HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

cultureswitch

512 karma · joined April 3, 2019

submissionscomments
cultureswitch··on Google Play will no longer pay to discover vulnerabilities in Android apps
Any big company is incapable and ultimately unwilling to bring meaningful security curation to an app store, exhibit 3843579401
cultureswitch··on One of the most unusual heists in America seems to be unfolding at Taco Bell
I have never even seen a Taco Bell IRL and yet I would consider hanging a reproduction of one of these paintings because of the story. And they're not really ugly either.
cultureswitch··on Boeing says workers skipped required tests on 787 but recorded work as completed
Is there a reason a publication will write "Boeing workers falsified records" instead of "Boeing falsified records"? What do you think it is?
cultureswitch··on Leaving Rust gamedev after 3 years
Mount & Blade 2 was released very early and despite constant improvement (they keep patching it at a strong pace), it's only slowly evolving.

It was even downright unfinished on release, with many game systems claiming to be doing something actually being simply unimplemented.

But despite all that it was and is still fairly playable and enjoyable, even at release. A game only needs a great core gameplay loop to succeed, even if large parts of it are completely broken.

Interestingly, Taleworlds make their own engine with fairly unique capabilities. 200 players can fight in fast paced, precise melee combat on a single server. Even more than in fast-paced shooters, it can be extremely frustrating for players when the game doesn't behave in exactly the way that you would expect (for example, standing undefended just a few centimeters away from the reach of an opponent's swing, or relying on interrupting their attack with your own landing 100 milliseconds before). They've made their own scripting language for everything related to policy. So this scripting language is what modders interact with. And it is absolutely atrocious as a language, but it serves the purpose well enough.

cultureswitch··on Leaving Rust gamedev after 3 years
I'm a Rust enthusiast and really surprised to discover so many people are apparently trying make games in pure Rust.

I think Rust is an amazing language for building a generic game engine, but a pretty crappy one for actually implementing a finished game.

Isn't it basically standard practice to have an engine written in a systems-level language with generality, reliability and performance as the top objectives, and the game itself written in a scripting/interpreted language that allows very quick iteration?

And it can even in many cases be a pretty horrendous home-brewed language. Despite having people without the computer-science knowledge to create a good language (and yes, inventing a new language is one of these things that leads to horrible results if you just learn on the job). This structure will still get you there easier and faster than trying to implement the whole game in a systems language.

cultureswitch··on Leaving Rust gamedev after 3 years
Hit the nail on the head.

Unless you're really dealing with absurd numbers of simultaneous blocking I/O, async has entirely too many drawbacks.

cultureswitch··on Leaving Rust gamedev after 3 years
> I don't think so, because there isn't a performance drawback compared to threads when using async.

There is. When you write async functions, they get split into state machines and units of non-blocking work which need to be added and taken from work queues. None of this has to happen if you just spawn an OS thread and tell it "execute this function". No state machine, no work queue. It's literally just another sequential program that can do blocking I/O independently of your main thread.

If you insist on implementing a thread-based solution in exactly he same way that an async solution would, then yes they'll both pay the price of the convoluted runtime. The point is, there's no need to do that.

cultureswitch··on Leaving Rust gamedev after 3 years
This seems strange to me. If you don't have millions of concurrent requests to handle at the same time, why would you bother with a whole async framework? Just straight up spawning OS threads to do parallel work when you need it is both easier to reason about and does not mess with your program's stack.

Isn't the point of async/await that spawning OS threads is not scalable when you reach ridiculous numbers of simultaneous blocking I/O? It doesn't sound like you're really dealing with this sort of problem.

cultureswitch··on Apple could be in trouble over security warnings, as well as Core Technology Fee
People should stop pretending Apple products are secure in any sense of the word. Pegasus software and similar have been working just fine on iPhone. For literal _years_.

Apple is fundamentally incapable and more to the point unwilling, to protect the users from external threats but especially from Apple itself. They are abusing their control over iOS and strip mining the users for data regardless.

cultureswitch··on Paris preserves its mixed society by pouring billions into public housing
When someone rents a small apartment in the center of Paris for 4k on the private market in all likeliness they're paying more than 3k of pure rent profit to the owner.

The rent can be levied by the owner however the owner actually did not provide any of the investment or labor required to give the apartment the value it has. The apartment has value not because of anything inside the apartment or the building. It has value due to its location, something that the owner has no control over and did not spend a single penny to make more attractive.

This is obviously a huge inefficiency in the economy. Why should someone profit from the attractiveness of a location they haven't actually built? This is a positive externality.

Part of the solution of our huge housing crisis across most developed cities is obviously that there should just be more housing. This would bring prices down overall. However, new construction is extremely difficult, and that is due the in part to lobbies of wealthy owners which seek to keep prices high by maintaining scarcity.

Turning private rent housing into public housing is a good way to eliminate the economic inefficiency of rent in that one case and it also drives the price of nearby housing down too, as the private market has to compete with the public offering.

cultureswitch··on First beta of Nintendo Switch emulator Suyu goes live
Been gaming on PC (and a little bit with consoles) for 20 years and the hubbub about Nintendo closing Yuzu made me want to try it to see what's this all about.

And yes it's unbelievable how much better these games are on emulator, even if you only judge based on the games themselves.

I've been thoroughly captivated by TOTK and the worst I've had to ensure was mild microstutters which I didn't even bother to try and fix yet. Even that could have an easy solution.

cultureswitch··on EU Probes Apple's Decision to Shut Down Epic's Developer Account
Nothing is forcing any website to show these prompts.

Only websites which abuse personal data have to do it. Why are you angry at the legislation and not at terribly designed websites?

cultureswitch··on EU Probes Apple's Decision to Shut Down Epic's Developer Account
The problem with that argument is that Apple is demonstrably incapable or unwilling of securing their devices, despite the walled garden. Pegasus and a dozen other spyware exploit iOS vulnerabilities which have remained open for at least a couple of _years_ and Apple seemingly doesn't care.

The only way to secure a device is to actually give control of the device to the user. But that would imply no more Apple tax, so Apple would rather die on that hill than follow the DMA. Add to that their psychopathic need for control.

cultureswitch··on EU Probes Apple's Decision to Shut Down Epic's Developer Account
Yes they did?

Violating some company's ToS is completely irrelevant when it comes to actual laws.

And more importantly, it makes no sense that Epic has to interact with Apple at all in order to sell software to owners of Apple products. Apple has implemented systems which makes this very hard or impossible for non-expert users. Which means Apple violates basic principles of ownership.

cultureswitch··on Why it's so challenging to land upright on the moon
Playing KSP is the reason why I empathize with the tipping over situation
cultureswitch··on A lock-free ring-buffer with contiguous reservations (2019)
I was faced with the same constraints a couple of years ago and came up with an almost verbatim solution. It's an interesting problem where a lot of very subtle bugs can happen, it's good to know that I went with the same solution as people who put a lot more effort into making sure it is correct.
cultureswitch··on Hallucination is inevitable: An innate limitation of large language models
LLMs can remember their sources. It's just additional knowledge, there's nothing special about it.

When you ask an LLM to tell you the height of Mount Everest, it clearly has a map of mountains to heights, in some format. Using exactly the same mapping structure, it can remember a source document for the height.

cultureswitch··on Hallucination is inevitable: An innate limitation of large language models
That is the argument we're having though.

The central claim is that a machine which answers exactly the same thing a human would answer given the same input does not have understanding, while the human does.

This claim is religious, not scientific. In this worldview, "understanding" is a property of humans which can't be observed but exists nonetheless. It's like claiming humans have a soul.

cultureswitch··on Hallucination is inevitable: An innate limitation of large language models
Are you telling me that WW1 artillery crews didn't understand ballistics? Because they were using tables.

There's no difference between doing something that works without understanding and doing the exact same thing with understanding.

cultureswitch··on Hallucination is inevitable: An innate limitation of large language models
Should it matter how the object of debate interacts and probes the external world? We sense the world through specialized cells connected to neurons. There's nothing to prevent LLMs doing functionally the same thing. Both human brains and LLMs have information inputs and outputs, there's nothing that can go through one which can't go through the other.
cultureswitch··on Hallucination is inevitable: An innate limitation of large language models
> you can train the network to act as if it knows its knowledge limits

Humans need more training to do the same.

And this does not answer the question of whether there's self-reflection going on. Practical LLMs available today are perfectly capable of telling you about their own reasoning process.

And much like a human, an LLM is incapable of fully explaining it's reasoning process from first principles to a human. Why is that? Probably because humans are too limited to grok large scale complex processes like the human brain or an LLM.

Finally, there is no difference between acting as if you know your training limits and knowing your training limits, if your acting is good enough. This goes for both humans and LLMs.

cultureswitch··on Hallucination is inevitable: An innate limitation of large language models
> The answers are not comming from a thinking mind but a complex pattern-fitting supercomputer hovering over a massive table of precomputed patterns. It computes your input then looks to those patterns and spits out the best match

Can you tell that's not how you yourself function?

cultureswitch··on Will scaling work?
The internet did change things dramatically, but the change wasn't as dramatic as industrialization. And that one matured over two centuries.
cultureswitch··on Reckless DMCA Deindexing Pushes NASA's Artemis Towards Black Hole
Disconnecting the economic rent from the value of a piece of cultural to each individual is a horrid idea.

Culture, like everything else, is subject to the pareto principle. A handful of works are so much better than the rest that they capture almost all of the money that the public is willing to part with. This is true regardless of economic system.

cultureswitch··on Reckless DMCA Deindexing Pushes NASA's Artemis Towards Black Hole
We would be better off without copyright enforcement at all than whatever we have now.
cultureswitch··on Reckless DMCA Deindexing Pushes NASA's Artemis Towards Black Hole
Hans get the skull measurer
cultureswitch··on Reckless DMCA Deindexing Pushes NASA's Artemis Towards Black Hole
The DMCA forces them to act this way.
cultureswitch··on Visualizing fighting game mechanics (2020)
I think I follow the gist of what you're talking about and it doesn't sound all that advanced at all. Deliberately missing out getting blocked to make the opponent think they have an opening is not a particularly high level play in other games. It still baffles me that traditional 2D fighting games and Tekken in particular are so complex and that it is so hard to even pull off a specific move due to control schemes that are maximally unergonomic.

Compare this with the simplicity of Mount & Blade Warband which achieves greater depth, in 3D, with a very simple and intuitive control scheme.

cultureswitch··on To revive Portland, officials seek to ban public drug use
Because despite significant variance, resisting to the lure of addiction using willpower is much more effective than using willpower to reconnect one's spine.
cultureswitch··on To revive Portland, officials seek to ban public drug use
Actually, I pay taxes because I have to.
← PreviousPage 2 of 11Next →