5,638 karma · joined February 24, 2020
Looks like they're just trying to catch up. Bad timing.
But still - a lot easier than semiconductors
Assembling a motherboard is to semiconductor fabs as flying a toy drone is to landing a Boeing 747. One you can learn in an afternoon; the other takes years to learn.
Plus, even if it is causal, it's not really new information: we know high-salt, high-calorie, nutrient-deficient foods (which ultraprocessed foods tend to be) DO causally drive the negative health outcomes described in the paper.
So like, this is basically a study that goes "yup, all the small studies are still saying this know-to-be-bad thing is still bad, despite recent interventions - let's go figure out if there's more mechanisms we missed here, or if it's just a matter of more interventions/individual choice at this point"
When my business logic sits in a script, I get a lot of free tooling to help me (code editors, git, jira, etc.). If it sits in a db field, I lose all that along with the benefits (e.g., git blame) they provide.
It appeared then that schools were no longer requiring test scores as a defensive move - if they don't require tests, it's harder to use them in court.
Today, the court appears to be signaling that they won't continue cracking down. [B] [C]. Accordingly, we should not be surprised that that admissions offices are reacting by reinstating the requirements - they've always been useful; they were just briefly dangerous.
[A] https://www.harvard.edu/admissionscase/wp-content/uploads/si... [B] https://www.reuters.com/legal/us-supreme-court-rejects-virgi... [C] https://www.insidehighered.com/news/quick-takes/2024/02/05/s...
I was going to disagree with this, and then I thought "but what is generational wealth, except enough money that nobody in your family is worries about that one major sickness/accident"
And now I agree with you
(1) US folks are fragile. They pathologize normal thoughts/behaviors to the point that they never actually learn to live with (or fix) them.
(2) Non-US folks are under-informed. They ignore diagnosable mental health issues to the point that they never get appropriate care for a problem that can be fixed.
It's probably a bit of both. I'm American, and its obvious to me that we are great on some dimensions compared to other countries. E.g., Asbergers-type autism is SO MUCH more understood (and addressed!) in the states. At the same time, "diagnosed with OCD thinking" is a nonsense phrase, as far as I can tell, and is probably going too far.
Therapy & medication are powerful tools; the US is learning to use them more than other places; that might be good or bad for any given person - hard to tell.
It's general resilience for critical materials given geopolitical risk, not a fear of the US per se.
Most of the (risk averse) great folks I know have purposely found safe harbor over the past ~2 years.
“Hey Microsoft - you for real about that offer?”
Maybe it's a factor, but it's insufficient
With a big enough org, the ongoing deterioration occurs faster than you can actually root cause and fix the problems.
You divide the orgs, they divide the pillars, they divide the groups, they divide the pods, they divide the teams… all the sudden, a 4 week root cause exercise takes a year and a half. By the time you implement the solution, you’re 3 years out of date. Whoops - administration flipped. They don’t care anymore. “What do you mean accounting - why are we behind China in AI?!”
Fed govt migrations are ALWAYS shitshows. The army alone has like 20 individual email services. The pentagon is to org complexity what big tech is to technical complexity. It’s turtles all the way down.
This is literally one of the largest bureaucratic challenges on earth. There’s no simple fixes
There's actually precedent for this - SEC lawyers are on the SK pay scale, not GS.
It's exactly the same problem: the alternatives in finance were too lucrative to retain competent enough attorneys to regulate wall street.
Congress should create a separate tech pay scale, given the alternatives are too lucrative to retain competent enough engineers.
The presidential innovation fellows are 1-year stints, and after the next election, there might not be a next role. Maybe a campaign? Maybe a consulting firm? Unclear.
Even if the parties don't flip - senior leaders churn through fast.
I love this attempt, but I can't imagine trying to be a mid-senior tech leader in an organization where, in 18 months, the next guy might be trying to actively tear down your work.
More generally, urban folks are more resilient because they're more flexible - as long as you're importing food, you're not reliant on one locale; you can always import as long as one place hasn't collapsed.
Eg, “spans and layers” optimization specifically targets middle management, while there’s not really a similar lever for ICs alone (maybe automation? But you prob get rid of managers there too)
In a high comp place, there’s no safety, only alternative options.
ICs are vulnerable because they’re low-level, but they’re also more fungible, so they can be more easily transferred/find new jobs.
Management is more of a socio-political game (it’s all about the people). A huge chunk of your value is reputation, trust, and relationships - which are very much non-fungible.
So managers are vulnerable (like ICs), but non-fungible (like execs).
As they say: slow to hire, quick to fire.
> unaccounted for negative externalities
The scale of these is uncertain, as are countervailing externalities. Looks like someone wrote a paper on it in the UK and came to the conclusion that it's not clear which is worse (i.e., the externalities either way aren't big/clear enough to matter) [1]
> I would be curious to understand how progressives decide which priorities are of greater urgency than environment and climate
I don't think progressives think this way, rank ordering a hierarchy of preferences (to their credit and detriment, at different times). I think it tends to be more "we noticed [problem X] in [Community Y] - let's solve it!" leading to an amalgam of policies.
[1] https://www.actuaries.org.uk/system/files/field/document/Iss...
It would be equivalent to increasing US prison population ~4x. [1]
It’s not really a serious argument in the American context
https://amp.theguardian.com/world/2023/jul/27/el-salvador-na...