HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

courtf

660 karma · joined July 2, 2012

submissionscomments
courtf··on The economic value of targeting aging
... yes? Preventing immortal dictators is absolutely worth keeping death around.

It's hilarious to me how shortsighted this whole thing is, if immortal dictators rule humanity indefinitely, how long do you think they'll let you live?

courtf··on Bezos donates $100M each to CNN contributor Van Jones and chef Jose Andres
On a long enough timescale aliens will come and rescue us! See how silly that sounds? Pretending to save humanity with absurdities is a cowardly way of facing the real, imminent problems we actually have here and now.
courtf··on Bezos donates $100M each to CNN contributor Van Jones and chef Jose Andres
It's a religion at this point. The problems facing humanity on Earth appear daunting, so it's easier psychologically to put faith in sci-fi ideas that might be impossible, but are simple by comparison to thinking through concrete solutions to our woes.

Humanity sits atop a food chain that is going extinct, right before our eyes, and it's long past time to stop hiding from it. Human life on Mars is neither feasible nor imminent. We aren't getting level 5 autonomous vehicles or AGI or androids or flying cars or time travel any time soon either. These are ideas we run to when facing the absurdity of our existence becomes too much to bear.

courtf··on Bezos donates $100M each to CNN contributor Van Jones and chef Jose Andres
There's no reason to believe we can sustain human life on Mars. Immense technical and biological hurdles stand in the way of that being possible, much less worth focusing on while the planet that does sustain life can still be saved. Believing the human race needs to go to another planet in our solar system to survive is philosophical suicide for sci-fi fans, akin to believing that saving Earth is futile because the rapture is imminent. To the degree that it distracts from the very real problems on Earth that must be solved and are in fact less daunting than living in Mars, it may even contribute to our literal suicide as a species.
courtf··on Bezos donates $100M each to CNN contributor Van Jones and chef Jose Andres
Yeah of course there's gravity, there's gravity in space too. I'm saying it won't be enough.
courtf··on Bezos donates $100M each to CNN contributor Van Jones and chef Jose Andres
Getting to the moon and Mars won't save the human race, Earth is where life can be sustained. Humans cannot reproduce in space, on the moon or on Mars because gravity has a strong and vital role in gestation in mammals. Beyond that, these other locations are quite inhospitable (radiation, temperature, pressure, etc), more inhospitable than pretty much anywhere on Earth.

If we can't make it work here and end up destroying the ecology of Earth, upon which we depend, there's no reason to think we'll survive on the moon or Mars.

courtf··on Bezos donates $100M each to CNN contributor Van Jones and chef Jose Andres
They are great choices, it's a generous and interesting form of charity. The focus on civility is a strange demand from the guy who has his workers peeing in bottles, but ok, I guess you need to stand for something at some point in the face of criticism.

Will this counterbalance the negative responses of the last few days? Probably not, the criticisms about the power wealthy individuals wield in society aren't affected, but it's a well timed gesture of good faith and the recipients are well chosen.

courtf··on Blue Origin first human flight
It's not really about the individual billionaires, that's missing the forest for the trees. That individuals can afford glamor rides to the edge of space in personal rockets is merely a symptom of gross inequality that has many more downsides than upsides.

Life expectancy is dropping, climate change is accelerating and while we can't solely blame any individual billionaire, they have as a group profited astronomically [:)] from the collapse of our institutions and middle classes, and from the wholesale destruction of livelihoods during the pandemic.

The government is more corrupt, more attuned to the needs of the rich than ever, so you don't need to wonder why the government has failed to attend to the needs of the majority. The same class of people currently culminating in rockets launches toward space have been directing the flows of tax dollars for decades.

courtf··on When will programmers grow up? (2014)
There is a certain zealousness that comes with learning new things and looking for ways to apply them. Any programmer likes to do this regardless of experience or maturity, so it's a little inaccurate to say programmers need to grow up, although perhaps a reduction in zealotry would be good.

Often workplaces don't provide programmers, especially new programmers, the opportunity to flex their new skills as they are learned. It's rare for the business to be able to function as an incubator for programming talent when there are tickets to be closed. So, we can encourage ambitious learners explore in their free time, or we can decide for ourselves to take the subversive route and shoehorn our new skills into projects to satisfy our own desires. I am not so critical of the subversive route, it can be a great source of motivation and the business doesn't need to get everything it wants all the time, the programmer can take something for herself once in a while. In the absence of a genuine dialogue with management about helping the programmer grow, it may be quite justified to behave this way.

That said, there might be a better way that involves reducing the focus on "efficiency" that has "optimized" a lot of exploratory work out of existence. There are things like 20% time and such, but getting a programmer to focus 100% on their fresh ideas is difficult for just one day a week. The cost of context switching etc. After working in a variety of small companies that were able to leave time on the table for programmers to dabble in personal interests, I have become quite skeptical of large, rich companies that don't seem to have the ability to create slack in their processes. Too much management, too much over-optimization, too many meetings and sync-ups and arbitrary metrics and other nonsense have been foisted on the workplace by various snake oil salesmen who then clog the hierarchy and continually meddle in processes with vain attempts to justify their existence.

The solution isn't obvious, even the useless need jobs after all, but a lot of this frantic over-analysis is driven from the top. The need to constantly react to the market, respond to threats and opportunities, change directions 100+ times over the course of a year as leadership squabbles over who has the reins, everyone trying to build a name for themselves as quickly as possible no matter the collateral damage etc etc. The programmers aren't the only ones who need to grow up... If a workplace could manage to cultivate calm and focus from the top (easier when you aren't in the red, of course), we might be able to allow programmers the space they need to grow as individuals, while simultaneously making the most pragmatic technology decisions needed by the business.

courtf··on Julia and the Reincarnation of Lisp (2020)
> What happened to the programmer’s time is more important than the machine’s?

I've never thought this way, primarily because I sympathize with and love computers, and don't like to watch them suffer. But there's more than that even, because there's more to software than just finding the most expressive language.

Someone has to package, deploy, verify, monitor, scale, debug and optimize the software and do all of these things with as little money and as little CPU/RAM as possible. It's often a matter of worse being better when it comes to these types of concerns. Simplicity is exactly what is needed when performance starts to matter, and "clever" men often seem to be conspicuously absent when it comes time to take out the trash.

Sure, it's fun to gather up your little clique of ivory tower CS nerds and get into a DSL measuring contest, but I've never seen the value in it myself, other than as defining one extreme end of the overton programming window.

courtf··on Branson and crew reach space, return in runway landing
Branson got infinitesimally closer to the stars and supposedly achieved his dream, although the 50 years spent on other businesses would seem to indicate he took a rather circuitous route to that dream. His pyramid is made of assets and holdings, rather than the sandstone of the ancient Egyptians, but we shall see whose monument to narcissism outlasts the other.
courtf··on Fewer young men are in the labor force, more are living at home
Definitely a good list, but I'd add a few more that just aren't around as much anymore. Things like spear-hunting mega fauna, traveling with the great herds and just enjoying the endless bounty of nature. The world was once much wilder and more abundant with major species. Lions in Europe etc. But yeah, we had so much fun chasing those critters around, we drove a lot of them to extinction and now must satisfy ourselves with video games to sublimate some of our hunter-gatherers instincts.
courtf··on Fewer young men are in the labor force, more are living at home
Not to mention, many jobs actively encourage this busywork grind, giving out more money for more grinding. So you get trained to chase the rabbit, but then you lose your job or something happens that makes it harder for you to get employed and you are left satisfying these ingrained habits any way you can, just so you don't go nuts. Video games can fill that need for grinding and give a feeling of virtual progress, but they aren't necessarily the source for that drive in humans. I blame school and work for training us to be this way, like a Skinner box. I don't blame young men for getting hooked on video games, even though it can become an unhealthy coping mechanism.
courtf··on Once a bastion of free speech, the ACLU faces an identity crisis
The article seems to be mostly grasping at straws and doesn't support the notion that the ACLU is against free speech. Articles that primarily reference tweets shouldn't be taken seriously. It's not like the ACLU has never experienced such internal debates over the proper course of action. If the ACLU stops defending the 1st amendment I would consider that a major loss, but that doesn't seem to be the case at all, opinions of individual members in a few scattered instances notwithstanding.
courtf··on The bullshit-jobs thesis may be bullshit
Who are you going to believe, The Economist or your lying eyes?
courtf··on The bullshit-jobs thesis may be bullshit
Companies are the most rational and levelheaded of God's creations, and so could never engage in any activity so at odds with their raison d'etre, like wasting budget on useless endeavors. Why, with all the well-trained MBAs filling out the bureaucrat ranks these days, I'm sure business has never been more efficient!
courtf··on The bullshit-jobs thesis may be bullshit
It may just be the common perceptions of these jobs are so pervasive, it influences the worker's own assessment. It's certainly in character for the bureaucrats to consider their jobs to be important. Desensitized to petty politics and constant surveillance, they probably thought their answers would get back to their boss, and didn't want to appear redundant.
courtf··on LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator
Yes in Oregon it was ultimately very similar. I was just perhaps a little too close and saw the sausage being made behind the scenes.
courtf··on LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator
I waited until I was eligible, which was about a month ago. Anyone could have lied about their eligibility and gotten shots early, and although I wasn't comfortable doing so, I also don't begrudge people who did. Frankly, the vaccine should have been distributed more widely from the beginning. It was disheartening to watch the politics play out where only the "most deserving" people were granted vaccine, which quickly turned into "hospital executives, their families, & high ranking admin" before they got around to the most deserving.

I certainly wouldn't have encouraged a group of wealthy or soon-to-be wealthy tech founders to lie for vaccine. "Hacking the system" has always implied a sort of robinhood ethos, at least to me, not just greed purely for its own sake. I guess it's easy to be confused when you were raised inside the bubble and everything is monopoly money.

courtf··on You Owe Me
I think the system was revealed a little too early, and someone like me will try to decide what the system is right away, rather than patiently waiting for the author to fully explore the idea. So it does feel a little long, but I'm not sure it's a flaw. I have felt the same way about gimmicks in other well-regarded and much longer writing (400 page books that give away the whole thing in chapter 1), but here it seems balanced enough. Part of why it felt too long to me was just because the people in the story are boring, although I think that is also intentional.
courtf··on You Owe Me
Clearly targeted at a certain class of Westerner (both men & women), I enjoyed the story and thought it was quite clever.

Is the world depicted in the story any more absurd and implausible than the world we already experience? Is the system in the story all that different from systems we encounter in our lives? Perhaps a bit more explicit, but not really that different. Just a small tweak that makes things normally taken for granted feel alien and uncomfortable, great art!

courtf··on Amazon offers 'wellness chamber' for stressed staff
Be sure to clock out before you attempt suicide.
courtf··on Amazon offers 'wellness chamber' for stressed staff
No shitting in the sanity cube!
courtf··on Overwork contributes to 745k premature deaths per year
This is true, but when so much of our culture and the starting conditions many people find themselves in are decided before our birth, often as a matter of public policy, the whole exercise starts to feel a bit, contrived? The rules of the game are really up to us, we're not talking about axioms of the universe here and yet, we're so often expected not to question anything, and simply focus on our personal success while ignoring externalities and plights of others.

What if succeeding personally while watching many others suffer unfairly, in a rich country where it needn't be that way, isn't enough to enjoy life? Do we have a duty to expand our sympathies beyond the self and the family? Most ancient wisdom says yes, and yet the modern status quo has failed to conserve this crucial pillar of humanity. Instead we have prosperity gospel, and its more secular version, the mythical meritocracy. Failed ideas that the human race has fought off more than once, only to find itself in the same boat again.

courtf··on Overwork contributes to 745k premature deaths per year
Why do we feel the need to get ahead of others? Because we see how the lower classes are treated and would rather live a better life. Our justified fears of falling behind the curve are manipulated by our circumstances, that we have no control over, but others do. We are driven in the direction of escape from these circumstances. It's just more fight or flight, and we mostly choose flight. Our fears are a yolk, our labors are harnessed and converted to profit. We may get ahead of our peers, but we do not get very far.
courtf··on Humans Could Live up to 150 Years, New Research Suggests
Not sure I see the point in extending our lives. All the problems we have with history being forgotten and humanity repeating the same mistakes won't go away, the cycle will just take 150 years instead of 100. It will take longer to evolve, longer to learn our lessons, but in the meantime the wealthy get a few more good decades riding high on the backs of the billions living in poverty around the world. Hurray for that I guess.

This sort of research is tailored to the infantile concerns of narcissists who believe their individual lives matter more than the health and longevity of the species and the planet. Is death really so scary? Is it so difficult to imagine that it might be important for our lives to end? Oh you poor, mistreated mortals, the heavens weep for you.

The only way life extension really makes sense to me is if we imagine that humans have reached the zenith of their evolution, which is just laughable. Just remember,the last laugh is on you ;)

courtf··on The problem with reinforced concrete (2016)
The Roman scholar Pliny the Elder described underwater concrete structures that become "a single stone mass, impregnable to the waves and every day stronger."

https://www.nature.com/news/seawater-is-the-secret-to-long-l...

Sounds like they knew.

courtf··on Biodiversity decline will require millions of years to recover
Beautiful comment,thank you.

The closer we look at anything, like fungal growths, the more we realize how little we actually understand. Trying to tease apart the microscopic mechanisms that underlay the behaviors of fungal spores and slime molds is enough to make an atheist reach for God. The world is still very much inexplicable and so exquisite, it puts our efforts as builders to shame. Everything is a rabbit hole stretching back to the creation of the universe, just as humans have inherited life from an unbroken chain of organisms stretching back to the first cell.

We are still evolving, still bringing our frontal cortexes fully online, like teenagers. It is hubris to assume we are anything more than the link between our past forms and our future forms, although we may not survive through this particular transition.

courtf··on Woke at Work: Why tech firms are trying to run away from politics and failing
This gets tricky when employers ask workers to internalize the company values (incorporating them into their identities). Probably helps with retention, but then you get everything else that comes with identity. If you represent the company, and vice versa, it's only natural to want the company to use its influence in ways that embody that, even if it seems superfluous from a purely financial standpoint.

There's a case to be made that we should tone back the importance of work in all of our lives, which would potentially help with these issues. I understand the need to defend minorities from bigots, and even from milder, less intentional forms of discrimination/bias that can accumulate over the years to cause a strong drag on your life. I still like to think there are ways to do that without a lot of outrage and constant, inane meetings, but who knows.

courtf··on Leaked emails show crime app Citizen is testing on-demand security force
Prevention is cheaper and results in a friendlier environment for everyone. The proliferation of expensive, reactive solutions that tend to aggravate the very problem they're ostensibly working on is great for shareholders though. Public health is boring by comparison, and no one gets rich when it works.
← PreviousPage 2 of 9Next →