear", "parasite"

I'm just trying to use fewer words, because people's attention spans are really short these days, which naturally requires the words to have more dense and intense meaning.

> it's so much easier to lambast someone

It's not easy, it's hard. People are refusing to accept that corporations are not your friends. Have you ever tried criticizing Apple?

My critique is specifically that the article:

1) presumes that Docker Hub should provide the service, despite clearly not responding to their application for free service.

2) then uses an article that invites peer pressure onto the company to get what they want.

Instead, I argue that it would be healthier if they:

1) explained why relying on Docker Hub is dangerous

2) what the alternatives are, and why they're not good enough

3) what needs to change, which may include consumer behavior - things that we control, because we really don't have control over Docker Hub.

> indentured servitude

By collectively perpetuating our dependence on them, we are engaged in self-enslavement.

And I think this type of article is a form of begging that our masters haven't given us enough breadcrumbs lately.

concerndc1tizen··on We Need to Talk About Docker Hub
> the absolutely horrendous behaviour

They've ignored their application. That hardly qualifies as "horrendous".

Don't you believe in freedom?

It's fair to criticize them for monopolistic practices and creating a closed ecosystem. But if you want social goods (enforced through social norms), then the company should be publicly owned, not private.

concerndc1tizen··on We Need to Talk About Docker Hub
To some people, rejection is uncomfortable.

And rejection is noisy and wasteful. And companies can't really be honest in this situation anyway, so it's pointless.

So I like the Hollywood approach: Don't call us, we'll call you.

concerndc1tizen··on We Need to Talk About Docker Hub
> If you're reading this and you work for Docker in some relevant capacity, give us a hint as to what we're supposed to do here, we'd really appreciate it.

It sounds to me like their ultimate goal is to get more free stuff.

And I'm saying: open source should not rely on benevolent corporations.

And writing articles to beg for services is not a healthy strategy in the long term.

Instead: use open standards, don't rely on centralized infrastructure, create a marketplace for providers, and create a better future. Stop maintaining the status quo of indentured servitude.

concerndc1tizen··on We Need to Talk About Docker Hub
I don't agree that you can speak on behalf of "everyone".
concerndc1tizen··on We Need to Talk About Docker Hub
> we were preparing for our annual DSOS renewal. This process is abysmal, there's no way to apply to roll over membership, or even a renewal process per se, you have to reapply from scratch every year using the same badly-designed form ...

It sounds more to me like those who run DockerHub aren't that interested in giving away free service.

concerndc1tizen··on We Need to Talk About Docker Hub
Your position is one of presumed entitlement, where you rely on services being provided because the outcry of not doing it would be costly.

So you're right in that sense. It's essentially blackmail: free services in exchange for staying silent.

I think it's unhealthy.

And I argue that we need properly funded, independent services, with clear motives.

concerndc1tizen··on We Need to Talk About Docker Hub
And once those services are fully developed, and the market is captured, do they still need to provide free services?

Isn't compatibility issues a major problem for alternative registries?

concerndc1tizen··on We Need to Talk About Docker Hub
If you don't like it, then why don't you use a different provider?

If you want free stuff, is your strategy to smear them into giving you more free stuff?

Storage, compute, and traffic, isn't free. You've been the beneficiary of charity for years.

Yes, the open source community has relied on this implicit charity as a parasite, by exploiting whatever free services they could. And now we're paying the price, as you say, by having DockerHub as the default provider.

My suggestion is therefore that we need independent solutions, that are fully funded as a charity, and stop relying on freemium services from corporations that fundamentally don't care about the public good.

concerndc1tizen··on UK's hardware talent is being wasted
Nice charts, but M0100CUSM070NNBR is from 1948 to 1963 :)
concerndc1tizen··on TikTok goes dark in the US
Fair point :D it was more about arguing that the situation is complex and it can be an excellent and terrible app at the same time, depending on what your measure is.
concerndc1tizen··on TikTok goes dark in the US
Is it possible that all of these are true at the same time?

- Tiktok has great content and a great algorithm to help you find it

- Tiktok advances Chinese interests

- Tiktok spies and collects data, such as scraping your clipboard, network

- Tiktok collects face recognition data on citizens worldwide

- Tiktok is addictive, and designed to be

- Tiktok is cultural expression, and contributes to people's feeling of identity

- Tiktok provides a platform for critical thinking and debate

- Trump wants to control it for his own profit motive, not because it's what's best for the US

- Tiktok contributed to Brexit, and similar political crises in the EU

- Tiktok is part of the Chinese 100 year marathon strategy

and so on...

concerndc1tizen··on So you want to build your own data center
@railway

What would you say are your biggest threats?

Power seems to the big one, especially when the AI power and electric vehicle demand will drive up kWh prices.

Networking seems another one. I'm out of the loop, but it seems to me like the internet is still stuck at 2010 network capacity concepts like "10Gb". If networking had progressed as compute power has (e.g. NVMe disks can provide 25GB/s), 100Gb would be the default server interface? And the ISP uplink would be measured in terabits?

How is the diversity in datacenter providers? In my area, several datacenters were acquired and my instinct would be that: the "move to cloud" has lost smaller providers a lot of customers, and the industry consolidation has given suppliers more power in both controlling the offering and the pricing. Is it a free market with plenty of competitive pricing, or is it edging towards enshittification?

concerndc1tizen··on So you want to build your own data center
There's no reason to attack generalists.
concerndc1tizen··on Rsync vulnerabilities
Do I read correctly that this is related to "rsync daemon" (rsyncd), and therefore has minimal impact on people who just use rsync over ssh?
concerndc1tizen··on The mistake of yearning for the 'friendly' online world of 20 years ago
Could just be a bot ad for that app though.
concerndc1tizen··on The mistake of yearning for the 'friendly' online world of 20 years ago
It's hard to prove either way, for or against, because behaviors are different in different countries, age groups, apps, and so on. Maybe it works for some segments, but not others.

But I've met countless people, of both genders, who swore that dating apps is a waste of time, and money. They're designed to be gambling machines. The house always wins, which in this case means the customers keep coming back.

concerndc1tizen··on Why was there a wall near runway at S Korea plane crash airport?
> Firefighters said some bodies were scattered 100 to 200 m (330 to 660 ft) from the crash site while others were found mutilated or burnt among the wreckage.[61] Police officials said it would require over a week to identify the more than 600 human remains recovered.[62] Some family members provided officials with DNA samples at the airport to help identify the dead.[4] (Wikipedia)

Does this mean the crash was so violent that the 179 bodies disintegrated into more than 600 parts?

concerndc1tizen··on Why was there a wall near runway at S Korea plane crash airport?
Why is it always Boeing?
concerndc1tizen··on Extracting AI models from mobile apps
Yes, that's what I'm saying. An LLM washing machine doesn't get rid of the copyright.
concerndc1tizen··on Extracting AI models from mobile apps
And similarly, translating those sentences into data points is still a derivative work, like transcribing music and then making a new recording is still derivative.
concerndc1tizen··on Human study on AI spear phishing campaigns
The same is true for operating systems. Why don't they sandbox properly?

We have sandboxing on mobile apps. Why can't we have the same for desktop?

concerndc1tizen··on Missiles are now the biggest killer of airline passengers
So, Lee Harvey Oswald?
concerndc1tizen··on Missiles are now the biggest killer of airline passengers
That is indeed another improvable alternate theory.

From my perspective, it's unusual to commit suicide in such a silent way, with such elaborate attention to detail. He could have killed the copilot, and had knowledge about disabling beacons, perhaps also about avoiding radar detection. But why? As an elaborate prank in creating the greatest mystery in aviation history?

Hijackings are usually far more loud. Distress calls, passengers contacting loved ones, a manifesto is published, or the airplane is destroyed defiantly (GermanWings, Q400 2018 incident, ...).

Everything about it is extremely unusual.

concerndc1tizen··on Missiles are now the biggest killer of airline passengers
"In politics, a defector is a person who gives up allegiance to one state in exchange for allegiance to another, changing sides in a way which is considered illegitimate by the first state." - Wikipedia

You can have defectors internally in the country. In Russia, defectors have a tendency to fall out of a window, regardless of who might be walking on the street (collateral damage).

concerndc1tizen··on Missiles are now the biggest killer of airline passengers
I would say the most salient example is MH370.

The more you read about it, the more you become in disbelief. If it was an operation, it is one of the most advanced ones that I've ever read about. They knew exactly how to deactivate beacons, avoid military radar, there was a power and communications outage (computer interference?), the airplane kept flying for another 7 hours (without detection!), there was no distress call, ... and so on, which cumulatively is extremely unlikely to occur by chance, and would speak to extremely knowledgeable and capable agents. The bodies were never found, so it is possible that the passengers were offloaded. Imagine going to those lengths just to capture one person, or a group? The only other time I've seen that level of coordination was with Edward Snowden.

← PreviousPage 4 of 6Next →