HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

craigsmansion

2,304 karma · joined August 20, 2016

submissionscomments
craigsmansion··on No CS Degree – Interviews with self-taught developers
"This 22 year old self-taught PHP developer earns $15k a month and lives in an Austrian farmhouse"

I mean, f*cking seriously?

Yeah, that's harsh, but such a headline's an insult to those with a CS degree and serious self-taught developers alike.

To those who made this stay on the front page: given you're competent, you already make the same or more money as those with a CS degree, even if you might know less about the fundamentals, get over it! Upvoting cruft like this isn't going to vindicate your choice.

craigsmansion··on Melissa Di Donato Appointed CEO of SUSE
From the end of the press release:

``About SUSE

SUSE, the world’s largest independent open source company''

"Wait, isn't RedHat the lar... oooh, someone at SuSE marketing is on the ball."

craigsmansion··on Two Years With Emacs as a CEO and now CTO (2018)
> emacs is, by default, worse than $IDE

Depends on the language really.

For anything Lisp[0], Haskell, Ocaml, Idris, Coq, I haven't found a better development environment than Emacs. Probably because Emacs is usually one of the first to support a lot of languages and then maintains the lead.

> The world has moved on, emacs is a relic of the old world and I finally feel fine in saying that.

«It works. I’m grateful for things that work. Not many things do work, you know.»

0. except maybe Clojure?

craigsmansion··on Microsoft is investing $1B in OpenAI
> I think the parent has made their position pretty clear through their employment choices,

Their employer has just received a 1 billion dollar cash investment to futz around with computers. I don't think the employment choice is some sort of personal sacrifice here.

The level of skin here is a cushy guaranteed job for years to come until the next AI-winter hits, likely set into motion by such very claims of "AGI" being near or feasible.

"AGI" is good marketing for getting money to research real AI, ostensibly on the path to "AGI", but if one drives it too far, one might up retarding the whole field as the hype winds down (again).

craigsmansion··on Microsoft is investing $1B in OpenAI
> At what point would you deem it a good idea to start working on AGI safety?

I don't know, but I'd say after a definition of "AGI" has been accepted that can be falsified against, and actually turn it into a scientific endeavour.

> The tricky thing with all of this is we have no idea what an appropriate timeline looks like.

We do. As things are it's undetermined, since we don't even know what's it's supposed to mean.

> So given all of that, wouldn't it make sense to start working on these problems now?

What problems? We can't even define the problems here with sufficient rigor. What's there to discuss?

craigsmansion··on Australians making music with computer code
Some other Free Software programs for live-coding, as the practice is called:

Fluxus (https://www.pawfal.org/fluxus/) with scheme

Tidal Cycles (https://tidalcycles.org/index.php/Welcome) with Haskell

craigsmansion··on Anaxagoras Was Exiled for Claiming the Moon Was a Rock
Thanks for your reply and links.

After trying some more angles, it seems "up" and "down" lighting makes the difference between "innies" and "outies", which hints the brain's interpretation of lights and shadows is in play here. "Left" or "right" doesn't seem to make a big difference.

craigsmansion··on Anaxagoras Was Exiled for Claiming the Moon Was a Rock
Wow, indeed.

My thanks to both you and the OP. I had to replicate this to see if it wasn't some sort of trickery.

Frankly this is a little unsettling; why am I primed to to recognise something "with the light source coming from the upper left"? Is it an effect of previous continuous exposure or a general principle of how the brain interprets lights and shadows?

craigsmansion··on Skills Poor Programmers Lack
The question is: if making a schema to distinguish between "good" and "poor/naive", can one do so whilst keeping biases in check, viz. without inadvertently putting one's own understanding (or unknown lack of understanding) in the "good" camp?

Unless you're EWD, the answer is "no". No you cannot.

craigsmansion··on Vulnerabilities found in GE anesthesia machines
Is suspect we're referring to different types of proof here. The sort of formal proof I refer to guarantees that the software will never display unspecified behaviour; your procedures are now backed by mathematical definitions with known properties.

It's not about security. It's about the software functioning correctly so no functional updates are necessary, diminishing the need for remote updates and all the security problems that bring along.

Even if remote access is needed to conveniently store various data in a different location there is no need to run everything on the same level. Smartphones are mass-produced computers that separate concerns with having a baseband and a main cpu. There is no reason a medical device could not have such a separation. One OS to keep the device working correctly under all circumstances, one OS to slap networking and interfacing on.

I don't expect the medical technology industry to change quickly, but as things are they are adopting bad practices of software development and moving in the wrong direction.

"If problems pop up, we'll update it later remotely" should not be an acceptable mindset for some classes of computer equipment.

craigsmansion··on Vulnerabilities found in GE anesthesia machines
> That it does what it's supposed to?

and that is doesn't do what is not supposed to do.

As for your second point, if you could provide some background reading for that, I would appreciate it. I know of Knuth jokingly stating "Beware of bugs in the above code; I have only proved it correct, not tried it", but if he or someone else wrote a more serious paper on the occurrence of software errors in proved software, I would appreciate a link. A proof should prove against all software errors--if it doesn't I'm eager to learn more.

As for your third point: software errors are a solved problem, but as you noted, it's a hard (expensive) solution. The solutions also currently may limit functionality, so it's unfortunately not applicable everywhere, but some classes of software should warrant it.

In my view medical devices that can directly interact with a patient's physiology is one of them.

craigsmansion··on Vulnerabilities found in GE anesthesia machines
> First, how does the machine get updates?

By eliminating updates. Why isn't software that runs on such machines proven correct? Yes, it's expensive, but medical equipment commands a premium price since it's supposed to meet stringent standards regardless. There's no reason to not up the standards for the software they run.

craigsmansion··on Apple reveals App Store takedown demands by governments
And by "he says he doesn't know" you mean he meticulously, in paragraphs, explains the difference between GNU and linux, and how he basically started the GNU operating system out of a desire for freedom, but that he technically or philosophically has nothing to do with the linux kernel, which is correct, technically and otherwise?

I guess he doesn't know a lot then.

craigsmansion··on Japan resumes commercial whaling after 30 years
We, as a species, are also any other animal.

At the moment, there's very little we can tell about the exact make up of their intelligence.

Imagine, with your current intelligence, growing up in a world where you can move in three dimensions which has poor visibility but carries sounds very well. There are no fixed spots, so there is no "here". You also have no opposable thumbs, so you will never create tools or written records.

Now imagine that evolving over eons and generation upon generation: you might end up with a world view, a culture, and thought process that is complete alien.

What we observe as whale-songs might simply be them re-telling their Edda in an Ent-like fashion. We might be inadvertently hunting members of a species that is intellectually equal to ours, but too alien to understand.

craigsmansion··on As a system programming language, C still deserves learning today
Very much so. But there are many architectures and C is a reasonable "portable assembler" of sorts, so having an inkling of a single ISA and a grasp of C will help a lot in de-mystifying more complicated data structures in any language on most architectures.

But you are correct that C by itself is not quite enough.

craigsmansion··on Dijkstra Archive (1930-2002)
https://www.cs.utexas.edu/users/EWD/transcriptions/EWD01xx/E...
craigsmansion··on The New Socialism
Liberally licensed software is also Free Software, just like copyleft licenses. One can argue which type is "more free", and many have, and many more will, but ultimately they're all Free Software licenses.
craigsmansion··on The New Socialism
The article itself is a bit of a train-wreck, but hopefully it can provide some insight for "open source" people to how they are perceived, if the article is anything to go by.

- You work for free, and should work for free.

- You sharing your programming is equated with sharing whatever non-sense on Flickr and Twitter.

- Collective action and sharing is always positive, even if it erodes privacy and strictly gains commercial 3rd parties, because it's "culture".

In short, your ideals and ideas are being co-opted by large businesses and pundits, and in return you get to be part of "a movement" that might not benefit you.

Please be aware of that when large corporations "warm up" towards open source, or when pundits proclaim that, in effect, you should be more "pragmatic" and go with the flow or miss out on the revolution.

In contrast, Free Software, even if considered crusty and old-fashioned, is about one thing: respecting the freedoms of users.

That single thing can facilitate making great, fun communities; it can create a solid basis to boost commerce and enhance capitalism; it can serve to prop up your libertarian Utopia. It can help with all these things and many more, but it is none of these things.

craigsmansion··on Only 37 dogs of each breed can have the same name
> There is nothing to suggest this, and overwhelming evidence to the contrary.

I'm willing to read a good citation here if you have one, but the "overwhelming evidence" lies on the other side where docile and submissive specimens of fighting breeds and aggressive and dominant specimens of family-friendly breeds can be easily observed. There is plenty to suggest this.

> No, some subset of purebreds will have genetic defects. Just as some subset of mutts will.

These subsets are not equal. I'll clarify in a bit.

> Why? They are doing the same thing you are complaining about, just using a specific cross of two breeds rather than a specific single breed.

That's not how genetics work. Inbreeding increases the number of recessive genes floating around in the gene pool, increasing the number of carriers.

Say, for simplicity's sake, hip dysplasia is bound to a single recessive gene. If you cross a breed that is prone to hip dysplasia with one that isn't, none of the offspring will suffer from hip dysplasia, and it will halve the number of carriers of the recessive gene in the genetic lineup.

Do that a couple of generations with different breeds, and it starts becoming very unlikely that two recessive genes for dysplasia will match up.

Now understand that a lot of genetic diseases are the result of the interactions of many genes of which the exact mechanism is unclear, and it should become clear there is no solid way to prevent a disease from expressing itself through careful monitoring.

For now, the best way to guarantee a healthy dog is to mix in new genes and keep the gene pool healthy, which is very much the opposite of breeding for conformity.

craigsmansion··on Only 37 dogs of each breed can have the same name
Sorry, but no.

Breeders, even if ethical, are part of the problem. Just because they try and reduce the chance of genetic defects by avoiding direct inbreeding, it's still a minor statistical manipulation.

> (and therefore the parents, grandparents behavioral traits)?

Behavioural traits (with very few exceptions) vary more widely in between individuals within a breed than from breed to breed.

I know people can get very defensive about their best friends, but purebreds will have genetic deficiencies. That's no reason to love your current pooch any less, but do give cross-breeds some consideration for your next member of the pack.

As silly as "labradoodle" sounds, these people have the right idea.

craigsmansion··on My Personal Journey from MIT to GPL
> if you write 9,990 lines of proprietary code and include 10 lines of GPL code, the whole 10,000 becomes GPL, right?

No. The 9990 lines remain under whatever license you desire. The 10 lines remain GPL. You can't distribute the whole work.

> And then the whole 10,000 becomes public property according to the GPL

The GPL doesn't make software "public property", whatever you think that entails.

> so the person who wrote the 9,990 lines of proprietary code starves to death and dies because you can't monetize public property,

No capable programmers starve to death, or even earn poorly because of the GPL. Approximately 90% of programming work is in-house development.

> because you can't monetize public property,

I don't know what this means; the GPL isn't about commercial software but proprietary software.

>and our food system only accepts money in exchange for food, not "good deeds" or whatever?

Again, I don't know what this means or what money (or even food), have to do with anything.

>If so, then this is what people mean when they say the GPL is a "general public virus".

If so, they are woefully misinformed and shouldn't be writing any sort of detraction lightly disguised as a very poor analysis online when the GPL is being discussed.

craigsmansion··on When murderers were hanged quickly (2014)
> yet be totally OK with locking people up for the rest of their lives

There are countries where prisons are not exploitative hellholes, and locking people up for life is not a form of punishment but an acknowledgement that society has failed them, so there is no point in making the prisoner's incarceration as unpleasant as possible.

If it's "cruel and unusual", it's your society that makes it cruel and unusual. It doesn't have to be that way.

craigsmansion··on Firefox: The Evolution of a Brand
"It’s a radical act to be optimistic about the future of the internet."

With half a billion dollar in revenue your radical act amounts to "be optimistic about the future of the Internet" and share that now through a branding exercise? No actual radical acts that would actually improve the future of the Internet?

"We disrupt the status quo because it’s the right thing to do."

Unless the status quo is advertising, or microsoft, or google, or drm in the w3c.

"Build better products."

Maybe start with "product", singular. Also maybe stop talking about your browser as a "product" that needs to be peddled.

"Open. Open-minded. Open-hearted. Open source. An open book."

Not open-web though, only fuzzy and easy feel-good "open" stuff.

"The brand system is built on four pillars [..] We make transparency and a global perspective integral to our brand [..] The Firefox brand exploration began [..] working on the Mozilla brand identity."

What do these things even mean? Remember when driven users took out a 2-page advertisement in a well-known newspaper to spread the word? Because you made an awesome browser? A browser that put its users and the open web first?

"branding without walls"

Unless you were Debian, or some other distro that needed to patch your stuff because market share is more important than getting a good browser into the hands of as many users as possible.

craigsmansion··on Blender Is Free Software
> The idea that a company should just hire a programmer they don't otherwise need just so they can make some software work is asinine

Weren't you just saying the magic ingredient was "support"? Do you believe a first line help-desk is going to provide better support than a guy whose livelihood depends on it and you can call to your desk?

>That's like saying a home builder should hire a full time auto mechanic

In this specific case, it's more like fairly large transporters having their own mechanics, which they have, because it's cheaper, and better, and faster, and generally very convenient all round.

craigsmansion··on Blender Is Free Software
It's nice a high profile project such as Blender speaks about freedom to push back against the "source available" movement.

I've always wondered why niche specific software such as Blender doesn't have a ton of industry backing. Any medium sized graphics shop could have a full developer on the payroll for a fraction of the repeated licensing costs of proprietary solutions, that is, someone who works full time on Blender and whom you can directly approach, in-house, for features and fixes.

And it wouldn't even interfere with their competitive edge, since the software isn't their business. They don't have to care about the GPL as long as the software does what they want.

I think it has something to do with appealing to an employee's vanity, where getting a very expensive software package "for free" to do your job makes one feel appreciated.

craigsmansion··on Apple is now a privacy-as-a-service company
Next up: Aaas, Anonymity as a service...

The bottom line is, only you care about your privacy, because you're the only one who can care about your privacy. You can do that by voting, and by running Free Software.

Effective privacy and anonymity are based on control:control of your software, control of your hardware, control of your life.

Everyone asking you for control in exchange for anonymity or privacy does not necessarily have your best interest at heart.

Apple's business model is about monetising control, and now they're extending that by ostensibly selling some of that control back to you. Apple will only grant you privacy as long as it doesn't interfere with them taking control.

craigsmansion··on Cameras Came to the Newsroom
Normally I'd agree, and there are plenty of work sites where cameras can work in the employees' favour, but for a journalist of a large respectable newspaper?

At the very least they would have had something to write about, because this article is lukewarm at best and feels like a complainy blog post.

Also, getting fired at a news paper for blacking out the cameras in the vicinity of your desk as a protest because a new security chief wants to feel important is probably a blessing in disguise.

craigsmansion··on Cameras Came to the Newsroom
So, nothing a spray can with black paint couldn't have fixed, but let's blog about it instead.
craigsmansion··on GM fungus can rapidly kill mosquitoes that spread malaria, study suggests
> that looked further out than you did.

Very much so. You were presenting how there would be no danger to the ecosystem if these three sub-species were successfully destroyed. I never got as far because I wondered about the similarities of population regrowth after destruction with insecticide and destruction with modified organisms.

> Before you bring up the recent boeing failures

I don't need to. Building nuclear facilities is (usually) a very rigorous field with the highest quality of engineering, but sometimes factors of design considerations interact in ways that create new conditions that were impossible to predict. And since you mentioned aeroplanes: if you look at NTSB reports, you often find the cause of crashes is a long chain of trivial events, every single one of them meticulously checklisted and tested with fallback modes to avert disaster. It's not the components, but the intractability of the web of interaction.

> Why do you think that evolution and resistance are novel failure modes

Because evolution and resistance are novel failure modes in the context of genetically designed natural enemies. Previous statistical models might not hold even though the situations modeled appears exactly similar.

> why do you think they'd have been missed in the analysis?

Genetic modification is a statistical process, much like an AI network where something goes in and the output is measured for fitness and fed back. Random artifacts are to be expected and accounted for, but cannot be known to exist before the fact. As such their model might be complete, but it might not be sound.

As you implied, rigor is important, and faced with potentially irreversible consequences, skepticism is not an unnatural or irrational response.

craigsmansion··on GM fungus can rapidly kill mosquitoes that spread malaria, study suggests
Your counter examples are about the mitigation of unexpected and unwanted effects. These were implemented after the fact.

There are situations that have no possibility of redress.

Your paragraph about ecological impact can serve as an example of the lurking danger. I wasn't even concerned about ecological impact. My concern was about artificially creating a resistant species. That's one of the pitfalls here. We're talking about the same thing, but because it's new we're not addressing the same issue.

We got away with DDT because:

- We could stop using it.

- There were alternatives that reshuffled the genepool of a now largely resistant population the other way, after the fact.

These two are not a given when deploying engineered organisms. Even though both are means to fight malaria, they are not the same and need different considerations of which some are new and not valid for any older approaches.

> The people working on this understand what will happen if their solution isn't good enough.

So do most programmers...

← PreviousPage 6 of 19Next →