4,002 karma · joined October 28, 2007
We are also giving away free tiles to paid Life360 members, which is probably not as relevant to the hacker news crowd but we do have over 20% of US families using our service. We think tiles should be free with membership, including getting new devices.
At Tile we just launched an Anti-Theft feature where you can turn off stalking notifications if you share your government issued ID and agree to extremely stringent penalties for misuse, including a large fine.
All Life360 users are now scanning for Tile devices, and that equates to over 10% of all phones in the country, so our network in any moderately dense area is almost as good as Apple's. And, we are cross-platform.
https://chrishulls.medium.com/tile-is-taking-a-different-app...
We've put a ton of thought into this problem so happy to answer any questions.
https://chrishulls.medium.com/tile-is-taking-a-different-app...
I'm the CEO of a 500 person company and our lease cost is negligible relative to everything else, and being fully remote means lots of travel and expensive all-hands get togethers which almost fully negate any office savings.
The overlap between VCs and public market investors and "rich investor friends who have money tied to urban office real estate" is non-existent from a pressure and influence standpoint.
If I took at as a deep philosophical treatise I might agree with you, but that isn’t what it is and I don’t think that makes it vomit.
I'll admit I was a bit surprised how controlling some parents are, and we built our Bubbles feature to address this - you can turn off exact location and still keep safety features active. We encourage all teens to use Bubbles and have a conversation with their parents about responsible use of the app.
I've also taken a lot of vitriol for publicly calling out parents who misuse the app. This culminated in a TikTok campaign that got over 7 billion views publicizing our privacy features (look up #ghostmode - the number is not an exaggeration)
I am also not getting any pushback that this as an extreme outlier. If companies started reacting to every extreme outlier you can think of we would not have progress.
I agree with you on your point about moral responsibility. I was more trying to make the point that in a simplistic sense, if our good outweighs the bad, it is good. It doesn't mean we shouldn't also try to minimize the bad, which we do.
Going a bit deeper though, and putting aside the question of prevalence, how would you suggest we solve this problem?
-We have actively collaborate with law enforcement (sidebar: we are used to the HN crowd going after us for this due to data privacy issues) -We are a "noisy" app - no one can install Life360 on your phone without you knowing -We have a resources page specifically to help people who feel Life360 is being improperly used -We have a "bubbles" feature that allows you to keep safety features active while hiding your exact location -We have a customer support team that passes all reported instance of misuse to our legal team, which contacts authorities as needed.
If there were some easy way to do more, we would certainly consider it.
But, getting more philosophical, in some ways you are advocating that all for-profit companies pay for their own externalities. In some respects this makes a lot of sense (e.g. pollution, carbon credits, etc). How do you do this though when an externality is extremely rare or almost impossible to quantify?
Should car manufacturers pay into a fund that compensates people who are injured by speeding drivers who emulate racing in car ads? Should hammer and kitchen knife manufacturers do more to prevent murders? Should cigarette manufacturers pay insurance companies for their share of increased actuarial costs? Should social media companies pay for free therapy?
Life is grey and I don't claim to be the authority on right or wrong, but I don't feel the critique here zooms out and looks at the bigger picture. Odds and ratios matter.
If we are extending the sex theme, how often is alcohol used to limber up a young woman to lower her inhibitions? Having gone to college I wouldn’t even consider that an outlier, yet alcohol is prevalent and almost expected at almost all social functions. Should we move back to prohibition?
And it is provable we have saved thousands of lives. So yes, I do think the fact that this an extreme outlier vs the good we provide is relevant and does absolve us. And we do take action as evidenced in this very article - these creeps went to jail in no small part because of us.
It is a bit ironic this article is highlighting traffickers who went to jail because they stupidly used the app to incriminate themselves. You’d think a trafficker would use one of the many location apps that doesn’t have the same collaborative stance with law enforcement that we do (we store location data and will share it with a legal subpoena). There are many apps that explicitly market the fact that they use encryption in a way that makes this legal discovery impossible.
For the rationalists on this thread this article about evil cardiologists come to mind.
https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/DSzpr8Y9299jdDLc9/cardiologi...
PS: while I don’t appreciate the story I do appreciate the reporter gave me a fair hearing. So many journalists these days have no ethics and literally cut/paste quotes to distort the meaning. Thomas didn’t do that here, so kudos to him.
We are trying to thread a needle.
We can do things like rotate MACs to make it harder and that might be coming next.
The main point is adding increasing levels of difficulty and friction
Do you want us to unleash millions of dollars of lawyers on you? I don't think many people will want to find out. I genuinely believe this plus a ID scanning will be a huge deterrent. Stalkers will go buy $30 real time stealth GPS trackers on Amazon instead.
I'm the CEO of Life360, Tile's parent company. I wrote a very long post that goes into way more detail about what we are doing.
Here it is for reference. https://medium.com/@chrishulls/tile-is-taking-a-different-ap...
I'm also happy to answer any questions.
I normally maintain a healthy weight if I only eat from 12-8. If I really don't pay attention and graze that entire window, I can still creep up doing this. If I hit 175lbs, my rule is I cut my eating window from 1-7 until I reach 165 which happens in less than a month on the 6 hour window.
I've kept this up for 5-6 years. You get over the hunger pangs within a few weeks and then it just becomes normal. I've only had to cut my window down to six hours I think three times since I started the routine.
PS: I have had diagnosed ADHD since middle school. I wonder if there is any correlation between ADHD and intermittent fasting as a successful diet strategy. I think there is something similar between struggling with focus and a proclivity for absent minded snacking. It makes it so much easier to have a binary rule that I can follow that tells me when this is or isn't allowed.
Large population coordination, both implicit and explicit, around high leverage alt-coins explains much of this cycle.
We do not use wifi - as to other commenters it is bluetooth only, but we have some other big plans in the works.
You could probably test this by asking a few friends this question and see what they say. Outside of pure math problems you can get into an infinite regress defining the underlying first principles behind any given assumption.