HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

craigsmansion

2,304 karma · joined August 20, 2016

submissionscomments
craigsmansion··on Stallman Still Heading the GNU Project
Wikipedia states:

"Bushnell [..] is employed by Google LLC. He is a member of Saint Mark's Episcopal Church."

With all due respect to his employment and religious beliefs, that is not the sort of person to provide a better understanding of Stallman, in general or psychologically.

craigsmansion··on Stallman Still Heading the GNU Project
> have described him as a "creep".

"Creep" is a description of how attractive you personally feel someone is.

By that rationale it should be okay for someone to describe her as "hot", and question her professional capacity on that assessment, e.g. "she is way too attractive to be the EFF's director of cybersecurity", that is, casting aspersions because of personal preferences.

craigsmansion··on Stallman Still Heading the GNU Project
> Some pretty responsible and knowledgeable people such as the EFF's head of cybersecurity have described him as a "creep"

Seems like it's a pastime over at the EFF who can be outraged the most in the vilest manner (senior staff technologist):

https://twitter.com/cooperq/status/1173802200901939200

From their home page:

"The leading nonprofit defending digital privacy, free speech, and innovation."

Maybe it's time to stop supporting the EFF until they decide to re-focus on their core mission instead of being a den of hypocricy.

craigsmansion··on Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007)
Wondering about your effort to maintain an argument in good faith, I read up a little:

"mav3rick: What about the KoolAid that HN drinks against anything Facebook, Google ?"

"mav3rick: He seems like an out and out terrorist."

I think these are indicative you will say whatever it takes to discredit rms, because he takes a stand against everything you believe in.

You are being dishonest in your motivations. I think I'll conveniently ignore you all together.

craigsmansion··on Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007)
Again, please read what I wrote. I'm starting to doubt you are providing an argument in good faith here as you are constantly generalising.

If some religious members of an audience, who are very serious about their faith, go to see a known outspoken atheist, maybe that wasn't the best idea. As far as I know the St. IGNUcius skit is fairly well received in general.

craigsmansion··on Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007)
> You get to decide how much time is enough to exonerate someone of all accusations i.e. 1 week

Not at all. Again, something I didn't say or imply. Please make an effort to read what I write, not what you think I wrote (e.g. "That's a long time", empatically not: "That's enough time"). If something substantial comes up at a later time, I will make sure to critically read it.

> You say that other accusations are "too old"

I said that one specific accusation is probably too old to retrieve the exact words and circumstances, and as such can be considered unsubstantiated.

> this is precisely why victims are afraid to come forward in every such case.

What case(s) are you referring to? To put it differently: what, exactly, do you think Stallman is "getting away" with here? And why do you think he's getting away with it?

> No one takes them seriously and in fact vilifies them more than the alleged perpetrator.

That is of course very regrettable, but again, how does Stallman fit in here? You can't just take a person you obviously dislike, ascribe various characteristics and motivations to them, and then rile against that.

> Have fun being a "Knight of RMS", defend him on his most egregious qualities.

I'm not having "fun", and I don't see why you would assume that. I find the whole situation very regrettable.

craigsmansion··on Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007)
You are aware that the St. IGNUcius bit is a spoof on dogmatic religion, right?

Maybe that offends you as a religious person, but it's hardly fair to hold that against Stallman whose audiences are usually mainly fellow atheists, or religious people who can tolerate being the subject of a bit of light satire.

craigsmansion··on Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007)
>You are part of the same system that vilifies assault / harassment victims

"I'm out of arguments, so you're just a ..."

Please don't do that.

>by saying accusations are "too old" / "he / she isn't remembering correctly".

It's been nearly a week now. That's a long time for people to come forward with police reports, official complaints, etc. So far there is "Knight for Justice (also: hot ladies)", and, "I hear people have spider plants in their offices to keep him away."

>You have the gall to call anyone who does care SJWs,

I do? Feel free to quote my stuff back at me. I know you won't, because you can't, so you resort to making stuff up about things you hope I would have said.

Please don't make stuff up, it's all there for you to read.

>I guess I didn't expect anything more from you.

I'm sorry if I disappointed you. But I can only start caring the moment someone presents me with something substantial to care about.

craigsmansion··on Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007)
> your narrative of sexism in the software industry being a mostly made-up issue

Is this what this is all about? Stallman has approximately 0 sway in the "software industry".

I'm sure it is a real problem, but Stallman is neither the cause nor the solution to it. I would look into how paying high salaries for unethical work would attract abusive people, and one shouldn't want to work in those industries in the first place.

craigsmansion··on Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007)
Of course that's not a coincidence, hence the ellipses of omission. I left out the bits that weren't factual. Even then your "Asking female coworkers to lay down topless on a mattress in his office" comes out of nowhere.

"He kept the door open to proudly showcase" could have easily been "He kept to door shut to hide his actions", that is: both cases would be equally damning from the writer's perspective, and hinges only on their "implications that went with it" which are their invention alone.

Facts remaining, he had a mattress in his office. He left his door open. Sometimes people were sitting on the bed.

> "it happened long ago, so it isn't true"

No. It happened a long time ago. People, over time, remember the emotional impact of something on them, but no longer the precise wording. She remembers the gist of someone talking about suicide, because that's what she thought he meant. Without the exact wording and cirumstances, it can be very difficult to figure out what transpired. So it's not "it isn't true" or "she must be lying", but the account is unsubstantiated, likely irretrievably so, because "it happened a long time ago."

> completely disregarding the fact

I don't disregard them, I check them one by one, and so far I found them lacking.

Why are you angry at me for reading what other people said before believing them at face value?

> that all these accusations have been corroborated by witnesses, ranging from people interviewed on several media and dozens of reports and online comments from people who claim to have worked with him over the years, let alone the several unrelated victims of his "urban legends", and most of all, the fact that people repeatedly let him know about his attitude and he didn't give a damn.

Please provide links outside of twitter. So far most accusations lead back to the initial article on medium by Salem G.

> In short, yet another big, somehow coordinated witch hunt by overly sensitive SJWs.

I don't know, and frankly, I don't care. I read the allegations, try to find the various sources, and try to put them into a logical context. I guess I'm simply a Knight for Justice (also: old weirdos)

craigsmansion··on Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007)
> Asking female coworkers to lay down topless on a mattress in his office.

Even the initial accusation doesn't try to push the story that far:

"He literally used to have a mattress on the floor of his office. [..] (the mattress was also known to have shirtless people lounging on it…)"

Person has sleeping accommodation in place where he lives (odd thought it may be). Sometimes people use it as chair. No mentions of requests or toplessness.

> -Threatening a colleague to kill himself if he/she didn't go on a date with him.

Unsubstantiated: saying something like "I can't imagine life without you" can be interpreted just like that depending on a variety of circumstances. That was also decades ago.

> Posting up signs in his workplace along the lines of "Knight for Justice (Also: Hot Ladies)".

Really now? Incidentally also the only one of your accusations of which there is evidence instead of hearsay or urban legends. Furthermore, "a sign" not "signs".

craigsmansion··on Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007)
I understand ignoring her goes counter to your notion of justice, and this is somehow fair play. You have every right to doubt her, but you should realise it doesn't matter.

No matter how much doubt you could reveal about her person, you will never see a headline: "MIT alumna found to be axe-murderer, RMS cleared and re-instated as FSF president".

She doesn't matter, and any attack on her will be seen as petty at best by those who only read the articles.

Any effort expended on her could have been expended on dispelled one of the falsehoods being propagated about rms.

The truth takes time and patience, and you can't expedite matters by stooping to the levels of those maliciously perpetuating this smear campaign.

craigsmansion··on Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007)
Please don't.

Salem G. made a mistake in desiring to address a problem that is worth discussing, but did so with a hasty ill-conceived reaction constructed through gossip and hearsay. It shouldn't happen, but it does.

The various publications should have checked their facts and performed due diligence, but something, anything MIT related is money in the bank right now. They sold out.

Breaking down Salem for her mistake isn't going to help Free Software, rms, or the FSF, but reason and facts, and holding the publications accountable for their disinformation by correcting it, will.

craigsmansion··on Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007)
> I sincerely hope that there will be people in the FSF

There are: https://www.fsfla.org/%7Elxoliva/

But apart from being next in line, he's also next in line: https://twitter.com/sarahmei/status/1174371580547223553

craigsmansion··on Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007)
> on a university mailing list has direct negative effects for a lot of people.

That very mailing list was about to arbitrarily accuse a dead innocent man of a crime to help provide cover for actual criminals still walking the halls at MIT.

This charade around Stallman is an injustice against Epstein's victims, the decent people at MIT, and Minsky.

craigsmansion··on Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007)
Some might have found it funny, others might have found it tacky. It's the way jokes work. Important here is that his is not the first time it happened or where it was used disproportionally against him:

https://stallman.org/articles/texas.html

From the above, from someone at TI he met later who was amused by his joke:

"The plant incident, which I found rather humorous, provided a reason for people in the later camp to become offended. This was convenient as they had been looking for one. They were subsequently able to blow it to suitable proportions to gain the attention of management. "

Stallman will always offend people because he speaks about their unethical behaviour. Those offended will use whatever he does as an excuse.

craigsmansion··on Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007)
> If he’s defending

That's a big "if"

Stallman was reviled not for things he didn't do, but for thoughts he didn't think.

craigsmansion··on Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007)
> and also afraid of plants

from someone who actually worked with him:

"p.s.: In the closet-sized "office" Bushnell, McGrath, and I shared for a time we did have some spider plants as part of a running silly joke. They did not actually scare RMS away OF COURSE"

https://archive.is/7qepC

craigsmansion··on Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007)
Those are terrible starting points.

For the actual background on the current chain of events at MIT:

https://sterling-archermedes.github.io/index.html

For earlier allegations, take the original sources including quotes and references:

https://stallman.org/archives/2006-mar-jun.html

(note: there are many more archives. This also gives you an idea of the effort it must have taken to find those few "damning" posts, and to skew those out of context)

craigsmansion··on Richard Stallman’s Exit Heralds a New Era in Tech
Someone took the time to actually sift through all the accusations and put them in context.

https://sterling-archermedes.github.io/index.html

This is only about the publications on medium, Vice, and The Daily Beast, not this new one in Wired, who apparently also discovered there's good money in selling pyres.

craigsmansion··on The media's hit piece on Richard Stallman
So "no" then? Unless you mean him asking for a date and people saying "no", which is in no way related to "abuse of his positions".

Words matter, even if you can't feel bothered to motivate them, which is the problem in a nutshell in the first place.

craigsmansion··on The media's hit piece on Richard Stallman
How about not alleging dead people are violent child rapists without any evidence, and then, when being called out on your false allegations, create a media storm of manufactured outrage to punish the person who called you out on them?
craigsmansion··on The media's hit piece on Richard Stallman
> It dismisses the decades of Stallman's abuse of his positions at FSF and MIT

Does this extend beyond hearsay and having a "Knight for Justice (also: hot ladies)" sign on his door?

Also, where do these "decades" suddenly come from? His most vociferous accusers on social media wouldn't have been alive, or at least far too young to have attended MIT.

> which are the real reason he should have been removed from power.

Power? Exactly what power can a "visiting scientist"--a made-up quirky title, wield?

Or do you mean his power to travel around the world and talk about Free Software?

Do you even know who he is?

craigsmansion··on Richard M. Stallman resigns
RMS was pointing out inaccuracies in how a deceased colleague who was being accused of a heinous crime might simply have slept with a prostitute, if at all (which turns out probably wasn't the case).

> This is a man who said something wildly inappropriate in an MIT forum and got fired.

This is a man who said something mildly inappropriate in a forum, as is his wont.

> He deserved it.

A completely appropriate and reasonable verdict, no doubt. Doubts are for unreasonable people, of which one you are not.

> I welcome anyone to provide a counter-argument.

Somehow I doubt that.

craigsmansion··on Stallman's final interview as FSF president
Yes, the actually unpalatable elements of the FLOSS community are crawling out of the woodworks now. I would have never expected the Software Freedom Conservancy and the EFF to be amongst them though.

Poor Richard, having his life's work usurped by the ankle biters and the self-aggrandising.

craigsmansion··on The End of the Golden Era of American Chess
If it becomes too boring, the rules might be modified. Castling and en-passant were not always a given.

Something simple like a draw is 1/4 point for white, 3/4 point for black, might re-invigorate matches in classical format.

craigsmansion··on End Software Patents (2007)
Let's not pussyfoot around then. Let's enforce software patents rigorously, and do it retroactively.

Now we can make it easy on ourselves and cut a single cheque of what amounts to basically all the value in the world to Don Knuth. I'm sure he can pass various bits on to the other stake holders.

Congratulations:

- The technology company you work for is now out of business, you're jobless.

- Don Knuth is now Emperor of the planet.

...

which sounds like a pretty good state of affairs, really. Satire isn't supposed to end up like that.

However, bottom line remains: no one who would be a real stakeholder in the field is in favour of software patents. Software is mathematical; again, no experts have ever argued software isn't mathematics, almost by definition.

craigsmansion··on E.U.’S New Digital Czar: ‘Most Powerful Regulator of Big Tech’
The abundance of cookie warnings is a sign of the sorry state of the Web, not of bureaucrats gone wild.
craigsmansion··on (Un)Informed Consent: Studying GDPR Consent Notices in the Field [pdf]
Almost 100%.

I'm always pleasantly surprised when some outlet does seem understand the GDPR, or at least not weasel their way out of it in a most obvious manner.

Following a link to theatlantic.com just a few hours go was such a pleasant surprise.

What's more: I noticed I trusted the reporting more. If an outlet can't or won't understand the GDPR, why should I trust their journalism?

It also made me wonder why, apart from non-deceptive "I accept" and "I do not accept" options, there was a "Set my preferences" option. Turns out they also offer cookie tracking without 3rd parties, which is fair enough, I guess.

The bottom line is that it's a sad affair that transparency and clarity are not a given for serious news outlets and protecting their readers' privacy is very much seen as optional.

It's nice to see some--if few, do try to make an effort. I hope the effort is enough to give them a competitive edge, at least until the various enforcing agencies get around to weeding out the non-compliant ones.

craigsmansion··on Margrethe Vestager stays on as EU competition head in blow for tech giants
There's "tech" meaning mostly "data-mining/advertising" and "tech" as short for "technology".

As long as the EU remains strong in actual technology, the EU doesn't need to reinvent itself on the spot. As far as being "stuck behind for a long time" is concerned, if it remains behind in corporate surveillance and privacy trampling, that's alright by me.

← PreviousPage 4 of 19Next →