HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

cranky908canuck

171 karma · joined September 9, 2021

submissionscomments
cranky908canuck··on The Rest Is Silliness: Peter Schickele and PDQ Bach remembered
FWIW, I found and played a youtube sound+score of the Quodlibet. I have not figured out if it breaks the magic or increases the understanding or even intimacy with the work. Leaning to the latter.
cranky908canuck··on The Rest Is Silliness: Peter Schickele and PDQ Bach remembered
I loved the record with "Iphigenia in Brooklyn" (including and especially the Schickele 'Quodlibet' --- need to listen again, I expect to discover new jokes there).

A couple of years ago, I found at a thrift shop a bunch of PDQ Bach recordings that I hadn't heard, and grabbed them.

When I played them, the jokes didn't seem to work the way they did when I was twenty.

I was sad then about that, and sad now. I need to figure out how to recover the delight.

cranky908canuck··on The possibility of making money from shredded banknotes using computer vision
Might be useful for this:

https://www.cbc.ca/radio/asithappens/dog-eats-cash-1.7075889

cranky908canuck··on Future gigantic solar farms might impact solar power elsewhere in the world
This could also work as a benefit --- for example, the 'heat island' effect of (sub)urban areas. True, the panels are black, but now A/C (and other sources of waste heat) is running on local energy, not energy fed in from far away.

I have no idea how significant the effect would be, but it would be an interesting study to do / read.

cranky908canuck··on Why paying bonuses to employees isn't always a good idea
Fundamentally misses the original notion behind company bonuses. The idea was, a base salary, plus a bonus based on company performance. So, participate in corporate profit (theoretically in a transparent way) without locking that into salary structure.

Key is, do not incorporate individual performance. That introduces subjective factors and conflicts between 'my goals' and 'company goals'.

The second and third options both look like "do things you think we will like and maybe we will reward them". Lottery tickets are cheaper and require less effort.

cranky908canuck··on Ideal monitor rotation for programmers (2021)
It sure would be!
cranky908canuck··on BC Supreme Court bars man from calling himself an 'engineer'
Missing from both the cited news item and the discussion is:

As an engineer, you are required to maintain a duty of care that overrides employer/client relationships. As in, even if the boss says "seal it" on an inadequate bridge design, you are legally required to refuse. Key thing is, that seal is required, so (at least in theory) the boss is stuck, since nobody else with a seal will seal it either.

Now stuff happens, ultimately the penalty is dismissal from the ranks of the PEng (and likely civil lawsuits), but an engineering license is a matter of entrusting the recipient to create a cost effective solution that does not compromise the safety of third parties.

In economic language, this 'internalizes' the cost of failing to build things that will be safe to third parties (eg., the users of the bridge).

As near as I can tell, the individual never had that accreditation, so the issue isn't about 'paying tribute', it's about false advertising.

cranky908canuck··on I'm Not Participating in This Year's Advent of Code for Good Reasons
The comment that "this is the worst time of the year" hits it on the head.

How about the "New Years Resolutions of Code" instead?

cranky908canuck··on Why Isn't Landfill Mining More Popular?
My notion was, conventional mining often doesn't bother to clean up after itself (eg., orphan wells), whereas landfill mining will likely be held to a higher standard.
cranky908canuck··on Portugal just ran on 100% renewables for six days in a row
"If you need..." misses the point.

The point of the article was that there is sufficient renewable capacity that the standby wasn't needed, for six days. So that's a milestone of some sort. Or, if not a milestone, then at least a checkpoint that shows that seven, eight, ten, or twenty days is only a matter of continuing to scale up.

cranky908canuck··on Panama Canal is so congested that one ship owner paid $4M to skip the line
It could be cheaper than the typical container port, if you can co-ordinate the ships: the Rustbucket Pacific unloads to a train/series of trains that carry the containers to the waiting Rustbucket Atlantic at the other end. No need to sort out destinations at the individual container level.

This does mean that you would like to work with the same shipping line at both ends, to address the matching of ship capacities.

cranky908canuck··on Panama Canal is so congested that one ship owner paid $4M to skip the line
The electricity to do that would (in the near term) be hydroelectric, so in energy terms you'd be chasing your own tail.

I thought about this maybe being a usecase for small modular nuclear, another commenter suggested that that has already been done (when the US was running the show).

Several others have commented on the environmental issues with pumping seawater into the freshwater ecosystems.

cranky908canuck··on Nitrogen electroreduction with almost 100% current-to-ammonia efficiency (2022)
>> ... would this method result in less CO2 emissions using regular grid >> electricity, or would it need to be 100% low-carbon electricity? ...

Who cares? This is about electricity to ammonia.

Given: a very efficient way to make ammonia (as an energy store) using electricity, this becomes a storage mechanism. So then, make ammonia and money whenever the grid is in a 'pay to take power' state, and (up to a point) even if you have to pay. End source is irrelevant.

Alternate process: run a solar farm, produce ammonia whenever that's cheaper than paying someone to take the power (or curtail), then sell the stored power when prices are high. Or, sell the ammonia directly.

cranky908canuck··on Sodium batteries offer an alternative to tricky lithium
Towing actually seems in practice an awful place for renting. Use case is taking kids trailer camping: UHaul at least offers only trucks with (a) single row seating, and (b) no brake controller. Even if spouse did drive, the lack of the brake controller is a showstopper.

If someone knows where I can rent a crewcab with RV brake controllers, I'm all ears. I'd love to not have to own a tow vehicle.

cranky908canuck··on How to scale nuclear power
Nuclear could succeed if the plant size (and cost, and time to build) got smaller. I think it's at a disadvantage wrt wind/solar (see my other comment), but I guess the 'tiny reactor' designs have a sporting chance, assuming that they solve the time-to-first-kwh problem and piggyback on the same storage solutions as wind/solar. There are definitely cases where micro-nuclear might be good, the trick is to scale it past those use-cases.
cranky908canuck··on How to scale nuclear power
I see nuclear having a lot of trouble competing with solar/wind for two reasons:

1: incremental construction costs: (NB, numbers speculative, think order of magnitude). Roughly speaking, 100e6 dollars gets you a decent solar/wind utility scale installation (heck, you can do it retail for a few 10e3's on SFH rooftops), but only (maybe) a feasibility study for nuclear. Definitely not an operating plant. Spending 100e6 dollars a year gets operating solar/wind generating capacity on an ongoing basis, same on nuclear gets you a working plant in how many years?

2: backend costs: I don't think nuclear has a business plan about the cost of decommissioning a plant. Or maybe it ends up like orphan wells: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Orphan_wells_in_Alberta,_Canad....

Reason 1: means that the business risk associated with solar/wind is far less than that of nuclear. Given that nuclear and solar/wind are very similar as being base load [1] and not well suited to tracking fluctuating demand (so, both need the same sort of backup / storage tricks, albeit for different production profiles), solar/wind win the "cheap 'n' cheerful" race hands down. Also, manageable by private entities, so no WPPSS scandals ("whoops!" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/WNP-3_and_WNP-5).

Reason 2: decommissioning/recycling costs are far lower. This reduces taxpayer risk (ie., externalizing costs). There's nothing exotic: aluminum frames can join the "beer can to beer can in six weeks" loop and the other materials (can't be bothered to find the references just now) aren't as hard to reprocess as detractors claim. Also, again, it's smaller increments, so no massive 6 reactor plant that will take twenty years to dismantle. It's far easier to develop a 'panels to panels' industry with a steady stream of little projects than with a "my career was about remediating Splitters Bay" model.

[1] nuclear has to 'throw it away' by paying someone to take the power, they can't ramp down. Solar/wind has to 'throw it away' by not taking what's on offer. No way to make back six hours of curtailed sunshine.

cranky908canuck··on How do you say goodbye?
I think this is the fix:

https://jakeseliger.com/2023/10/16/how-do-you-say-goodbye/

cranky908canuck··on ChatGPT Will Destroy Your Shitty Medium Coding Blog
It's already destroyed, not sure if it's because of ChatGPT. I've previously commented on how the [Corporate OKR: understand $tech enough to make a plausible blog post on it] dynamic leads to a lot of dross articles on "the three (whatever) essential OAuth Authentication flows" and drowns out anything more involved -- AI just doubles a 5:1 noise-to-signal ratio. ChatGPT may wall be a blessing in that most of those checkbox goal-kicks can't clear the 'and better than autogenerated' bar.
cranky908canuck··on Ask HN: What is that one program in Windows that umatched in Linux?
Printing. Intuition and scuttlebutt says 'driver issues'.
cranky908canuck··on Whenever I buy things I try to prioritize cost per use
If you step back a bit from the boots example you can see the boots theory in action.

Consider socks (I know there's another thread that calls this a 'micro-optimization', likely right, but still...).

Never buy a pair of socks. Or, never buy one pair of socks -- buy a few packs, identical, well priced, and ideally on sale. If on sale, buy them now: if they're clearance, you may not get to come back tomorrow. Now you save:

- money: when one sock wears out, you don't need to discard an orphan. Also, if they are prone to early wearing out, you get enough warning to look for another sale.

- time: when sorting, you don't need to match individual socks --- the green ones all match

But a dozen or more pairs of socks looks like an investment when you are on minimum wage.

cranky908canuck··on A fresh example of how zoning has become a micromanaging busybody
I don't think I agree with you, based on the actual wording. But I do agree in that the specificity of zoning is a problem.

I've done some deep research to confirm my understanding of Japanese zoning rules. (a whole minute! :-) ) So what I see there is:

- levels based on "how much nuisance could this generate to close-by properties" [1]

- at a given level, all 'lesser nuisance' uses are permitted. If you want to build a house beside a tannery, bless you

So, if you have 'level 2: residential (apartment buildings .le. 3storey) plus retail commercial (small shops, small restaurants, etc)' [2], nothing stops a mix of that plus single family and duplex (level 0 / level 1).

Now agreed, there needs to be agreement (ideally consensus) that highschool and college are similar enough 'nuisance' as to be in the same bucket. I reckon that an argument that they are not in the same bucket is going to get a rough ride.

[1] the levels approach is deliberately broadly based, so less susceptible to micro-zoning/backroom deals

[2] my understanding of the actual levels is vague at best, this description is extracted from my left ear.

cranky908canuck··on Why Mangers Exist
Because you need to feed cows.

The referenced article doesn't seem to align with that...?

cranky908canuck··on NYC Lost 100K Homes in Apartment-to-House Conversions
I'm all for more housing, but at least theoretically I'm on the fence about this.

The example (17 => 1) is "not optimal", but the ability to buy two adjacent strata properties and merge them solves the "2br condo vs suburban house" problem. As in, the notion of "observed preference": that given that choice, people choose the latter, and so -- here's the fallacy -- people "want" the suburban house (and therefore that's what we should be optimizing for).

Experimentation around the 'missing middle' (condo/townhouse with SFH square-footage/room diversity) seems very much a work in progress.

cranky908canuck··on Labour council using diesel generators to charge electric bin lorries
Similar teapot-tempest in my part of the world. Provincial ferry ministry [1] bought hybrid diesel-battery ferries, but has not yet contracted for charging terminals. Work well, now have a fleet of 6 (I think --- enough, anyway, and enough sea-time, to show they're not cranky maintenance-intensive toys), but (minor) uproar over "taxpayer's money" being spent on electric ferries with no charging infrastructure.

Meanwhile, in the parallel universe next door, the provincial ferry ministry [1] upgraded terminals to accomodate electric charging facilities for hybrid diesel-battery ferries but has not yet contracted for the boats. Work well, but uproar over "taxpayer's money" being spent on terminals without having boats to charge.

Two observations: 1) <sarky> gummint can't do nuthin' right (proof: someone always can tell you how they screwed up) </sarky>, and 2) it's a 'one step back, two steps forward' sort of process.

My two cents: The vehicles are cheaper and more liquid assets than the infrastructure, so do them first. Then, even if they don't work for you, you can sell them on to someone else who can use them more effectively.

[1] for political reasons, superficially an independent corporation, but wholly owned by the provincial government, and regulated by the independent Provincial Ferries Commission. The corporation is free to operate as it chooses, except for fares, routes, frequency of service, and seasonal capacity.

cranky908canuck··on Streak Redemption
This sounds like you aren't reliant on an external arbiter for your streak calculation, it's just between you and the calendar with crossed-off dates.

That being the case, you can implement your own algorithm and go with it.

I'm interpreting what you have said as that you won't (and do not want to) rationalize your way to the answer you like.

Same as how I calculate my "benchmark" weight: there's a bit of latitude in saying "oh, that's an outlier", but the process (essentially a moving average) is immune to most things short of outright fabrication, and I can't self-deceive about that.

cranky908canuck··on Streak Redemption
An additional flaw with Duolingo's streak process (but I'm sure common since they've at least thought about skip-one-day) not mentioned in the article is that there's no way to preserve even part of a streak if you miss a week, even if you know in advance and it's either necessary (business trip) or part of the process (camping out of internet coverage - yep, still a thing).

There's also no way to ask them for this (no "feedback/feature requests" area).

This happened to me recently, and I was a few days late getting back on the wagon since I knew that my months old streak was just as dead either way.

What would help is some kind of 'streak hibernate', with whatever trickery is needed to make it something you don't just leave on all the time (perhaps: you lose a day for every inactive day plus an additional day on the invocation).

Or, just don't care much about the streak at all (which would seem to diminish the motivational value).

cranky908canuck··on Famous chef wants to open a Bay Area restaurant. A gas stove ban may prevent it
So use a standalone gas cooker (google 'countertop butane cooker'). Yes, I have seen professionals use them (granted, in a 'demo kitchen' setup).
cranky908canuck··on How Much Can Duolingo Teach Us?
I agree. I'm thinking that online exercises won't get proficiency. If that's all one does, it's just a game.

What I'm seeing for me (and it's incomplete, it might be a fiasco in a year) is that it keeps me doing at least some daily roadwork. Once you get to reading news/magazines/whatever (that's how my father expanded his ESL vocabulary) or childrens books, you can start to work beyond. The real hazard is that once you break the chain, the incentive to do something (even when you are tired) is gone, then you probably drop it altogether. So I see the gamification of 'keep the streak' as helpful.

cranky908canuck··on How Much Can Duolingo Teach Us?
A general point: not all foreign language users need to pass for locals --- or, not all foreign language use-cases require that. An extreme example (not one that Duolingo caters for) is opera singers (and singing in general): they need flawless diction, and thorough understanding of the text, syllables, and how they map to the meanings that they are singing. But they don't need to speak, read, write, or understand the language for day-to-day communication --- and there are anecdotes about being cornered in (eg) Russian, and having to 'fess up that they don't actually know how to chat in the language.
cranky908canuck··on How Much Can Duolingo Teach Us?
The thing for 'sounding like (whatever)' is, a chance to practise. The thing that Duolingo does not provide is the live with real people forum. (Well it does, sort of, but it would feel like sending FB 'friend requests' to strangers.) So I'm not surprised that DL learners sound like three-year-olds, I'm actually impressed that there's the courage to speak at all. Give them a couple of beers, that might help.
← PreviousPage 5 of 7Next →