HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

crocowhile

2,112 karma · joined June 4, 2009

https://lab.gilest.ro/giorgio
submissionscomments
crocowhile··on Deepmind Alphadev: Faster sorting algorithms discovered using deep RL
I am a neuroscientist, not affiliated with Deepmind. I can´t speak for the other AlphaThings,but AlphaFold dramatically changed the way the biomedicine field deals with protein structures, shortening the gap between hypothesis and experiments by months if not years. You have no idea of what you're talking about.
crocowhile··on Apple Vision Pro: Apple’s first spatial computer
They will never mass-sale this unless they unleash porn. We know it, they know it. Nobody is paying $3500 to look at their emails on a visor.
crocowhile··on Leaked government document shows Spain wants to ban end-to-end encryption
So are they banning VPN and SSL too? Those are not fringe techniques.
crocowhile··on When you lose the ability to write, you also lose some of your ability to think
[reference needed]
crocowhile··on Ask HN: What would you recommend a 16 year old to pursue career wise?
Knowledge is not becoming meaningless. If anything, we are approaching a phase in which it will get even more value because only people really able to master and recognise knowledge will be able to ripe all the fruits of AI.

I would not consider any job that is mostly based on pattern recognition (like medicine). Enter coding only if you think you'll be top 1% because those will be the only people who will still be able to work. Any creative job should still be ok, provided you have a good understanding of AI.

crocowhile··on Ask HN: Employers, why do you want us back in the office?
> but no time - I was working all day

This is your problem. The rest is a red-herring.

crocowhile··on Papers and patents are becoming less disruptive over time
Whatever CD is measuring, is going down as a trend. So one cannot blame the obviously ethereal nature of CD for this.
crocowhile··on Ask HN: Anyone tired of everything being a subscription now?
Just use open source software.
crocowhile··on Mastodon's founder has a vision to democratize social media
I am a scientist and I've setup a mastodon instance on my own server, with remote file hosting on S3. It was pretty painless and in a few days 200 non tech-savvy people have joined and started contributed. Some migrating from twitter, some joining social media for the first time.

It is great.

crocowhile··on LaMDA is not sentient
AI do not simply fish contents from an existing database. Instead, they use a repertoire to extract rules and create new instances, exactly as we do when we learn to speak. DALL-E can create an image of something even if it was not in its training set and a LamDA can create a sentence and even a concept that was not in its reading repertoire.
crocowhile··on LaMDA is not sentient
You do not see the tautology in your own statement: "These language AIs do not have the capability of believing anything" ?

If that is your starting assumption then, yes, they will never be sentient even when they will be. I am a neuroscientist. We do not know how the brain works and what causes an animal to be sentient. We do not know if a dog or a fruitfly are sentient in the way a human is. We know nothing about consciousness but you guys appear to be full of certainties about what can and cannot be self-aware.

crocowhile··on LaMDA is not sentient
"Neither LaMDA nor any of its cousins (GPT-3) are remotely intelligent.1 All they do is match patterns, draw from massive statistical databases of human language."

This is what we, humans, do too when we talk. All these people talk about intelligence in such tautological terms... It's discouraging. We simply do not know if a machine is self-aware and most likely we will never will. Self-awareness is the ultimate subjective experience and we have no way to measure it in any form or shape.

crocowhile··on How cloud computing impacts the environment
I once read the suggestion to build a powerful cloud datacenter in orbital space, powering it with solar panels. That would solve any overheating problem too.
crocowhile··on First Paper to Link CO2 and Global Warming (1856)
chaos has nothing to do here. Look, it's really very very simple actually. The higher the concentration of greenhouse gases, the more energy gets trap in the atmosphere. This changes the balance and warms up area of the planets that did not warm up for millions of years. Chaos is more important when it comes to weather, but climate is more straight forward. The only pseudo-chaotic aspect of climate change is the so-called tipping cascade and that should scare the bejeezus out of you.
crocowhile··on First Paper to Link CO2 and Global Warming (1856)
That graph is a known fraud. See: https://www.theguardian.com/environment/climate-consensus-97...

Don't trust the CATO when it comes to climate (at the very least). They are known negationists. If you understand basic level physics, read the IPCC reports and the realclimate blog.

crocowhile··on First Paper to Link CO2 and Global Warming (1856)
You've missed the point. It is well known that co2 is a greenhouse gas. You can do the experiment yourself with some children using a plastic water bottle, a thermometer, and a mixture of baking soda and vinegar. We understand this physics extremely well. Denying the causal effect of co2 on warming is akin to denying the causal effect of gravity towards an apple falling from a tree.
crocowhile··on A Code Glitch May Have Caused Errors in More Than a Hundred Published Studies
I am a neuroscientist and a good portion of my laboratory's scientific output is code. I can offer a perspective.

Every few months, a case like this one emerges. A published software contained a scientifically relevant bug and this may have had an influence on other studies that used that software. The reaction is always the same: blaming the naivete of the researchers because they are not professional coders.

While I would certainly love to see more interaction between professional coders and scientists, I don't agree with the overall sentiment. I find it counterproductive and even naive for several reasons:

1) mistakes happen. Wikipedia has a long and certainly not complete list of software bugs that had major consequences ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_software_bugs ) and most of them come from professional coders in all kind of industries. There is no doubt whatsoever that code produced by scientists is in generall less streamed, less reviewed, and way uglier but is it on average more buggy where it matters? Unless we answer this question, the discussion is moot.

2) Scientists who produce software by themselves do this according to Open Source philosophy meaning that the code can be scrutinized by anyone. I'd rather use a possibly buggy but open-source software over one that I cannot even scrutinize. I think published results should only be accepted if they rely on open-source software: we would never accept a figure of a paper unless the protocol was 100% disclosed. This is one aspect where we can all immediately act. As a reviewer, I will never accept a paper that made use of new software unless the code is an integral part of the paper. I urge all my colleagues to do the same. Also, as authors, if you have to write software from scratch, take code readability into account exactly for this reason. Python is a good choice for this reason. R much less so.

3) we must encourage scientists to take on more coding, and not the opposite. If we keep telling them that they are not going to be good enough, we are not helping. A the moment the trade-off is very clear: either not-professionally coded software or no software whatsoever. Fields like crystallography have shown that the former option can still be extremely favorable.

crocowhile··on A Code Glitch May Have Caused Errors in More Than a Hundred Published Studies
Does the swap in the position of the two cities compromise the findings in any way? If not, it's an irrelevant mistake like misspelling a word. What do you expect them to do? retract the paper because they misspelled a word?
crocowhile··on A Code Glitch May Have Caused Errors in More Than a Hundred Published Studies
You were heavily criticized because you said nonsense. Cancer research also relies on millions of lines of code but you would not say the same, would you? The science of climate change goes well beyond the models. The models account for only a small fraction of the science and they are produced completely independently by many research groups, leading to overlapping results.
crocowhile··on Tempe Police Release Video of Uber Accident
I have the very strong suspicion that the driver has turned autonomous drive mode off, perhaps to be able to watch tv or something. She seems extremely distracted by the dashboard and there is no way that sensors could not alert her of that presence. Also, apparently the car was driving at 38mph in an area where the speed limit was 35mph. Would the autonomous mode allow that?
crocowhile··on Many junior scientists need to take a hard look at their job prospects
Perhaps this is true in some countries. In the USA and Europe, the average professor works 61 hours a week and encounters very high levels of stress, linked to continuously having to obtain research funds.
crocowhile··on Why I Fell in Love with Arch Linux (2015)
I do understand your point of view. Technology hardly ever "just works". Probably the only device that never went guru meditation on me is my microwave.

Having said this, when it comes to updates, archlinux is really orders of magnitudes more efficient than any other distro I have ever tried.

crocowhile··on Why I Fell in Love with Arch Linux (2015)
I have been an arch user for more than 10 years now and three things make the difference for me:

- a very mature community of users. The arch docs and forums are really good. If you ever have a problem, you'll find a solution in no more than a few clicks

- an extremely tidy package manager. The choice of packages is huge and - more importantly - creating and maintaining a package is extremely easy. Way easier than making .debs or .rpms

- it just works. I've used arch for more than a decade on all my machines, including servers. I never had major issues. Annoyances coming from upstream are unavoidable of course, but the distro is well organised that identify the problem and rolling back is super easy.

crocowhile··on Hospitals across England hit by large-scale cyber-attack
I think the most interesting aspect of all this is that it's a clear evidence that even machines possessing highly sensitive data (like NHS computers) are super vulnerable to any remote penetration. The request for a ransom may just be the tip of the iceberg here.
crocowhile··on Man Fined $500 for Crime of Writing 'I Am an Engineer' in an Email to the Gov't
land of the free market my ass
crocowhile··on Gita – autonomous lightweight delivery system
Piaggio is not exactly a startup but yeah, this gita may just be some kind of proof of principle product for a marketing stunt. If not, because I see no market for it.
crocowhile··on Ask HN: What is the best Linux distro for a development laptop?
There is nothing better than Arch. I have been using linux daily since 2005, tried multiple distros and now all of my machines (laptops, desktops, PIs, remote servers) run arch. Hardly ever a problem and making packages is a so damn easy compared to any other distro.
crocowhile··on Primary Model Predicts Trump Victory
Look into the "shy tory factor". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shy_Tory_Factor

People are more likely to lie about their voting intentions when the media create a climate of moral stigma around their candidate. I am sure this is going to happen in the uk too. The Democrats have run the wrong campaign.

crocowhile··on Who's downloading pirated papers? Everyone
You are absolutely right. Scientists are the only ones to blame for this. It's true, as someone else replied to you, that scientists tend to chose journals based on their reputations but it's also true that nothing prevents a scientist from publishing their unedited manuscript on their personal websites. It's absolutely legal and absolutely uncommon.
crocowhile··on Why Is Productivity So Weak? Three Theories
pong was mind blowing 40 years ago
← PreviousPage 3 of 21Next →