HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

cucumber3732842

1,064 karma · joined January 20, 2026

I'm not so vain as to put contact info here.
submissionscomments
cucumber3732842··on Dam removals are bringing fish back across the northeastern United States
They knew what would happen. They just didn't have modern values. People would rather make them out to be stupid than admit that anyone at any point looked at the tradeoff and decided the dam would benefit everyone enough more than the ecosystem to be worth it.
cucumber3732842··on Dam removals are bringing fish back across the northeastern United States
Because the government lays claim to anything and everything involving water so you can't "just" buy a bunch of adjacent land and start building a fish ladder around an old dam without going through insanely costly bullshit that everyone here cheers for because the peddlers of the bullshit act like it only ever gets used to stop DuPont from dying the river blue or whatever. And of course you can't touch the dam either without comparable cost because of "you touch it you bring it up to modern code" rules and whatnot. And this stuff isn't just a matter of going through the motions. Without friends in high places "helping" have to fight for every inch with lawyers and whatnot because these process pathways are designed to be exclusionary and expensive because they're designed to stymie industry.

So basically all these 100-200yo dams are stuck in this limbo where doing anything with them is a non-starter until they're at the point the government decides they could fail any day now and starts pulling out stops.

cucumber3732842··on MapQuest will now show you where Flock cameras are in your neighborhood
One time someone gave me an old name for a road and Mapquest was the only place that had it. Cool story, I know.
cucumber3732842··on Dam removals are bringing fish back across the northeastern United States
Abutting landowners get un-fucked as the jurisdictional wetland that was formerly upstream of the dam recedes. It really is a win all around.
cucumber3732842··on Dam removals are bringing fish back across the northeastern United States
Yes and no. Most of the dam removals are 100-200yo old low head damns that fed mill ponds so they weren't really holding anything back when there was high demand.

Thaaaaaat said, moving from "slap up a damn somewhere" based stormwater management to local stormwater management is probably gonna go down in history as one of the biggest boondoggles in the history of environmentalism in the wet eastern half of the country (the desert west where aquifer replenishment is a concern is a different story)

cucumber3732842··on Tesla Unveils 'Flying' Roadster with SpaceX Thrusters [video]
"gimbal cupholder" is what you want to google.

They're typically used to affix your beer to the steering wheel of your boat.

cucumber3732842··on Tesla Roadster
Like everything else we regulate.... right up until it becomes cheap enough that "undesirables" might get their hands on them.
cucumber3732842··on The insider trading you're allowed to do
On the flip side, even if the company is on the way up and you're on some team that's at the center of it and you'll never benefit from it if your manager doesn't like you. All the opportunity to do all the things that lead toward career growth and compensation will go to other people.
cucumber3732842··on Jev meets the Trolley Problem
The venn diagram between people worried that Comcast customer support and the welfare office will suck worse and people who are actively scheming up ways to use AI bureaucracy to "nudge" people toward the outcomes they want on other issues has so much overlap it would embarrass people if they had any shame.
cucumber3732842··on Americans' social activity has steeply declined in the past 30 years
The "new" part was who it was happening to. Instead of just stealing some poor hicks town for a dam and reservoir (after circling the plan for years to depress land values of course) they were interfering with substantially more established communities in far more volume than the railroads ever had. And it was more than just the highways, zoning codes and all manner of municipal regulation proliferated hugely over this time bringing government into people's lives (remember, the economy was way different too, people didn't all work in cube farms with a compliance department between them and the rules).

All those centrally planned things you mentioned were green(ish) field developments

cucumber3732842··on Show HN: Unfenced – Land for sale that borders public land
First off, that's like asking your building inspectors "what can I do without a permit". Governments are dearth to "help out" like that. Even if you know a guy, the boundaries typically aren't binding until a survey has been done the state or municipality has a approved it and it's been registered with whoever handles land stuff in your jurisdiction.

Second, most states that regulate wetlands beyond the federal minimum adopt some sort of absurd expansive standard far above what the feds want. It's complex and varies by state. Sometimes there's a square footage minimum, sometimes there isn't. There's also "gotchas" where manmade areas can become wetlands if they are let to be that way too long, so like farmer Johnson can absolutely get screwed by his grandfather's bright idea to make all the drainage converge in one spot 40yr ago. Sometimes there are exemptions, sometimes not. There's huge variation by state and some states allow local governments to enforce rules above and beyond the state ones.

cucumber3732842··on Show HN: Unfenced – Land for sale that borders public land
>I think it's probably a pretty prosocial thing to do, unless I'm missing something

Also massively illegal if you live anywhere that has a state level wetlands protection type law and the enforcement authority decides to exercise their discretion to make your life hell. They typically claim jurisdiction and authority over all activity in/around wetlands so theoretically you should be getting a state permit before digging a mailbox post hole or doing any sort of "management" of plants/animals but most of the time they just turn a blind eye to private homeowners who are being reasonable.

Wetlands laws and rules (non-criminal code generally, but wetlands are some of the worst) are written in a way to make RICO look like a meticulously scoped out piece of technical legislation.

cucumber3732842··on Show HN: Unfenced – Land for sale that borders public land
>The mere existence of a fence on government property does not constitute an agreement to maintain said fence.

Can you imagine the sneering and hand wringing that would ensue in the comments if you tried to make such an argument about private property?

If a private landowner failed to maintain anything that was created by man (as opposed to nature) they'd say things like "public nuisance", "blighted", "antisocial" and all the other buzzword people of that bent love to use.

I don't really care what the standard is. If some standard is good enough to be worth legislating enforcing then it ought to apply equally to all land owners regardless of public or private.

cucumber3732842··on Suicide rates highest ever among middle-aged men
Because we have a largely paper pushing service economy and so the guy who's plumbing a luxury condo is dependent upon the existence of some overpaid javascript monkey who the builder/financiers are counting on to buy the condo when it's done.

If you automate the paper pushing what happens? Jeff Bezos isn't gonna buy more condos.

cucumber3732842··on Suicide rates highest ever among middle-aged men
Yeah the information has been available for awhile. What stops people is all the indoctrination and conditioning.

"I'm not allowed to replace my water heater, the government says I need permits, the government says only a plumber can connect a gas line"

I don't think people realize that the people doing entry level skilled work like replacing your water heater or swapping your brakes at jiffy lube often only exceed the caliber of labor that's in a McDonalds when it comes to attendance and pissing clean.

cucumber3732842··on America didn't lose its rare earth industry, it sold it
Per capita?
cucumber3732842··on America didn't lose its rare earth industry, it sold it
> you probably expect it to remain operational for 30+ years,

You cannot afford this in the era of the modern regulatory state. You need projections showing you will be in the black in 5-10 to get financing most of the time. Anything you get after that is just gravy.

There are some exceptions for government intertwined industry (energy, farming, etc) but even then the long term risk is pooled and counter-balanced through financialization so nobody is holding the bag the whole time.

cucumber3732842··on Americans' social activity has steeply declined in the past 30 years
I think it's important to remember that the 1950s and 1960s were the time when western society really started to swing the government around for each and every thing in a way what we think is normal now but was fairly unprecedented at the time. When the government is seemingly capriciously regulating your life, pulling strings to get neighborhoods redeveloped in accordance with some new vision, bulldozing other neighborhoods for highways, that's not someplace you want to put down roots, raise your family or be in it for the long haul.
cucumber3732842··on Tesla's Robotaxis Blow Through School Zones, NHTSA Petition Alleges
Speed trap towns (and all manner of other local government predation upon the populace) work because the harm is spread thinly among the public. You pull that shit on a megacorp and their legal team will show up in court and mop the floor with you.
cucumber3732842··on America didn't lose its rare earth industry, it sold it
If you've spent your lifetime voting for all the policy that sent the industrial jobs overseas you have to tell yourself that to sleep at night.
cucumber3732842··on America didn't lose its rare earth industry, it sold it
>Nobody predicted the existence of the voter base that brought us the last run of presidents, they predicted different voter bases.

Surely there was someone in the 1980s or 90s that saw the demographic writing on the wall and tried to warn everyone and got laughed at.

cucumber3732842··on America didn't lose its rare earth industry, it sold it
The guy who runs SendCutSend has repeatedly said he'd love a CA facility but it wouldn't pencil out without the value-add powder coating, electro plating, painting and other services offered and that intentionally adversarial state policy precludes new facilities that do that so he's not gonna try.
cucumber3732842··on America didn't lose its rare earth industry, it sold it
>The whole economy for 40-ish years now been built on finance engineering away labors grip on anything in the US

Because when these plants and facilities come up for reinvestment the rules and laws have inevitably made a piecemeal sell out the only financially viable move.

The environmentalists point at the financiers. The financiers point at the environmentalists. It's like the two party system.

Worse, there was always some degree of unwritten understanding between government and big business. Like if big business built out a factory they would expect to use it for 50-100yr with refreshes every 30 or so. When the government started crapping on that sort of thing to the degree that various investments became wholly non-viable it became risky to make those investments, less of them, less to spread any risk over, more expensive, it's a spiral. And so if you can't be sure your facility will be allowed to be viable in the long term you've gotta milk what you can each quarter.

cucumber3732842··on ICE Planning $100M 'Nightmare' Domestic Spy Program
The part that gets me is how many useful idiots who are smart enough to know know better will cheer for these things when sold piecemeal. Your DEP starts trawling the cell phone location records to nab some guy who sold bad dirt. Your traffic cameras tell law enforcement how to tailor their revenue generation toward those who can't push back. Your school system monitors social media to nab some teenager for selling vapes his older relative bought. And people cheer. They call it progress.

Only when the comprehensiveness of this 1984 is presented in an unflattering way like "we're gonna snoop on everything so ICE can round people up" (or an AI camera goes up on every street corner) do they even become uneasy.

cucumber3732842··on Details Leak from Meeting Where Weiss's 'Handpicked' Editor Threatened CBS Staff
I don't care what their religion is. I care that they want to run cover for and/or promote policies that benefit a foreign nation that's interests not only do not align with mine but directly run counter to mine.
cucumber3732842··on Why is every rationalist blog post way too long?
First off, it's not my belief system. I'm not a rationalist.

Second off, I didn't call the whole audience "sneering POS's". I only implied it. Regardless of whether they're 5% or 50% those types are sufficiently plentiful in the comments, here and elsewhere, such that anyone posting stuff that's against the grain will be quickly predated upon by them unless their take is hedged in a nearly airtight manner.

cucumber3732842··on Why is every rationalist blog post way too long?
It's like those HN commenters who just spew links to cherry picked sources at you when you call them out for misleading people. It's an only slightly obfuscated attempt to move the goalposts from "hey idiot take a step back and look at the big picture, your core point is garbage and you're a bad person for even making it" type argument to one of implicitly accepting their premise and then bickering over sources (in the case of the filthy linkposters) or the exact nature of the minutia and excruciating detail they have produced in droves (in the case of the rationalists).

That said I consider the rationalists a little bit higher brow since they're at least DIYing (or were before AI) the words and the arguments and responsible for all that verbosity whereas any idiot can cherry pick links.

cucumber3732842··on Why is every rationalist blog post way too long?
I think it comes from their culture "growing up" in hostile parts of the internet (twitter, Reddit, HN, etc) and so having to hedge every statement with excruciating delineation of edge cases and precise scoping lest some sneering POS leave drive by comments that twist their words into some straw man that the local majority will be against.

Basically it's a defense mechanism against adversarial HN commenter type behavior that's been cargo culted a couple times over and doesn't actually service it's original purpose anymore and is just a group signaling mechanism.

cucumber3732842··on The United Kingdom generates less electricity per person than in the 1970s
>That looks like rationing. Economies ration by raising prices until poor people can't consume as much.

With the massive extra "pro" of plausible deniability so all those who's interests are served by it can lie up down and sideways about how it's a good thing.

A lot of things are like this. It's really hard to overstate the cost of laying unpopular things bare.

cucumber3732842··on Hiking the world in search of rare cheeses
I was a janitor at a Cabot facility in college. It's an industrial product like anything else. Tanker trailers drain go into one side of the factory. Reefers of finished product exit the other.
← PreviousPage 7 of 34Next →