HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

corinroyal

275 karma · joined May 25, 2018

submissionscomments
corinroyal··on Why There Is No Moral ‘Right to Strike’
So? Anyone can uphold or betray their own values. This is a pure expression. Did you read it?

Sections 53-60 of his apostolic exhortation Evangelii Gaudium (2013) make a strong case in favor of looking at economics through the lens of ethics.

As a flavor, it begins:

No to an economy of exclusion

53. Just as the commandment “Thou shalt not kill” sets a clear limit in order to safeguard the value of human life, today we also have to say “thou shalt not” to an economy of exclusion and inequality. Such an economy kills. How can it be that it is not a news item when an elderly homeless person dies of exposure, but it is news when the stock market loses two points? This is a case of exclusion. Can we continue to stand by when food is thrown away while people are starving? This is a case of inequality. Today everything comes under the laws of competition and the survival of the fittest, where the powerful feed upon the powerless. As a consequence, masses of people find themselves excluded and marginalized: without work, without possibilities, without any means of escape.

Human beings are themselves considered consumer goods to be used and then discarded. We have created a “throw away” culture which is now spreading. It is no longer simply about exploitation and oppression, but something new. Exclusion ultimately has to do with what it means to be a part of the society in which we live; those excluded are no longer society’s underside or its fringes or its disenfranchised – they are no longer even a part of it. The excluded are not the “exploited” but the outcast, the “leftovers”.

corinroyal··on Why There Is No Moral ‘Right to Strike’
The Pope disagrees: https://www.vatican.va/content/francesco/en/apost_exhortatio...
corinroyal··on Why There Is No Moral ‘Right to Strike’
So do most oligarchs. Their victims, not so much.
corinroyal··on Why There Is No Moral ‘Right to Strike’
I love that a conservative think tank funded by oligarchs has an opinion about morality. I'll take my morality from people who know what that is.
corinroyal··on Ask HN: Should I Learn Blockchain?
It's not a very useful data structure, despite all the hype and investment. You'd be better off learning general programming with an emphasis on data structures that are widely used. The book "Designing Data-Intensive Applications" by Martin Kleppmann is a mind-blowing modern survey of data structures and their applications.
corinroyal··on IBM promised to back off facial recognition, then signed a $70M contract for it
And never leave. No going to the store. No driving. No friends coming by. No servants. Every supply run is a clandestine operation.

Individualist solutions don't work here. Only regulatory solutions can address the source of the problem and those require solidarity and collective action.

corinroyal··on A Harvard professor became the world’s leading alien hunter
I hope you find your way back to righteousness, brother. I hate to imagine the impact of this line of thinking on your soul.
corinroyal··on Parallel garbage collection for SBCL [pdf]
OMG! I read the SBCL release notes every month, but when you put together recent highlights like this, I'm blown away. Android binaries? True static executables? Yes, please!

This is impressive progress, especially for a language so many have written off as moribund. And that's just one implementation of the spec. ECL, ABCL, and Clasp are all progressing at a brisk pace too. Maybe the only good language is a dead language.

corinroyal··on Scientists Have Developed the Whitest White Paint Ever Made – Can Cool Surfaces
So true. I love that Gamblin Colors produces their Torrit Grey paint every year from pigment recovered from cleaning the air filters in their warehouse. They say it tends green due to the tinting strength of Phthalo Green. https://gamblincolors.com/torrit-grey/
corinroyal··on A Harvard professor became the world’s leading alien hunter
It does not take "balls" to speculate wildly. Any grifter can do it, whether they have a uterus or not. Sensationalism is always easier than evidence-building.

> I think having people with courage to stand up and argue against the consensus is incredibly important.

I agree it would be nice if Loeb tried that. So far he hasn't made any arguments, just bloviated.

And what "consensus" do you imagine Loeb is your champion against? Tarter is a pioneer carving out a new discipline, not the latest head of some ancient SETI cartel started by Aristotle. Any "consensus" is tentative at best. To hear Loeb speak, you would think it were he who started searching for techno-signatures forty years ago--with Tarter in a dominatrix outfit and a whip waylaying him at every step.

He yelled over her, refused to let her speak, misrepresented her arguments, and tarred a diverse research community with a broad brush. Nobody made him show his own ass on Zoom. That was his choice.

By contrast Tarter was polite, gracious, and statesman-like. She defended her colleagues clearly and let the clown dig his own grave. Never interrupt your enemy when he's making a mistake. If I were one of the researchers she were defending, I would be proud to have her up there representing me, and certainly glad I wasn't the one who was asked to find time in my research schedule to act as some narcissist's punching bag for an hour so he can build his social media viewership.

Loeb is just another science grifter who pumps up bad ideas with hot air in order to make some post-truth money off rubes who watch Joe Rogan--where making wild and evidence-free claims made with a flourish of performative masculinity beat decades of careful research.

corinroyal··on Can a worker-owned restaurant work?
Oh, I miss Arizmendi so much since I moved away.

I heard about an Arizmendi customer who went to Paris and was really excited to try real French bread. When she got there, all she could find was horrible like you could find in any supermarket. She told her French friend about her disappointment and asked where she could get some real French bread. The friend's reply was, "Berkeley."

There are a lot of great worker co-ops in the Bay Area. Here's a map from Network of Bay Area Co-operatives: https://nobawc.org/map-of-nobawc-coops/

corinroyal··on Scientists in Antarctica say they were left alone against sexual harassers
You're just a fount of unconventional wisdom, aren't you? Today I learned that:

- All men, except maybe defective gay men, are ticking time bombs who will commit violent felonies if their whims are not catered to consistently

- While we punish murderers and home invaders, rapists are a special class of criminal that deserves accommodation

- Suggesting that rape is something that men can and should choose not to do is illogical

- Admitting on a public forum that if you reach a certain level of sexual frustration, you may fail to uphold your "ideal" of refraining from committing a violent assault--that's totally rational

- In other news, Freedom is Slavery

I'm convinced. I think that we should radically reorient society so that it's focused on catering to the sexual needs of straight men. Otherwise we'll just be awash in rape and there are absolutely no other solutions. I wish there were another way, but a very stable genius on HN told me this, and they are a man who works in tech, so they're obviously an expert on everything, except self-control apparently.

What's so striking about your argument is how utterly pessimistic you are about men's capacity for moral action. Essentially you are saying that men are a criminal class too large to kill or control and that the best we can do is to try not to provoke them. If a feminist expressed that level of hatred for men, we'd be rightly pilloried. But then, maybe I'm expecting too much of the rape enthusiast community.

Call me a traditionalist, but I'll stick with Feminism and Christianity which tell me that I get to make my own choices whether to rape or love.

corinroyal··on Scientists in Antarctica say they were left alone against sexual harassers
Not raping people is "an ideal" for you? That's really useful to know. A lot of people would prefer not to be around someone with an admitted propensity for violent crime.

I don't think most of us have such a hard time refraining from hurting people for kicks as you appear to. Honestly, I can't even remember the last time I committed a felony due to sexual frustration. Usually, I just take care of business myself. But perhaps I'm old-fashioned, don't confuse sex and rape, or lack your terrifying sense of entitlement.

corinroyal··on Scientists in Antarctica say they were left alone against sexual harassers
Let's see if I understand your take:

Men are naturally amoral and violent.

We should force victims to accommodate the perpetrators amongst them and see if that helps.

Many women don't even want hang out with rapists in Antarctica.

---

Damn, and they say we feminists have a negative view of men.

As an alternative to this take, we could hold violent criminals accountable without regard to gender or distance from the equator.

corinroyal··on Retailers say thefts are at crisis level. The numbers say otherwise
Didn't read the article. Has an opinion anyway.
corinroyal··on The Bipolar Lisp Programmer (2007)
"Lost the battle?" Ruby is a far better ecosystem now than it was when it was getting popular. C is "dying" according to your definition. It's number 2 on the TIOBE index, while Ruby is in the top twenty. I'm using Common Lisp do build my product, and that one is long dead and buried according to popularity.

Maybe there are business reasons to avoid less popular programming languages, but there aren't any programming reasons to avoid them. Maybe we should stop treating tools as if they were candidates for homecoming king and queen.

corinroyal··on The cartel that controls the US meat industry
I'm not sure I'd want to admit in public that I follow RFK Jr. If he said it, it's unlikely to be true.
corinroyal··on The cartel that controls the US meat industry
I feel for you. You might enjoy a book from a small farmer called "Everything I Want to Do Is Illegal" by Joel Salatin. He talks about the absurdity of ag regulatory capture and it's effects on small farmers. It's an inspiring call to arms.
corinroyal··on The cartel that controls the US meat industry
> They will act

Citation needed. Anti-trust enforcement went out with Clinton.

corinroyal··on Ignoring boys' emotional needs fuels public health risks
You sent me all these great texts and then ignore them when they don't show what you said they would. Being a straight nerd does not in fact put Aaronson in one of the least privileged classes in society. It's not actually misandry for men to be criticized for common bad behaviors justified by an ancient system. I'm sorry that it's hard on men to internalize the lessons of the anti-racism, anti-sexism, and queer liberation movements. Imagine being a rich person hearing "billionaires suck" while you're writing a check to charity on your private jet. That must feel like a slap in the face.

When you say it hurts to hear "men suck" my flippant response is "Have you tried not sucking?" If you have and were successful, then feel free to ignore any men-sucks coming your way. That's what I do. I don't know what else you're asking then that men's behavior just not be critiqued, or only ever be critiqued in a completely dispassionate way that ignores the dynamics of women's suffering and recovery. Do you get upset when an abused dog acts skittish or barks around you? Do you think the dog is being anti-human for not immediately realizing you're one of the good ones? How is trust regained once broken?

Why are we comparing being socially awkward to being gay or a woman? Because we're each lower-status in society? Because nerds defy certain social expectations for manliness like gay men do? Ok. But one can get over being social awkward, one can gain confidence, and put work into building skills for reciprocal relationships; but you can't get over being a woman or a fag. Refactoring unworkable notions of manliness sounds like it would be of benefit to nerds, women, and queers.

If you're suggesting we need a movement to help men figure out their way in a changing society, then I'm all for it. I was member of one myself back in the nineties. There are many ways men suffer under patriarchy and much work that has already been outlined. Paternity rights, anti-circumcision, domestic violence and sexual assault resources for men... If you were to start a men's organization, what would it look like and what would you work on?

corinroyal··on The Suicide Attempt by Red Hat
None of the suits cared about Linux in the early days when we sysadmins were extolling it's benefits. The idea that Linux could ever take on commercial Unix offerings from companies like IBM was laughable. It's so strange to me that the argument that suits don't care what geeks think is still being made. Current users will stick with Red Hat until they fear they won't be able to hire for it. But that's what happened to AIX and why IBM bought Red Hat in the first place.
corinroyal··on Douglas Rushkoff: Crashing Technosolutionism [video]
LMFAO!
corinroyal··on Ignoring boys' emotional needs fuels public health risks
Thanks for the great links. I've just read Aaronson's piece, Penny's response, and Marcotte's diatribe.

I do not see the misandry you suggest is here. Penny's response is remarkably compassionate to Aaronson. ["Hi there, shy, nerdy boys. Your suffering was and is real."] Marcotte's, while brutal and snarky, makes some insightful points. It is not misandry to be unkindly criticized for your ideas, even when you're being honest and confessional about a traumatic time in your life.

Like Aaronson and Penny, I was also a nerd who took refuge in nerdy pursuits as a way to deal with social and sexual awkwardness. I too grew up terrified that someone might find out I might be attracted to them. But this wasn't because I was afraid to be called a "creep" but because I was afraid they might become physically violent. This isn't an idle fear, since I've been gay bashed a few times, once that required hospitalization, each time contributed to my crippling PTSD.

Laurie Penny suffered nerd sexual anxiety like me and Aaronson did. But her fear was being called "crazy" and "slut". She says, "we were terrified, just like you, and ashamed, just like you, and waiting for someone to take pity on our lonely abject pubescence, hungry to be touched. But you did not see us there."

On top of nerd sexual anxiety, Penny had to deal with misogyny, while I had to deal with murderous homophobia. And yet Aaronson claims, without a hint of irony, "But I suspect the thought that being a nerdy [straight] male might not make me “privileged”—that it might even have put me into one of society’s least privileged classes..." LOL, Wut!? Hello Scott, we're right here. He doesn't see that we're dealing with the same shit PLUS an Imperial Fuckload that is SO extra. But unlike Aaronson, I do not blame my problems on feminism. I'm as shocked as Marcotte that this dude literally thinks he's at the bottom of society's totem pole because he has to figure out how to talk to women in a time of changing social mores.

Aaronson states that his nerdy anxiety was so severe that, "My recurring fantasy, through this period, was to have been born a woman, or a gay man, or best of all, completely asexual..." This statement is mindblowing in it's failure of solidarity and imagination. He so fervently craves the empathy he denies to people like me and Penny. He acts like it's only straight male nerds who have ever feared rejection. WTHF!? It must have been nice ONLY to have feared being rejected or being called a creep and not say, rape, gay bashing, or racially-motivated violence. Aaronson suffered a common experience of fear of rejection, and since the objects of his affection were women, he twisted his anxiety into an indictment of feminism as a way to protect his privileged-as-fuck male ego. This would never have occurred to me to do, since the targets of my affection were men. I never had any problem figuring out what feminists meant by consent. It was the same as my own. I never had any trouble figuring out that Dworkin was a dismissable reactionary. I get the feeling that Aaronson read feminist writers with the intent of cherry picking whatever confirmed his fears.

It's hard to imagine anyone labeling Penny's piece as misandrist, so I assume you're referring to Marcotte. But while uncompromising and uncharitable, her critique of Aaronson's letter matches my own. She writes:

"There are many women out there who are also crippled by social anxieties who would prefer to hide in their hobbies and interests. The difference is a) they can’t blame the entire opposite sex instead of themselves for their mental health issues and b) when they actually try to turn those interests and hobbies into professions, they are told by various social forces, both explicitly and implicitly, that their femaleness means they will always be second-rate at best. Being able to hide in mathematics is, in fact, a privilege, because it is one that has long been and continues in many ways, denied to women."

Aaronson loudly decries the notion that he has male privilege, but both he and I were able to take refuge in our nerdiness, while women nerds are constantly getting tossed out of the tree fort. This notion that only dumb alpha males are sexist and that enlightened nerds are somehow sexism-free is absurd. It's like the straight geeks don't even realize we gay geeks have been in the same rooms. We see you. Yes, you're very often being creepy and sexist. Do you see us? We have had to negotiate the same fraught terrain as you have. We managed to do so without resort to blaming feminism for our suffering. Maybe learn from us?

If the extent of the misandry you've suffered is hearing that "men suck" from people who are unreasonable or deeply wounded or both, then that sounds remarkably tame to me. Perhaps my experience isn't typical, but problems for me are things like homelessness, poverty, trauma, queer bashing, and incipient fascism. I'm a man too. Hearing "men suck" doesn't even move the needle.

I was ready to accept that you've suffered misandry, but I'm absolutely not seeing it from what you've posted. What was your reaction to Penny's writing? Were you not impressed with her empathy and nerd solidarity?

corinroyal··on Ignoring boys' emotional needs fuels public health risks
Point taken. It is much better to build up than to tear down.
corinroyal··on Ignoring boys' emotional needs fuels public health risks
I appreciate your thoughtful and heartfelt reply. I can relate so much to what you're saying. I too am depressed, deeply lonely, and struggling with poor self-esteem. I've dealt with chronic illness, PTSD from watching a few people die badly and one living death [worse], poverty, and frequent homelessness.

On "Men suck!"

I can understand how hurtful could be, but it never personally bothered me. Oppressed people let off steam in all sorts of ways and some of those ways are unfair. But compare "Men suck" to "Billionaires suck", "Cops suck", "White people suck" etc. Do all of those bother you equally? The fact is that waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaay too many men do suck in so many ways while being perfectly lovely in so many other ways. Rapey, dominating, violent, criminal, oligarchic, etc. People who have been harmed by such men have an absolute right to vent. I've got friends who regularly bitch about White people in front of me. It does not bother me. White people do suck in so many ways. And even though I don't have an "All Lives Matter" sticker on my truck, I know that even I exhibit some racist thinking and behavior my self and that I benefit from a racist system.

My only recommendation is to seek understand the hurt behind the speaker's statements. Empathy with their suffering may help explain why they are acting out.

On Popular Feminism

I would never suggest that popular feminism isn't feminism. We are what we do. And yet, not all who identify as feminists are particularly good at it. WitchesvsPatriarchy, for example, strikes me as a rather immature expression for young women who are just beginning to work out their relationship to the world. This is valuable for them and us. People need a playpen where they can develop. Just as we expect college students to express the dumbest, most strident, and self-defeating version of whatever political philosophy they have adopted, we must recognize that newbies are stupid in every discipline.

There are, of course, terrible people who are feminists. There are those who simply use feminism as a cudgel to gain status.

And there is a Imperial shit ton of anti-feminists who parody feminist positions in memes. I am ogen accused of supporting a "feminism" which I do not recognize.

One of the rules for good debate is to argue against the best possible version of your opponent's argument. This is hard to do in the context of a well that has been poisoned by those who spew falsehood so hard and fast that it's difficult to sort the true from the false. And yet, there are plenty of coherent and internally-consistent feminisms to be found for those who can put the effort in to find them. I wish we were doing a better job to make things easier for those trying to make sense of things.

On Negative Stereotypes

The stereotypes are too often true. I have never raped or abducted a child, but when a parent gets nervous around me for being too close to a child, I just have to swallow my indignation and realize that the actions of others have ruined things for me.

The men loudest about "Not all men!" are those who never made an effort to understand the critiques in the first place.

And yet, these stereotypes are hurtful. Especially to men already struggling. The only advice I have is to do your part to build a world where these stereotypes have no basis in reality. In the mean time, thicken your skin. If you're not the creepy type, then realize that such unfair statements do not apply to you.

On Navigating Relationships

I'm gay and can't imagine how hard this must be. Straight people have such overwhelming and conflicting social expectations laid on them, that I don't know how they even function. We queers are used to making things up as we go along. There's a freedom to being a hated outsider.

So I guess my advice would be to make things up as you go along. Ignore all the advice you've ever heard about what women want. And listen to the specific individual that you are interested in. The are few interpersonal problems that can't be resolved by prompt, honest, and empathetic communication, and there are few problems between people that can't be made MUCH worse by the lack thereof. Listen. Express. Compromise. Repeat.

As a Christian, my faith tells me that we are each divine beings made in God's image. This informs how I treat my partner. Even when they are acting badly I try to remember that they have infinite Godlike potential within them and that my love for them can help them reconnect with their deeper nature. Indeed this is the point of a relationship. In bell hook's book "All About Love" (highly recommended} she suggest that romantic love is not about the pleasure of fucking or feelings of infatuation, but about a desire to see your partner realize their highest potential. When you start from that perspective, the specifics of the relationship become much easier to work out. The problem is when we see our partner as a fuck toy built for our pleasure and service. That is not a loving frame for a relationship, and only exploitation is possible from that position.

Under patriarchy, women are seen as servants who clean, nurture, and cook for men. This attitude is the root of so much suffering for both genders. I knew a guy who never learned to cook, ate ramen and canned spaghetti daily, and was way too desperate and lame to find a woman to serve him. Patriarchal expectation left him unable to even care for himself. His only solution was to try to trick some poor soul into being his servant.

Men and Feminism

Feminism started with women and has been primarily focused on their needs and the harms to them under sexism. It took quite a while for people to realize that men also suffer from the system. But women who have been harmed are focused on their own resolution and are under no obligation to develop feminisms focused on men's needs. That's our job and we simply have not done enough of the work to present a comprehensive, well documented, easy-to-understand feminism that addresses men's needs.

So if you feel like feminism isn't focused on you, you are absolutely correct. In an emergency, you put on your own mask first, even before your own child. The version of feminism we need isn't written yet. That's why it is important for men to introspect deeply over these issues, to take up the tools and clues previous feminists have left us, and to build what we need.

Think of the project of creating a men-focused feminism in terms of programming. You've found a project on Github that looks close to what you needed, but whole chunks are missing for your use case. No logging, no authentication, no input sanitization, random open ports everywhere. These you will have to write yourself. But that is still much easier than starting from scratch.

I hope this unpolished rant addresses the issues at least some of the issues you raised.

corinroyal··on Ignoring boys' emotional needs fuels public health risks
I never heard of him at the time. I only know him in his aggrieved jilted lover incarnation and didn't care for it.
corinroyal··on Ignoring boys' emotional needs fuels public health risks
This is true enough. We didn't get very far before the backlash set in. We were seen by some as feminized men who were traitors to our gender, which I take as a great honor. There were so many obstacles to overcome:

* Straight and gay men talking about emotions and hugging * Men confronting unearned privileges * Men confronting their own unjustified anger and aggression * Men trying to gain emotional intelligence to understand and control their moods and triggers * Men grappling with women invading traditionally men-only spaces

So it was absolutely a hard sell. But so is every other anti-oppression movement. No one expected to eliminate a millennia-old system overnight. The thing is, when you're right, you're right. Regressives can't keep a good idea down forever. The progress I've seen in my short lifetime confirms this.

Even if anti-feminists succeed in their efforts to overthrowing democracy and bringing about a patriarchal authoritarian state the gain will be temporary and we will return in force. After denial, anger, bargaining, and depression, comes acceptance.

corinroyal··on Ignoring boys' emotional needs fuels public health risks
Feminism is the movement that seeks to free both men and women from traditional gender relations. Feminism isn't the term for the women's side of a war between the sexes. It's an intellectual framework that offers tools and analysis to understand and dismantle the patriarchal system that harms us all.

If you read my post from that perspective, you'll see I'm very much talking about men. Perhaps this is easier for me as a gay man to understand since the harms of patriarchy are VERY clear to me.

corinroyal··on Ignoring boys' emotional needs fuels public health risks
Your point about fake cures is well taken. But I hope you can see there was more involved. Imagine touching clients, working on their sexual expression, and pushing radical, explicitly anti-fascist social change in the USA during the height of "Leave it to Beaver", Behaviorism, and the Red Scare. The knives were out for him with or without the box. He came to the US to escape persecution but it followed him all the way from Europe and led to his untimely death and the utter destruction of his liberatory vision for psychiatry. The ground was scorched and we are still bereft of a comparable vision.
corinroyal··on Ignoring boys' emotional needs fuels public health risks
> I hope we can at least agree that whatever socio-political winds may prevail, the needs of children should not be neglected.

Absolutely. Have a great night.

← PreviousPage 6 of 9Next →