HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

csydas

4,075 karma · joined August 9, 2015

on HN, I use they/them for myself

if you really want to write me for some reason, stallmanniquin at gee mail dort corn

I don't check this often though so please don't be upset if I don't respond fast.

submissionscomments
csydas··on How To Get Started In Soldering
I don’t quite get the thrust of most of your post beyond that you have a more generous understanding on the quote.

As I get your post based on the amount spent on why it’s bad to dismiss older persons, I don’t think this is really what the article or GP suggested. similarly, I am not sure that it’s fair to say genz often doesn’t do a lot of the mentioned things. GenZ is full of individuals specializing in niche or old fashioned skills and showing the skills off on specific mediums. Coding and repair twitch streams are quite common, just maybe not as much as subjects that are easier to appreciate without much knowledge in the subject. It’s pretty easy for most people to grasp why a contortionist’s skill or someone skilled with sewing has a rare and unique talent. it’s a lot easier to understand what went into it and the precision and the result is very apparent. I think it’s not so clear with subjects like electronics repair as the tech might work afterwards, but there is too much to understand going into it to fully appreciate the result in its own, and thus audiences rely on the presenter to fill the gaps.

The authors examples are good ones if you’re already inclined towards fixing stuff on your own; but if it were me, even with a simple fix like string lights, i’d have a hard time justifying repairs on my own as i’d need to invest into the repair kit and it would be hard to shake concerns on if I did a safe repair or if I made a mistake that needs to be fixed. I imagine it’s like this for many, as even a few years back when I did laptop repair at a university, students (even technical ones) were antsy about such manual repairs and fixes, and often just preferred to put the liability on someone else. for something really disposable like lights, a cheap phone, etc, i can easily get why people of all ages would just prefer a new one.

Soldering is a fun hobby, and i think that the hobbyist community would easily eat it up if they don’t already (i’m positive you can find some electronics repair vids/channels). it is just lacking practical reasons for people to be interested and/or personalities to bring people to it.

csydas··on He who submits a resume has already lost
I'll offer a counter view from my (annoyingly large) experience interviewing and hiring; I would ignore such statements on a CV at best, and depending on how much a candidate bets on this strategy, it might even work to their disadvantage.

I need smart people that want to work and are willing to do that work with my team; I don't want or need someone to promote the party line, that's why we have Sales and Brand teams, I need people who for some amount of time are willing to spend their time and skills on our problem sets. Our problem sets aren't so unique, so I also want them to stick around for awhile (not forever, that's unrealistic). Finally, I need and want people that can at least be cordial with the existing team as opposed to disrupting it.

If I ask my colleagues who also decide on hiring, probably they'd have different wants and needs, maybe echoing the parent post, I don't know for sure. There's what my colleagues say and then what they think when deciding. It's a crap shoot for the candidates for sure, and I'm very sympathetic to this; it's also a crap shoot for us as it means that depending on who takes the interview, a different set of criteria is being used, so it's a real risk; autocratizing isn't good either because then it means higher chances we can't evolve the team.

Hiring is a real mess, and I have no good answer on making it better, just that it needs to be. The short list of problems I think are pretty universal for candidates and employers includes:

- It's an inefficient and time consuming process for all

- It encourages both sides to lie to each other for legal reasons and because it's the only way to get attention

- It's too easy for misinformation/weak points to cloud the process with misinformation, intentionally or otherwise

- Everyone has to make decisions based on incomplete and often inaccurate information

- The interests of employers and candidates are set up to be at odds, even though it shouldn't be this way (salaries, benefits, demands on time/skills, emotional costs, etc)

With CVs/resumes, I probably spend no more than 2-5 minutes on them, and it's usually with ctrl+f to hunt down the keywords for skills we identified would solve our problem set and to give me something to talk with the candidate about during the interview, and the interview is mostly to figure out "does this candidate actually have relevant experience here or it's just keyword spamming?"

I'm very lucky that at least one of our Talent Acquisition teams is quite good and their initial interviews/screenings have a higher success rate than the other TA teams, so I've come to rely on that a lot, but it's still difficult as the TA team are not technical persons, and despite their earnest interest (and KPIs) to get us in touch with good candidates, mistakes happen.

I really wonder what hiring would look like if work wasn't a requirement for people to survive, that is, in a world with universal income and guaranteed living. The work still needs to be done, but the candidates in this scenario have a much different incentive since their literal livelihood doesn't depend on them getting the job. My hope is that it would mean candidates choose to apply because of their genuine interest, and the type of problems the company tries to solve suddenly become a much more competitive currency we barter with. I think some might say that it already is like that, but I think that's an incomplete understanding of how hiring has worked for a very long time.

So I'm really not sure how to make it better and more efficient, and how to get past the awful situation we have now; I hope that removing the "you need this job to survive" can gain traction and make it better, but the cynic in me says this isn't likely in my life time.

For the time being, what I would recommend for technical candidates is the following:

1. Be cordial with the recruiters. You don't have to suck up to them, but if you can't at least be cordial with them, I have low hopes you are going to be cordial with the people you need to work with every day. The recruiters have their guidance on what we're looking for and yes it's going to be basic and limited stuff I told them to check out; they aren't going to understand everything about our tech and work naturally, but what they're screening is the basic stuff that they can understand so that I don't have to check these basics. They want you hired also remember, because it is their job to get people hired; at least the TA teams I like are constantly advocates for candidates they think have a chance, so don't burn bridges with the persons who are sticking up for you internally†

2. Keep your CV relevant and concise. Concise doesn't mean short, write what you think we're interested in, but make it parsable. I want to be able to understand what tech you've worked with, your responsibilities regarding it, and to have some items for us to talk about. Hundreds of bullet points or listed items doesn't help me if it buries the relevant experiences for me under layers of irrelevant experiences. Length, specific words/phrases, it's not as important even for the auto-screening tools. Just take a small amount of time to make it well formatted, free of typos, and it's likely fine. Freebie CV generators are perfectly fine, and preferable to CV templates in Word or other hand rolled CVs. Length doesn't matter as we're just going to ctrl+f anyways.

3. Make it clear what problem sets you're interested in, and during the interview, ask questions so that you understand if our problem sets and day to day are among your interests. I'm usually happy to talk about our day to day pretty directly so that you have a complete picture on what you're applying if it means

4. Just be cordial during the interview; I don't need people to flatter me or the company, and I just need to see you can work with the team; I don't learn that from hearing how great the company is.

† I'm fully aware that many Talent Acquisition Teams are quite awful, and many recruiters are not like I described here; nevertheless, they are often still the only advocate you'll have unless you know someone on the inside. I think most hiring managers rely heavily on their TA teams regardless of how good they are, so at least be cordial with recruiters.

csydas··on YouTube millionaires are not your friends
happens :)
csydas··on YouTube millionaires are not your friends
Keep in mind, childhoods are a lot different now because you are exposed to a lot of information and people you never would have had a chance to meet when you were a child. As a kid in the 90's, my parents gave my brothers and I a choice: cable TV, or DSL once DSL came to our area of the city.

We chose DSL, and definitely the Internet experience I had growing up was way different than every other kid at school since it was actually feasible to download a few small movies or games at the time, and to talk on chat apps/message boards at a very early age. All the online activities became part of my childhood along with my friends who lived locally and my other activities, and turned out, I enjoyed those a lot more than the in person activities which I mostly just _could_ do, as opposed to wanting to do them. So I had a pretty good balance I felt between physical activities, meeting with friends locally for bike rides or playing games, and the online social life also.

Edited addition: One of the most positive parts about this was that it was so new that my parents had very little to say because they did not understand it; if I wanted to join a message board or crack a game, my parents and teachers and other authority figures in my life absolutely could not say anything about it in a reasonable way; it was brand new, there were no guides or playbooks, I had to learn this all on my own. While I was a very independent child, it was mostly stuff in a familiar scope for my parents. They "knew" that if I went on a bike ride with friends, probably we were up to some mischief, because that's what happened when they were kids. Same with if I went to a friends house to play games, to the park, etc. The Internet was (and still is) completely out of their scope along with all the tech and knowledge required to use it at the time, so it was a major point of growth for me to learn this new world and how to survive in it. That felt really nice as a child, as I'd slowly start to learn the skills that helped me succeed as an adult.

I think that the current childhood experience probably would be what most of us would have had as online is now a normal aspect of kids lives, whether it's games or various chats/message boards, etc.

When you write:

>It's like there is an entire part of the children/teen population that have such a blend [sic] life they feel good while watching somebody else living it.

(I assume you mean "bland")

I'm not sure it's about a bland life. There is a lot of social interaction, just in a different form. Some people have trouble with understanding that online light interactions don't have the same weight as in real life impersonal interactions, but that's pretty normal I think. Most adults from the previous generation still have troubles with communication in my opinion (at least a fair amount of persons from businesses I work with have weaker communication skills that most children I know), so I'm not sure it's that these children are missing anything or have a "bland" life, it's just different. A lot of my younger friends are often in shock at my childhood pastimes before I had a nice computer and access to the Internet, cause man my friends and I used to get into a ton of trouble and do really dangerous/mean stuff to each other sometimes. We meant it in good fun, but in retrospect, I think that I'd rather my children were doing social stuff and learning/reading like I did when I got Internet as opposed to the stuff I used to do as a kid, which frankly speaking, was petty vandalism at times even just because we were so bored and wanted something "fun".

So it's not really that one is worse than the other or that modern life is bland, it's just different. There are lots of videos you can watch about early 2000's and 2010's internet culture, and it's really interesting for me because it wasn't the Internet I experienced as a kid; stuff like virtual worlds or alternate reality games that pop up on message boards seem like they were a lot of fun, and looks to have sparked a ton of creativity in the kids participating. I don't think this is a bad or bland life at all; just different.

csydas··on The Offshore Networks of Oligarchs
I think you're missing the point here. I'm not a crypto advocate, but Visa and Mastercard definitely have too much power as do most online transaction processors, and the amount of information that online processors collect (at the request and joy of governments) is quite scary.

A select few organizations can control whether you can buy necessities or not and cut you off even from legally earned money on a whim. Banks have finite cash on hand which limits your mobility and liquidity at any given moment in the event of an emergency. Online commerce at this stage may as well be a secondary benefit given how your information is scooped up and resold to advertisers.

Financial systems are quite convenient, there's no denying that, but they're extremely fragile and the system exists at the whim of a few select people. Visa and Mastercard have demonstrated they can effectively remove persons from modern civilization at their discretion, not even with official government requirements, and that this has not been challenges is really unsettling.

To reiterate, cryptocurrencies are not the answer here in their current state, as they're too unstable and basically inherit not only all the issues that normal banks bring, but also introduce a ton of new issues. I don't know how to ensure sovereignty for individuals who are legally earning compensation when a support representative for banks can click on a checkbox and make them penniless. Nevermind if the company the representative works for is influenced by an unhappy government.

Finance is terrifying, and we're really in a strange place where we don't have a good answer for ensuring individual sovereignty with any currency, crypto included. I stress over this because I'm less and less confident every year that there is a good solution for this besides eschewing Finance entirely (and that's quite the magic trick...)

csydas··on Supreme Court rejects man’s bid to sue police over arrest for Facebook parody
This doesn't hold to scrutiny I think.

The case discusses a total of about a dozen calls. If this was enough to disrupt a moderately sized suburban police force in a meaningful way, then I think the issue is larger than just a Facebook impersonation account.

The bar for disruption must be higher, else any call that is not strictly the jurisdiction of the police is grounds for arrest as you're disrupting the services.

Consider a situation where someone runs a parody account about upcoming social events and makes a parody post about an upcoming "baby bbq" and asks residents to find they plumpest baby and bring it for a cookup.

While the account page mentions it's parody, the community members spread the post around without this context

Dozens of people call the police, some even demanding they send officers to stop the bbq, and the police only confirm the post not the account; should the police be able to SWAT the parodist without repercussion?

This gets into way too many edge cases of how much _immunity_ should the police have when performing due diligence. In the actual case, the disruption is arguable, and the urgency of stopping the posts/account was also arguable. That people fall for it is not the point; onion articles from more than a decade ago still get posted as real and get real outrage, so the general publics opinion is not a good bar as it constantly shifts and changes depending on who you ask

In this case there was not a major disruption any more than a concerned parent calling the police because they didn't recognize their neighbor at night.

The police had no urgent need to take action, could have handled this without any police action.

The charge is that the police did not like being parodied and thus used their power to shut down free speech, and now the courts are supporting this.

I think it's a bad choice to not hear this case and the police are in the wrong. They are over reacting and trying to litigate someone into having their rights suppressed.

csydas··on IRIS²: The EU’s Response to Musk’s Starlink
I'm from the US originally and emigrated about 10 years ago; I think you're conflating different aspects of technology. The boom of US tech isn't superior infrastructure, it's that tech is a very lucrative investment vehicle so it gets a ton of attention. (Well, it was anyways, not sure what 2023 is going to do to this)

While I understand what you're saying, I think what you're observing and commenting on is the huge amount of money that is thrown at technologies developed in the US compared to similar technologies developed by an EU nation which don't get the same attention. US tech infrastructure is by no means exceptional. It's good in many places, don't get me wrong, but it's an extremely similar or lesser experience compared to many EU nations (including the ones you mentioned), and a lot more costly for end users.

Even when I lived in Russia for a time, the infrastructure/costs were amazingly better in Russian cities (outside of Moscow and Saint Petersburg even) than in many US cities.

This is not to say everything US == bad everything EU == good; far from it. Instead just try to understand that the main difference between the tech you read about in US that gets millions or billions and the tech in the EU which just stumbles on like any other business is simply the high attention from investors looking for investment vehicles.

Beat for beat, the day to day technology that I used in the US has either an acceptable or better EU-accessible version, and the EU version is often even a bit cheaper.

The big projects like Starlink are extremely subsidized by the US government; it's the US residents paying person like Elon Musk to let him sell them something right back, without having any real control or input over the way that money is spent by Musk and other similar corporations, or even ensuring that everyone has a chance to use the stuff that billions of dollars of their tax dollars are going to. It's an oligarchy that's been fully legalized and approved.

I really don't think that's the direction we want any nation to be taking, as it does _not_ provide good results long term for the people. US broadband is a perfect example for this with the incumbent providers doing everything in their power to offer as little as possible while still technically qualifying for the subsidies so they can pocket the remainder after the bare minimum requirements are met.

Don't misunderstand the high investor attention that US tech companies get as always being great innovation; investors want a good investment vehicle, and that doesn't always mean the vehicle is a worthy and innovative product. It just means it's something that has a way of providing good returns on investments, including short term fads.

csydas··on VRChat Sex Worker Denied Entry to US over ‘Prostitution’
Also not a lawyer, but reading the document, the language for a lot of this document is incredibly subjective and broad. Neverminding the fact that immigration office workers generally don't have to justify their position, very likely sex workers who never actually have physical contact with their clients would be subject to the conditions of ineligibility because of fairly prudish conditions on the immigration document:

(3) (U) Crimes Committed Against Person, Family Relationship, And Sexual Morality:

I think the main sections that might apply would be prostitution and lewdness. Prostitution doesn't require physical contact as I get it [0], and even acts meant to "satisfy a sexual desire" are counted. Lewdness I cannot find a specific definition of with a very quick search, but in general the language on what I can find focuses more on the public nature of "indecent" elements.

As I understand from the document later on you don't even need a conviction for the immigration officers to reject you, an admission is enough (see section 9 FAM 302.3-2(B)(4) (U) Admitting to Crimes Involving Moral Turpitude)

To be very clear, I think that the ruling on this case and such rules in general are absolutely ridiculous and puritanical, and should be removed as they are overly broad and group persons who don't bring risk with those who bring risk. I don't know the history of these rules, but I can imagine that a modern defense of the rules likely would include discussion points on preventing "sex trafficking", even though the person from the article likely is not related to sex trafficking at all.

I'm not sure a wrongfully rejected application for immigration is something you can sue over in general, and even if they could, I suppose that with the current law/rules presented by your document, it would be pretty easy to spin VRChat Sex workers as ineligible due to the extremely broad categorizations used for Sexual Morality.

Again, I must stress that I think including such clauses against "sexual morality" is very stupid and only serve as a means for individuals to weaponize their own agendas/morals legally speaking. The conditions for violating Sexual Morality even mention bigamy for some reason, and I honestly just cannot understand how that would be considered a concern for an immigration application.

I have no idea how it works for non-US Citizens if they want to sue the US government, but as a layperson I understand that even US Citizens cannot sue the government outright, there are a lot of caveats for the lawsuit to even be applicable.

This is really a sad example of poorly written law that punishes persons needlessly, and the persons punished likely have very little recourse :/

0 - https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/prostitution

csydas··on United States tells citizens: Leave Russia immediately
I lived in Russia for 6 years prior to the invasion of Ukraine (2022 edition), and I can confirm that the US has frequently warned very heavily for basically all actions in Russia, even during peace times (before the first invasion of Ukraine even). I think even in 2015 when I went the first time, Russia was still on the 2nd level of warning despite overall decent relationships between the two countries at the time.

These warnings have been persistent for the last 8 years and in my discussions with the US consulate when I was there, it's less about indicating anything in specific and more about the US protecting its own interests and being as clear as possible that they cannot assist on a lot of things right now due to very limited diplomatic presence. The message that I was told at the consulate during the first Ukraine invasion was "we're very limited on staff and influence; we cannot make you leave, but you need to understand that if you get in legal trouble, we likely cannot help you." (this was a bit after the Saint Petersburg US embassy was closed)

While I don't doubt there is some concern about persons being taken for negotiation purposes, I think the major concern is just that the US is not in a position to assist for many foreign citizen services as the diplomatic tensions are far too high right now. Unless you already have good connections in Russia, at best you're stuck in a bad spot without help from the consulate, and at worst there is a chance you become a means of bargaining (though this has always been the case).

csydas··on Gen Z Netiquettes
I work with the exact same setup and demographics across the globe, from Eastern Europe to China to India to Japan to the US to South America.

These aren't US specific Gen-Z rules, these are quite global. This is happening far outside the scope you're limiting it to, and it matters.

csydas··on Taking the initial phone screen with candidates
Search your job title on a few job aggregator sites or on the job pages of a few companies in your field; how closely does your day to day get represented in an intelligible and understandable way from the postings you find?

The Job Search process is fraught with a lack of clarity for both sides; businesses "fluff" their positions just as much as candidates "fluff" their CVs because the wrong wording, incorrect wording, misleading wording, or wording that sounds less appealing than what other businesses use makes you less competitive in the eyes of potential candidates.

Talent Acquisition teams can only go so far; I work with a great TA team who meets with us frequently to discuss our needs and to ask for help interpreting questions/comments from potential candidates and how to best represent our needs to some of the challenging (but good!) questions potential candidates have. I am well aware that I am quite lucky in this regard as many TA teams do not work closely with the teams they're finding candidates for.

I wouldn't fault a candidate for explaining their understanding of the position but asking for a more clear picture of common activities they might do during a week, or about team/reporting structure, advancement prospects, etc. That's different than if they come to a position and balk when being asked about their experience with elements directly on the posting or normal/expected for the given position.

csydas··on Gen Z Netiquettes
I'd like to propose look at it an alternative way; language has changed to be much more focused on intent, interpretation, and cognizant of your conversational partners.

I work with a fairly large and diverse IT team with age ranges from 22 to 60+; a lot of this involves disagreements as is natural with any conversations with a large group of people.

Discussions with the younger demographic are far more productive and faster as they're quite specific in their statements and when there is a disagreement, they put it out there fairly openly, explaining intent and feelings, and when I reciprocate, we get to a faster understanding of one another and any potential misunderstandings we might have had, view points we hadn't considered, or parts that aren't clear for us. The initial conversations take a bit longer, but ultimately end up with all parties understanding the situation well. It's quite healthy I think.

With the older age group, I definitely know _when_ they're angry or upset about something or when they disagree with me, but I rarely know _why_. Trying to slow down the conversation and have the same "help me understand what you're thinking/feeling so we can better communicate" often is not received well, and while the conversations are more direct initially, they last far longer and result in more tirades, walls of text, and dozens of arguments with loose or no connection to the topic at hand.

I don't see the younger persons as being sensitive, I see them as being specific; I think they're better trained socially to express themselves and reflect on their reactions and their state, and embracing this by participating in the same way is very freeing. I can have what might be considered difficult discussions (corrections, disciplinary actions, etc) and understand that while likely the conversation partner is not happy, they feel understood, I've presented my point of view, and when presented with new information, all sides have been very receptive.

With my older colleagues, the same sensitivity and emotions are there, but I'm far less aware of it even if I specifically take actions to show I want to understand more.

There is definitely a culture clash, and I think that the reactions of "snow flakes" and "triggered" are not accurate, and it's more about two persons separated by a common language failing to communicate. Given how well conversations with my younger colleagues go, I'm more inclined to prefer this model.

csydas··on Gen Z Netiquettes
I think you're being overly harsh on this when it comes to informal communication.

As others pointed out, capitalization is similar to white space, punctuation, and other tools that English has when it comes to informal communication.

Especially online, you can invoke a lot of imagery and thoughts and emotions by simply playing with the rules of English in a live-chat setting. Try to imagine in a chat the following sentence with different stylizations:

"The Customer is always right, so we need to work to correct this"

"thE CUsTomer iS aLWays RIght, So WE neEd To WoRK To cOrrECT thiS"

"the customer is always right, so we need to work to correct this :))))"

The first is quite formal and it's direct; perhaps it could be understood as sarcasm if someone knows you well, but it could also be taken at face value and quite seriously, or it could be taken as a throw-away statement.

The second indicates a mocking tone and maybe even resentment, taking the time to mimic a meme and also to purposefully make the sentence silly looking.

The third introduces the sarcastic smiley (I disagree with the article's interpretation, as I've always seen :))) to more represent desperation or exasperation)

With traditional rules of English, tone is difficult to convey with a single sentence and it's built with the surrounding text as a point of consideration to understand how to interpret a statement; with chat, this is far more difficult to communicate the emotion/intention as chats can be very fast and disconnected, and it's hard to follow the attitude and mood of a person to understand their intended messaging.

You could try to divorce the message from the emotions, which might lead to expediting some discussions, but it also leaves a lot of room for incorrect/wrong interpretations. Even if you divorce yourself from such concerns and try to be above it, your conversation partners might not approach it the same way.

The evolution of chat might be bastardizing the classic rules of English, but it's quite expressive and personally has made many conversations and relationships much easier with fewer misunderstandings.

csydas··on Ask HN: LinkedIn sent me a cease and desist for my Chrome extension. Help?
As people have said, just contact a lawyer willing to provide a consultation, and likely take their services to get assistance in addressing a response.

You have time to get a consultation and draft a response; the language in use is overly broad in the letter and intentionally so. This is to be rebutted and basically tell them "you will stop advertising that it _can_ scrape LinkedIn, but LinkedIn cannot outright ban any tool that might be used for scraping as that's not their right." A real attorney will write this in a very nice way with proper wording that you will stop advertising that it can scape LinkedIn but they can stuff the other parts of the demands wherever is convenient for them.

It will cost a bit of money regrettably, but it should be manageable.

csydas··on Japan was the future but it's stuck in the past
I want to respond to this as I think you just have a fundamental misunderstanding on how wealth, relationships, and childbirth can be related.

A child is not made by the equation (One Female Parent + One Male Parent) + Marriage = Child.

This is not the actual requirement. It just requires sperm + ovum + body to carry the organism to birth. I interpret your comments here as attempting to take a purely logical/fact based approach, but you tie yourself to an unnecessary old fashioned notion of one man and one woman in a contractual union.

A woman and two men can absolutely be parents by inseminating the woman's eggs with their sperm and having someone else carry it, or artificial/manual insemination involving other women. I don't think you take your idea of efficiency here anywhere near the much more natural and sensible conclusion of "for-hire birthers", which already happens. A person, regardless of how they identify, should be allowed to do this; for simplicity sake though, I don't see why you don't mention this in your model -- a rich woman, paying for successors, and having multiple male partners who meets her scrutiny/desires raising the children and passing on genes/knowledge/personality traits.

You can suggest that your ideas imply this possibility, but frankly speaking I don't accept this suggestion; if you meant it, you would just say as such and/or use neutral terms for identifying the progenitors in your examples.

csydas··on Japan was the future but it's stuck in the past
I think you're being downvoted because people consider your original comment poorly constructed and poorly thought out.

That men can participate in polygamy does nothing to encourage birthrates; what is the incentive of the wives to want children? What is the incentive for the man here to want children?

Unless it's implied in your idea that the purpose of marriage is to produce children, polygamy solves nothing here. If that is the presumption that the arrangement requires children, how does this counteract the very common reasons for not having children?

- It's extremely time consuming and life changing; you have to commit substantial time or resources (or both) to ensuring the child is cared for

- A person or persons simply don't want children

- There isn't a strong reason to have children outside of one's own desire to do so (there isn't incentive to maintain a lineage of successors, build out an army of loyal subjects, and so on for the grand majority of people anymore)

- Even within religions, the impetus for having children just isn't emphasized in many sects like it was in the past

- Social mobility, while nowhere near perfect, is far more achievable via other arrangements or even to a degree with personal effort; it won't be the peasant to noble move that existed previously, but it's more possible than it has been in the past (though social mobility is still ridiculously difficult and fraught with discrimination and exploitation, so understand I am not at all saying that it's in a good spot)

Your idea doesn't really address any of the actual reasons a lot of people hold off from having children, it just presents a suggestion to "legalize polygamy for rich men", implying that this somehow addresses the many reasons that people aren't having children.

Your follow-up comment here I think also misses a lot of points as to why people check out and undermines the idea that society can incentivize its way out of these problems. If the problem is a bleak economic future for people, trying to utilize childbirth as a pyramid scheme to overcome this economic uncertainty isn't really a great idea, as that means you need to somehow convince the children of the already checked-out persons that "no, really, it's a great system. Ignore why your parents are so miserable, it will be different for you for reasons."

I don't think you can just economically incentivize your way out of a declining population, not in any meaningful way aside from temporary trends which will fade. If the root cause of the issue is poor economic conditions and unstable comfortable living conditions, you need to first understand why those are happening in the first place. If it turns out that it's because only a select group have the economic stability to support a life that includes children and this select group is not a huge portion of the population, aside from mandating child birth, you haven't actually given incentive to make more children, you just have given special status to the already elite.

> But consider what the future would look like if you don't increase the birth rate:

I have, and I imagine we probably see more adoption of universal income and automation, and far more acceptance of such a system and interest in keeping such a system where you don't need to struggle for basic needs in place by investing time and effort into the system. There's a lot of this which of course is fantastical thoughts right now, but we're already seeing this in many nations, and the quality of life in these places is pretty good while birthrates are just "so-so".

csydas··on You don't have to engage with people on the Internet
I absolutely understand your strategy and that there is a huge frustration to have such awful pithy ideas continue to spread.

One thing I'd like to offer though is a reminder of the quote "living well is the best revenge."

I deal with a lot of prima donna managers, technical persons, you name it, and it became a lot easier for me to just let things go when I realized the best thing I can do to counter the pithy/ridiculous notions they espouse was just to do my thing and be comfortable in what I do, say, think, and feel (regardless of the feeling).

It has an amazingly convincing effect on many without me having to write/say a single word, I am much less stressed as I don't feel a need to defend my thoughts and ideas, and I find my methods and ways far more simple and effective than those which are espoused by my colleagues. I don't insist that I'm right in every case or my strategies are right for everyone, I just focus on what is right for me. That it sends a strong message is simply a side-effect, albeit a positive one I think.

csydas··on Apple Has Begun Scanning Your Local Image Files Without Consent
Sneak, I think you're defending your article a little too loosely here.

Your article states that Apple is scanning your files and points to network traffic as evidence for this, combining in your summary that Apple scans the data and then tries to reach Apple owned APIs. You spend a non-trivial amount of the article discussing the CSAM plans Apple had, and making it very clear that Apple never said it wouldn't scan and send files/data to law enforcement.

Your article builds a case that Apple is exfiltrating data, be it document information, media analysis, etc, outside of the local machine; I find it difficult to accept this was not the intent based on how the article is structure, the bullet points, and the summary.

> I was literally viewing images in the Finder via spacebar QuickLook (not even in Preview) when it hit the network for the first time.

Yes, this is likely LiveText and other OCR features done live on the M1/M2 models: https://developer.apple.com/documentation/visionkit/enabling...

There is a lot of live processing done with the M1/M2 boards even without iCloud/Photos.

I understand you think your article presents an objective and curious item that asks the reader to investigate more, but I and other people in this topic are telling you this is not the way your article is understood and interpreted, and we've pointed out how the other conclusion was reached based on your article. An inquisitive article with a call to action would be just that, as other commenters have already posted:

- I see this daemon trying to reach out to Apple APIs

- At this time, I was doing this

- I have not investigated the binary or network traffic

- I find this interesting, but I have not yet drawn a conclusion on it

- I invite others to comment on it more

If the article was presented like that, you wouldn't have so many comments here stating that they find your conclusion premature and misunderstanding your intention.

If your intent is really to call for investigation, I would suggest that you add an addendum section to the article clarifying your goals and purpose, as it seems that overwhelmingly readers are not taking this interpretation.

csydas··on Apple Has Begun Scanning Your Local Image Files Without Consent
I am not to say you made false claims, but I'm not sure that your connection between what com.apple.mediaanalysisd and the com.apple.snoot API call is fully justified or backed by evidence.

It is interesting to understand what this call is for and what the mediaanalysisd daemon is actually doing/sending, but just triggering LittleSnitch while browsing local documents I'm not sure is enough to draw a direct connection. Correlation perhaps, but honestly I think before making the claim that Apple is sending specific document information to their servers, it'd be better to get something a bit more concrete.

Checking with just activity monitor on the mediaanalysisd process and its network traffic while browsing through pictures, the sent/received data is bytes in size; I'm not in a position to do a proper network capture, but already I question what those few bytes are and if it's really related to my media browsing activities or just background noise. There is a fairly significant amount of received traffic (like close to 200 GiB) compared to the sent traffic (13 GiB), so I'm not quite convinced that this correlates to media scanning.

Passing psgrep with mediaanalysisd to lsof shows a lot of fairly normal background processes/daemons like webkit, AppleSupport, the AppStore, etc., so I find myself thinking it's more a general process despite the name, but far more research of actual packet data is needed.

The only mistake I think you've made is that I think your conclusion is premature to connect file browsing to this daemon, as it seems to handle a lot of stuff besides the implication that it scans documents or that it's specifically related to CSAM.

Basically, more information is needed in my opinion.

Edit: Changed "feel" to "think" in 2nd to last text block to correct my own language issue.

csydas··on Recent improvements to Safari
Not exactly; this is a bit of semantics, but "Native Advertising" is different than traditional advertising, and Native Advertising might be _an_ answer to ad-blocking, but it's by no means _the_ answer.

Native Advertising seems to be at this stage fairly tame, but I don't hold any belief that it can't/won't change. If it stays at the level where the most you get is 30 seconds of a YouTube video dedicated to ads and occasional ad-only articles, in my opinion it's fine. It's still annoying, but it's not the immediately disruptive experience that more traditional web advertising are, and with YouTube at least, it seems many of the creators have settled on having predictable timing for their ad segment, either right after their intro or right at the end, and I think this is a healthy way of handling it. It's not interrupting the actual videos typically, the advertisers get their precious views and tracking, and the creators get paid. With native advertising articles, it's fairly fast to recognize that there's no real information in an article and to just skip it; if the authors still get paid and the advertisers are satisfied with the screen time, then so be it, I'm ultimately not too annoyed by such a situation as I don't get interrupted by ads.

I hate advertising in general, but with the above, I would call it acceptable for the time being; I haven't even bothered with the YouTube ad segment skip plugins/scripts for such items.

csydas··on Recent improvements to Safari
To add to the other responses here, I won't deny the lack of uBlock Origin was a painful point for me going all in with safari on Mac; even the previous broken incarnation that had to be manually built and was a bit buggy was still fantastic compared to non-uBlockOrigin alternatives.

A small combination of user scripts for YouTube specific blocking with TamperMonkey and Wipr+KaBlock+1Block seem to work, with only Wipr requiring a purchase.

But I really wish Apple would walk back the position on how ad blocking runs in safari, as uBlock Origin made the argument for Safari much more convenient.

It is good though that a small number of user scripts and extensions get it "close enough"; I mainly miss element zapping/blocking from uBlock Origin at this point.

csydas··on My coffee maker just makes coffee
I'm very sympathetic to designs at the beck and call of someone else making the decision on features, but I'm not sure that some of the points above are the right way to frame it.

> you bought that over-complicated appliance for the same reason everyone else does: it has more features, and you like features. Everyone wants features.

I don't think this is accurate for a substantial part of the population. A novel-length feature list is a guaranteed way to ensure that no one really understands what your product does. A product I worked on had the usual hundreds of features and novel-length user guide, and probably one of the most common questions our support team would ingest was "can product X do thing Y?" which was even just a quick online search away.

Featureful updates I think look better for the people investing in the product, not the ones selling/buying it. It justifies expenditures, can be correlated to growth/progress, etc. For specialized products, e.g., coffee makers, I have personal doubts that a substantial amount of buyers care much more than reading a few reviews to confirm that the product "makes good coffee" or " is easy to clean".

> Second, that designer likely has as much real agency as the engineers building the firmware for the control board. Corporate mandated 12 months ago, “A coffee maker with features A, B, and C and price point P and trim level T.” The designer likely has no place to argue with any of that. A product marketing executive made these decisions, and for one reason — to build what sells.

This one I agree with mostly, except for the "build what sells" part. What sells is what the company effectively SEO spams and price-points well within the market. Let's not forget Juicero's history and how well it sold until someone did the groundbreaking journalism of actually using the device and showing how ridiculous it was. I think it helps support the idea that enough moxy/aggressive marketing, you can get just about anything to fly for awhile to turn a profit. And Juicero is just one example of many such things; I doubt that the executive guidance on Juicero was anything more than "Make it squish these bags, read our juice DRM, and set up a subscription service to buy more juice bags."

The answer to this is pretty complex I guess, as voting with our wallets is historically pretty ineffective at enacting change. There are a lot of tricks that can be used to make hot garbage a top seller; Amazon is raking in billions doing just this and has been for years, despite constant outrage articles and proof of the garbage-ness of the services.

At a certain point, change does need to come from within the company rather than external pressures; the market gets fooled really easily by fancy enough presentations and rich enough people talking about a failed product for 30 seconds.

I think that's why the author made the call-out; I read it as fairly tongue in cheek, but it has an element of truth that the pushback likely needs to come internally; I think the author though, and many people, realize this is not as simple of a situation as that though for the points you mentioned about executive decisions. I don't think designers should completely abandon their agency though on products; saving money is pretty persuasive to the decision makers, and probably _that_ is the best way to influence products via a wallet. Just it's the company's wallet, not the consumers.

csydas··on South Korea’s online security dead end
My information here may be outdated, but when I was in Seoul for awhile, it wasn't limited to just banking apps, many services had similar requirements for specific plugins, even requiring Internet Explorer 11 and a bunch of plugins for that.

I remember trying to get tickets for an event, and it was not possible within MacOS at the time due to the various Windows only requirements. I remember even having to re-download another version of Windows 7 as Tiny7 had various Windows Services removed that for some reason the plugins/apps relied on.

My cynical guess is that the plugins/apps include user data/telemetry that the companies get a cut for, but of course this is just supposition. It's entirely possible it's just some liability thing that has become entrenched in Korean IT, who knows.

But the practice was everywhere.

csydas··on How ^NOT to Forge a Search Warrant
Happy to help.

And interesting, yes, the gofundme was live when I watched the video on the site (link is on the site).

I think it's just maybe how GoFundMe handle's the links?

https://gofund.me/a58c25bd

Works as normal I suppose for you.

csydas··on How ^NOT to Forge a Search Warrant
In case anyone else is confused, apparently this comes from a defendant in a wire fraud case, [name redacted], as per the gofundme page [0]

The case apparently found the couple guilty and charges were held against them, and I believe some jail time also [1] [2].

My post's purpose isn't to affirm or deny the claim in the video, but to add the context I was missing for when the video got to the end and changed its tone considerably.

I do think their observations are interesting, but I also assumed at first this was from an attorney showing instances of forged warrants, not from a layperson.

So while I do think there are interesting discrepancies, I would feel more comfortable taking them at face value if persons within the field of law would confirm some of these statements.

0 - https://gofund.me/a58c25bd

1 - https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/appellate-courts/ca10/1...

2 - [link redacted]

Edit: Fixed gofund.me link

csydas··on Conversation skills essentials
Vouched since I don't get the downvotes and want to respond.

The author sort of conflates two things in this section of the article; lack of interest and lack of knowledge.

The author's lack of interest in drinking adventures is actually their faux pas in my opinion if it's a story from a friend wanting to share a story. My friends have tons of interests I do not share, but I love to hear them talk about their interests because it's something new and they're my friends. I would not be as open to listening about beading or car mechanics from someone I'm not close to since I lack the knowledge to really participate and I just don't really care about someone I don't know very well and their hobbies unless they're a really engaging story teller (then I'm all ears)

The author's article in general sets a lot of weird social rules that they seem to prefer but this is not really some universal standard, it's just some social rules that the author abides by and is positioning as a good set of rules to follow.

Some of the advice is okay; if someone is visibly bored and not engaging, don't keep going on with the same topic, switch it up or move on.

Other advice is weird, like the positive disagreement; disagreement is fun! You have a chance to learn something new and as long as you aren't positioning your entire self worth on a position, probably it's a fun discussion. I disagree with people in a friendly way all the time, most importantly my friends, and we're better for it, not worse. We say how we feel and feel more.relaxed that when there is a disagreement, we understand it's normal and natural.

The article weirdly tries to position some nice advice, but I think it does more confusion than good.

csydas··on Customer service reps for Disney and Airbnb who have to pay to take calls (2020)
The information is asymmetrical here in most cases; Arise knows exactly how it works while presenting it as something else. A quick search on Google for Arise Call Center and the first three pages are lacking of any critical articles on Arise and some Glassdoor/SEO-spam blogs fake-answering the "scam" question.

And looking at an actual posting on Arise, it looks quite legit: https://www.ariseworkfromhome.com/opportunity/remote-custome...

You could expect this on basically any tech job aggregator posting aggregator site or even most companies' own postings. The only big giveaway that something is off about it is the last line:

> *This is not an offer of employment. It is an opportunity to enter into a business-to-business relationship with Arise®.*

If a person is fortunate enough to see that and check the FAQ [0], hopefully they realize how much of a mess this is and that you're basically paying Arise to maybe get paid by someone else, but how you get paid is up to you and might as well be a mystery.

But for those who don't check that and are in desperate need, yeah, I can easily see how Arise at face value looks perfect and desperation goggles hide the flaws:

- Site looks very normal and legit

- The work it discusses is shit call-center work that no one wants to do so there's likely lots of openings for someone who really needs money

- No training needed, you will be trained so a bad job history/no job history isn't a problem

- Criminal records don't seem to matter so if you had issues in the past, it's no big deal

- Work at home so no need to worry about commute/office hours

- The site is "up front" about you needing to pursue opportunities, so that makes it more "honest" and trustworthy

It's a very nice blend of honesty mixed in with the misdirection that likely its enough to get many people to pay the initial fees, maybe for a training or two, and even do a few hours of work for basically free during a high volume period. Arise pays pennies for the work, gets $$$ from the companies for getting the workers, and ropes in tons of cash from the agents. It looks and feels like a normal employment offer to get enough money out of a person to justify the efforts, and then the person is saddled with reality that they don't have a job, they basically paid for the opportunity to pay to get a few $$$ at awful rates.

It's a gross and exploitative company. I think our ire should be focused on that part instead of people who don't realize it's a scam.

[0] - https://www.ariseworkfromhome.com/faq/faqs/

csydas··on Password Requirements: Myths and Madness
No, I think you misunderstood the post I responded to a bit.

In the case where the current password is captured on the password change, you have two plaintext values that aren't stored yet and you can just do some text analysis and understand how close they are.

With past passwords, you just take the current input and transform it with common transformations (adding numbers, incrementing/decrementing numbers, etc), hash it, and see if it matches a previous password hash. If so, then you know that they're using a very similar password pattern repeatedly.

csydas··on Password Requirements: Myths and Madness
ah, that's reasonable and logical I guess to just do common "simple" transformations and check the hash. Thanks!
csydas··on Password Requirements: Myths and Madness
> The problem is that the demand isn't being made by security professionals, it's being made by risk management people

I'm actually not sure how true this is. There is a huge "security checklist" industry backed by persons with some fancy Security title that provide security analysis checklists for companies to follow, often citing very interesting interpretations of best practices from actual security orgs. These checklists are pushed on regulators who likely lack any ability to assess the validity of such requirements, rubber stamp the checklists into regulations, and now you have a series of unenforceable or ridiculous security policies and practices that basically serve to frustrate the user while failing to prevent actual attacks.

I've been at companies where there were rather interesting policies like

- Three factor authentication (because a single method isn't enough for some reason)

- No password managers allowed (how this is enforced is completely unknown)

- 6 week password lifetime

- Past password similarity checking (I'm actually not even sure how they do this unless they somehow have access to the plaintext version of user passwords; if there's a benign/secure way of doing this I'd be very curious)

- Random character requirements/limitations (you must use non-letter characters from set X, but not from set Y, and absolutely only latin letters)

And those are just some of the bangers surrounding password policies; the less said about the network security policies and antivirus policies the better.

And these requirements don't come from some regulation/risk assessment group; they're enforced by such groups, but the actual requirements come from some security firm that sell lists and a stamp of approval once you have every box checked.

It's difficult to not look at such firms as swindlers with a guaranteed paycheck from a captive audience; they sell their services to regulators as a benchmark to meet, and then in turn they sell implementation services to companies that are forced to meet said regulations.

And the end result is just extremely frustrated users who still end up falling for "Hey Bob check this out" phishing emails which is plenty for an attacker to get in and jump around your network until they compromise enough of the environment to take the business down. But hey! The business followed the checklist, so they can't be held liable for exfiltrated data!

← PreviousPage 7 of 34Next →