HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

corinroyal

275 karma · joined May 25, 2018

submissionscomments
corinroyal··on Ignoring boys' emotional needs fuels public health risks
Reich had been persecuted on two continents long before he went crazy and raved about cloudbusting and orgone. The early psychoanalytic period was a wacky time by modern psychological standards, and his pseudoscience about "bions" didn't help. But what really did him in was his transgression of practitioner neutrality, his advocacy of free sexual expression, his touch-based therapies, and his insistence that a psychiatrist's job is to help reform society to better meet the psycho and the somatic needs of the masses. Only then could we prevent "neurosis" rather than just treat it. Even today the idea of reforming society to prevent mental illness is hugely controversial.

They burned his books, including "The Mass Psychology of Fascism" and his seminal "Character Analysis" in what has been called one of the worst instances of book burning in US history at the time. Looks like the burning times are back, eh?

He was jailed for refusing not to proselytize the Orgone box, but that was really a pretext. Orgone boxes aren't in any way dangerous. He was jailed because his theories and practice were a threat to the status quo.

corinroyal··on Ignoring boys' emotional needs fuels public health risks
> A well rounded upbringing with all emotional, social and psychilogical needs met is all I advocated.

Fair enough, but then:

> What I said was that it is not a father's job or rather, if a mother is available then she is best suited for that job.

Who says that she is? Plenty of women suck at nurturing. Plenty of men are good at it. Why not have both parents capable of providing emotional support and guidance? What about single dads? Why assume that dad is better than mom at training a kid for fitness and to stand up for themselves. There are a lot of women jocks and soldiers. Have you ever seen the arms on a bread baker? She could punch you through a wall and go back to kneading without missing a beat. Why assume that girls don't need to throw a punch? They deal with both bullies and rapists. You are falling into the trap of gender essentialism. There are sex differences, but they are not the straightjacket traditionalists say they are. Did you think Neanderthal women laid around on fainting couches waiting for some dude to hand them a hankie?

If you want to know what men and women can actually do, don't look at traditionalists, look for us iconoclasts. The fags, the dykes, women athletes, men that stay at home with the kids. We are living examples that essentialism is dangerous bullshit. If you want to see true bravery watch a drag queen walk down a city street past all the people who want to kill her. Balls of fucking steel. Talk to the girl coder in a room full of coder bros trying to either fuck her or drive her off. Imagine being Madeline Albright in a situation room full of generals. That's bravery.

My grandmother was a pioneer in computing and women's liberation. When her husband was off in the merchant marines under the constant threat of U boats, she wanted to do something for the war effort. She saw a sign for engineering classes. When she went to sign up the man told her, "Sorry honey, engineering is for men." The instructor happened to overhear and replied, "Let her take it Harry. Then she'll learn her place." Of course, my grandmother took the class, did better than all the other guys, and went on to a long career designing nuclear torpedo circuitry and keeping the mainframe running, while raising four kids alone, and dealing with a constant stream of sexist men. Pure bravery. On the flip side, she couldn't cook to save her own life, thought Sanka in tepid tap water was coffee, and was hopeless at nurturing her kids, who have the emotional scars to prove it.

My father is an example of a boy who was never taught emotional intelligence. He simply doesn't understand his emotions or why they change. If I say, "Dad, it seems like driving is making you anxious. Do you want to switch?" He doesn't recognize the category of "anxious". All he knows is that something is wrong, it could not be him, so it must be mom's fault. On the flip side, dad is one of the best people in the country at programming cultural events for college campuses and single-handedly transformed student life for generations of students and is one of the funniest guys you'll ever meet.

Humans have evolved to be flexible and resilient. A big brain frees us from the monorail of instinct. Men and women can be whatever we need to be. This period of reaction to progress will pass like so many others have. You can't stop a good idea forever. And we who know freedom will NEVER go back.

corinroyal··on Ignoring boys' emotional needs fuels public health risks
Be careful not to confuse nature with nurture. Naturally humans have a high degree of variation. The traditionalist system you refer to is a construction, if a long-standing one. We can critique the success of this system like any other human construct.

To argue that stoic fathers tend to produce better sons requires evidence. We might ask, "Better for what?" Better to be a disposable cog in a rich man's machine, perhaps? There's quite a bit of evidence that stoic fathers produce sons with emotional problems. There is quite a bit of evidence that expecting fathers not to express intimacy with their sons is destructive for both. There's quite a bit of evidence that men who don't understand their emotions and have not been supported in expressing them safely tend to act out in dangerous ways.

Yours is a recipe for an exploitative, dangerous world. Intersectional feminism offers a path toward a safe, loving, and moral world.

corinroyal··on Ignoring boys' emotional needs fuels public health risks
Under traditional patriarchal gender roles, men are seen as self-sufficient, and women as dependent. When men fail to be self-sufficient, they do not tend given the same level of support as women who are expected to need help. Add class relationships into this mess and low-class men are left to rot on the street. Our oligarchs see all poor people as disposable tools. So it's the intersection of gender and class that results in more homeless men. This is an example of a negative result for men under patriarchy.

Keep in mind, that women at the same level of risk may not be on the street, but that doesn't mean they are safe. Women at risk are often preyed on by exploitative men and take refuge from the street in unsafe housing where survival sex and abuse is common. That may be a step up, but perhaps not by a lot.

Intersectionality is also informative when understanding the reaction many poor men have to the line that "men have privilege over women". Poor men don't feel privileged, even if they do enjoy higher privilege than women in the same economic class. But compare Joe Schmoe to Sheryl Sandburg, and it's the CEO lady who has the relative privilege, even if she's much lower status than the Zuckerbergs of the world.

Intersectionality is also the basis for critiques of "White feminism" where relatively privileged women dominate the discussion for women as a whole.

corinroyal··on Ignoring boys' emotional needs fuels public health risks
> If everyone needs therapy, it’s society that’s wrong.

This. Pioneering psychoanalyst Wilhelm Reich, father of character analysis made a similar claim. He was pilloried for suggesting that we should focus on prevention of mental illness over treatment. To do this he said that we should radically reorient our societies so that they meet people's organismic needs. He died in US prison.

The psych establishment now is a tool to rehabilitate workers who have become unproductive, not a way to help humans fulfill their potential. Therapy has been helpful to me, but woefully inadequate. That is by design. It's not about my needs, it's about my employer's needs.

corinroyal··on Ignoring boys' emotional needs fuels public health risks
Yes, this was the mythopoetic men's movement.

> Men's rights have been denigrated to the point my younger male (Western) friends are Andrew Tate fans because there isn't anything else left.

OMG, yes. The MRM has successfully redefined the men's movement to be regressive not productive. Any discussion of men's issues has to refer back to this body of worthless propaganda. But you know, we don't actually have to take the bait. Just as that scientist doesn't actually have to debate vaccines with jackass Joe Rogan. If he wants to learn something he can read a book like a normal person.

I don't pretend to have all the answers, but here's a few points off the top of my head.

* Intersectional feminism is a powerful frame. When we look at the places where sexism and classism intersect, for example, then we can begin to explain the fact that the vast majority of homeless people are men. We can see ways that careerist academic feminism fails those who don't have such constraints. And we can see how popular working class feminist movements can benefit from the research that more privileged feminists have had the freedom to do.

* Men who are open to feminist critiques don't often do the research. We don't read feminist authors. We don't know the history of the struggle, nor of men's role in feminism. Second-wave feminism started with consciousness raising groups. Maybe we men could do some self-educating and soul searching.

* First world feminists need to accept leadership from feminists in poorer countries. There is so much right going on with feminism in places like Mexico. These men and women are confronting millennia of machismo. How do they do it? We should know.

* Men need our own organizations. Who are the groups working on paternal rights? I don't know. Are there any? Can we start one? If the MRM is about whining about feminism. A real men's movement could be about actual organizing. We used to hand out anti-circumcision flyers at 24th and mission. We got some weird looks, but even the MRM has carried on the work we started in their ineffective pissy way.

* Feminist men need a popular social media presence. We have ceeded the space to reprobates and literal criminals. Rather than engaging in tit-for-tat with MRM people, we should address regular, reasonable men who might be open to us if we made a reasonable effort. We need to accept that we have dropped the ball and that that the growth of the MRM is significantly our fault. We were too quiet.

* That said, what I don't think we need are sites like "We Hunted the Mammoth" which are about ridiculing the MRM. This is an example of stooping to their level. When we engage with the MRM, we neglect our organizing. They know this, which is why they constantly bait us into making it all about them. Similarly democrats fail by harping on all the stupid things republicans do. We should be focused on our own failures and solutions. Let the idiots argue amongst themselves.

* Feminist men need to be able to critique other feminists. The movement gets plenty wrong. We need to feel free to call that out even when doing so invites blowback from other sectors of the movement. In the past, feminist men were too afraid to confront bullshit in the movement. We deferred too much to women. That needs to stop.

When MRM people bring up straw men like "Why are there no domestic violence shelters for men? See? Feminists hate men." Feminists often respond, "Feel free to get to work cleaning up your own mess." So let's do that. Let's get to work. We're way behind, but there's no time like the present.

corinroyal··on Ignoring boys' emotional needs fuels public health risks
Thank you. The history of the feminist men's movement was the first target of the MRM. They are very good propagandists. Even the name Men's Rights Movement sets up the opposition with feminism perfectly. But let's never forget that we were and can be allies.
corinroyal··on Ignoring boys' emotional needs fuels public health risks
The wrong here, it burns! Feminists fight to integrate the military (while developing an critique of militarism), powerful traditionalist men fight to keep them out. Feminists are winning and now the US military is ~18% women and growing. In sexist Ukraine and Russia, the percentages are much lower. So tell me again how women are too weak for combat?

It's not feminists calling for powerful men to send disposable poor men into the grinder. It's not feminists calling for men to "man up" and pretend they don't have emotional needs or fears. That's all on traditionalist men. Sexist men don't get to both enforce such traditional roles while decrying them as unjust.

corinroyal··on Ignoring boys' emotional needs fuels public health risks
In the nineties I joined a men's group retreat where we circled up and listened to each other's struggles, gave lots of support, and lots of hugs. Then we did some consciousness raising around circumcision and it's barbarity. We took our cue from the Feminist movement. They were getting their shit together and so could we. Gary Snyder read his gorgeous nature poetry, Peter Berg sold us on a green cities concept that would make our urban areas more livable.

Later, the monstrosity called the "manosphere" completely gutted our movement and turned it into a grievance fest against feminism. They stole our issues but instead of working on them, they weaponized them against feminists, especially against us feminist men. Domestic violence by and against men, paternal rights, genital mutilation, psych support, male fragility and toxic aspects of traditional masculinity, etc. But then they never did anything about any of these problems but bitch and bash feminists with them. As if it's womens' job to clean up our mess.

Step one to improving the situation for men is to destroy the right-wing MRM. "Let men be men again!" is the cry of the regressive who sees the problems and plugs his hears screaming "Naaaaaah!" No progress is possible from that position. If you bother to look, the MRM does absolutely nothing to confront the problems men face in this world. Why? They don't want to. They do not care about men's problems, they only care about protecting men's ability to rape, dominate, and abuse.

Take a look at this thread. For so many commenters their problem is with acknowledging the problems. Pointing out the toxic aspects of traditional masculinity is seen as an attack rather than an attempt at resolving the issues. How the hell are things supposed to improve if we can't acknowledge problems or ally with the movement [feminism] that did the first work to outline such problems? Feminists have been pointing out toxicity of the "man up" attitude for decades. So have queers. Feminists and queer men are natural allies in this struggle to improve men's lives. But we've let proto-fascists hijack the conversation.

My greatest fear is that reactionary men join across class and race lines to form a united front for fascism. That's certainly the goal of the MRM. We must stop them. Let's go back to a Men's movement that forms alliances, rather than buries heads in the sand.

If we did that, we could have men's domestic violence shelters, an ACLU for paternal rights, education policy makers that tackle bullying and lack of emotional support for men, and so much more. But we don't because too many are lured in by propagandists who would gladly destroy democracy to protect the status quo.

corinroyal··on James Cameron slams OceanGate safety, regrets not speaking up more
Did you even watch the interviews? Cameron pointed out that the safety record for these kind of craft is perfect until today, that these subs are a known quanity, that he and others warned OceanGate against using carbon fiber because it's a laminate that delaminates and fails catastrophically with no warning, and that Cameron knew of the implosion the day it happened. All quite newsworthy.
corinroyal··on It’s High Time to Prepare for Russia’s Collapse (January 2023)
Right? Collective punishment for crimes is always the right choice. Nobody had any problem with the Japanese internment, for example. All Americans should be jailed along with Trump for his crimes. We let it happen.
corinroyal··on James Cameron slams OceanGate safety, regrets not speaking up more
Right, who wants to hear the opinion of a leader in the field? Virtue signaling is whatever I want it to mean.
corinroyal··on Ancient Maya city discovered in Mexican jungle
I choose to presume you're trolling. The alternative is that you're a monster.
corinroyal··on Ancient Maya city discovered in Mexican jungle
No. It's undeformed limestone karst, meaning old uplifted seabed that was not crunched up.
corinroyal··on Lace Card
The card punch machines at my school had a hopper for all the holes punched out. I would collect this confetti and deliver them to a little girl on my paper route who was delighted by it.
corinroyal··on Homeless Numbers Rise in U.S. Cities
> At least in the US, the predominant view is that homeless men on the streets is a good thing

I've been homeless a lot and literally never heard this view until now. Asserted and dismissed without evidence.

> we are a long way to having social discussion about helping men.

Are we? Which men? With which problems?

I hear this argument all the time from anti-feminists. MRM propagandists often make an argument like, "Almost all the domestic violence shelters are for women. You feminists only care about women." The response from feminists is generally, "Feel free to get to work." But of course, MRM people don't care about men's suffering under sexism, they care about bashing feminists, so they don't do any organizing. This dynamic would be funnier if it weren't so sad.

So what are you personally doing to address the suffering of men under sexism? I mean, aside from alienating your natural allies?

corinroyal··on Homeless Numbers Rise in U.S. Cities
I came to HN for the tech discussion but stay to watch the train wreck whenever tech workers try their hand at humanities. Sure, maybe if we were even more cruel to one of societies most hated groups, we could make them disappear from view. Perhaps we should just move fast and disrupt homelessness with a solution that removes their suffering and provides a real benefit to normal, respectable people. Let's turn the homeless into into protein bars and hand them out at the Google HQ commissary.

Kidding aside, don't speculate--educate yourself. Then you would at least recognize when you say ridiculous and cruel things about people you don't like, don't know, and never bothered to understand.

corinroyal··on Homeless Numbers Rise in U.S. Cities
Homeless people tend to be homeless where the are from. They do not tend to move to places where being homeless is easier. If they could move, to somewhere better, they wouldn't be homeless.
corinroyal··on Against longtermism (2021)
LOL! If Drax were around today, he'd be seen as just another Silicon Valley entrepreneur and would lecture at Stanford occasionally.
corinroyal··on Against longtermism (2021)
Right? That's because it's not a philosophy but a fig-leaf of a justification for the status quo.
corinroyal··on Against longtermism (2021)
> birth control would be completely unacceptable since you could lose an immense number of future people

Operative word = "could"

Or lack of birth control could lead to an unsustainable level of population that causes resource exhaustion and we die that way. Oh, wait, that's already happening. We can't know how our actions effect the far future, but we can be more confident in our ability to improve the near future, and we should do that.

corinroyal··on Against longtermism (2021)
Do you understand that the Luddites were protesting the use of technology to undermine labor, not technology itself? Calling someone a neo-luddite isn't the insult you think it is. https://www.smithsonianmag.com/history/what-the-luddites-rea...
corinroyal··on My friends who cheated in interviews are getting promoted (2022)
> The MBA's took over the technical companies and fucked everything up, but we're just supposed to keep doing the 'right' thing? NO. Fuck them, we should get ours.

Yes. That's what Christ teaches. We live in an unjust world and we make it better by holding our moral ground despite the enormous pressures to sell out.

corinroyal··on Reddit is currently down
DailyKos is down too, so I expect it's an AWS problem.
corinroyal··on From Common Lisp to Julia
When you are reduced to arguing that your opponent's passion proves your point, you know you have lost.
corinroyal··on Ask HN: What do you read for a more objective view on the Russia-Ukraine war?
Thanks! Great selection of articles to dig into.
corinroyal··on Cory Doctorow: Amazon's $31b “ad business” isn't
You've captured one of my chief frustrations with the left. There's an overwhlming focus on analyzing what is wrong but so little stategizing to give people concrete actions to take that could improve matters. Too much explanation just depresses people rather than motivates them to make changes. Still, Doctorow's analysis is spot-on here and he does more strategizing than many.
corinroyal··on Ask HN: What do you read for a more objective view on the Russia-Ukraine war?
What you are feeling is not "analysis paralysis". It is right that you search for context and nuance. Only fools take action before knowing the basic facts of the matter. Keep looking for truth. It is available with a little work.
corinroyal··on Ask HN: What do you read for a more objective view on the Russia-Ukraine war?
Good summary of the issues. This matches what I found while looking for context too. I wish more respondents to the question put in the work you clearly have.
corinroyal··on Ask HN: What do you read for a more objective view on the Russia-Ukraine war?
And yet there are neonazis in the Ukrainian military who attack Russian-speaking separatists in the east and who were in the vanguard of the 2014 revolution. It's wacky and hard to believe but a conflict the large is never black and white.
← PreviousPage 7 of 9Next →