HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

core-questions

1,950 karma · joined January 22, 2018

submissionscomments
core-questions··on In Stockholm there's currently an IT battle underway
Yeah, 100%. People underestimate what "kids" can do - especially when we're talking about 14+ year olds who have been using technology their whole lives. Giving them the opportunity to work on Something Real might be more appealing than a bullshit project that goes nowhere.

> I'd love it if we lived in a society where everyone could contribute to everything.

That's still the dream, but SaaS kills open source in many ways - by monetizing what has already been done for people other than the authors, and by locking all applications behind paywalls. A return to running our own decentralized software, a return to protocols instead of platforms, is what we need to get over this.

core-questions··on In Stockholm there's currently an IT battle underway
I love this idea, but it seems that in general bureaucracies are not agile or freethinking enough to be willing to risk doing something like this, even though in the long run it might be amazing. Imagine if an easy-to-administer system of this ilk was freely available and was picked up by school districts around the world; that would be an incredible pool of talent to work with. Especially if the product can be a little bit fun and whimsical, being not-for-profit, compared to working on something dry and corporate.
core-questions··on Remove RMS from the GCC Steering Committee
Yeah, that's the long and the short of it. RMS has had fantastic ideas, and I think he generally cares quite a bit about humanity, but the guy is weird, and people don't seem to be willing to put up with that brand of weird.

(You can be plenty of other sorts of weird and not be cancelled, of course, making the whole thing quite arbitrary....)

core-questions··on About the RMS Cancellation
Implying I put a mask on. Do you think I'm bothered or intimidated by the fact that I hold a contrarian opinion?

I think RMS is a net good in the world. 99% of everything he's ever said and done has been some weird superposition of cringe and prophetic. The entire world owes him a debt of gratitude, but instead he's being slow boiled like so many other folks. I find it disgusting, and cowardly.

Go on ahead and pretend "equity" is somehow progress for as long as you want; eventually, when you're living in a failed state along the lines of South Africa, you'll understand.

core-questions··on After crime plummeted in 2020, Baltimore will stop drug, sex prosecutions
Hamsterdam is finally real!
core-questions··on About the RMS Cancellation
> I'm pretty sure the mechanism is: backing down from your position of power, apologising, being quiet in the community, and finally reintegrating once you've shown that you've learned from your past mistakes.

This requires that you actually accept that your punishment is deserved; which implies giving into the Woke Mob. Not all of us are interested in doing that. Not all of us care so much about "disadvantaged" people, especially in the area of open source which has been as close to a true meritocracy as the species has ever created.

> This person has done some crummy things

RMS is clearly autistic, so whatever "crummy things" he's done need to be taken with a grain of salt. Maybe a boulder of it. I don't care what RMS thinks of women, honestly; I care what he thinks about code and computers and freedom. Why would you look to him for an example of how to treat or think about women? It would be like looking to him for how to think about the NFL or about the coronavirus or something: totally outside of his wheelhouse and ultimately not that important to what he contributes to and works on.

> Being able to do anything with no social consequences would allow people to serially commit to doing horrible things, without ever losing their ability to continue doing them.

The problem is that the Woke Mob has co-opted the control of the definition of what is horrible, and expands it continually over time into areas that were not always considered horrible; and what's more, they apply it retroactively. Giving those assholes access to controlling what happens in computing is not exactly a win for the species.

core-questions··on Ask HN: To what extent does “culture fit” affect productivity?
Think teleologically: the _real_ purpose of the Culture Fit rubric is to give hiring managers and teams an arbitrary way to deny someone from being hired. Any language written around this concept is purely designed to protect HR or managers from discrimination lawsuits.

This is an exceptionally powerful tool to have; as capricious as it may be from time to time, it is critical that a team still actually have some amount of say into its composition. Sometimes it's hard to put into words why you don't want to work with someone; something they said rubbed you the wrong way, or their approach seems like one that will result in arguments and sore feelings, who knows.

This is where a good manager is able to actually use their intuition and wisdom to weigh in on a hire where otherwise a strict business process may force their hand. We need to leave opportunities for this, even if it can backfire. A good manager is not going to let personal bias get in the way of having an effective team; but in turn a good manager is not going to hire someone that breaks their team dynamic even if they have the exact skillset that's needed.

> Are there corporate definitions of culture fit?

If there are, they will be made by individual HR departments, and the wording doesn't matter, because the wording exists to defend the original purpose, which is to enable hiring managers to arbitrarily reject people.

> To what extent does "culture fit" affect productivity?

Massively.

"Culture" in this context refers to sort of a mishmash of things:

- Workplace-specific norms and customs (working hours, expectations around productivity and turnaround time, etc) - Quality of personal interactions (this is where language barriers, activist politics, argument style, ability to explain things clearly, etc. weigh in) - Mindset and approach (this is where you need actual alignment, a new hire has to not go completely against the grain of the team or there will be a negative impact).

I've been on teams where we've hired people the team said "don't hire, not a culture fit". The result has been a worker who isn't making friends on the team, isn't working closely with people, isn't meshing with the work expectations, and ultimately holds the team back. Gossip and drama are the natural result, lots of DMs and behind-the-back conversations. It can wreck a good thing, and hold back work more than not having the person in the first place.

> being older, I suspect it means "young and politically aligned", but again, that probably betrays my age.

I am getting close to that age myself, and I gotta tell you, I would probably be a little intimidated being on a team of 20-somethings. Think about it: they can spend 12 hours a day working if they want, I need to pick up kids from school, feed 'em, put 'em to bed, spend time with them. They can coast on their metabolisms when need be, I need to exercise near-daily or I will lose whatever fitness I've retained. They wake up bright-eyed after a night drinking, I need a whole day to recover. It's tough.

This may mean at some point that I will need to flip to working on things that were once cutting edge and are now legacy. Will I every truly learn K8S? Hard to say, but on the flip side, will zoomers who have grown up Cloud Native ever really learn how to manage physical hardware? There's a big niche for us with older skillsets and it's not going away - ask a COBOL programmer.

Culture fit is something you-as-the-prospective-employee should care about too. They may be saving you from signing up for something you really actually wouldn't enjoy or be effective at. Or, politically speaking, they may save you from ending up on a team of Woke People. Plenty of teams of old white guys still out there, may as well join one of them and have coworkers you can actually joke around with and enjoy the company of more...

core-questions··on Reddit’s most popular subreddits go private in protest against ‘censorship’
> Some people would argue that "censorship" would not apply to a private company owned platform.

These people would deliberately enable corporations to restrict your freedoms, and are simply seeking justification after the fact for it by hiding in the letter of the law, and ignoring its spirit. This goes against the fundamental values of the West and goes against what anyone who ever wrote a free speech law would have intended.

Reddit is one of the public squares of the internet. The only content that should be banned sitewide should be content that is expressly illegal in the countries that host their servers. That's it. Subreddit moderators should have a much firmer hand, because if you don't like a sub, you can create another one. The site as a platform, which was created expressly to be a bastion of free speech originally, should not be in the business of banning people for their ideas.

Reddit instead picks and chooses what people can say and think, and can't even hide behind 'obscenity' as they allow plenty of porn but don't allow anyone who doesn't abide by their strange new set of ill-defined postmodern values. Can we get a list of the concepts that fall into their new wrongthink? Hardly.

I'd prefer they just state their policy aloud, in clear terms, rather than couching it. Just say you can't advocate for or even argue in favour of white people, for men, for heterosexual cisgendered people on the platform. Just be honest and say it like it is. It would be much less insulting and much easier to deal with conceptually if there was even a shred of honour in their approach.

core-questions··on Insect Has Gears in Its Legs (2013)
> say if N DNA pairs can be theoretically shown to only encode a pattern of "blah" complexity (time/space) regardless of future protein interactions

I don't think it's going to end up this simple. You're going to end up in the Godelian trap with this one. Consider how simple a Turing machine is, or a tiny cellular atomaton, and yet there's no limit to the complexity that they can produce chaotically from any established starting position.

The fundamental laws are going to come from simulating what the DNA does in practice, like running code in an emulator. It needs to be 'decompiled' and 'decompressed', in a sense; our current approach is like trying to understand why a REST endpoint gives a certain response by staring at gates within the processor. It might be doable but it's not going to be the most fruitful approach.

core-questions··on About the RMS Cancellation
> Don’t people sometimes reflect upon themselves, “are we the baddies”? Don’t people see a value in having a moral ground?

That's not the point. The point of this cancellation is the exercise of power; it makes those who are perpetrating this action feel powerful, and closes the loop of a feedback cycle of justification.

Intentions and facts do not matter, because ultimately in this new era there is no path to redemption, no mechanism by which an apology can be accepted. The point is not consistency or actually building a safer or better world - if it were, RMS would rightly be considered a saintly figure for his contributions to the world. The creation and popularization of Free Software is a higher moral act than anything any social-justice keyboard warrior will ever accomplish, no matter how many luminaries they take down.

No, the point is to exercise power, to show any straight white (or white-presenting) male that they are vulnerable, and to ensure that more and more of us hide our heads lest we be the tall blade of grass that gets the scythe. This is, of course, our new privilege.

core-questions··on Insect Has Gears in Its Legs (2013)
I think we're still a generation or so away from getting to this level. Fundamentally, though, it doesn't seem to be too wild of a suggestion that DNA is going to end up looking like an incredibly complex, incredibly hacky computer program, utilizing every last potential possibility of its mechanical substrate.

Think about demoscene or 80s video game programming, tight little assembly routines by developers that did not care anywhere near as much about simple and clear code, security, portability, or anything else as they did about raw performance. Analyzing some of these after the fact (not that I've done it, but I've read the stories of people doing it) seems to be every bit as difficult as being able to do it in the first place. And this is something that _is_ the product of intelligent design; when raw evolution is responsible for the work, it's even less liable to make some kind of logical sense when viewed at the lowest level. The emergent effect of random change (and its impact on reproductive fitness) is the only thing that matters.

Now, consider this: scientists analyzing a simple processor can't even tell you how it works, using modern equipment:

https://journals.plos.org/ploscompbiol/article?id=10.1371/jo...

> we take a classical microprocessor as a model organism, and use our ability to perform arbitrary experiments on it to see if popular data analysis methods from neuroscience can elucidate the way it processes information. Microprocessors are among those artificial information processing systems that are both complex and that we understand at all levels, from the overall logical flow, via logical gates, to the dynamics of transistors. We show that the approaches reveal interesting structure in the data but do not meaningfully describe the hierarchy of information processing in the microprocessor. This suggests current analytic approaches in neuroscience may fall short of producing meaningful understanding of neural systems, regardless of the amount of data.

What do we take from that? It seems to me that our current understanding of DNA is extremely crude, and that we're still a few breakthroughs away from understanding any moderate to large scale 'logical structure' in it.

core-questions··on Duke Nukem 3D Mirror Universe
Is anyone doing realtime photon mapping, maybe using some of that RTX stuff?
core-questions··on The Art of Warez Documents the Lost ANSI Art Scene (2019)
I used to use ACiD Draw for this kind of thing. The blinking parts were my favourite, you could almost make crude animation with it.
core-questions··on The Art of Warez Documents the Lost ANSI Art Scene (2019)
We emphasized the zed out here - so like 'wares', except the z has that vocal fry buzz to it, usually extended out a beat to make it clear.
core-questions··on Ask HN: What are some “10x” software product innovations you have experienced?
I strongly believe that if Opera had had a cool name, it would have been a real contender. People don't like operas, they're boring and stodgy.
core-questions··on Moore's Law for Everything
> The reality is, there is no place for humans in an AI driven world where AI is smarter than humans and robots can make stuff.

Luckily, that's a hell of a lot further away than AI bulls indicate. Can't even use AI to help with hiring people without it getting cancelled as racist, after all.

core-questions··on Moore's Law for Everything
Sounds like an instance of the No True Scotsman fallacy to me, friend. What is capitalism if not the systems that purport to be it? It's like saying "communism has never been tried". They tried _something_, and they certainly labelled it communism.

That said, I do find the Equity Fund idea interesting, though it's not entirely clear what this looks like in practice, especially for the unbanked, the mentally ill, homeless people, etc. who might not really know what to do with shares, since some of them don't really know what to do with cash, either. Seems to me these are the people most in need of uplift, no?

I'm not too worried about most lawyers getting automated out of a job anytime soon, after all, to the extent where I want to see the economy overturned for the likes of them.

core-questions··on Magic Mushrooms Are Decriminalized in DC as of Today
> But non-whiteness excludes you from a lot of places, or gets you treated with suspicion when you're allowed to be there at all.

Could you tell us about some of these places? I keep hearing there are such places but I never really get any concrete examples. Certainly no large business, nor any government entity, still qualifies for this. I want to know what White-exclusive operations there are that are still holding out.

core-questions··on Moore's Law for Everything
Phrasing things as an optimization problem can result in better, more efficient arrangements than how things are presently, but only within the limits that people are willing to accept. It also depends what we're optimizing for - if we naively set it for "maximum number of humans fed and cared for", we really are all going to be eating bugs and living in pods.
core-questions··on Why the new USPS mail trucks look so weird
I think you're thinking of Alternating Current and they're thinking of Air Conditioning.
core-questions··on Justice at Spotify
> They seemingly don't understand the business they're in... at all.

Do you know any musicians? Like, real musicians, for whom music is their life and their life's work, not dabblers?

Typically these are not shrewd business types. They don't hold a lot of negotiating power; if they're lucky enough to get a chance with a label deal they often don't push back on the terms very much at all. Labels are notoriously predatory in this regard, particularly mainstream large companies.

All they want is a fair shake. They see themselves and their fellow artists being screwed continually, while people that have nothing to do with their hard work, long nights, and passionate effort make money off their backs. For every artist that learns, there are ten more willing to take their place just for a tiny sliver of a chance at popularity.

The solution here is to do whatever we want to continue the slow work towards destroying mainstream labels. Indie labels still offer a reasonable value proposition in terms of the promotion and recording work they do in exchange for a share of the proceeds; mainstream labels don't. Like most media industries, they're headed by parenthetical elites, cosmopolitan types who have no loyalty to anything but profit, and will squeeze out every drop no matter the impact to the actual working artists.

Fuck 'em. Don't listen to mainstream music. Support indie artists and labels; buy direct wherever possible. If anything, the protest should be to make it trivial to directly host your music with Spotify for a nominal hosting fee, so that all revenue can go direct to the artist, rather than having to go through a 3rd party service.

core-questions··on Refund of pre-installed Windows: Lenovo must pay 20k euros in damages
Sure does, but my beautiful-but-old amplifier does not have HDMI. I use SPDIF a lot, but haven't found a good cheap USB-to-SPDIF sound card yet. Plenty of pricier ones, but the point here is to find some use for something I already cheaped out on in the first place.
core-questions··on Gun sales rise in past year, especially among women and African Americans
No, you're stuck at some kind of 2008 view on the topic.

The conclusion here is actually "these things are not caused by racism, because you can completely remove white people from the equation and yet the situation only ever gets worse".

Social policies combined with demographic realities are the proximate causes here. Continuing to paper over the latter with the former just entrenches the issue generationally.

core-questions··on Gun sales rise in past year, especially among women and African Americans
> If there was a meme name for an angry woman would you have an issue if it was a predominantly black woman name?

This is a pretty ridiculous way of talking about this. Let's be concrete about it: if the name was "Shaniqua", we'd all know that it was intended to be insulting toward Black women, right? Are you implying I'd be okay with that one? I'm not.

"Karen" has evolved into being an anti-white slur, and I'm not okay with either option, nor any other slur of this sort. It degrades the conversation and makes it impossible to discuss actual problems that have highly predictable demographic correlations.

core-questions··on Gun sales rise in past year, especially among women and African Americans
> People should not have to sit in a cage and then be "judged"

Reads like the words of someone who has never experienced life in a high-crime area. Likely, your sentiment about this is entirely created by false premises, an illusion from Hollywood about the nobility of gangsters. Life is not like that. Scary, sociopathic or even psychopathic people abound; violence is a daily fact of life; everyone has a mugging story.

The vast majority of these people sitting in cages have broken the law. Do you remember the law? The list of things you may not do, the list of things you will be punished for doing. A 2-year-old can understand this: do bad thing, sit in the corner as punishment. I'm not sure what happens in the brain of a mature adult to make them forget these basic mechanics; it really feels like you must have been sold sob stories that make your mushy heart over-empathize with a media construct. In reality, there are people out there who will stab you for $20.

> Many people sitting in jail right now should not be in jail because their "crimes" never affected anyone else or society at large.

There are certainly some such people, but have you looked at the 'revolving door' phenomenon where police arrest people who are punted back out onto the street hours or days later? They learn that there is no real lasting consequence for their actions besides an uncomfortable few nights (albeit, out of the rain and cold, and with free food). There are not that many people who end up in prison for crimes that don't affect others - and when they are in jail for a minimal offense, oftentimes that's the only thing that police and prosecutors could concretely nail them on, despite knowing or believing that they're involved in far worse actions that they haven't been caught for.

The other thing is, many actions do affect society at large. Drug use does; advocates for Legalizing Everything pretend otherwise, but opiates have a massive effect that cannot be mitigated just by making them legal. The addiction doesn't go away; the cost of the drugs doesn't disappear; and the actual impact of being a junkie doesn't stop. You don't end up all-of-a-sudden being able to hold down a job reliably just because your risk of arrest goes away. You don't remove chances for fentanyl to kill people by turning a blind eye to the problem.

> it has become a weapon for use against anyone the two parties did not like.

Guess what, Yank; these problems exist outside of your country and your two-party bubble bullshit too. Every major city in the world faces these problems, in predictably direct proportions to demographic factors that may not be politely discussed. The problem is endemic, it's not a function of the system except to the extent that the system finds ways to profit off of corruption and drug money.

core-questions··on Refund of pre-installed Windows: Lenovo must pay 20k euros in damages
Mmm. I have an RPi 4 but misclicked when ordering and ended up with a 1GB model. The Kodi performance on it is unacceptably bad; which is surprising considering that codebase used to run on an Xbox 1 with one core and 64MB.... so it became a Volumio machine instead, once I got an external USB DAC that didn't suck as much as the onboard sound does. (Talk about electrical noise, ugh).

The reason I wanted to see if I could get that Sony hardware running on some other screen (besides the re-use angle) is because Android TV gets you access to the first party Netflix and other streaming services with the proper UI. Netflix-via-Kodi is not really a very good user experience presently. You mention open source Android TV - is that something I could run on other kinds of devices? Can you get the Netflix etc. apps on it?

core-questions··on Gun sales rise in past year, especially among women and African Americans
> caging people you don't like or don't look like you

This is such a toxic, false statement. It denies reality: people are getting jailed for their actions. Due process is still in effect, you understand; and if anything, far fewer people are jailed than probably should be due to overcrowding, high costs, etc. Recidivism rates are very high.

Pretending that people are being jailed because of the color of their skin is ridiculous, especially considering that in many cities the jury, lawyers, judge, clerks, etc. are also of the same skin color. People are being jailed for committing crimes; and yes, these crimes are being disproportionately committed by some groups - as statistics have consistently shown for decades.

Statements like yours throw the entire justice system under the bus. You essentially call into question the entire appartatus that remains to protect normal folks in the burnt out husks of cities like Baltimore and Detroit.

> Karens' across the country feel that they need to control everyone and everything

Karen is an anti-white slur. "Karen" expects people to follow the rules and to be pro-social, and gets mad when they do not; this used to simply be good, mutual enforcement behaviour that everyone engaged in to keep people honest and to fight corruption. Stereotyping middleaged white women who simply want the process to be observed as written is offensive, and as sexist/racist as any other single term you could use these days.

core-questions··on Refund of pre-installed Windows: Lenovo must pay 20k euros in damages
Is there a community for rooting Smart TVs and putting some other OS (i.e. LibreElec) onto the hardware?

Conversely, does anyone know if there's some way to re-use smart TV hardware? I had a Sony Android TV get smashed by a wayward child's actions some time ago and took all the boards out before recycling the rest, and I'd love to use it on my old dumb TV which has an aging Xbox 360 driving it, but I can't figure out how I'd get normal video output from the thing.

core-questions··on The internet didn’t kill counterculture – you just won’t find it on Instagram
For what it's worth, I remember people posting on Livejournal and various forums about how cool they were to have a Facebook account....
core-questions··on Doom: An irrational number that is finite and conditionally constant
> Imaginary number is irrational

I don't think that's the case. `i` is not irrational, it's just perpendicular to 1.

← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →