HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

crazydoggers

974 karma · joined May 18, 2012

submissionscomments
crazydoggers··on Ethereum Services Are Centralized
Why should it be against the rules to openly discuss these issues in a thoughtful manner? That kind of silence would only encourage proliferation of the rings since no one is allowed to talk about it.

It’s one thing to just randomly spout accusations, but if a number of users are seeing consistent problems, I think people and mods would want to know.

Anyway, see my other reply to dang. If you search on Twitter you’ll see rando accounts posting weird formated links to HN articles, and things auto posting to HN, etc etc. I avoid Facebook alltogether, but I can only imagine there’s more of the same.

> These accusations seem to have accelerated a lot since the 2016 election and related claims around astroturfing.

Don’t we know for a fact that social media sites have been and are targets of influence campaigns?

ie.

https://www.technologyreview.com/2021/09/16/1035851/facebook...

https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2020/10/08/faceboo...

Since 2016 these issues have rightly had more light shined on them.

It’s better that people at least discuss openly that social media is being targeted and gamed for money than have us all stick our heads in the sand.

crazydoggers··on Ethereum Services Are Centralized
I think if you look into Twitter for a couple minutes you’ll see…

Here’s foone complaining about it:

https://mobile.twitter.com/foone/status/1440375176604966924

crazydoggers··on Ethereum Services Are Centralized
I may be wrong, but I’ve felt for a while that there are some pretty strong vote rings avoiding the HN systems. There’s always a lot of strong downvotes or upvotes for specific subjects, but not that many voices in comments to go with them.
crazydoggers··on Ethereum Services Are Centralized
This lacks an understanding of how Ethereum contracts can function. He’s assuming that a single person or entity must own a contract, and that’s not true.

That’s the whole point of DeFi. Uniswap is a great example, which is a fully decentralized exchange.

crazydoggers··on What a solid made of electrons looks like
Nature did get it right. The grandparent comment is incorrect. See my other comment.
crazydoggers··on What a solid made of electrons looks like
It is a solid, and your description isn’t really accurate. It’s not the semiconductor that is being imaged.

The semiconductors are being used to generate a contained cloud of electrons, basically a gas of electrons between the semiconductors.

That gas is then cooled until it crystallizes.

So what you are seeing is a layer of crystallized electrons.

> It is not a "solid" that is only composed of electrons, with no atomic nuclei present.

That is indeed what it is.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wigner_crystal

From Wikipedia:

“ A Wigner crystal is the solid (crystalline) phase of electrons first predicted by Eugene Wigner in 1934. A gas of electrons moving in 2D or 3D in a uniform, inert, neutralizing background will crystallize and form a lattice if the electron density is less than a critical value.”

crazydoggers··on Secret military aircraft possibly exposed on TikTok
Also found this:

https://www.mvg-world.com/fr/products/antenna-measurement/ra...

Someone’s going to have the clearance revoked.

crazydoggers··on The reason employees aren't returning to work in America [video]
Spoken like someone with no knowledge of the other person, who’s arguments are based primarily on ad hominem, and who seems to be wed to a socialist workers agenda where every person should be compensated equally for any work.

I have done many types of jobs, including physical labor. I’m way more tired, and usually much more stressed out, after doing what you call “easy” jobs. Often the hard labor makes you feel healthier.

crazydoggers··on The reason employees aren't returning to work in America [video]
Your definition only includes physical difficulties (although many developers can tell you that development jobs are horrible for your health, and roofing in the sun actually might be better for your health)

But difficult or hard doesn’t mean physically tiring. It is not easier to make complex decisions, nor to dedicate years of training in order to even begin doing a job.

Some trades require more training. Things like electrical work or plumbing. In those trades people apprentice and as their experience grows so does their pay, often rivaling or exceeding that of software developers… why? Because it take years of dedication.

The reductionism that hard only means physically taxing makes little sense. It leads to the idea that only physical laborers should be paid well, which doesn’t make any economic sense.

Does that mean a factory worker that stand around all day pushing a button should get paid next to nothing? Many of those are physically easy (some even provide chairs) but boring as hell. (And before someone says that factory jobs are all hellish, I have talked to people who have done jobs sorting coffee lids, or monitoring automated work lines. And those people’s first hand experience will tell you it’s often just mind numbingly boring, and not at all difficult)

Ultimately compensation isn’t made against someone’s arbitrary sense of difficulty. Instead it’s made against how many people are willing and able to do the job. And that’s the current distorted reality. Some people are thinking due to pandemic related consequences that there are fewer people willing and able to do the job.

crazydoggers··on The reason employees aren't returning to work in America [video]
Texas literally stopped extended unemployment last week. That means it’s going to end soon.

I talked to the owners. The applicants aren’t even asking what the pay rate is or negotiating it. They just don’t want to be out in 100 degree Texas weather picking up dog poop and are holding out while their paychecks still come in.

So real world data, real world talking to people, rather than just conjecturing on the internet.

crazydoggers··on The reason employees aren't returning to work in America [video]
Okay, we’ll I agree with your assessment. But it’s turtles all the way down…

Ultimately every human, and every creature on earth is coerced to work for survival. Thats the only way I can interpret your definition of coercion.

It’s okay to say you want a society where people can feel free to escape that. But that utopia which we haven’t yet reached needs to be earned.

I don’t, and I don’t think anyone has a solution or answer for how to get there.

But as of today, if you want to be free not to work, the only way to do it is to take from someone else who has been coerced by nature to survive and provide.

In the mean time, our society has at least allowed us to provide, each according to our gifts so we don’t all have to be farmers or hunters.

Bettering working and labor conditions should be the goal of all of us in society. Unfortunately it’s not. But as I’ve said in other threads, that’s something that has been and will continue to be fought for.

No philosophy can free any human from that.

crazydoggers··on The reason employees aren't returning to work in America [video]
That is patently absurd… you literally just said it’s as easy to clean a toilet as write software. Is it as easy as doing particle physics? How about brain surgery? Is there a line? If they’re all so easy, what is keeping all these would be software engineers and brain surgeons from getting better jobs? Some sort of conspiracy??

This is the distorted reality I’m talking about.

crazydoggers··on The reason employees aren't returning to work in America [video]
You don’t actually know what you’re talking about since, yes, they were my “class”… indeed my relatives.

Society can’t function without these jobs. It’s precisely why the jobs are important, why they aren’t demeaning; why people should take pride and be given respect for doing them.

Complaining that working jobs in the sun, or cleaning toilet is beneath you is what I have a problem with, and is what these people are saying.

I think we’re on the same side. There are people who think being a janitor is beneath them and they would never do it… unless of course they were paid a CEOs wages for it.

And that not hyperbole, that’s the hyper distorted reality I think some people are living in.

If you think everyone should be compensated the same, then I don’t think there’s common ground.

If you think there needs to be an increase in minimum wage. Better working conditions, then I couldn’t agree more.

But those things aren’t accomplished by complaining life is unfair. That unskilled jobs pay less than being a software developer. They’re accomplished by working hard, getting out what you put in, and organizing, voting and working for change.

Progressivism is a constant struggle. It doesn’t come for free and that’s life.

crazydoggers··on The reason employees aren't returning to work in America [video]
Why do you think they will come begging you for anything. What power do you hold in the situation, given that their is not actually a labor shortage.
crazydoggers··on The reason employees aren't returning to work in America [video]
I guess I don’t see the coercion. To me I come from a background where grandparents either plowed the fields or died. Where famines caused starvation of relatives and friends. So coercion doesn’t make sense to me. To me it’s nature, and I do my part for society how I can.

One of my favorite quotes is from Star Trek:

“As with all living things, each according to his gift”.

It’s a play on the Marxist adage “From each according to his ability, to each according to his needs”.

It leaves off the second part since what an individuals needs are and what should be supplied to everyone is a quagmire of a problem, given that humans can be selfish and unfair (hence why socialist countries tend to corruption just like the rest). And I fully agree that voting for policy change is a must. So is demonstrating, organizing, etc etc. I just think goals should be clear, and a willingness to understand ones own role, rather than only point fingers.

BTW, I’ve upvoted your comments even if I disagree with them, since they’re insightful and constructive. More of this is needed, and less moral outrage, so thanks.

crazydoggers··on The reason employees aren't returning to work in America [video]
Great goals! Now start motivating people around you to ask for those things, vote on those issues, unionize their workplaces. Work half as hard as the generations that came before did to enshrine our current labor laws. Don’t just complain on YouTube videos. If the video had a coherent call to action and clear headed vision that’s one thing. But in reality a lot of it is clouded by misunderstandings of the job market and the world around them.
crazydoggers··on The reason employees aren't returning to work in America [video]
Well I think we’re getting down into philosophical political divides here which have been argued for ages, and probably can’t be solved on an Internet forum.

I’ll just say this about the video that started all of this. At the moment there is a clear perception issue from some in the society on job fairness. Everyone is entitled to their perceptions, but all I’m claiming is that it is inaccurate, and those perceptions are doing them a disservice. I honestly believe it’s clouded by lack of insight.

I think if you met some of the people I have who can tell you six ways to Sunday how to game the welfare system, collect unemployment, sell drugs on the side etc, you might feel different about that “free market” ideal which doesn’t really exists. Instead look to nature for the truth where you have exploiters in most species around every corner. So we must always be vigilant.

> the ultimate system of nature for humans is collectivism and government

The ultimate system of nature is an evolutionarily stable strategy that involves things like pacifists, parasites, violent struggle, etc. Society attempt to regulate those things and protect from the worst of it, but it can’t make it disappear by itself.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Evolutionarily_stable_strate...

The United States wasn’t founded with the idea of keeping people out of poverty. Indeed it’s primary concern was the protection of private property from the government taking that property without representation. See John Lockes philosophy equating theft to war etc, etc.

Welfare is required to lift parts of the society out of destitution who really truly need it. It’s not meant to provide for perfectly capable people to receive free passes from the rest of society. And that’s part of the problem at the moment causing an illusion in the job market.

As to your point if someone tried to sell me a bandage for a million dollars while I was under duress, I and the rest of the community would remember that person and treat them accordingly. We live in a society, and there are consequences to actions. Both exploitation and parasitism. Those consequences don’t always hold people accountable like they should, and that’s where we get into trouble.

crazydoggers··on The reason employees aren't returning to work in America [video]
I think the gig economy is a serious issue in need of federal regulation. Companies are managing to convince people that they should trade benefits that have been won through labor disputes over the decades for “flexibility” whatever that means. When you break the veil you see they are just skirting labor laws.

Another issue is that unions have lost their strength and have been vilified. Although they are not perfect, they are a critical part of forcing companies to maintain positive work standards. This is where people need to stop complaining about their plight, and stand up for themselves. The laws and systems are in place to support it. People just need to motivation. We’ve just seen this occur when workers voted against unionization at Amazon against their own interests (also demonstrates that claims of massive worker unhappiness just don’t ring true)

As for copy-left, wikipedia etc. Those were donations made from people’s hard work, so again nothing comes free. Such donations should be treasured as such, not taken for granted. I and many others donate significant sums to Wikipedia and the like to promote their existence.

crazydoggers··on The reason employees aren't returning to work in America [video]
But the current labor issues didn’t start until after the pandemic, and until the massive government spending to ease the issue of business closures and people losing jobs.

It’s not a fair market when people are avoiding those jobs because they can get paid for not working.

Once the government spending stops, things will change quickly.

And in fact we actually have had the opposite, people willing to give up benefits for worse jobs, gig economy jobs that provide no stability nor benefits. The reason is because there’s not actually a labor shortage at all.

So you might say that the pandemic reset people’s value assessment on the job market. That may be a good thing. But until government payouts stop we won’t see the actual market in a clear light.

For instance here our dog daycare can’t hire enough employees. What’s been happening is people apply, in order to show applications, and then don’t follow up because they’re still able to receive extended unemployment benefits. So at the moment there is gaming of the system.

And you are correct. Downvotes are not censorship. But they are a toxic method to communicate outrage and add little to positive discussions. As has been outlined both from other articles here, as well as recent coverage from the Wall Street Journal, social media companies are well aware these tactics result in increased outrage and mental health issues, but they choose to ignore them because it adds to their bottoms lines.

> what I hear them saying that they think people have to be compelled into working under the threat of poverty and violence in order to keep the current system from collapsing.

But this is ultimately the system of nature. If you don’t provide for yourself you starve. If you don’t provide for your shelter you freeze. If you don’t provide for your safety you are a victim of violence. Society has distributed those tasks, yes, and we can debate that distribution. But you can’t claim that you just shouldn’t have to work to prevent those things. If you assume you have free access to those things, they are being supplied by someone else. So why should they be free for that person and not the provider?

Could we supply those things free for everyone? I and everyone else would love that utopia. But it’s not where the world is at the moment, even if it’s a worthy goal. We need to keep moving forward as a species. Parasitic behavior is a real issue in any area of life, and in nature things balance out via Nash equilibrium.

crazydoggers··on The reason employees aren't returning to work in America [video]
I definitely think it’s interesting that those arguing these things tend not to be the ones who have worked those jobs, instead avoiding them. I think that tells you something right there.

It feels like an era of moral outrage outweighing common sense. And I think social media bears a very large responsibility. Facebook, Twitter etc is creating a generation involved in spending too much time online becoming angry and not enough time actually going outside and changing the world.

crazydoggers··on The reason employees aren't returning to work in America [video]
Im not the one moralizing. In fact I’m doing the opposite.

Scrubbing toilets pays less because fewer people can write software. Any human being can scrub a toilet. That’s what unskilled labor means.

I have done menial jobs and taken pride in every one. The vast majority of your “managerial class” have done the same.

The difference is they never stopped applying themselves and worked tooth and nail to get where they are.

The idea of some huge protected aristocracy in the US is a convenient myth. It makes up less than 1%. The rest of us work and worked our asses off.

So please stop covering laziness with moralizing. The rest of us are working and tired of the entitlement from the parasites.

Edit:

One only needs to look at your words. “Puppet masters”, “preisthood”, “debt based economy”, etc.

None of it jibes with reality. I suggest perhaps examining what psychologist would call your external locus of control, it won’t serve you well in life. Taking a class in economics and reading up on labor history on the US would also be helpful.

crazydoggers··on The reason employees aren't returning to work in America [video]
So who does the hard jobs? Who slaughters the cows. Who picks the vegetables in 100 degrees.

It sure is damn noble. Someone has to do it, or we all have to. And I give those people amazing props for doing those things.

Many of us have either done those jobs and taken pride, or have family who have in order to better the lives of those children. Saying that work is not noble is demeaning to those who worked for your current standard of living.

crazydoggers··on The reason employees aren't returning to work in America [video]
> Most jobs can and will fire you for no good reason and most jobs provide little to no protection. Most jobs will fire you for being late a couple of times.

Well at least in the US we have unemployment benefits when you’re fired without cause. But yes, being late a few times is cause to be fired, and rightly so.

I think perhaps the real issue is that people’s perceptions have changed, and I don’t think for the better.

If you’re an unskilled laborer, then for the moment, your value to society is doing unskilled jobs.

Now a whole host of reasons cause people to be unskilled. From their current socioeconomic status, to mental health reasons etc, to just honest poor life choices, like not valuing education.

But there’s no free lunch in society, and ultimately that’s the current disconnect. Those that can only get unskilled jobs have now gotten benefits extended and are enjoying not doing “demeaning jobs”. And yet how do they enjoy that? Without society safety nets people would then need to do the demeaning jobs of supplying their own food and water. Hunting or foraging for food in 100 degree weather for 0 dollars, dealing with injuries on their own.

So these same people complaining are also willing to take for granted the strawberries and meat at the grocery that another person worked hard for to provide. They take for granted the shelter that was built and maintained over there head, but they don’t see that they should provide equal work back to society for that enjoyment.

Now there’s obviously a lot of real issues with labor fairness, minimum wage needs to be increased across the board, companies need to be held accountable for pushing a gig economy that strips employees of benefits etc. But the progress in labor fairness in the US, 8 hour work days, minimum wage, workplace safety, has been fought for in literal blood.

Now we have a generation of people who take all that for granted, and that’s a problem.

Edit: I also add this. These same people who say others haven’t worked such jobs, have not themselves lived in a society that is truly difficult. Many people have lived through or had family live through conditions that would make these people cry. Ask a migrant. Ask people who have had to flee countries and could barely subsist.

Those people are the ones thankful to have a “demeaning job” because in reality, difficult does not mean demeaning.

It’s entitlement, very pure and simple. And it won’t serve this generation well.

Prove me wrong with reasoned responses and discussion rather than downvotes.

crazydoggers··on Samantha considering the prospect of being monitored for violations by OpenAI
I also meant to add this link for lots of great insight into how the human mind and thought works. It also happens to touch on some aspects of artificial intelligence, explaining that the idea of a fully human like artificial intelligence of silicon is not misguided, it’s just that its an extraordinarily complex engineering problem which evolution has managed to solve over millions of years:

https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0042XA2XG/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_awdb_8K1...

crazydoggers··on Samantha considering the prospect of being monitored for violations by OpenAI
I’m pretty sure they asked it what it wanted.. which lead to it choosing to sacrifice itself. The idea is that the officers made the choice to accept orders, and it at least was due the same choice.

My favorite episode though is the one in which Data’s rights as a being are put on trial. Still probably the best science fiction handling of the moral issues of artificial intelligence. They even went so far as to discuss the aspect of slavery, which almost certainly will be a real issue if artificial intelligence leads to sentience.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Measure_of_a_Man_(Star_T...

crazydoggers··on Samantha considering the prospect of being monitored for violations by OpenAI
I’m in no way saying we know how thinking works in it’s entirety. But I am saying we know a fair amount, and it’s not supernatural. It’s determined by electrical and chemical signals in the brain. There’s nothing in theory preventing you from writing all that information down on paper, as it is after all, information.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Entropy_in_thermodynamics_an...

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boltzmann_brain

If you’re claiming that thinking for humans involves a soul or some other supernatural element, then I completely disagree with that.

> It's meaningless to draw any conclusions from a comparison between ML and human thought which we don't understand at all.

Again, just to be clear, we don’t have to understand consciousness completely to understand thought to some degree. If you’re unfamiliar with work in this field, it’s quite complex, and there is a complexity of understanding even if we don’t understand everything. So saying we don’t understand thought at all is simply ignorant of the science. Here’s some basics if you’re curious.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neuroscience

Also, comparisons with ML are not meaningless in the slightest. Information processing is integral to brain function, so there are definitely things to be learned by comparing the two.

Indeed the Wikipedia intro to neuroscience puts it really well, illustrating why the comment that comparisons of ML are meaningless, just isn’t accurate.

“is a multidisciplinary science that combines physiology, anatomy, molecular biology, developmental biology, cytology, computer science and mathematical modeling to understand the fundamental and emergent properties of neurons and neural circuits.”

crazydoggers··on Samantha considering the prospect of being monitored for violations by OpenAI
The human brain is a complicated network that fundamentally is performing calculations. Neurons are the building blocks that allow this, in ways that can be compared to transistors.

So it doesn’t matter what the substrate is. The question is not , “is this a turning machine”, or “could you write out on paper what the calculations are being performed”. Indeed if you had perfect insight into all neuronal activity you could probably print output the activity generating thoughts leading to a response.

Instead the question should be, does the entity performing those calculations have sentience. Do those calculations provide the emergent property that allows it to sense and feel, and can it reflect on that sentience.

It seems unlikely that these chatbots do, but that’s not because it’s just a computer. Instead the neural networks don’t seem to be complicated enough to support sentience, and more than likely we are seeing only a very good illusion of sentience.

However, let’s be careful when we asses these things. Although given human treatment of animals, never mind each other, I’m not super hopeful.

crazydoggers··on The fungal mind: on the evidence for mushroom intelligence
I’ve almost read the Julian Jaynes book a couple times. Richard Dawkins once said something along the lines of its either complete genius or complete rubbish. I think that’s always a good type of book to read. :)

And thanks for the link!

crazydoggers··on The fungal mind: on the evidence for mushroom intelligence
I think where people get caught up is that there’s a lot of confusion on definitions (partly since consciousness is almost certainly a spectrum). But a lot of people confuse human sapience with a requirement of consciousness which is not really the case. When looked at in that light, conscious fungus makes a lot more intuitive sense.

My favorite description of the difference was from the cognitive scientist Daniel Dennett. He gave the example of a dog sitting in the sun. When we see our dog sitting in the sunshine looking content, it is almost certainly enjoying the warmth, and we are probably correct in assuming the dog is feeling content in a way that we can relate to. The difference with a human, is that we can reflect on that state; we can contemplate the experience itself (sapience) rather than just sensing it (sentience).

So complex mycelial networks probably allow some level of sentience (experience states of sense, awareness of the environment), but we shouldn’t think of it as something that is contemplating it’s existence on a higher level. Would we define that as consciousness? Perhaps the difficulty of that assessment is just in applying a single word to represent reality.

crazydoggers··on Three Super-Massive Black Holes Merging Together in Our Nearby Universe
I agree the wording in the article isn’t too clear, maybe a bit oversimplified.

One thing to keep in mind. What we see as the black hole is really the “event horizon”. To a local observer there’s nothing special at that location. You wouldn’t notice anything crossing it.

So really as the black holes merge, we see their event horizons merge. It’s not really valid to say one horizon falls into the other, as they are simply space time points like any other.

What happens to the singularities is probably a whole lot more complex and I don’t know if it’s well defined. In addition, there’s a lot more typically going on around most black holes since many have accretion disks of materials accelerated at relativistic speeds and are also rotating causing other gravitational complexities.

Where I think the article hits the nail on the head, is we need complex simulations and ultimately more data on observations to create more accurate models.

← PreviousPage 7 of 19Next →