One thing to note - UWB is very short range now. Even now AirTags and Tile are primarily BLE. Upcoming chips and standards updates will be dramatically increasing range. I think that is when the magic happens.
4,002 karma · joined October 28, 2007
One thing to note - UWB is very short range now. Even now AirTags and Tile are primarily BLE. Upcoming chips and standards updates will be dramatically increasing range. I think that is when the magic happens.
I think we will end up with ID verification - I bet Apple could do that too. Then you'd be risking a felony if you use the product illegally.
I'll make a few points:
1) Stalking is completely different than a data platform used for targeted advertising and research.
2) Good minds can disagree on how user data should be used. We decided to shut down our data business because it wasn't worth the distraction - we have over $200m of revenue and it is not core to our business so we decided to move on. It should be noted we have always been extremely transparent with our customer and allowed anyone, whether a free or paying user, to have fine grain control over how we use data.
3) I am not positioning us as a more-private alternative to Apple. If this is a real problem that is emerging, I'd like to understand how we can address it. There are a lot of smart minds here.
4) Our user base is largely middle American moms - this is not the place we go to do PR!
AirTags has a much broader network than us as of now. Part of why we bought Tile is because we can expand their network. We aren't as big as Apple but we have about 10% of devices so it will get us way up the S curve.
So I could see it becoming more of an issue, which is why I'm looking for ideas. One thought would be to rate limit updates - at some frequency you get 90% of the benefit for lost items (since they don't move unless it was lost on say a train) but it dramatically hampers more nefarious use cases. That is just one thought. Or perhaps requiring ID verification and registering each device to a real human.
We have a number of initiatives in the works to help allay concerns. I would be curious if the community here has any suggestions. I know our very existence is controversial - so please be kind - I'm here to listen.
So I’m sure the shift is real, but probably lower than your estimate. I also assume Facebook will quickly figure a workaround through alternate IDs or fingerprinting in other ways.
This is the most twisted reporting that has ever happened to us. We participated in good faith and they cherry picked individual phrases from our written answers and omitted including the ones that hurt their narrative. I literally gave them a list of suggestions on how the industry could be better regulated for all involved and they didn't even mention that.
I do acknowledge we have a data platform. They made it sound like we have no safeguards and anyone can buy data which is patently false. I also pointed them to this blog post which we sent out to 100% of our email list which is highly transparent. We are one of the few companies to have a privacy center which outlines everything we do in plain english with no legalese.
I'm very sad and disappointed. And an @ notify feature could have helped but as you say this is not Discord
https://www.life360.com/blog/understanding-how-life360-uses-...
What we have found is that the average customer doesn't really understand privacy. They would likely not understand the difference between this and any website that puts the "256 bit SSL encryption" blurbs on checkout.
We are not a privacy first service per se, but do want to give users full control over their data, so let them opt out of things like a partnership we have where we analyze their driving data to match them with car insurance. Very few users take advantage of these settings.
I don't say this as a knock on the idea at all, but am sharing my experience of serving consumers outside of the tech scene. I wonder how you could package this value proposition for an ordinary user?
Privacy means different things to different people and I probably am more open than he average person on hacker news. A full comment on what it personally means to me would be quite a long essay!
Arity (an Allstate subsidiary) provides us tech that powers our crash detection service (think Onstar for your phone - we dispatched 10k ambulances last year) and other driving features. Arity also scores our drivers, like a credit score for your driving. But, this is extremely different than selling your data.
Arity does not know who these people are - they get a set of limited information which is not tied to an indvidual. They then take that information and match it with insurance offers based on a number of factors, but who that person is, or there forward looking behavior is never connected back. They don't have the legal right (or even the reasonable technical ability based on the data we give them) and the offers are not tied to an individual.
The insurance offers are similar to what Credit Karma does with your credit score. You go to Credit Karma, you give them your social and some seriously sensitive info, and then they match you with offers. They are NOT selling your info to credit card companies in the same way we are not selling your info to insurance companies. There is very little difference.
To the technical piece, I guess they could theoretically reverse engineer people from our data, but that is like say anyone who uses say Amplitude or some metrics provider could be selling your data to insurance companies. All of us developers use a number of 3rd party services that we are trusting to be shepherds of private information. In this case one of our third party providers is an insurer. So you could argue they have more incentive to breach to contract, but they would really get no benefit from that because a) we would sue the to oblivion and b) do you really think they could get insurance commissioners to allow them to price on stolen data?
As mentioned above we are extremely transparent about all this. It is explained at sign up. We push the information to our users. We give them a privacy center which goes through all of this in non-legalese. User can opt out of anything they want and we don't degrade the service intentionally (e.g. if you opt out of the connection to Arity we literally can't power the features). We even let free users opt out of the targeted promotions.
Some people may still not like this but we do not do corporate speak and we do not try to hide anything.
See blog post here https://www.life360.com/blog/understanding-how-life360-uses-...
90%+ of families have no issues and use it in healthy ways. We are going to try to help that remaining 10%
https://www.tiktok.com/@life360ceo/video/6827231499293576454
To address some other comments on the thread: 1) We don't sell your data to insurance companies
2) We are ultra-transparent on how we handle your data and give far more control than almost any other app out there. More here: https://www.life360.com/blog/understanding-how-life360-uses-...
I firmly believe if we as a community collectively stand up to trolls and never settle this problem can go away overnight - no need to wait for the government.
We're basically being sued for allowing you to click a marker on a map initiating a phone call.
This obviously should never have been patented, so we are doing all the legal defense work and sharing it with the startup community.
See www.stopagis.com if you want to see how we really pissed off our troll.
And public shaming also works, the CEO of our troll didn't own his domain, so we bought it and drive traffic to the site whenever people search for his name (Malcolm Beyer www.malcolmbeyer.com). They don't like that we "aren't playing by the rules".
I'd say you are a patent troll anytime you are using a bullshit patent to extort a third party. The rub is what constitutes a bullshit patent, but "sending messages through a map UI" seems obviously in this camp. It sucks you have to spend hundreds of thousands of dollars for the courts to validate this logic though.
So by that definition, I'm sure IBM could be a patent troll, just like any other company with BS IP.