HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

courtf

660 karma · joined July 2, 2012

submissionscomments
courtf··on You're enlightened – now what?
"The cemeteries are full of indispensable men."
courtf··on Work on What Matters
I tried to do this sort of thing for many years, with mixed results. One constant is that no matter the outcome of my efforts, whether something I built made the company money or was a waste, there was seldom any kind of conclusion or major takeaway. Making an impact has rarely helped me, not with promotions or prestige or even with getting a raise. Impact has been disconnected from any sort of return almost everywhere I have worked.

What does get rewarded is your social network and your ability to present yourself in a pleasing manner. Even the concept of "career growth" seems like a relic from a bygone age, as if it were possible to measure a human's value to their company on some linear scale, when in fact the vast majority of "growth" along that scale simply results in a schedule packed with inane, endless meetings. Meetings in which social network and presentation come to dominate a structure that can be accurately described as a primitive pecking order. The value of expertise rapidly decays in rooms where no one actually does anything anymore.

The advice in this article seems to be that if you just keep your head down and focus on making these impacts, someone, someday is sure to notice. It might take 20 years of being a doormat for the politicians, but you'll have retained your dignity (just perhaps not your keen sense of irony). And on that fabled judgement day, when at last your patience and diligence are recognized by a panel of wizened software elders, you will have earned passage into programmer Valhalla (another dev job, almost certainly reporting to another politician).

My advice, would be to completely ignore all the performative speeches given by HR and others up in the hierarchy about values and goals and whatnot, because what tends to win the day in any group of humans larger than a handful hasn't changed in thousands of years: power. You either have it, or you must ultimately become a sycophant. Anyone outside that binary can be safely ignored, regardless of their impact, and plenty of companies do indeed blunder along on pure momentum, essentially forever, happy to ignore or absorb any accidental impacts originating from the fringes.

As the article itself states, few care about company-wide success, only about whether they will personally benefit in some manner. It's a boring, reductive game in the end, but the good news is that it's really no one's fault, this is just how humans operate. Rather than appealing to the better angels of our nature, as this article nobly attempts, I posit it is better to accept the situation for what it is and make your peace with being stuck at whatever position in the hierarchy you can stomach sleazing your way into. The author would rather have you be an idealist, forever searching for the right group of leaders that will value your principles and your hard work. Feels a bit like titling at windmills to me, and perhaps as though the author is fluffing up their portfolio of "leaderly things I have said" in preparation for their next presentation.

courtf··on Family instability fuels rising nihilism among young men
I expected some level of hand-wringing here in response to this article. Maybe it's something in the water in rural America, but none of this is unusual or extreme, and if this behavior is foreign to you, then you and I grew up in different circumstances.

Getting together with the boys and breaking the law, pushing each other to go a little further each time, is a rite of passage all over the world. Maybe it's practice for the kinds of risks adults sometimes have to take to survive. A life without these formative experiences sounds dull and sterile to me. I sometimes wonder whether the outrage and histrionics people sometimes get into over seemingly trivial stimuli aren't caused by a lack of exposure to games with real stakes.

courtf··on The Four Quadrants of Conformism
I'm not quite so sure we live in a society that protects free inquiry now, and are suddenly in danger of losing that status.
courtf··on How Developers Stop Learning: Rise of the Expert Beginner (2012)
I remember this one, there are lots of good articles on this blog. This one is a little aggressive, but this is a real phenomenon. In many companies, styles and expectations fluctuate too much for anyone to get comfortable for long. Lots of others move glacially, and within those walls, the outside world can barely be heard.

I've bounced around quite a bit myself, but some of the best work I've done has been in situations where I could have slacked off and phoned it in. That was typically prevented by the opportunity to perform challenging work that allowed me to learn, not by fear of falling behind some imaginary peer.

The problem with many workplaces is that challenging, interesting problems are few and far between and that is by design. Why take on the risk to the business by having technical knowledge in-house to solve the hard stuff? It's expensive, and large chunks of that investment can just walk out the door. Most companies would happily pay for solutions from other businesses that specialize, and then ask devs to glue these mismatched pieces into a semi-cohesive whole.

This sort of glue-work is ubiquitous, even in companies that ostensibly specialize in making their own software. How much time is spent wrangling all those amazing, productivity-enhancing dev tools that have proliferated? The goal is typically to offload work for a fraction of what it costs to keep a dev employed. New businesses are cropping up all the time trying to sell tools to the big boys, so they can in turn keep their devs focused on core competencies. The companies that specialize in tooling of course all sell to each other as well, it's a little bit of a cartel, but this endless cycle of tool churn is nothing new.

If you approach this environment as a newbie, and you are concerned about becoming an expert, it's likely that you'll only make progress on that goal in fits and starts. Companies grow, job roles become both over-specified in their requirements and narrower in their responsibilities, and all the while you are expected to learn new tools that allow your employer to save on skilled labor. It's rare to find a job where mentoring and career advancement are given genuine care. Employers have an incentive to keep employees tuned for specific, ever-narrowing roles.

One of the few consistent places I've been able to find learning opportunities has been in start-ups. The overarching trend is the same there too, but at the beginning those roles are not yet so clearly defined and you can bite off as much as you want. You probably won't be rewarded for doing so, and it's a bit of a crapshoot, but it is one small advantage to those environments.

courtf··on Go is boring, and that’s fantastic
I write in Kotlin regularly, and occasionally in Swift, but I use Go for anything server-related, if I can help it. I find the stdlib to be an incredible simplifying force for these programs, not least because deployment is trivial. I guess you could say I belong to the 'b' community. My issues with programming circa 2010 were in part related to tooling, but also just bloated, over-engineered code bases that obscure all basic computing behind layers of nigh impenetrable (but still leaky) abstractions.

I can see how if you became fluent in a nicer language like Swift, it would be frustrating to move to Go and find your typical methods for expressing certain patterns are unavailable. They have been sacrificed for keeping the language overhead small, which in turn creates various warts and edge cases that give more ammunition for being frustrated with the language. I accept these tradeoffs when working in Go because I am typically thinking about concurrency and memory overhead in those projects, and Go makes measuring and reasoning about these properties of your program straightforward.

courtf··on Go is boring, and that’s fantastic
What does it mean to be a "PhD level language?"
courtf··on Why do so few people major in computer science? (2017)
Oh yes, this tool situation is the worst part of our jobs imo. Every time I see a new layer coming in, I instinctively duck.

I hate how much time and brain space these things occupy. I can't even by lazy when working with them, there's always a ton of tiny things to read about and factor in, and often no shortcuts to just getting it over with. You have to be cautious and try to get it right the first time because most of them inevitably involve spending money, and your dumb mistakes will be quickly discovered.

courtf··on Why do so few people major in computer science? (2017)
This is definitely an issue, and well put by the student you spoke to. Who wants to be surrounded by odoriferous, socially challenged young men, in any scenario? I occasionally consider myself as part of that group, and I'm irritated just thinking about us!

What knowledge could be worth the risk to your social life, computers!? You'll make more money and meet more interesting people elsewhere. Even just across the hall, the math class looks like they're having much more fun.

CS 101 should be cracking the enigma machine and defeating the damn nazis, not writing Python (Bleegh!).

courtf··on Why is Kubernetes getting so popular?
Wow, sounds like really challenging work. I still think those skills will be valuable for a long time, especially since they are becoming more rare. I'm curious how you prepared for that job, did a specific degree help? I have only learned what was necessary to solve the problems I've been given, and picked things up from others on the job.
courtf··on Why is Kubernetes getting so popular?
Good questions, and you are onto something here for sure. This wasn't too long ago, around 2014-2015.

This was all for a weather radar app, and you are correct, there really weren't any SLA's, but we had to handle very high loads. We did make use of cloud services for some pieces of the system (there was a database and a small API for some minor bookkeeping, mostly around users). I included those costs in my estimate of monthly expenses. We had lots of caches, for all our JSON and for things like user authentication, which saved us from having to really figure out the database side. The caches were typically push-based, so we didn't let user requests get to the disc, if we could help it.

The vast majority of requests were for those images though, which required moving lots of clumsy geographic data into the GPUs to render map tiles (at high-def and high zooms as well), so the requests were still somewhat costly to serve, even if they didn't hit a database. We were able to get away with a small footprint in the datacenter by making heavy use of CDN caching. Cache lifetimes for the latest weather images were often measured in seconds, and getting those timings right was crucial. Screwing up cache lifetimes would rapidly swamp the system with requests, but the software was good at continuing to keep latency low under heavy load, and degrading gracefully. In fact, the vast majority of bandwidth usage in the datacenters was actually not requests, but streaming geographic data from various government sources. We regularly had 50-100MB/s coming in, and we stored all of it in memory. The GPU machines had 100-200GB of memory, and we used all of it. We had to cycle through that memory pretty rapidly as well, so making sure allocations were low and memory was freed up on time was important.

It may not sound like we had much redundancy, but with all the caches, and each machine being quite powerful, it was better than it sounds in that regard. We often took machines in an out of nginx. The way the graceful degradation worked, we would prioritize the imagery from higher zooms (more zoomed out) so the worst that would happen on a typically day is that some very zoomed in images, in places few people were looking, might be slow or time out.

So, in the end, you are correct, the situations are different. The bank had to store things for a lot longer, and had to uphold more stringent SLA's and the like. That said, I still think they were flushing a lot of cash down the toilet, and making things over complicated :).

courtf··on The Collapsing Leviathan
This is all around Utica, but I imagine it lines up pretty closely with other rustbelt experiences from the region. It sounds a bit grim on second reading, and it can be, but we had a lot of fun. There is a lot of waste too, though.

Edit: Here's a little taste of the local culture, this guy was on tv all the time growing up :) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9FBY2qTLvTM

courtf··on Why is Kubernetes getting so popular?
I honestly couldn't tell you.

What I can tell you, is that the unbelievable bloat in the complexity of our systems is going to bite us in the ass. I'll never forget when I joined a hip fintech company, and the director of eng told us in orientation that we should think of their cloud of services as a thousand points of light, out in space. I knew my days were numbered at exactly that moment. This company had 200k unique users, and they were spending a million dollars a month on CRUD. Granted, banking is its own beast, but I had just come from a company of 10 people serving 3 million daily users 10k requests a second for images drawn on the fly by GPUs. Our hosting costs never exceeded 20k per month, and the vast majority of that was cloudflare.

Deploying meant compiling a static binary and copying it to the 4-6 hardware servers we ran in a couple racks, one rack on each side of the continent. We were drunk by 11am most of the time.

Today, it's apparently much more impressive if you need to have a team of earnest, bright-eyed Stanford grads constantly tweaking and fiddling with 100 knobs in order to keep systems running. Enter kubernetes.

courtf··on The nightmare that colleges face this fall
Yep. Thousands of schools are going to close down in the next decade unless they get a bailout. The elite schools will be just fine, this will all happen at 2nd and 3rd rate schools. No one is paying those prices for a severely reduced experience unless the brand is incredibly strong.
courtf··on The Collapsing Leviathan
The elite schools have always been a caste system, we just convinced ourselves after WW2 that the entire country belonged in a global upper caste. The notion seems just as absurd today as it did in the 1800s.

I attended public high school in rural upstate NY in the 90s and scored a 35 on the ACT when I was 16, without preparing at all. With some amount of studying I had a 1440 on the SAT that same year (1998 or 99) and didn't bother taking it again. I've always scored well on these tests, but it never translated into much acclaim or academic success. I smoked weed at lunchtime every single day my junior and senior years of high school, which was the kind of achievement that gets celebrated in those parts. For a while there we all dropped acid on the weekends too, the winters upstate are brutal. Unlike most of my friends, I went to college where I slacked my way through a 2nd rung liberal arts school with a 3.7 in subject (mathematics), graduating in 2005. By 2010 I was in a hurry to leave the miserable customer service/QA engineer role I had worked for 3 years at Surveymonkey.com, so I took the GRE. After about a week of half-assed prep in the evening I scored a 790 math 670 verbal 6.0 writing, enough to get me a scholarship for my Masters. Turns out going to school to escape your shitty job isn't the best decision, but I didn't have a lot of other options. Surveymonkey is worth what, a couple billion today? Well they didn't treat me very well back in 2007. In today's climate of online outrage I probably could have parlayed that mistreatment into something, I am a protected species afterall (gay).

From my perspective, the problem with this whole system is that smart kids are not challenged enough. Everything is too easy in public school, and bad habits are never corrected. There's also no role-models to show smart kids that they might go somewhere in life. Upstate New York is in a permanent state of decline, there's nothing these kids can look forward to and they have no money to go anywhere else. Depression and doubt, difficult home lives, access to all manner of drugs, child abuse etc. The best results from my high school came from a few Indian immigrant families who sent their daughters off to Harvard and the like. We still got those girls to drink and smoke weed with us though :).

There was another local (ie, white) kid in high school who was really smart and smoked lots of weed and got into trouble the same way I did. A real math talent. We took a double period of AP physics together right after lunch, so we were both high as hell in the back of the classroom. We both scored 5's on the test at the end of the year, too. He is a seasonal worker now, puts up tents for country fairs and the like during the summer.

The alcoholism in upstate New York is something people out in polite society would not believe. Lots of DUIs in my old friend group. These guys are conscious when they blow a .4 (or higher) on the breathalyzer. One ex-marine friend is a fire jumper (seasonal as well) and went to the hospital with a .6! He was joking with the doctor while they were pumping his stomach, a real character. No small number of these kids are dead.

I guess what I'm trying to say is, ain't nothing new under the sun.

courtf··on Trump signs executive order targeting protections for social media companies
Twitter, Facebook etc created this problem (exemplified by Trump) and continue to benefit from it. Social media has significantly amplified expressions outrage and taken an active role in spreading those messages, which in turn has given rise to all manner of demagogues and populists. If the day ever comes that these companies are forced to atone for the corrosive effect they have had on discourse and politics all over the world, it can't happen to a more deserving group.
courtf··on Idea Generation
> It’s important to be in the right kind of environment, and around the right kind of people.

Namely, people who went to an elite school (which inevitably implies they have rich parents) and aren't going to burden your fledgling cash grab with any world-weary ideas about integrity. Extra points if no one involved in the project has any programming talent. That frees up lots of time for coming up with brilliant ideas.

courtf··on A third of Americans now show signs of clinical anxiety or depression
I agree, the meaning of life is just that simple: to be alive. No greater meaning exists, and that's fine. We can live life without so much meta-analysis.

To arrive there though, we often need to see other personal sources of meaning exposed as illusory, or at least I did. I am trying to describe that process in the third paragraph.

courtf··on A third of Americans now show signs of clinical anxiety or depression
I believe the existential crisis so many are experiencing has been caused by the pandemic, but perhaps not in the way one might expect when approaching the problem rationally. Yes, we are more isolated, and perhaps concerned for the safety of ourselves or our loved ones, or even for some abstract concept of community or society, but depression is characterized by anhedonia: the inability to feel pleasure. Are we all sitting around, so preoccupied by the crises of the day that we have become numb to pleasure? That doesn't describe depression, although perhaps anxiety. I would describe depression as the loss of most strong feelings, not only pleasurable ones, and that is why death becomes so alluring: fear of death has been numbed as well.

No, an existential crisis is rooted in the meaning, or lack thereof, we are able to ascribe to our lives. And the pandemic has in many ways restricted our connections to those sources of meaning. Whatever stories we were telling ourselves about our life's purpose, the plotlines we imagined for ourselves, have been disrupted. The student has had their university all but taken from them. They cannot experience it in quite the same tangible way as they once did. The same is true for the worker who derives his meaning from labor. For many, that connection has been damaged, if not severed. It is the loss of meaning that accompanies the dawning realization that our sources of meaning were nothing more than illusions to begin with.

We realize now that life goes on without these guiding influences; that the rituals we perform do not in fact earn us the favor of the Gods. We come upon the idea that perhaps life really is meaningless and that we were in fact only existing previously because of a foolish, irrational faith. It has been thrust upon us, entirely by happenstance (and not because of any rational deduction or brilliance on our parts), that we are fools, rubbing our prayer beads and voluntarily deluding ourselves into thinking that some bit of our finite, meaningless lives could somehow persist alongside the infinite.

"For man to be able to live he must either not see the infinite, or have such an explanation of the meaning of life as will connect the finite with the infinite."

courtf··on A third of Americans now show signs of clinical anxiety or depression
We don't really know this with such certainty. Our records have gaps and only extend a few thousand years back, at most. Even then, we often only have bits and pieces for certain populations. It's a large stretch to generalize over human history.
courtf··on A third of Americans now show signs of clinical anxiety or depression
I wouldn't be so sure, history is an awful long time and we don't have great records for most of it.
courtf··on One Word Broke C
I see something similar happening with functional programming. Beyond measurable improvements (ie, in error rate, etc) there is often a mindset where if a language does not implement the latest syntactic patterns, then the language cannot be considered truly functional. HN seems a breeding ground for these sentiments, and adherents can be quite self-righteous.

Out in the untamed wilds of the broader industry (and the further you move away from the Stanford sphere) I have found that fanaticism, of all sorts, tends to taper off, to be replaced mostly with the mundane tasks of churning out software for money.

Of course, no matter where you hail from, the influence of C is inescapable. Yet, provincial priests are mostly concerned with budgetary constraints and deadlines. If switching to Scala will make hiring 10% easier, then by all means.

courtf··on Simple Systems Have Less Downtime
I think there are multiple levels to this phenomenon. With Go in particular, after having used it in some high performance scenarios (10k request per second for images that are rendered on the fly by GPUs, on systems holding 200GB of binary radar imagery in memory, that also need to ingest 50MB per second of new radar data), I've seen that the simplicity of the language is not a hindrance in these areas.

Edit: if you find yourself spending most of your time trying to come up with the perfect abstraction, Go may really piss you off, I won't deny that, it's not a strength. You have to be satisfied with 'good enough' and move on, solving edge if/when they arise. Go often encourages moving toward the concrete, and you can solve generic problems in really basic ways sometimes. As an example, I was writing a DAG server last year, and coming up with ways to move data between vertices in the graph in a general way. Rather than getting out my abstractions, I just pass around []byte, and leave the interpretation of those bytes up to each vertex (often just a type cast). I personally find this refreshing, and while there are costs to doing it this way, with a few basic helper funcs, you can get 95% of what you want from a generic server like this without doing a lot of modeling.

courtf··on Second U.S. coronavirus case of unknown origin confirmed in Santa Clara County
Apparently, there are some conditions where it can go airborne, but most transmissions are by droplet. I'll amend my comment. Healthcare providers will been using airborne protocols, which was where i got the idea.
courtf··on Second U.S. coronavirus case of unknown origin confirmed in Santa Clara County
I did make a typo, I should have used "incubation," not "gestation."

It is not infectious during incubation, by definition. Then there is a "prodrome" period of a few days during which you would be infectious.

courtf··on Second U.S. coronavirus case of unknown origin confirmed in Santa Clara County
Thanks! Fixed it
courtf··on Second U.S. coronavirus case of unknown origin confirmed in Santa Clara County
My husband is a career public health clinician who organizes vaccination clinics (has given out hundreds of thousands of vaccines for infectious disease, many for free via grants). At the state level here in US, he has mounted responses to H1N1, ebola, measles and now this coronavirus. The conventional wisdom around this outbreak, right from the beginning, has been that almost everyone on the planet will be exposed. It's no surprise this is hopping around stateside.

The virus has a two week incubation period, during which the host is not infectious, but also has no symptoms, making tracking vectors difficult. In addition, after incubation there are a couple of days where the host is highly infectious, and still has no symptoms. The term for this period is "prodrome" (pre syndrome). Under certain circumstances, it's also airborne, which is can be a problem for providers. It's spreading fast because of these characteristics.

Similar to flu, it is expected that this virus will find enough hosts to essentially never stop circulating. Expect to see it again next year, and the year after, etc, in perpetuity.

Get your flu shots! You might prevent someone from getting very sick or dying, even if you don't see symptoms yourself.

courtf··on The Zen of Go
A few hot responses! (all in good fun)

> polyglot, blub, functional paradigms

Damn, one more I would have had bingo.

> Go is actively hostile to functional programming

Well, it does have genuine first class functions, lambdas and closures.

> you add a try/catch/throw, and you don't even need to look at the exception! 99% of programs need only one exception handler

pretty sure this is the exact reason Go does not have exceptions

> It's a better C. But as a language to take over the world: Not a chance.

Oh, you sweet summer child.

courtf··on The dystopian world of software engineering interviews
I love these anecdotes, thank you!

The greatest programmer I've had the privilege of working closely with could easily pass most technical screens, but he's an odd fellow, and I don't think could handle the stress and anxiety of these crazy interviews. Lots of diamonds in the rough out there, but I suppose large companies understand that and just consider it acceptable loss.

courtf··on The dystopian world of software engineering interviews
Not sure if they were using this exact method, but I did interview at a place that had a long, grueling process (series of interviews, coding challenge, etc). They also asked for every employer back to high school, as well as contact info for supervisor for all of those jobs, which of course was ridiculous. I did enjoy seeing them taken aback when I provided that information and, despite being in my early 30s, having 20+ jobs listed that included things like "fruit picker," "janitor" and "waiter at gay bar". I blew away the algorithmic coding challenge, mostly because it was a take-home test (I have flubbed some white-boarding ones pretty badly).

The company was almost entirely men, many with quite obvious and malignant ego issues. Their method for making technical decisions was to get all ~20 of them into a conference room and argue about how things should be done, with the loudest, most forceful arguments tending to win. The entire time I worked there, the socially dominant clique was primarily concerned with moving their stack into Kubernetes, despite having almost no traffic that I could discern. I wouldn't say I was impressed overall, people who didn't fit the mold had little chance of making career progress, and I personally felt I had more experience and could code circles around the majority of them.

← PreviousPage 6 of 9Next →