1,478 karma · joined October 30, 2008
If people would be willing and able to make proper digital records, the Cloud would not exist. Actually, most of the technology stacks in use today do not make any sense until you consider the fact that a very large segment of the market wants to have all the goodies IT-fairy-godmother can provide, but are too damned stingy to pay for even 10% of the cost.
Your characterization of Banks is correct, but irrelevant. In many ways they are the perfect IT customer: deep pockets, an inner culture that values detail orientation and rational risk assesment, appreciation of external expertise, etc. Most organizations are very not like this.
Healthcare IT, in particular, are the stuff of nightmares. A culture of bikeshedding, - excesive regulation of what systems ought to do, plus borderline criminal negligence of the implementation details, - reliance on obsolete OSes that cannot be updated anymore, needlessly large attack vectors... do I need to say more?
The thing you fail to grasp is the resilience of physical records. Imagine Germany trying to take down England's records during World War I, one hundred years ago. The destruction of merely 3-5% of all relevant documents would have required the coordinated strikes of hundreds if not thousands of arsonists, all of whom would need to be part of an even bigger spy network. That's for England proper; you might be able to scale it up to Scotland and Walles, but it would be completely unimaginable to pull this off accross the whole British Empire.
Today, it might be harder to take down one hospital, but once you have gone that far, scale it up to national level should be pretty feasible.
> Imagine that your monoculture crop could develop immunity to a new disease within hours, days or weeks
You never have opened a priority bug in one of the big software companies, have you?
> (especially since this is not really considered a crime)
The seed is already planted: it is ok to display the face of a citizen, as long as he's a criminal. No debate about what kinds of public need does supersede the privacy rights of the individual citizen, or what kind of crimes would justify this kind of behavior from the part of the government. It is all "rulebreakers brought this on themselves" nowadays.
All they have to do now is to lower (or I'd say, keep lowering) the threshold; jaywalking is right around the corner.
Which is what I expected to hint the the mention of Guillotin: the French Revolution. That did not happend because of social injustice. No human society has ever been 100% fair, -and probably none will, ever,- and most people is able to accept that without making a fuss about it. The problem with the Ancien Regime back then, -which is the same problem with financial elites nowadays,- is that they have become increasingly detached from the realities of their decisions for the rank and file, even to the point of cluelessness.
To borrow your example: In agricultural age, if you fucked up harvest your family starves. Today, if you fuck up the housing market, thousand of families end up in bankrupcy, and tens of thousands of small investors loose their savings... but you do not personally know any of them, so you wont even feel shame when you cash-in that million dollar yearly bonus.
There's historic precedent for that kind of divorce between actions and consequences, and it is not pretty. There's a certain French doctor you should google: his name's Josheph Guillotin.
Boring corporations like boring spaces, and have to pay big, boring salaries to get any talent at all.
On the other hand, cool code slingers may or may not prefer tabs out of personal idiosyncracies, but as long as all of them get shortchanged by the VCs and/or startup founders...
It is curious you mention Snake Oil. There was a post a few days ago on HN, reporting that Science has found actual biochemicals in oil of some snakes that may be useful in modern health care.
Snake oil was a well known remedy in Chinese pharmacopea, but unfortunatelly is was introduced to America by an unscroupulus peddler and bigot, who thought that as long as it was a con anyways, it did not matter what kind of oil he would peddle.
Then, the name of a genuine prescientific remedy ended up being the class exemplar of all fake cures out there. And the discovery of this chemicals took 200 years longer because real doctors would not dare take the status hit to even consider the possibility that it might be something real behind the quack's claims.
You claim that people hear and believe bullshit. That itself is a symptom; mainstream medicine has been unable to provide adecuate healthcare services, so the quacks come in and fill in the gap. Your chosen side is very eager to throw accusations of malfeasance and stupidity, but in many cases it would be more accurate to say that people is doing a (perhaps misguided) attempt to deal with hard realities with limited options. It does not help that said side is prone to downplay its own pursuit of profit motive.
This state of affairs is not new at all. According to Lester King's "The Medical World of the Eighteen Century", this goes back at least to the days of Henry VIII in the English speaking world (and has its roots in the medieval customs and institutions of the guilds and the Church). The problem is fundamentally economic and political (who has the right to ministrate health of their fellow man), but doctors like to hide behind appeals to authority (ancient tradition first, later science).
True Science should have no business taking sides on what ultimately ends up being comercial disputes; theirs is to look at Nature and figure out how it works. I am obviously engaged in the Alt-med scene, and I can tell you by personal experience that it does work well enough. The problem is that, being a low status subject, the ranks of its practicioners are filled with anti-intellectual types; and yes, this means there're lots of bullshit being peddled out there, and even the stuff that seems to work does probably work according to principles that are unknow to the people that use them. And it is an herculean taks just trying to figure out what's complete bonkers and what's real phenomena waiting to have an actual explanation.
The terapeutic modalities you have label under the collective label of "bullshit" is a valid options for millions of people in America alone. And the reason this is so is because doctors distill hubris in their interactions with everyone else (like you), and then when they are found in a mistake or in some sort of self serving scheme, they pretend nothing happened (like you) and try to blame someone else (like you).
What to help science win? You need to win back the hearts of all those millions of people that got disillusioned with modern medicine. And the way to do so is to treat people with respect and let the strenght of your arguments set the direction of the debate. Once you have to resort to censorship and name calling, you have already lost.
Last time I checked, Chc was not the infallible God of Truth and Goodness. Maybe it is not a good contribution, but it is not for you alone to tell.
If you want to argue that liver cleansing is a quack, do so in a comment. Better yet, ignore the parent and let it fall to the bottom of the conversation.
As a professional community, we have uterly failed at giving a flying fuck about anything other than quarterly revenue (aka. upholding a basic ethical standard). But now, we can at least be hopeful that the biggest and meanest shark in town is going to sue into oblivion any other party that tries to spy on its customers; and over pattent infringement, nonetheless.
However, I cannot stop noticing that all the worst traits of the software industry start with the talented professionals amoungst us "caring less" about their jobs; and then the bozos running the show are free to go around wanking their minds and fucking up everything for everyone. If you ask the authors of every monstrosity out there, they will claim the Nuremberg defense, pennies to peanuts!
The same argument works for negative reinforcement as well. The most convincing argument I have heard about avoiding harsh rising of children has nothing to do with the intrinsic rights o kids. Instead, it points out that one day, not that far away, you may find your teenager consuming drugs, or engaged in unprotected sexual intercourse, or commiting petty crime; and if by then you have not left yourself enough room to escalate short of corporal punishment (or not even that) then you might find yourself in a fight that you cannot win a hormone loaded young person that never learned to respect you and surely won't start today.
So, I think this has a lot to do with signal to noise ratio. Whether you praise or you demean, the point is to make it rare enough to be noticed when it happens. I did not always do it that way, but I have got better results when I began following that advice.
I agree that toilling at useless task adds zero value in the best case -more often than not, it adds negative value by creating commitments to perform further useless tasks in the future- but what is so wrong with considering costs of production within the value added? I think it makes more sense to recognize zero (or negative) value added task for what they are instead of declaring them "marginally valueable" and then try to push the externality of their cost unto others.
Most common causes I can think for this problem are: an indiscriminate hiring process that fails to keep out poor candidates, either defective operations or hostile work environment that results in excesive burn out rates for employees, irrational expectations from management teams (specially founders who struggle to make the transition to later stage startups).
In practice, American unions failed to see that. Even if we ignore the cases where leadership just enriched themselves, unions concerned themselves mostly with extracting as much value as the employer would bear, and to a lesser degree to shield employees from the consequences of their mistakes.
On the other hand, fluid capitals means jobs would have gotten outsourced regardless of union's stance. In Mexico, which is far from having the cheapest labor in the world, minimum wage is less than $5USD per day. There are loads of social problems derived from that, but the fact that this is feasible at all relies on a much lower cost of living compared with USA. Try to implement that on the other side of the border and you'd be facing bread riots in no time.
I guess nobody told the nerds that back-breaking work was not really a metaphore in the good old days.